During the final weekend of Second Generation Theatre’s production of Douglas Lyons’s Pure Glitter at Shea’s Smith Theatre, Matthew Crehan Higgins sat down with Jimmy Janowski on the set for a public conversation about LGBTQ theater.
The show had begun as a one-night reading in Second Generation’s free reading series a year and a half earlier, and the talkback that followed kept circling back to memory: what audiences had carried with them from decades of queer Buffalo theater, who they had lost, and what was still needed. What follows is an edited excerpt, with thanks to Second Generation and the cast.

Jimmy Janowski has been a fixture on Buffalo stages for more than four decades and is widely regarded as the dean of Buffalo’s queer theater scene. A Buffalo State alum, he is a longtime mainstay of Buffalo United Artists (BUA), the LGBTQ+ theater company founded in 1992 by Javier Bustillos, who continues to serve as its executive producer. Janowski wrote and starred in The Birds Attack and has appeared in productions of Quilt, The Laramie Project, Some Men, Mommie Queerest, and Gross Indecency, among many of the Buffalo premieres of unpublished gay plays that Bustillos brought to BUA stages. He will be appearing in the upcoming Torn Space production of The Legend of Georgia McBride, from May 29 through June 20.
Matthew Crehan Higgins is associate vice president of specialty care at Evergreen Health and the former senior director of the Pride Center of Western New York. His decades-long professional career has been in HIV/AIDS prevention and LGBTQ+ health advocacy. As an actor and writer, he came up at BUA in the early 2000s alongside Janowski, Chris Kelly, Tim Finnegan, Caitlin Coleman, and the BUA ensemble. Pure Glitter is his first stage role in roughly a decade.
Below are excerpts from the conversation, recorded on the set of Pure Glitter, or listen to the full conversation here, or via the embed below.
WHY THESE STORIES HAD TO EXIST
Matt: I went home the night of the reading and couldn’t fall asleep. I’d done a one-night part. I was telling everybody it was the perfect Jimmy Janowski supporting role, the character shows up at the end of the first act, and everyone’s been talking about him the whole time. I thought: “I cannot believe I’m finally in a Jimmy part.” I just wished so much this would become a real thing, but it seemed unlikely. And now here we are, in the final weekend. There hasn’t been a single night where someone hasn’t said to me, “This reminds me of the good old days. This reminds me of when you were young.” And they’re talking to me about when I was young, which I thought I would always be. So maybe we start there. Why did we need these stories in the first place?
Jimmy: At the time, it was the need. There were no other options. I’m not an Anthony Chase; I can’t give you a history of gay theater, but think about it: the first time you really had gay characters come to life on stage was The Boys in the Band in the late ‘60s. Before that, you had Brick in Cat on a Hot Tin Roof. Blanche’s husband Allan in A Streetcar Named Desire. The scandal of The Children’s Hour. But not characters whose lives we examined. So, where did gay people look to see a mirror of themselves? That’s why I always talk about the women I played on stage in the camp shows. Those were the people I identified with, because there was nothing else to identify with. I went to Buffalo State in the ‘70s, took theater classes, and I wasn’t anxious to be an actor. There were no parts for me. I certainly couldn’t play Stanley Kowalski, and there was nothing written beyond that for us.
Then I moved to New York, not to act, to go to Studio 54, and I saw Torch Song Trilogy. Three hours long. Fire trap of a place, you sat on the floor. Matthew Broderick appeared in the third act and sat on the floor with you during the second act. That’s how casual it was. But I saw it, and I said,
Oh my God, somebody’s finally written something I understand, something I could do.” I had to bring friends, I thought, “Am I just making this up? I can’t believe that somebody is saying these things and playing these parts that are… us.”
I was working at the Barnes and Noble on 8th Street, and Paul Joynt, who played the hustler Arnold falls in love with, would come into the bookstore between his scenes. The show was so long he would do the first part then he would leave the theater and he would come to the bookstore. We became friendly. Eventually, I told him I’d heard he was moving up to Broadway, and I would love to play that part. He was so sweet, he said, “Come meet Harvey Fierstein.” Just like that. So we went to this dive bar on the East Side, and there’s Harvey Fierstein, sitting at the bar. Paul says, “This is Jimmy. He works at the bookstore, he loves the show, he wants to be your understudy on Broadway.” And Harvey goes, God’s truth, “Audition.” That was it. I never followed through. But that was the moment. [Jimmy did play the role to much acclaim in Buffalo years later.]
