A SKULL IN CONNEMARA, a play by Martin McDonagh, directed by Mason Beggs, starring Robert Creighton, Pamela Rose Mangus, Phineas Goodman, and Brendan Didio. Show runs February 13th through March 1, 2026. Thursdays, Fridays, and Saturdays at 7:30 pm, and Saturday and Sunday matinees at 2:00 pm. Presented by Irish Classical Theatre Company (ICTC), located at 625 Main Street, Buffalo, NY 14203. For more information and tickets, call 716-853-4282 or visit irishclassical.com
RUNTIME: 2 hours with a 15-minute intermission
THUMBNAIL SKETCH: Set in Western rural Ireland, Martin McDonagh’s 1997 play is built upon deception and centers on Mick Dowd, who is hired by the local parish to dig up older graves every autumn in the overcrowded cemetery to make room for new ones. Mick’s wife, Oona, died in a mysterious drunk driving car crash seven years ago, but the townsfolk whisper about whether it was an accident or that Mick killed her and staged the whole thing just to look like one. He admits to drunk driving and that everyone does it, but he vehemently denies that he would ever intentionally hurt Oona. The annual unearthing of corpses is disrupted when Mick must dig up his wife, which resurfaces the rumors of his involvement in Oona’s death and exposes many of the lies told by everyone in the process.

THE PLAY, THE PLAYERS, AND THE PRODUCTION: I went into A SKULL IN CONNEMARA completely blind on Friday evening. I only knew it was set in a rural West Irish town and that it is part of a trilogy of plays by McDonagh that depict murderous occurrences there. I am very familiar with Martin McDonagh’s work, having seen several of his plays on Broadway and in the West End such as The Beauty Queen of Leenane, The Cripple of Inishmaan, The Lonesome West, The Lieutenant of Inishmore, The Pillowman, and A Behanding in Spokane, as well as films he has written and/or directed: In Bruges, Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri, The Banshees of Inisherin, and Seven Psychopaths.
Academy Award-winning McDonagh is a British-born Irish playwright known for his absurdist, dark humor and for challenging the modern theatre aesthetic. Many of his plays are unapologetically Irish, and A SKULL IN CONNEMARA is no exception. Mr. McDonagh reigns supreme over contemporary Irish theatre; however, this play is among McDonagh’s earliest works and the second installment of The Leenane Trilogy. We only hear from four characters: Mick Dowd, our leading protagonist and gravedigger, solidly played by Broadway veteran Robert Creighton, who is aided and abetted by his oafish and prone to violence sidekick Mairtin Hanlon, played charmingly by Phineas Goodman; the pitch-perfect Pamela Rose Mangus as the irascible Maryjohnny Rafferty; and the consistently delightful Brendan Didio, local inept police officer Thomas Hanlon, brother to Mairtin and grandson to Maryjohnny.

I thoroughly enjoyed ICTC’s production for its abundant charms in plain sight. I love dark comedy and certainly relish in this play’s humorous contrast of both the living and the dead, the sacred and salacious, and all the polite lies people tell so they can get along, as compared to the bitter thoughts in their minds (which come out eventually, regardless). I appreciate the playful quality of the language and McDonagh’s distinctive storytelling style. He brings mischievousness to upend polite society through outrageously funny yet sad situations, often tinged with alcohol.
Mason Beggs has expertly directed A SKULL IN CONNEMARA with a brisk pace and a passionate heart; he also serves as the sound designer and successfully sets the moody tone of the piece with faint heartbeat sounds, music, and later an old school portable radio with a cassette deck (look it up, kids). Along with Colin Ranney’s perfectly versatile and wonderfully constructed set and Derek Heckler’s exquisite dark, undertoned lighting, Beggs creates an eerie atmosphere that pulls you right into the bleak world of these folks. They have also eliminated all physical representations of religious images on stage, in the script, and in many other productions, large crosses loom. There are no crosses present, just the bleak platform.
All the elements combined create an ambience that is not some silly Scooby Doo Mystery romp, but reinforce the sinister plot and highlight the darker, more dramatic moments on stage.
Adding to the immersion of this world is a lithe and ethereal Camilla Maxwell, who seems to float around the stage as Oona, Mick’s dead wife. Maxwell never utters a word, but she effectively elicits empathy for her character, begging us to wonder what really happened to her. Beggs adds the physical presence of Oona, who is not embodied in the script. I believe her beautiful ghostly presence added to the mystery and overall success of the piece. And shout out to props designer extraordinaire Diane Almeter Jones, who created some pretty cool skulls and bones that were a major part of the storytelling here.

