Yes, I know this one is a bit hard to love but love it I do. It is a brute but it has good bones. Dwell Magazine in this online story agrees with me. The building was built at a time of major urban renewal in this part of downtown. The paper originally occupied a very old and ornate commercial building on Main that stood in the way of the proposed Marine Midland Building (now HSBC). The old building was beautiful but it was the kind of beauty that was not so much appreciated in those days. It also was not the kind of building that said – “major metropolitan news paper”. So the paper traded up to a new signature building by a signature architect.
The signature architect they chose was Edward Durrell Stone. Stone was a very prominent early modernist architect. One of his early major commissions was to design the new home of the Museum of Modern Art in NYC (interesting side factoid – in doing research for this story I stumbled on a site noting that A. Conger Goodyear, Buffalo’s multi-gazillionaire of yesteryear, was the first president of MOMA). Stone was controversial because he, along with a few others such as Yamasaki and Bertrand Goldberg did not follow the minimalist party line of the emerging international style of the mid century. Stone’s buildings were often quite decorative and he did not shy away from historicist forms such as arches. As such he was not allowed into the cool guys club with Mies and Corbusier. His buildings were often derided but held a certain popularity with the public. Today his work looks dated and is often in danger of desecration or destruction. I have heard that he designed Diefenforf hall on UB’s Main Street campus. I cannot confirm this but, the building with its lacy masonry screen wall and thin profile overhangs fits the style he is best known for. The building he designed for the Buffalo News does not fit his popular profile. By the time Stone was asked to design the News building he was running a very busy firm. I read somewhere (again unconfirmed) that when asked why he chose to accept the commission of this relatively small building his response was that he wanted his name listed in the company of history’s great architects, Sullivan Richardson, and Wright.
Unlike many of Stone’s more well-known buildings the News building is an unabashed expression of pure modernist architecture. Its structure is boldly on display throughout the building. Massive concrete coffer beams span the large open spaces within the building freeing up internal space for the newsrooms. The coffers are lit to form a highly sculpted ceiling. Similarly the exterior is clad with monolithic concrete panels sculpted to create depth and shadow on the facade. Typical of this period of architecture everything is meticulously thought out and detailed. Also typical of the time is the great attention to interior work environment. The interior is quite wonderful. The core of the building is carved out for a two-storey atrium naturally lit from above (skylights spanning the building between the coffer beams). Sun light streams down onto a large central planter lushly filled with tropical plants, which is lined with a smooth terrazzo bench wall. Much of the News staff works in large open rooms on either side of this planter. Editors work in glass walled offices ringing the perimeter. It has the classic newsroom feel of the movies (note to movie scouts!).
As a modernist building it is of course not free of flaws in its interaction with the city. The modernists may have greatly advanced quality in the interior work environment of buildings such as this one but they did not have much understanding of or appreciation for cities and how people use them. One interesting feature of this building is also its most brutish element. The first floor is set back under long cantilevers, which appears to float the weighty building. It is an interesting visual play but also makes for a somewhat unpleasant pedestrian space. The dark cavernous area hides interior activity and feels dead and a bit scary. This is a minor flaw however and could be easily fixed. With the down sizing of the News in recent years much of the first floor is currently unused. I could see this area repurposed and built out for more active uses. The cantilevered spaces could be enclosed with frameless glass walls that would bring activity up to the sidewalk without substantial compromise to the floating visual effect. So anyway, Mr. Buffet, if you need an architect to study this idea further you can get a hold of me through Buffalo Rising 🙂
Many thanks to Buffalo News writer Mark Sommer who graciously gave his time on a busy day to show me though the whole building from the basement to the amazing press machines. I might be able to squeeze a second post out of the building.