Shortly before 11 p.m. on Thursday, a loud scream that seemingly went on forever was heard on Sycamore Street on Buffalo’s far East Side. It was coming from the newly constructed Mother House on the sprawling St. Luke’s Mission of Mercy campus.
Charlene Mallory was wearing her signature Buffalo Bills #17 jersey and Amy Betros, the co-founder of the 30 years young mission in one of the city’s poorest neighborhoods, was seated very close to her autographed photo of the Bills’ franchise quarterback as they and other Bills’ fans were watching the NFL Awards show. Their all-time favorite Buffalo Bill had just been named the National Football League’s Most Valuable Player and as Josh kissed his fiancé, Hailee Steinfeld and his parents, and then made his way to the stage, the cheering in the Mother House just got louder and louder.
Quite a difference from the scene in the same room 11 days earlier when Josh, under extreme pressure, heaved a desperation fourth down pass that slipped through the arms of his tight end giving their nemesis, the Kansas City Chiefs a three-point victory and a ticket to its third straight Super Bowl, LIX in New Orleans.
“I love my Josh,” explained Betros, who watched her first Bills game when she sat with her father and family members crowded around a black and white television set as the visiting Bills shocked the San Diego Chargers, 23-0, to win their second straight American Football League championship in 1965. That was the last time the Bills won a title because their bid for a three-peat and a trip to Super Bowl I in 1966 ended in a 31-7 loss to the Kansas City Chiefs, who were led then by quarterback Len Dawson and coach Hank Stram.
Amy truly believed God had set Josh and the Bills up to break the streak and finally advance to and win the Lombardi Trophy this year. She said too many right things had been happening that led her to believe this, including Charlene, her missionary for 25 years, being awarded two Super Bowl packages by NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell and Bills owner Terry Pegula before the Bills defeated Baltimore, January 19 at Highmark Stadium. The pre-game surprise to Mallory, one of the greatest Bills fans in the city, was taped and aired on national television at the two minute warning in the first half. CBC announcer Jim Nantz narrated the transaction with such passion and enthusiasm about Mallory and all she does at St. Luke’s, where she is one of 10 missionaries and where she lives and works with the poor and takes no salary for her tireless efforts in managing the Mission’s Mall on the second floor of the school building. She and her team of volunteers have it so well organized that there are separate rooms of clothing, shoes and supplies for kids, adults, men, women and children along with a food pantry. It is open daily and donations are encouraged and accepted daily.
Ecstatic that her favorite Buffalo Bill was now the league’s MVP, Betros reflected on how she felt after they fell short of their goal again. “I could not sleep at all the night of the Kansas City game,” she said in a near whisper, wiping tears from her eyes. “I could not get Josh’s face out of my mind. He was so sad when the cameras showed him leaving the field.
“This was the year,” she shouted with emphasis.
“Those plays. They (the referees) took the game away from our players,” she said, reliving each of the close plays that went against the Bills. “Even Tony Romo (CBS color commentator), who does not like the Bills, even said, ‘That should have been in.’
“What makes a bit more at ease about the result was what Josh said after the game. Looking right into the camera and with his true sincerity, he said, “The Mafia has anguished,” and that really resonated with me,” Betros added. “Then he and Coach McDermott talked about their love of Buffalo and our fans and how they will never give up until they bring a Lombardi trophy home. That’s why I love Josh Allen.”
A St. Luke’s Missionary is at the Super Bowl today
Charlene Mallory was living down the street from St. Luke’s as a single mom of 3, including her youngest who was born with down syndrome. It was 1997 and when her son, Eric, began spending a lot of time at the Mission, Charlene and her two other kids walked onto the grounds inquiring what was there that kept her son coming back. She soon met the founders, Amy Betros and the late Norm Paolini, who listened intently at her story and then prayed over her and the children. They told her each Friday there is a healing Mass and invited her to bring her children to that Mass for prayer. She did and not being a Roman Catholic, Charlene confessed that she really wanted to live the life they were living.
Amy enrolled her, her sister and family members into the Right of Initiation to become a Roman Catholic and upon completion of the program they were among 17 who were baptized into the Church in what Amy described as “an extremely moving ceremony where you felt God all around us.”
Charlene, who loves the peaceful setting among the missionaries and volunteers at the Mission, committed herself to become a missionary in 2001 and since then she has become Amy’s personal St. Michael the Archangel. “She is truly my Guardian Angel,” Betros said with pride. “Wherever I go, Charlene is with me and here at the Mission she has taken over our St. Luke’s Market where volunteers, under Charlene’s direction, carefully place the accepted donations in various rooms for kids, adults, kids, household items, etc. on the second floor of the school building (Located adjacent to the church on Sycamore, between Oberlin and Miller Avenues with Walden Avenue on the north end of the property).
Two years ago, St. Luke’s Mission of Mercy was one of 20 Western New York agencies invited to participate in the Buffalo Bills extremely successful Huddle for Hunger program. This year, after a kick-off meeting for the agencies at Highmark Stadium, Michelle Roberts, the Bills’ Vice President of Community Impact and the Executive Director of the Bills Foundation, players, Billy Buffalo and young students spent an afternoon at St. Luke’s volunteering and receiving a tour from the passionate missionary, Charlene, who was wearing her colorful Josh Allen jersey.
Charlene must have had quite an impact on the Foundation officials because the Monday before the playoff game against the Baltimore Ravins, NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell, called the Bills to say he was coming to the game and was bringing a pair of Super Bowl packages that he wanted donated to someone who was making a difference in the community.
When the Bills agreed Charlene was the one, Roberts called her on Wednesday inviting her and a guest to be the guest of the Bills in their endzone suite, a parking pass and a pre-game field pass to watch the players warm up. Charlene was on cloud nine and immediately called Amy who was so happy for her. The following day, Roberts called Amy to inform her that Charlene will be surprised on Sunday when she meets Goodell and Bills owner Terry Pegula and learns she is going to the Super Bowl with a friend.
Charlene, who has been such a life-time Bills fan that long-time St. Luke’s volunteer and donor, Ellen Snyder and her husband, have donated a pair of season tickets and the playoff tickets to Charlene the past two seasons. She picks a different missionary or volunteer to join her at the games. Sadly, Ellen died late in the season and Charlene and Amy are convinced she was the angel who made the Super Bowl tickets available for her.
While watching the warmups and texting photos to Amy, who was set to watch the game with others in the Mother House, Roberts asked Charlene to follow her to meet someone special. As she approached the commissioner and Mr. Pegula, the cameras were rolling as Goodell thanked her for the important work she does at St. Luke’s in feeding the hungry and caring for those in need before giving having photos taken with her an oversized gameday ticket.
What went through your mind, Charlene and what did you say? “It was too much for me to understand and all I did was thank God for this amazing opportunity and then I said to Mr. Pegula, ‘Can you make sure Josh, and the Bills are there with me?
“I truly believe Ellen sent this gift to Charlene from heaven because our God is a good God and when I saw Charlene on national television receiving this Super Bowl package and then we beat the Ravens, I truly believed in all my heart we were going to win in Kansas City and go to New Orleans for the Super Bowl,” Betros said.
“Our Bills are a good group of players and I hope they keep the core of this team together. After the loss they never blamed anyone and they never finger pointed at anyone,” Betros added.
“No one deserves this gift more than Charlene. Her entire life has been about helping other people,” Betros said. “She is so proud of our St. Luke’s Market and how nice it is because those who visit to obtain clothing or household items are in extreme need and Charlene wants them to shop in dignity for these items that we give to them because that is what God wants us to do at St. Luke’s.

