The exterior of 95 Johnson Park is a little more muted these days. Developer Chris Wan purchased the former New Phoenix Theatre and has removed a lime green paint scheme. Wan’s LLC 61 Johnson Park of Buffalo purchased the property from the theater company for $370,000 in April 2023.


Built in 1884, the 8,849 sq.ft. 95 Johnson Park had been home to one of city’s most beloved theater groups from 1996 until closing in 2022. Before it transitioned to a theater, it was home to a séance house, a vaudeville house, and also a soup kitchen. With the theater on the first floor, a grand second floor space (30×88) was used as a rehearsal hall, offices, and studio. The third floor (24×82) is a three-bedroom apartment.

Wan has not announced plans for the building. A building permit was issued last year for stabilization work. The building is in good hands. Wan has completed a number of renovation on and near Johnson Park and is currently constructing a mixed-use building at S. Elmwood and W. Tupper streets.
