THE BASICS: A Few Good Men, adapted by Aaron Sorkin, produced by Road Less Traveled Productions with support from Shea’s, at Shea’s 710 Theatre, located at 710 Main Street, Buffalo, NY 14202 (corner of Main St. and Tupper). The show stars Nick Stevens, Renee Hawthorne, John Fredo, Adam Yellen, Chris Avery, Johnny Barden, Ryan Butler, Talon Powell, David Mitchell, David Lundy, David Hayes, Daniel Torres, David Wysocki, Steven Maisseke, and Bob Grabowski. The show runs from June 11 through June 28, 2026, Thursdays and Fridays at 7:30 pm, Saturdays at 8:00 pm, and Sundays at 2:00 pm. Tickets and info at sheas.org or roadlesstraveledproductions.org.
THUMBNAIL SKETCH: A Few Good Men is set in the summer of 1986 in various locations around Washington, D.C., and the U.S. Naval Base at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba. It follows the trial of two Marines, Harold Dawson (Talon Powell) and Louden Downey (Ryan Butler), charged with the murder of a fellow Marine, William Santiago (Dan Torres), during an illegal disciplinary action known as a “Code Red.” Their Navy lawyer, hotshot Danny Kaffee (Nick Stevens), initially aims for a plea deal, but he is pushed by his dynamic and persistent defense partner, Joanne Galloway (Renee Hawthorne), to take a stand. As Danny and his team challenge military values and honor, they go head-to-head with the formidable and most intimidating Colonel Jessup (John Fredo). Peppered with sharp humor and subtle romance, this gripping courtroom drama explores military morality, leaving the audience to question not only the truth but also who is right and who is wrong.
RUNTIME: Approximately 2 hours and 35 minutes.

THE PLAYERS, THE PLAY, AND THE PRODUCTION: Road Less Traveled Productions and its artistic director, Scott Behrend, consistently bring high-quality productions with diverse and fascinating subject matter to WNY. I, for one, am very grateful for their unwavering commitment to presenting some of the most dynamic, well-executed, brilliantly acted, and thoughtful shows in Buffalo, and their latest offering commands a solid salute. A Few Good Men came onto my radar, as it did for most people, via the late Rob Reiner-directed film starring Tom Cruise (LT. Daniel Kaffee), Demi Moore (LCDR Joanne Galloway), Kevin Bacon (Captain Jack Ross), Kevin Pollak (LT. Sam Weinberg), Kiefer Sutherland (LT. Jonathan Kendrick), Cuba Gooding Jr. (Corporal Carl Hammaker), and three-time Academy Award winner Jack Nicholson as Colonel Nathan Jessup. The blockbuster film was based on a 1989 Broadway play of the same name, written by Aaron Sorkin (writer-creator and showrunner of The West Wing and The Newsroom on TV, also represented on Broadway with productions of The Farnsworth Invention, and his adaptations of Lerner and Loewe’s Camelot and To Kill a Mockingbird). Mr. Sorkin is a multi-award-winning screenwriter, having won the Academy Award for his work on 2010’s The Social Network. I did not see the 1989 Broadway production. I was a college student working two jobs at the time, but I did catch two different productions of this show. The first was in London’s West End at the Theatre Royal, Haymarket, in 2005, starring film and TV actor Rob Lowe as Kaffee (yes, he is that pretty up close and in person) and John Barrowman, also dreamy, as LT. Jack Ross. Mr. Lowe was surprisingly at home on stage and completely riveting. The second production was in Fort Worth, Texas, in 2007 at the Casa Mañana Theatre, starring Jensen Ackles (Supernatural, The Boys) as LT. Kaffee and Lou Diamond Phillips (La Bamba, Young Guns, Stand and Deliver) as Colonel Jessup. It was a thrilling, gripping production in this cool, thousand-plus-seat theatre in Texas, and one I thoroughly enjoyed, granted I am a big fan of Mr. Ackles and have long admired Mr. Phillips’s work. And now, on to the current production of A Few Good Men that is inhabiting Shea’s 710 for the next few weeks.