Charlene is in New Orleans with Karen Garigen, an associate missionary who has been supporting and following Betros and Paolini since before St. Luke’s opened and for the past 30 years she has done a variety of tasks but primarily has fund raised for them. “God has kept me and because of St. Luke’s I have experienced so much. There is no way Charlene and I would have ever been able to attend a Super Bowl on our own.


“Ever since we landed in New Orleans Friday afternoon it has been surreal. We stood and watched a two hour parade through the French Quarter today and it felt like Mardi Gras. We are having so much fun and we hope to be the first in the stadium early tomorrow,” she added.
Before they go to the game, they will attend an early Sunday Mass at Our Lady of Guadalupe Church and the International Shrine of St. Jude by Fr. Tony Rigoli, its pastor and a native of the West Side of Buffalo. “I am so looking forward to meeting Charlene tomorrow,” Fr. Tony said. “There are so many people here and security is the highest it has ever been. I am so disappointed the Bills are not playing. I had so many families and friends coming to town and with all the Bills fans there would have been millions of people in the French Quarter singing the Shout song.

“Next year,” he added, which means it goes to San Francisco, which was the first NFL stadium Josh Allen attended as a kid. Fr. Tony also said there is a popular Oblate Church across the bridge in Oakland which will be ready to welcome Bills fans in February 2026.
Betros just wants to see a World Championship for the Bills because the city she calls home truly deserves it. Watching the Bills win its last championship in 1965 turned Amy into a lifelong fan. A former owner of Amy’s Place on Main Street, Amy and friends owned season tickets from 1971 when Rich Stadium opened to 1994, when they became the last worldly possession she gave up when her and Paolini gave their life to Christ to open St. Luke’s Mission of Mercy.
She has always admired Bills founder, the late Ralph C. Wilson Jr. for bringing the Bills to Buffalo and for being one of the owners who led the American Football League to merge with the NFL. “Mr. Wilson quietly helped many organizations when he was owner of the Bills and what his foundation and Mrs. Wilson have done with the proceeds of the sale of the team, is absolutely remarkable.
“Through my friend Scott Bieler (owner of West Herr Automotive and a friend for nearly 30 years) I met Mrs. Wilson at a breakfast and what a wonderful conversation we had. She is such a pleasant woman, and I would love to someone have Charlene and I give her a thorough tour of our entire campus and to hear our vision for the future,” she added.
Amy said she was too busy to sit and watch games after she gave up here season tickets because they were building the mission. “However, seven years ago when they drafted Josh Allen, and I heard his opening comments, there was something about him that told me he belongs in Buffalo. He is one of us.”
Last summer, Betros received the ultimate gift from Bieler, who invited her and others to a meet and greet with the Bills players who star in the West Herr television commercials. Amy patiently waited at the end of the line to meet her favorite player, who had been told about each of the guests.
“I will never forget shaking his hand and talking with him,” she said. “He knew who I was. He is so kind and he treats you as if you are the only person in the room. After he signed a picture for me, he said, ‘Amy, thank you for what you do.’
“That is why I love Josh Allen.”