True to McDonagh’s formula, the play opens on the meaningless banter between Mick (Broadway star Robert Creighton) and his always thirsty, frequent drinking buddy Maryjohnny (Pamela Rose Mangus), the town gossip. As I mentioned earlier, most of the townspeople (embodied here by Maryjohnny) suspect Mick wrecked the car on purpose or that he murdered Oona outright and staged the car crash to cover it up. The volley back and forth between Mr. Creighton and Ms. Mangus is truly fun to watch as he lobs insults, teasing her, and as she politely snarls back with her quick wit between their discussions of the weather and gleeful attacks on locals. Mangus, as Maryjohnny, serves as a sort of mythical hag or a seer, if you will, framing the play’s events and commenting upon them sagely, except this hag likes the drink a bit too much and cheats at church bingo. Another exceptional performance by Mangus in an extraordinary career on stage.
Creighton is a master performer who has graced many stages, appearing in 8 Broadway shows and featured in several episodes of popular television shows. Buffalo has the good fortune to house him at the moment, and he has become a part of its theatre community. Mr. Creighton, as Mick Dowd, adds just the right touch of poignancy to the role and has a commanding stage presence, giving a more brooding, slowly bubbling under the surface, about to erupt feeling to his mysterious gravedigger compared to the lighter touch Phineas Goodman as Mairtin provides. Goodman as Mairtin, through his clowning outlook on life, sing-song whiny voice, and his excellent physical comedy, gives the perfect foil to Creighton’s hardened Mick. He adds a goofy quality to this loutish, morbid ghoul of a young man, and it makes for a most compelling performance. Goodman is currently a senior seeking his BFA in acting at SUNY Fredonia, and he is certainly someone to watch out for in the future. Creighton is measured in his delivery, signaling inner turmoil, while an ultra-kinetic Goodman rapturously delivers his role. While we find Mick stern and sullen in the first act generally, a man who is used to being watched and judged all the time and who responds with a defeated, almost sympathetic quality, we learn he feels guilty and wants to be blamed and punished for the death of Oona. But after his confessions, he returns electrified in the second half, pivoting to a mischievous, menacing, gleeful side and ready for a bone-shattering bloodbath.
Brendan Didio, along with Goodman, supplies most of the high energy in this production. Didio mines his role as a somewhat conceited yet insecure Police Officer, Thomas Hanlon (older brother to Mairtin), who is convinced that most of the trivial deaths in town are all unsolved mysteries. Officer Hanlon has more ambition than actual ability and talent as far as his police work goes. When Didio, as Thomas, arrives on the scene, where Mick and Mairtin are digging up graves and tossing skulls around like they were kids’ toys, he begins to stir up the trouble. Another gifted physical comedy actor, Didio as Thomas, gazes fiercely as he hovers over the pair. He seems intent on proving his mettle as a cop, digging up the truth about Oona’s death, and trying to extract a confession. Mr. Didio plays his part so charmingly and so well, you can’t help but like this boob of a character immensely—think an Irish Inspector Clouseau.
Bottom Line: All four actors play their Irish Gothic parts to the hilt with fine accents that never waver; each is suitably cast as their respective characters. It is no easy feat to balance the humor and the macabre of this tale. Of course, it starts with good writing, but to make it leap off the page and onto the stage takes a well-equipped director, an impeccable production team, and an extraordinary cast. This production is well acted and well executed, as are most shows at ICTC. There is a line that young Mairtin crows as he and Mick get into their skull-crushing work, fueled by lots of whiskey, it’s like hell with the lid off. “This is more fun than hamster cooking!” It refers to an experiment the young dolt conducted on a live hamster once and one of the more troubling aspects of Mairtin’s personal history—however, that line could sum up the whole play. If this is the kind of dark humor that truly upsets you, then by all means, this one is not for you. On the other hand, if you believe that beauty (and a little truth) can be delivered in grotesque packages, and you are willing to laugh at the spectacle, much like our opening night audience, then A SKULL IN CONNEMARA is certainly the ticket for you.