Road Less Traveled Productions moves down Main Street to the 710 Theatre for the eighth time with A Few Good Men, continuing their long, successful, and collaborative relationship with Shea’s. Director Katie Mallinson smartly makes use of the entire stage at the 710 in such a way that the audience feels like they are in an actual courtroom watching the proceedings. The first act is a slow build to bring on the fireworks for the riveting and explosive second act. Miss Mallinson not only understands how to create dramatic tension on stage, she keenly guides her cast on how to inch toward a glorious intensity. The sharp and practical set by Lynne Koscielniak works very well, providing many areas and levels for the actors to play in, and the lighting design by Nicholas Quinn is gorgeous. It shifts from scene to scene, creating the mood and giving a cinematic quality to the production that will thrill fans of the movie. Lise Harty’s costumes are impeccable and impressive, especially the crisp consistency given such a large cast, which seems like a major task to achieve. Shout out to Diane Almeter Jones, prop master extraordinaire, for another great job with her attention to every detail. The cast handles the quick pace of the close-knit, talking characters very well, and their collective chemistry is magnanimous.
Nick Stevens plays the sardonic lawyer, LT. Daniel (Danny) Kaffee with such skill, nuance, and impeccable comedic delivery that you cannot take your eyes off him. He nicely delivers a few one-liners with the lightest yet zingiest of touches. He is simply one of the best young actors on our stages today. At first, Nick’s Danny Kaffee is a hotshot defense lawyer, all charming good humor and sexy swagger, but as he becomes more influenced by Hawthorne’s Jo Galloway, and as he begins to wonder if there is more to the case, he becomes wound up, a little nervous, overworked, but ultimately nimble, dynamic, and incredibly passionate. Mr. Stevens nails the incremental growth in moral stature on Danny as the play progresses, and it was a joy to watch.

Renee Hawthorne provides an excellent foil to Mr. Stevens’s Kaffee as the adamant and brassy investigator LT. Joanne Galloway. Miss Hawthorne plays Galloway as both compassionate and a real pain in the ass, a stickler for the rules. She pokes and prods, pushes, and firmly speaks her mind even though it was not really her case. Miss Hawthorne as Jo endows the play with sharp verve and an intellectual rigor. She serves as the moral compass and catalyst of the play, and she is its emotional anchor.
Adam Yellen plays Sam Weinberg, the quieter member of the defense team. Sam Weinberg is married with a child and certainly has other things on his mind besides the case. Mr. Yellen plays Sam with a warm, lived-in, softer voice that only raises when he needs to play referee to Danny and Jo. Mr. Yellen not only provides some comic relief as Sam, but he grounds the play with his everyday humanity and acts as a trustworthy sounding board to Stevens’s more headstrong Danny. Under Yellen’s skillful care, Sam is vulnerable and relatable while expressing his distaste for defending suspected bullies and murderers.
The great John Fredo plays LT. Col. Nathan Jessup. In addition to the sublime cast, I was particularly thrilled that Mr. Fredo was starring in this show. I first saw him in 1995 in Falsettos. He played Marvin, and it was the first time I was exposed to William Finn, who wrote the show, and the first musical I saw that prominently featured gay characters as leads. I went back several times. It was right between my mom dying and me moving to NYC. The show and Mr. Fredo’s award-winning performance impacted and empowered me greatly, and I carry that with me always. He does not just play characters, he inhabits them in a most organic and believable way. He was Marvin, and he ripped my heart out every night I attended Falsettos. Fredo is Jessup. His rousing performance in A Few Good Men is transformative. He commands the room with his dismissive voice, rough swagger, and physically threatening energy, yet there is another layer there. Fredo as Jessup is not just the tough, mean-spirited, evasive, and uncooperative Colonel, he is a man who lives by a code of honor to serve and protect, and he does not lack the strength of his convictions. This production and this performance make you question who is right and wrong. There is so much gray area. It can be claimed that men like Jessup and the men under him keep us safe and have to do what is necessary to make sure everyone on that team is operating at their best to do their job, but there are consequences, such as William Santiago’s (Dan Torres) death and the fate of Dawson (Talon Powell) and Downey (Ryan Butler). When Stevens as Kaffee relentlessly drills Jessup (Fredo) like a dog with a bone about his command and whether he ordered the Code Red, Jessup (Fredo) roars that Kaffee (Stevens) does not want to know what is required to keep order and maintain standards. The line made famous by Jack Nicholson, “You can’t handle the truth,” is delivered with such ferocity, it is jarring. I found some empathy for the character in Fredo’s depiction. He thinks he is doing what must be done and what is right to keep the American people safe.

