Bat Boy: The Musical has a book by Keythe Farley and Brian Flemming, with music and lyrics by Laurence O’Keefe, presented by Second Generation Theatre. It is directed and choreographed by Doug Weyand, with music direction by Ian Liedke, and stars Ricky Needham, Audree Woods, Marc Sacco, Arin Lee Dandes, Joe Greenan, and Michele Marie Roberts, with a stacked ensemble including Thomas Evans, Dave Spychalski, Dan Urtz, Karen Grace Harty, Kai Crumley, Collin McKee-Jackson, Danielle B. Walker, and Sabrina Kahwaty-Garcia. It runs October 1 through October 18, 2026, at Shea’s Smith Theatre, 660 Main Street, Buffalo, NY 14202. For tickets and more information, visit secondgenerationtheatre.com, call 716-708-7480, or contact the Shea’s Box Office at 716-847-0850.
THUMBNAIL SKETCH: Bat Boy: The Musical is an American horror-rock musical inspired by a 1992 Weekly World News article about a feral, bloodthirsty half-boy/half-bat who grew up in a cave. It’s set in a fictional town named Hope Falls, West Virginia, where three teen spelunkers, Ron, Rick, and Ruthie, discover our protagonist, Bat Boy, a deformed humanoid creature. The local sheriff brings Bat Boy to the home of veterinarian Dr. Thomas Parker.

RUNTIME: Approximately 2 hours and 30 minutes with one 15-minute intermission.
THE PLAYERS, THE PLAY, AND THE PRODUCTION: I first saw Bat Boy: The Musical, a dark comedy, when it premiered Off-Broadway way back in 2001 at the Union Square Theatre. I saw it three times during its run. The cast featured a charming Deven May as Bat Boy and one of my favorite Broadway actors, Kerry Butler, as Shelley. I also went back when Gavin Creel, who was a swing, went on for Rick. I love this type of show when done right; it makes you laugh out loud and pulls at your heartstrings.
The last time I saw Bat Boy was from a bootleg copy that Jonathan Groff gave me. He starred as Edgar, the title character, in a 2004 production at the Ephrata Performing Arts Center, not far from where he grew up in Lancaster, PA. Needless to say, I loved it.
Recently, Bat Boy: The Musical enjoyed a successful 2025 New York City Center production starring some heavyweight performers: Taylor Trensch as Edgar, Kerry Butler returning, this time as Meredith Parker, Andrew Durand as Rick Taylor, Christopher Sieber as Dr. Parker, Gabi Carrubba as Shelley, and Marissa Jaret Winokur as Mrs. Taylor, to name a few. I was crushed I did not get to New York to see this one, as I know and love several of these brilliant actors. Oh well, you can’t see everything, though I sure do try.
Second Generation delivers a hilarious, campy, and exuberant production of Bat Boy. Director and choreographer Doug Weyand’s attention to detail is astounding. He takes full advantage of the show’s dark yet campy tone and allows this super-versatile cast to milk every laugh without crossing over into cheap parody. Mr. Weyand is easily one of the best directors in town and one of my favorites. He maintains a sharp, tight pace, leaning heavily into the absurdity of the show while leaving room for its underlying themes of bigotry and otherness to land with genuine sincerity.
The live stage band, led by music director Ian Liedke, keeps the driving, eclectic pop-rock score moving at an unflagging pace. As soon as you walk into the theatre, you are introduced to the moody, horror-themed environment that Chris Cavanaugh has created with his sets and lighting. I felt he nailed the darkly satirical, rural atmosphere of the show completely.
Shout-out to Devin Prokop, the costume, hair, and makeup designer. Prokop scores high marks for the polished yet campy aesthetic, especially the work on Ricky Needham’s title character, transforming him from the cave-dwelling Bat Boy at the beginning of Act One into a well-dressed, sophisticated young gentleman.

