When her husband died of mysterious, seemingly sinister causes, Nancy Bowen feared she might be next. “Sassafras” Charlie Bowen was a medicine man on the Cattaraugus reservation, and the couple had supported themselves by selling indigenous crafts and herbal medicine in the nearby city of Buffalo. But in the last few weeks of his life, Charlie had become convinced that one or more witches were sending harmful spirits to haunt the little shack by Silver Creek. He would fire his revolver around the bedroom at night to frighten the phantom assassins away, but to no avail – Nancy saw him slowly waste away, as if under some curse, till one morning he was pale and lifeless. After his burial, she packed a few belongings and left the cabin.
Because of a belief that witches attacked remotely, she had not been able to identify the spell-caster with the power to taken down this healer.

Bowen was offered a place to stay by a local Sachem, Anson Jimerson (80), and Ann Snow (72), and she developed a special bond with Jimerson’s 36-year-old daughter. Lillian May Jimerson, known as Lila to friends, was intelligent and inquisitive, and sympathetic to the 66-year-old widow’s mysterious plight. Lila had grown up immersed in the traditions and lore of the reservation. As a 16-year-old she was featured in a Seneca death-dance that impressed tribal members and tourist spectators alike. Then in her late 20s she was baptized into the Society of the Disciples of Christ, and became the mission school secretary and pianist. At the piano, she gave church hymns a slow solemnity, bridging the gap between Christian and indigenous music.
Lila hadn’t married. She had a reputation for being proud, and interested in the finer things of the European-American world. Despite her education and conversion, she listened attentively to the widow’s eerie reports about the never-ending battle against infernal curses, malevolent spirit projections, the evil eye, and other forms of witchcraft. Many on the reservation had left these beliefs behind, but Lila wanted to know everything.
One night, Nancy and Lila sat up with a Ouija board. Nancy asked if a witch had remotely killed her husband, and the planchette drifted slowly but certainly to the answer: Yes. When they inquired about the name of the spell-caster, the piece drifted around the board, selecting a curious constellation of letters: Clothilde. When asked to interpret this, Lila said she was aware of a sorceress living in Buffalo named Clothilde Brown, who had visited the reservation on numerous occasions, and aroused suspicion by her ability to identify poisonous toadstools.
Nancy’s suspicions were aroused, and more messages followed, some in mysterious letters that began arriving from “Mrs. Dooley,” a respected medium. Lila shared them aloud with Nancy, who could not read: Mrs. Dooley had burned something and seen words take shape in the smoke, indicating that a “white witch” had spiritually poisoned Sassafras Charlie, and the next targets would be people close to Nancy, and finally the widow herself. They would be driven to insanity and death, unless the witch were properly killed by the 9th of March, 1930. After she heard this, “a chicken ran around in circles near the pig pen and then dropped dead.” This seemed to confirm it.

Other omens followed: “Nancy Bowen tells how this winter…Lila Jimerson’s treasured piano suddenly began to play all by itself. It was the middle of the night, the piano was closed and everyone in the house was abed… Somehow, Nancy says, she found the courage to rush outdoors, seize a soft pine knot – quickly inflammable – and set it ablaze in the stove. The minute the smoke began to ascend, the piano stopped.” (The Buffalo News)
In need of assistance, Bowen crafted small dolls of rags and wood, and buried them four inches deep above the graves of revered Native American warriors on the reservation. One wooden doll had nails driven through it. At least one was wrapped in a piece of paper, a section of a letter written by this mysterious Clothilde, which Lila had. The dolls were accompanied by gifts: beans, biscuit, tobacco, and small vials of whiskey. A witness said Nancy sang songs over the graves, and collected grave dust that she carried away in a little basket. For further protection, a blood-soaked doll was buried near the Jimerson cabin, apparently based on a belief that, as the doll rotted, the witch would waste away.
As the deathly date approached, Lila read Nancy another letter: “This German witch, the one she took Charlie away from us is working [on] three Indians two women one man… Be careful she said there only one way you do to stop it is to get rid of Clotilde Brown… Clotilde kill enough person now let her go next… Kill her any old way you want to if you don’t she kill you sure.” The letter, signed Mrs. C.J. Dooley, gave instructions to enter the city, call the museum to make sure Clothilde’s husband was there, call a school to confirm her son was in attendance, wear black, find 576 Riley Street, kill the witch, and burn the house down around her. The letter added that the family dog was not to be harmed, and that Nancy would soon die if it was. A post-script added: “As soon as read burn up all the letters.”