JAVIER, AND THE SCRAPPY YEARS
Matt: When you talk about Javier finding things for us, that’s a through-line to Pure Glitter for me. We’re working off an unpublished manuscript right now, from a writer who’s had a show on Broadway, has another coming, and is working in television. I had not worked from an actually published script until I’d been working as an actor for ten years, because we always had access to the unpublished manuscript. Javier would go to these things, he’d find the people, and we’d be doing them before they were even available. On this stage set, there is a published copy of The Last Sunday in June on one of the bookshelves. When I saw it I remembered, we were doing The Last Sunday in June and so many others before anyone else could.
Jimmy: And we were really scrappy. Honey, we were scrappy. Javier would fight to get us a space on some stage or the other. Do you remember the Roxy upstairs? Talk about a fire trap. I think about some of the scenes we did on that little, little stage, the size of this coffee table, and they were by no means not well done. I think they were quite good.
Matt: This is the most set I’ve ever had in twenty-five years of acting, minus ten. It’s beautiful and gorgeous, and I love it. But we didn’t have that then, and we still made those things.

THE FOOT TAP
Matt: One of those things was Some Men, by Terrence McNally. We were one of the the first companies after off-Broadway to do it. There’s a scene in it that’s just stunning, two not-so-young gay guys meeting two graduate students for their school project, played by me and Matt Hurley. The younger guys want to hear that the older men’s lives were all difficulty and full of strife. And Bill Schmidt and Jimmy’s characters keep telling them about all the joy they’d had. At the time, the Larry Craig scandal had just broken, the senator caught cruising in an airport bathroom. So we’re on opening night, and the script has, “How did you find each other?/There’s this, there’s this, there’s this.” And then Jimmy added, “Or you might tap your foot on the ground in an airport bathroom.” And the place went wild. The whole conceit of the scene was that the two young characters think nothing about this life is funny. I remember thinking, “I will kill him with my bare hands when we get off this stage tonight.” But I look back on it now, and it was perfect. And then your two characters started talking about the Everard Baths burning, how they let it burn, “we were standing there in our towels”, and after all that cacophony of laughter, the room was like a pin drop silence. That’s the thing you do better than anyone, bringing people from here to there. Sometimes when I’d wonder if I missed this work, I’d think about being on that stage with the three of you and think: “Why us? How did we get so lucky?”
DO HARD TIMES MAKE GOOD ART?
Jimmy: Look at the list, pre-AIDS, the height of disco, an energy of pride. Then the AIDS plays, devastation. Then, The Laramie Project, the horrible crimes. After that, a long fallow stretch of silly sitcoms. So, do we need hard times to make good art?
Matt: I do think so. Another actor once told me when I was young, “When politics are bad, the art gets better. The drag gets better. The music gets better.” And I wish we didn’t need that. I might even sacrifice good art for better politics. But the things on your list, The Laramie Project is about a horrible incident and the town’s reaction, but in those stories, there’s still a lot of joy. The musical Come From Away is five days after one of the worst things that ever happened, and has a lot of joy. Theater can create something out of a monstrous quagmire that brings people together.
Jimmy: I want to tell you about Quilt. My first BUA show. A musical, about the AIDS Quilt, each character on a panel tells their story. Anne Hartley Phfol directed. We made our own panel for the set. And then they brought an actual piece of the quilt to the Canisius gymnasium, and they allowed us to come and sing one of our songs from the show, a song called “One Voice.” We’re on the risers, the quilt is laid out in front of us, and the song begins: “I am one voice. I am one voice.” And it started to echo in the gym. You saw the quilt in front of you. And I said, “Theater can do this. Theater can do this.” That’s magic.
THE NORMAL HEART, IN THE WRONG YEAR
Matt: I desperately wanted to do The Normal Heart, and I got to in 2013. The Obama years were a time of an artificial sense that history could only move in one direction. New York State had just announced they were going to end HIV as an epidemic by 2020, but didn’t. I was approaching the play as history. Now I’m more angry than ever, and I think I would have thrown the milk carton differently knowing what I know now, that progress doesn’t only move forward. It’s hard to articulate that to younger people. The politics right now are terrible, but I still believe people like me move through the world more easily than we used to. And that’s hard to say without sounding like I’m downplaying their experience.