Ricky Needham as the Bat Boy, named Edgar, is truly outstanding. He always commits to whatever character he inhabits 1000%. In my opinion, he could not be more perfect in the role. He is completely lovable and utterly adorable as an overgrown boy with cute pointy ears, fangs, and a winsome smile. But beware: as much as you want to give him a big hug, he’s half bat, half human, and he does indeed bite.
Enlisting such a winning lead as Mr. Needham is genius on the part of the Second Gen team. Needham as Edgar believably charms his way into the hearts of a typically atypical family and the Hope Falls community. Whether he is communicating in clicking bat gibberish or belting out a song, he draws you right in. His rendition of “Let Me Walk Among You” is not only funny and sweet, but also truly heartwarming. Another highlight is the goosebump-inducing “Apology to a Cow” near the end of Act Two, where his phenomenal voice blows the roof off Shea’s Smith.
Then there is the detailed movement and physicality he brings to the role. Ricky is mesmerizing to watch as he adeptly captures the essence of the creature with his feral movements and is equally exciting when he gradually metamorphoses into an upright, articulate, handsome young man who just wants to be accepted and loved.
Shelley Parker is played by the exquisite Audree Woods. She is certainly one of the brightest young stars WNY has to offer. Miss Woods and Mr. Needham have built strong onstage chemistry, and they both soar on their main duet, “Inside Your Heart.” Her funniest and strongest moments come when she sets her sights on Edgar, engaging the audience to root for this odd couple to make it. Miss Woods as Shelley is a marvel to watch as she, too, has a transformation, from a shallow, bratty teen into a thoughtful, kind young woman who learns to see people for who they are.

Michele Marie Roberts portrays the somewhat restrained, strait-laced Meredith Parker. Her husband is the town veterinarian, whom she seems to tolerate, and her lovelorn daughter, Shelley, becomes the object of Edgar’s affection. Miss Roberts is always a delight to watch and listen to, and she delivers the goods here as her unassuming character starts to unravel in Act Two. Her luscious, rich vocals wrap gloriously around “A Home for You” and “Three-Bedroom House.”
Marc Sacco plays the unhinged, hypodermic-wielding veterinarian Dr. Parker with a bubbling-under-the-surface comedic and maniacal flair that only he could do.
This powerhouse ensemble effortlessly whizzes through dozens of chaotic character quick changes. Thomas Evans, Danielle B. Walker, Dan Urtz, Kai Crumley, Collin McKee-Jackson, and Sabrina Kahwaty-Garcia all deserve high praise and elevate the whole production, each and every one a star.

Big-voiced and equally as lovable as Mr. Needham is Joe Greenan, who nearly stops the show as he explodes onto the stage as the tub-thumping, faith-healing evangelist everyone in town wants to see. Their energetic, infectious rendition of “A Joyful Noise” is vibrant and highly satisfying.
The supremely funny Dave Spychalski proves there are no small parts with every character he embodies, be it a member of the townsfolk or an animal, and particularly Mrs. Taylor, the over-the-top mother to Rick, Ron, and Ruthie.
Arin Lee Dandes plays the conflicted, blustery sheriff. She made me laugh out loud a few times as she navigates being a “Good Ol’ Southern Boy” caught between the arrival and bizarre situation of this new creature and the mounting pressure of local townsfolk who don’t understand the Bat Boy, are threatened by him, and demand his execution.
Karen Grace Harty is delightful as she plays multiple roles, whether Maggie in the frantic town council scenes, grounding the silliness, or with her sharp, reactive comedic presence as Ron, the baby of Mrs. Taylor’s trio of teens.

Bat Boy: The Musical is not all camp and frivolity. The last number, a reprise of the opening number, “Hold Me, Bat Boy,” carries some lessons learned along the way: “To scapegoat folks is wrong”; “Let go the fears to which you cling”; “Don’t deny your beast inside.”
In short, don’t be afraid of otherness. Every single one of us has a shadow that needs to be integrated. Bat Boy: The Musical at Shea’s Smith should not be missed. It offers a laugh-filled, tuneful show and an opportunity to see the damage and destruction that constant mistrust of others, those you don’t know or who are different from you, can bring.

