THE BASICS: Stephen Sondheim and Hugh Wheeler’s Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street is being presented by MusicalFare Theatre. The production is directed by Randall Kramer, with choreography by Michael Oliver-Walline and music direction by Joe Isgar. The cast stars Steve Copps as Sweeney Todd, Amy Jakiel as Mrs. Lovett, Austin Marshall as Anthony, Ryan Butler as Toby, Emily Yancey as the Beggar Woman, Michael J. Galante as Beadle Bamford, Philip Farugia as Judge Turpin, Solange Gosselin as Johanna, and Bob Mazierski as Pirelli. The ensemble includes Christopher Andreana, Taylor Carlson, Chris Cummings, Julia Pitarresi, Emory Redfearn, Brandin Smalls, and Michael Wells. The show runs through November 8, 2026, at Shea’s 710 Theatre, 710 Main Street, Buffalo, NY 14202, at the corner of Main and Tupper streets. Performances are Thursdays and Fridays at 7:30 p.m.; Saturdays at 2:30 and 7:30 p.m.; and Sundays at 2 p.m. For tickets and additional information, visit musicalfare.com or sheas.org, or call 716-839-8540.
THUMBNAIL SKETCH: A wrongfully exiled London barber named Benjamin Barker returns home after 15 years in an Australian penal colony and assumes the identity of Sweeney Todd. Todd opens a barbershop above Mrs. Lovett’s failing pie shop. To tell the tale of Sweeney Todd, you really only need to know that rage and revenge consume Todd after he learns his family’s fate, driving the story toward its climactic conclusion.
RUNTIME: Approximately two hours and 45 minutes, including one intermission.THE PLAY, THE PLAYERS, AND THE PRODUCTION

Sondheim and Wheeler’s bloody masterpiece, Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street, easily ranks among my ten favorite musicals of all time. When I heard that MusicalFare was tackling it, and learned near the end of the summer that most of the principal casting was already in place, I was brimming with anticipation.
I have seen more than 20 different productions of this show, including Broadway, Off-Broadway, West End, touring, regional, community, and concert versions—not to mention the 1982 filmed stage production that started my love affair with the piece. That recording starred the great Angela Lansbury, the original Broadway Mrs. Lovett, opposite George Hearn as Sweeney.
Some productions have been incredible and continue to serve as my gold standard. I have been fortunate enough to see George Hearn, Michael Cerveris, Mark Delavan, Michael Ball, Jeremy Secomb, Norm Lewis, Hugh Panaro, Bryn Terfel, Brian Stokes Mitchell, Kelsey Grammer, and, most recently, Aaron Tveit in the title role.

I have also seen Patti LuPone, Elaine Paige, Imelda Staunton, Siobhán McCarthy, Carolee Carmello, Sally Ann Triplett, Emma Thompson, Christine Baranski, and, most recently, Sutton Foster as Nellie Lovett, to name only a few.
Then came Tim Burton’s stylish 2007 film adaptation, with a screenplay by John Logan. It famously starred gothic darlings Johnny Depp and Helena Bonham Carter as Sweeney Todd and Mrs. Lovett, alongside Alan Rickman as Judge Turpin, Timothy Spall as Beadle Bamford, Sacha Baron Cohen as Pirelli, Jamie Campbell Bower as Anthony, Irish singer and actress Jayne Wisener as Johanna, and West End and Broadway star Laura Michelle Kelly as the Beggar Woman.
The film was successful, and MusicalFare’s production feels somewhat inspired by it. There is a cinematic quality to this staging, especially because everyone is covered in pale gray-white makeup that would look right at home on The Walking Dead.

During my years reviewing theatre for Buffalo Rising, I have been accused by some members of the Western New York theatre community of loving every show I attend—and particularly every actor who treads the boards. I have also been accused of being overly effusive with my praise and not focusing enough on the negative aspects of the shows and performances I see. Of course, I do not love every show, every performance, or every actor, for that matter.
However, consider this: We are very fortunate in Western New York to have some seriously talented directors, actors, musicians, scenic, costume, and lighting designers, properties masters, and crew members. We have a rich theatre community. Most, if not all, of our local actors work full-time, 40- or 50-hour-a-week day jobs. They have families, are raising children, and are caring for parents, all while giving 110% of themselves onstage four or five performances a week.
They might have only an hour or two between leaving work and arriving at the theatre to eat, poop, and rest before dashing off to a rehearsal or performance. Yes, I greatly respect and admire the work ethic of our local actors. Many, if not most, bring me tremendous joy when I see them perform on stages across Western New York—and if I want to love on them, I will.

