Alleyway Theatre presents The Haunting of Hooverton Hotel by Jacob Albarella and Jason Kaiser, Oct. 24–Nov. 14, 2026, at 1 Curtain Up Alley, Buffalo, NY 14202. For tickets, call 716-852-2600 or visit Alleyway.com.
THUMBNAIL SKETCH
This world premiere is a Maxim Mazumdar New Play Award semifinalist. Four college kids. A dark and stormy night. A creepy hotel at the end of a road. The Haunting of Hooverton Hotel is a brand-new comedy that leans into the mystery tropes you grew up loving. Recommended for kids ages 8 and older, teens, and adults.
RUNTIME: One hour and 50 minutes, including one 15-minute intermission.
THE PLAYERS, THE PLAY, AND THE PRODUCTION
‘Tis the season for some spooky fun à la Scooby-Doo! Playwrights Jake Albarella and Jay Kaiser have been co-writers since 2014. Their script is cute and full of twists, turns, and clever wordplay.
Director Dan Lendzian keeps the pace sprightly. Some of the production’s strongest moments demonstrate how effectively movement and creative staging can deliver laughs.
Set, sound, music, lights, props, and costumes are colorful, imaginative, and appropriately evocative of 1960s Saturday morning cartoons. Projections are used effectively, and the creative use of lighting adds some magical moments. Kudos to technical director Emma Schimminger, composer Zak Ward, set designer Evan Frank, and the entire creative team.





The teen sleuths are Ayden Herreid as Johnny, the all-American hero in red, white, and blue; Janae Leonard as the brainy, sensible member of the group; Gabrielys Rosa Lozada as the group’s skeptical member; and Ryan Okun, who is a crowd-pleaser as the timid snack lover.
Rounding out the cast are Caitlin Baeumler Coleman, who plays a man-hungry widow; Vernia Sharisse Garvin as a representative of the bank; Zach Kushner as a mysterious hotel clerk; Connor McGuire as the offbeat backwoodsman; and Kerrick Woyshner as a Southern tycoon reminiscent of J.R. Ewing in Dallas.
My favorite performer of the evening was Scott Borish, who is fresh and in the moment as the wizened and wordy groundskeeper.
While there are plenty of laughs throughout, I would have welcomed even more physical comedy to heighten the cartoon atmosphere.
That said, this is certainly a pleasant production and Alleyway’s Halloween treat to Western New York. A suggestion: Why not extend the Saturday-morning cartoon vibe to the audience experience with a playful touch, maybe nostalgic snacks in the lobby before the show?