Talon Powell and Ryan Butler play Dawson and Downey, the two young marines accused of murdering PFC William Santiago (Torres). Both young actors rise to the occasion and give solid performances, capturing the nervous energy and unflinching dedication to what they have been told is the Marine way by Jessup and their superiors. Butler particularly excels here with a wide-open, expressive face full of wonder, shock, disbelief, hope, and ultimately disappointment. WNY has enjoyed Mr. Butler, a soon-to-be UB senior, as a song-and-dance man over the last few years, but with this performance and RLTP’s Ghost Brothers of Darkland County directly before A Few Good Men, he is proving to be quite a good dramatic actor as well. The victim of Dawson (Powell) and Downey (Butler) is another fine young actor, Daniel “Dan” Torres. Mr. Torres as Santiago, the harassed and ridiculed Marine who cannot seem to perform at Marine-level standards, gives the right look of fear and anger on his handsome face. It is painful to watch him be humiliated and hazed, really tortured, by the others. Mr. Torres also portrays a courtroom security MP alongside the always delightful David Wysocki. Every time I see these gentlemen in real life, they are always big smiles and hugs. Here, they are stoic with a laser focus, their solemn expressions never wavering or changing for nearly the entire second act. I kept peeping over at both of them here and there, and they were impressively consistent, which seems almost impossible, especially in this day and age where everyone seems to be fidgety and distracted.
Johnny Barden, yet another young, prolific actor who treads the boards frequently in WNY, portrays LT. Jonathan Kendrick with fierce intensity. Barden has a theatrical magnetism, and as Kendrick, he is both fascinating and chilling at the same time. The character often appeals to divine commandments to mask his toxic dedication to the Marine Corps. He operates with a righteous, zealous nature and a rigid sense of military and moral duty, which makes the character psychologically unstable but extremely compelling to watch.

David Hayes, recently seen in RLTP’s excellent Mr. Wolf, plays Marine Captain Jack Ross, the sharp and formidable lead prosecutor on the case and colleague and adviser to Kaffee (Stevens), Galloway (Hawthorne), and team. Mr. Hayes as Ross handles Sorkin’s rapid-fire, caustic dialogue with great ease, and some of the best moments in the play are him and Stevens playing a sort of verbal tennis.
David Mitchell portrays Matthew Markinson, a seasoned and deeply conflicted Marine officer who struggles with post-traumatic stress and the moral weight of a coverup. Mr. Mitchell embodies the moral struggle and guilt-ridden internal agony like a virtuoso playing a violin. The role is smaller, but integral and pivotal to the story, and Mitchell’s performance is heartbreaking and flawless.
Chris Avery makes a very memorable Judge Randolph and is another highlight of this production, maintaining the strict military order in the courtroom and providing a very satisfying foil to Fredo’s Colonel Jessup. Mr. Avery has the gravitas to go nose to nose with Fredo’s Jessup, as he is unflappable and commanding, refusing to let his authority as judge be railroaded by the high-ranking officers or the theatrics of the lawyers in his courtroom.
The outstanding ensemble also includes David Lundy (Dr. Walter Stone), Steven Maisseke (CPL Jeffery Owen Howard), and Bob Grabowski (Isaac Whitaker).
This nail-biting courtroom drama will not only entertain you, it will also enlighten you. “A Few Good Men” was a slogan enticing young men and women to be all they could be in the Marines, but in the context of this play, it makes you wonder: who are the “good men” in this story? Are the accused young marines actually “good men” deep down despite their vile and violent actions? What about the initial lackadaisical lawyers who wanted them to take a plea bargain deal even when the boys may just actually be victims of circumstance? The excellent script, paired with this brilliant cast and thoughtful director, makes it clear that each character believes he or she is one of the “good ones.” Even the play’s antagonists, Jessup, Kendrick, and prosecuting lawyer Jack Ross, seem to believe that their actions are for the greater good of our country in some way. The fast pace and sharp banter, combined with a deeply complex ethical drama, will keep you glued to your seat. This is a must-see for theatre fans and fans of the film alike. I salute RLTP and all involved in the production of A Few Good Men.