Having said that, while I loved many elements of MusicalFare’s Sweeney Todd, particularly the performances, I was somewhat disappointed. Perhaps my expectations were too high. Perhaps it was an off night—for me or for the production. I plan to return with friends who are eager to see it, so we shall see. Remember, this is just my little old opinion and nothing more.
I am a big Randall Kramer fan, and while it is true that I love almost everything he touches, something was missing here for me. The pacing felt rushed, as though some of the actors were racing the clock to deliver their lines and lyrics.
Chris Cavanagh’s scenic and lighting design is intentionally bleak, dark, and shadowy—which is certainly appropriate for Sweeney Todd—but it did not bowl me over. The set is minimal and serviceable but not particularly impressive. Even Mrs. Lovett’s butcher block looked sad, tiny, and cheap.

The signs bearing large white letters to indicate locations—including “Home,” “Oven,” and “Asylum”—seemed unnecessary, almost as if the production were telling the audience, “Just in case you did not understand where we are, here you go.” I did enjoy Kari Drozd’s costumes. The cast looks terrific.
Steve Copps’s Sweeney will turn some heads in those leather pants. I loved Amy Jakiel’s quasi-Victorian costumes and vibrant red wig as Nellie Lovett. She looks stunning.
Philip Farugia’s Judge Turpin looks richly appropriate, while an almost unrecognizable Michael J. Galante is wisely dressed as Beadle Bamford. Bob Mazierski looks flamboyantly sharp and dramatic in his exquisite Pirelli costume.
Ryan Butler is dressed appropriately for Toby’s station, although the wig beneath another wig—and a long strand of hair that sometimes obscures his expressive face—was distracting. Choreographer Michael Oliver-Walline has created clever, visually interesting movement that elevates the production. I found the choreography unique and unlike anything I have seen in another production of Sweeney Todd.
He has some excellent dancers and movers in the cast. With the sharp, jerky movements Oliver-Walline gives them, they resemble the dark, sexy zombies from Michael Jackson’s “Thriller” video. The band sounds terrific under Joe Isgar’s highly capable direction. When the musicians and ensemble come together, the results are gorgeous, particularly during “The Ballad of Sweeney Todd.”
“The Ballad of Sweeney Todd” launches the show with the striking and robust Brandin Smalls singing the first few lines. I actually got chills. Mark my words: In perhaps 10 or 15 years, this young man will play Sweeney on a stage somewhere. Smalls possesses a powerful voice and commanding stage presence, and he makes the most of his time onstage.

The entire ensemble pulses and seethes with an underlying sense of danger, dread, and fear. This is a tight and gifted ensemble filled with powerhouse performers. The opening-night energy was palpable during those first few minutes.
It was great fun to watch seasoned character actors Christopher Andreana and Chris Cummings share the stage with established and skilled MVPs Michael Wells and Taylor Carlson, alongside younger rising stars Smalls, Emory Redfearn, and Julia Pitarresi.
Each performer shines and showcases immeasurable talent as the ensemble invades the stage to tell the tale, culminating in one mammoth and thrilling voice. Steve Copps is Sweeney Todd, also known as Benjamin Barker. This casting is a no-brainer, as Copps seems born to play the dark and brooding character. He cuts a towering figure as Todd, with booming pipes and a menacing presence.
This score is not easy to sing, and Copps handles it expertly. I immensely enjoyed his rendition of “My Friends,” while his massive baritone propels Sweeney’s high-tension spiral into further madness during the pivotal “Epiphany” near the end of Act One. It is a triumph.
I also admired Copps’s commitment to portraying Sweeney as consistently unhinged yet entirely focused on the task at hand: exacting revenge upon Turpin and the Beadle, all while maintaining a pervasive sense of danger. Copps brings high-intensity theatricality to Sweeney’s obsession with vengeance.