Jimmy: That history is wildly important.
Matt: And that’s why these stories stay important, because history repeats. Even Gross Indecency, the play about Oscar Wilde, is about the way the media manipulated that story. That’s still happening now.
ROY COHN AT STUDIO 54
Jimmy: I’m embarrassed to tell you this, but I went to Roy Cohn’s birthday party at Studio 54. I had no idea who he was. We had to go through his private entrance. It was like being on Epstein’s Island, honestly, I’m not kidding, that’s how horrible Roy Cohn is. He liked me a great deal. Paid a lot of attention to me. I told my mother afterward, and she told me who he was. About the Rosenbergs. The nightmare of a human being he was. So when people say, “Oh, he was so charming to me”, that’s all I have for you. He’s a monster. [Jimmy had no further contact with Mr. Cohn upon learning this.]
Matt: That’s a reminder that these people are temporary, but there’s always new bad ones coming. Eventually, Roy Cohn died, and then other people came. The pendulum swings. I do believe it will swing back. But the bad people come again, and we have to remember them so we don’t forget.
A DREAM ROLE, AND THE OZONE
Matt: Anything you haven’t done that you’d still want to?
Jimmy: Maybe Kerrykate Abel will do it with me. I want to play in Mame. Not Mame, Vera Charles. Full Vera Charles. A good version, with orchestrations. The ultimate play in my mind, though, is Angels in America. Honoring history, honoring the nightmares, honoring the joys. In twenty years, fifty years, it’ll still have the music it has now.
Matt:
Every World AIDS Day I think about Harper’s monologue from the second part, “Night Flight to San Francisco, chase the moon across the sky.” The thing at the end about our souls eventually fixing the hole in the ozone layer. I think about people I’ve known from my day job in HIV work, people I worked with in theater. People who used to wait downstairs at 884 Main after a show. Some of them I know must be gone now. That language, souls patching the ozone, takes my breath away every year.
PASSING IT ON
Matt: We’re in an intergenerational cast for Pure Glitter. Dan, Bebe, and I are in our forties. Brandin Smalls is playing the younger character, and he’s so talented and he’s working so hard. I hope twenty years from now he’s thinking about who he watched work hard the way I still think about people I watched working hard when I was his age. That when things are going great, you’re there for each other, and when they aren’t, you’re still there for each other.
Jimmy: The Birds Attack!, that’s where Bebe first showed up. I had written it because everybody at BUA was doing coming-of-age shows, and there was nothing for me.
Matt: It was an amazing time to be 26.
Jimmy: Nobody wanted to do it. Timmy Finnegan had just moved back to town, and I asked him, “Will you do the show?” He said, “Sure, Jimmy. What’s the part?” I said, “It’s a fourteen-year-old girl.” He said, “Okay.” He stopped the show every night. And Bebe came to an outdoor picnic at a shelter in Cheektowaga, no dressing room, and put on full drag at a picnic table. I said, “That’s somebody I want to work with.” And that’s history.
ONE LAST THING
Matt: I never told you this. During the run of The Birds Attack!, you were doing it on Chippewa, where you could park right outside. I was ushering one night, so I had a spot right in front. I’m sitting in the theater, and somebody’s car is going honk, honk, honk, honk, honk. And I’m saying to my partner, “I cannot believe this person is not going out to fix their car.” And then I felt the key fob in my back pocket of my jeans. And I thought, “I fear that I might be the one who did this.” I crept up to the window, looked out, and yeah, it was my car.
Jimmy: It didn’t ruin The Birds Attack! I pretended it was a Canadian goose. That’s just me.
Matt: What Douglas has done with Pure Glitter has reconnected so many of us to something we had forgotten about. You could joke and say it’s a sitcom. But it’s deeply thought-out characters, and staging, and gorgeous physical comedy. I don’t come in until halfway through the show. But every night, I sit in the back stairwell to listen to what the other actors are doing. Getting to sit there and listen, and then getting to join them, it’s a reminder of every name of every play on the list you made. The gratitude to Douglas, to Michael, to Kristin, to Kelly, to Second Generation for placing this story, something we haven’t seen in a long time, I’ll be grateful forever. To remember all of these times, all of these people, all of these things, is a great joy.