On Saturday, March 1st, 1930, Lila brought Nancy into Buffalo to see this house, 576 Riley Street, near the Science Museum. Nancy sprinkled some dust she’d collected from ancestral graves on the doorstep, another measure of defense against the witch. Then Lila knocked on the door and it was answered by Clothilde Marchand, a 50-year-old French immigrant who’d moved to Buffalo five years earlier with her husband, the sculptor Henri Marchand. Nancy may have been surprised by the warm welcome: Clothilde knew Lila well, and led the two of them inside. She offered them food and soothed the family dog, who knew Lila but not her friend. Lila told her it was only a quick visit to say hello, and introduce Nancy, and the two returned to the reservation.
The date of the witch’s killing spree had been foretold, March 9th, but on Thursday March 6th, Nancy received a new message through Lila: the time had come. They walked five miles to the trolley line and rode into Buffalo, stopping at a hardware store to buy a ten cent hammer and a bottle of chloroform. Then Lila called someone who picked her up in a car, and Nancy headed gravely to the house on Riley Street.
At 1:30pm, Clothilde invited her inside, and again calmed the dog. Nancy said she was still nervous around the dog, whose name was Bear, so Clothilde put him in the back yard. Sensing Nancy’s unease, the French woman turned to the radio cabinet near the base of the stairs and asked if she’d enjoy some music. “You a witch?” Nancy asked. Clothilde laughed and said “Yes,” without turning from the radio. Two hours later, the Marchands’ 12-year-old son Henri Jr. came home from school, and called the police.
“Mrs. Marchand had been struck on the head several times with a hammerlike tool and had been choked and gagged with a chloroform-soaked wad of paper. Her skull was fractured and her lungs were filled with the lethal fumes. Mrs. Marchand put up a terrible struggle before she succumbed. Her nose and eye were badly bruised. The knuckles of her hands were swollen and scratched. Her knees bore marks of the battle with the slayer. The room in which the fight took place was a shambles.” The body was found at the base of the stairs “beneath a heavy cabinet containing a radio loud speaker… The remnants of a vase, which had been standing on the cabinet under which the woman was found, were scattered about the floor. Some pussywillows it had contained were resting on the body.” (The Buffalo News, March 7, 1930)
The two hammer-strokes that had killed Clothilde Marchand were on the crown of her skull and her forehead, in accordance with Seneca beliefs about how to banish the spirit of a witch. But the instructions to finalize the execution by burning down the house had not been followed.
Nancy met Lila again at the trolley station and they rode back to the reservation. Nancy still had her basket, containing the empty chloroform bottle and hammer, whose head had broken off in the struggle (“She was a little woman, but strong,” Nancy muttered). Nancy had also pocketed the bloodstained earpieces from Clothilde’s glasses, as a charm to ward off her spirit, if it should return for revenge. Returning to the reservation, they dumped the hammer in a stream, then burned Nancy’s bloodstained coat in the fireplace. Later, when the police knocked on the door, Lila hid Nancy in a compartment beneath the stairs. But she was soon found in the search, and Lila told them that she’d seen Nancy kill Clothilde Marchand with a hammer. Nancy didn’t argue or object. She’d done it to protect her family and friends from a witch.
To Be Continued…
This article is also available as a YouTube podcast special, with additional images.
