This spooky season, Alleyway Theatre presents a world-premiere comedy, The Haunting of Hooverton Hotel, that will leave you howling with laughter.
Executive Artistic Director Chris J Handley is thrilled to present the piece. “Our audiences have told me they wanted a play that is nothing but fun, and this certainly is! I am so proud that Alleyway can feature the work of these two local playwrights, whose play was a semi-finalist for the Maxim Mazumdar Award. Buffalo is going to love this play.”
The Haunting of Hooverton Hotel, by Jacob Albarella and Jason Kaiser, is a comedic caper inspired by Saturday morning cartoons; the play leans into every mystery trope that audiences love: ghosts, secrets, a missing will, a suspicious cast of characters, and a group of completely unqualified heroes who have no choice but to solve the mystery – no matter how ridiculous.

Buffalo-based playwrights Albarella and Kaiser are childhood friends whose friendship has always been filled with laughter. “Jay and I met in middle school,” said Albarella. “We started off as the goofballs passing notes during class when we should be working… Passing cartoons and stupid little sketches and just making each other laugh.”

Like so many comedy duos that have written before them, their work is amplified and strengthened because of their friendship. “I think comedy, a lot of comedy, whether it’s intentional or not, becomes a bit of a competition,” said Albarellla. When writing, the duo are able to bounce ideas off of each other. “It’s like, ‘Let me see if I can make Jay laugh and vice versa.’ It keeps us thinking about what is next and how we can step it up to the next level. And it’s nice to have that immediate feedback too.”
“When we write, we think of things that we think are funny, or things that we wish that we would see more,”
Kaiser continues, “That’s something that we always talk about, like ‘We wish that more shows would do this’ or ‘We wish there were more comedies, like 80s-type comedy, like stuff that they don’t do anymore’… We talk about, “What would we want to see? What makes us laugh? And then we start to think of characters and stories. If it makes us laugh, and we think it’s funny, then we’ll keep writing and usually come up with a couple of good ideas.”

The Haunting of Hooverton Hotel was conceived and drafted in 2020, during the pandemic. Albarella and Kaiser would social distance in their backyards and make each other laugh, hoping that when theatres reopened, Hooverton would be the perfect comedy to invite audiences back to enjoy a night out. “We were going through funny ideas. We landed on, ‘Why don’t we do that sort of ‘old cartoon comedy.”

The tropes, scenarios, and archetypes of those old cartoons may have inspired the pair, but the characters and plot of Hooverton are wholly original. Albarella remembers the ubiquity and popularity of the shows featuring hand-drawn sleuths solving mysteries, but he and Kaiser knew they needed to add their own spin on the familiar genre. “We wanted to pay respect to that, but also have fun with it and play with people’s expectations of what those characters would do and would be. And with that, there’s the opportunity for a lot of fun side characters as well, which of course we added in.”

Beyond its familiar characters, the production incorporates original music, video, projections alongside the physical scenery, gags, slapstick, silliness, and wordplay that Kaiser and Albarella hope delight local audiences. “We’re just hoping everybody that comes to see it is entertained,” said Kaiser. “We just want people to laugh and have fun and say, ‘I enjoyed myself.’ And I’m just so grateful that Alleyway is doing this show… we’re just so excited that this is coming together.”
The Haunting of Hooverton Hotel runs October 24 – November 14. Tickets are available here.

Please note: the author of this piece is also the director of the play.
