Ethan Cox, a founder of Community Beer Works, has embarked upon a new venture on the city’s East Side. He and his family purchased the Polish Co-Operative Savings & Loan bank building at 617 Fillmore Avenue this past October, with intentions of creating a community space that will include a cozy café element.
I spoke to Cox about the roughly 1300 square foot first floor space, and his intentions with it. He explained that there are many important elements to the story, which are continuing to unfold. First, we chatted about the fascinating history of the bank building, which was erected in 1925. Cox held an open house at the building this past December, after the official mortgage closing. He said that it was important to him to host an event that coincided with the building’s 100 year anniversary. He also wanted to “test drive” the space, to see how it would function as European-style café.
According to Cox, the origins of the bank – designed by Wladyslaw H. Zawadzki – first took root in the house located nextdoor, which still stands today. Cox believes that when the banker outgrew his household operation, he opted to build the Polish Co-Operative Savings & Loan building. For a detailed rundown about the bank’s history, you might want to check out this account posted on Buffalo as an Architectural Museum.
From 1925 to 1942, 617 Fillmore Avenue operated as a bank. Eventually, the bank outgrew the space and relocated, which is when the building became a branch of the Buffalo Public Library (1942-1965). When the library branch vacated the building in 1965, it became home to the Polish Army Veterans Association of America Post #1 (PAVA).
Eventually, community activist Robert “Bob” J. Sienkiewicz purchased the building, while allowing PAVA to remain on the first floor. This was just one of a number of buildings that Sienkiewicz bought in the neighborhood, with intentions of preserving. It is interesting to note that Sienkiewicz was also a founding board member of Eugene V. Debs Hall, which he also helped to preserve. To this day, Cox still bartends at “Debs.” As for the bank building, the second floor was converted to an apartment, where Sienkiewicz lived. Today, Cox’s daughter is living in that same apartment. To say that the lives and fortunes of Sienkiewicz and Cox were intertwined would be an understatement.
It turns out that shortly after Cox opened the original location of Community Beer Works, Sienkiewicz walked in to check the place out. Sienkiewicz and Cox ended up sharing a love of Buffalo through beer. That’s how their friendship began. When Sienkiewicz passed away in 2024, his sister Linda found herself in possession of the old bank building. It was then that she called Cox and said that Sienkiewicz wanted him to go through some old music albums – Sienkiewicz had previously gifted Cox an accordian that he had coveted.

When Cox heard that Linda was actively looking for someone to purchase the building, he raised his hand. Linda knew that Bob had wanted someone who understood the narrative, to step up and run the place, which is exactly what Cox intended to do. Cox had been thinking about getting into the café business once he exited the brewery business, so the stars were aligned.
If you happen to know anything about Ethan Cox, then you know that he is not destined to simply open a café. His concept will be lowkey-organic, based on cafés that you might come across in in Belgium, or the Netherlands. There will be no focus on a bar, as we have come to know it. Instead, there will simply be seating, with a communal table and plenty of spots to get comfy and cozy. Beer and wine will flow, along with a light menu with items that do not require a full kitchen buildout. Architect Mike Anderson (Abstract Architecture PC) is working on the layout and design, which will, of course, pay homage to the history of the building and its inhabitants. While most of the PAVA memorabilia has been preserved elsewhere, Cox is in possession of some fascinating documents.
Some of the inspiration that Cox is drawing from for the café comes from the Japanese jazz kissa café concept. One evening might be dedicated to “bring your own vinyl.” Another would showcase live jazz sessions. Or someone could simply choose a song from the jukebox.
“It’s going to be an analog place, where people can play a side of an album” Cox told me. “The jukebox is already there. People can listen to the music on the high quality sound system, while they do their own thing. They can bring along some knitting, or a book if they desire. We want to create a real sense of place. Something authentic – nothing fake. We’re creating something that respects the history of the building, the neighborhood, and the people that have worked so hard to preserve it all. I understand that I’m in an old Polish bank on the East Side. I will respect that.”
Speaking of staying true to the neighborhood, Cox is also excited to bring some authentic jazz sessions to the space, which he is calling Café Gezellig.
Gezellig (pronounced khuh-ZEL-ukh) is a central Dutch term defying direct translation, roughly meaning cozy, quaint, social, or pleasant. It describes a warm atmosphere or a sense of togetherness with friends or loved ones. It is used for both intimate gatherings and, when described as ongezellig, to mean cold or uninviting.
At the open house in December, a group of young jazz players called Spitballin’ Jazz Jam played the room. It’s the type of band where the core group invites other musicians to show up and sit in. The band will be back again on Saturday, March 7 (1pm-4pm).
To top it all off, the former bank building has off street parking, and a backyard that was – not so long ago – transformed into a wonderful outdoor setting by The English Gardener. Cox intends to add some outdoor seating to the mix, once he has some spare time on his hands.
All-in-all, Cox’s vision for Café Gezellig is one that we can all appreciate. Not only is he (along with his family) the steward of this beautiful building, he’s also the keeper of the keys for so much that has transpired within the walls of the edifice. And now, we will all have an opportunity to partake in this storied space, as this bold vision becomes another one of Cox’s steeped realities.
Cox anticipates to be open around May 2026 for day-to-day business, and will have a Dyngus Day event as well, so stay tuned for details.