Amy Jakiel is as delicious as ever as Mrs. Nellie Lovett, the frantic and bitterly funny pie-shop owner. She takes the character beyond caricature and appears to relish playing this iconic role. I have seen many Nellie Lovetts, and Jakiel makes the part entirely her own. She possesses a playful sense of fun while remaining real and desperate, making Lovett’s terrible choices all the more understandable.
Jakiel is a phenomenal performer who always delivers the goods. She never lets her audience down, and she handles Sondheim’s notoriously difficult patter perfectly. Her rendition of “The Worst Pies in London” is a tour de force that demonstrates why she is one of the finest performers in town. Another memorable moment is her morbidly chatty “Poor Thing,” during which she recounts Lucy Barker’s tragic history to Sweeney with chilling casualness, using dark humor as a survival mechanism.
Then comes the showstopping Act One closer, “A Little Priest.” Jakiel and Copps delight in this lighthearted yet horrifying number, punning their way through a list of professions—including clergymen, Royal Marines, lawyers, and actors—to be baked into future pies. The number showcases their sharp comic timing and playful chemistry.
Act Two brings us a fantastically delusional Jakiel as Nellie paints a rosy and completely absurd picture of retirement for herself and a visibly uninterested Mr. Todd during an enchanting and engaging “By the Sea.”
Austin Marshall as Anthony Hope is another excellent reason to see this production, especially for anyone who has never experienced a live production of Sweeney Todd. As the young romantic sailor, Marshall wraps his extraordinary voice around “Johanna” like a well-fitting glove.
Marshall’s clear-voiced performances of these now-classic songs soar, including his duet “Kiss Me” with Gosselin’s Johanna. He brings an earnest and likable quality to Anthony, along with a natural and intuitive connection to our wronged barber, Mr. Todd. Bravo, Austin.

Solange Gosselin, whom I have enjoyed in other productions, is beautiful and serviceable as the emotionally and mentally fragile Johanna. Ryan Butler brings vulnerable sweetness and remarkably clear, gorgeous vocals to the wayward Toby. Simple-minded and fiercely loyal, Butler’s Toby deftly traces the character’s tragic emotional arc.
Butler is a senior in the University at Buffalo’s musical theatre program and probably has more stage credits on his résumé than some 50-year-olds I know. He continues to surprise audiences with each new role during what has been an incredibly busy year for him. He is one of the hardest-working young actors in Western New York.
Jakiel and Butler share several lovely and tender moments as Lovett’s maternal instincts emerge. Their rendition of “Not While I’m Around” is a stunning highlight.
Emily Yancey’s Beggar Woman is a haunting and dramatic foil to Jakiel’s Lovett and Copps’s Sweeney. Yancey demonstrates her impressive vocal range as the ragged street oracle whose disturbing and sometimes comical presence weaves through the story. Her incoherent ramblings and unsettling advances toward Sweeney and Anthony heighten the impending sense of doom. Yancey balances raw, lingering desperation with piercing vocal power.






Philip Farugia as Judge Turpin and Michael J. Galante as the judge’s toady, Beadle Bamford, bring a delectably vile quality to the production and their performances. Their interpretations are less overtly menacing, and perhaps even creepier, than those I have seen in previous productions. Both men serve the piece well.
I would also be remiss if I did not mention the astounding Bob Mazierski as con man Signor Pirelli, who manages to steal the show. He is absolutely delightful in the role and possesses a voice that is a gift from the angels. What a showman!
This is a solid and worthwhile production of Sweeney Todd, albeit a somewhat flawed one, in my humble opinion.
I adored most of the performances, enjoyed the choreography, and appreciated some of the deliciously in-your-face staging—although not every company number needs to conclude with a chorus line at the lip of the stage. Well, folks, there you have the review you wanted: a not-so-loving Anthony Higgins summation.
While this was not my favorite iteration of Sweeney Todd, there is still much to praise. Based on the opening-night audience’s enthusiastic reaction, though it appeared to include many actors’ friends and family members, MusicalFare has created a visually distinctive and sonically impressive vehicle for superstars Copps and Jakiel to play their dream roles with great aplomb.
It will happily creep you out—perfect for the fall and Halloween season.
