Urban Vistas: Tunnel Vision

Urban Vistas: Tunnel Vision

Story Options

Regular readers may remember my Urban Vistas series a several months ago here, here, and here. I was digging through some old pictures and thought I would add a few more stories to the series. This view is looking west through a porte cochere centered directly on 54 Irving in Allentown. The view perfectly frames one of Buffalo's most perfect little houses. This view is much more intimate than the previous vistas I showed. It seems like it is designed with that house across the street in mind.

Though this bit of architectural collaboration may have happened quite by accident the results are very special. The architectural experience is both very private and public at the same time. It frames a view for the owner of the port cochere house but it uses public space beyond to create a more full experience. This is the kind of architecture and urban design that we have forgotten how to do (not to mention appreciate). The house with the porte cochere (more on this beauty later) extends its architectural reach across the street. It encompasses the city and pulls it in to create a whole bigger than either of these houses alone. It does not stand by its self. This is why it is so important to protect the heritage and cohesiveness of our urban fabric. Imagine that the house across the street was a parking lot or a prefab garage. This is not an argument for no change. It is an argument to take care of and remember that our architectural heritage should be treated as much more than a commodity. Buy a diamond ring and its value is that of its gold and gemstones. Inherit a diamond ring from your grandmother and the value is incalculable.

Speaking of change, take a close look at 54 Irving. You can see the faint outline of an earlier porch that once covered the entire front of the house. Most likely the earlier porch had a much lighter weight structure with spindly posts and a lot of gingerbread detail around the railing and roofline. At some time, probably in the 1910's o 20's, it became popular to "modernize" - to give the old houses a more up to date and trendy appearance. The current porch was very well done and does not detract form the house at all. It gives the house the kind of respectability that would have been found in new "suburban" neighborhoods in North Buffalo around Central Park.

Rock Harbor

What Others Have To Say

  1. EricOak

    2 ratings12345
    Mar 18th 2008, 13:28

    Steel, Thanks for the this wonderful morsel of a view and your thoughtful remarks about urban fabric. I don't know if you've been inside 54 Irving, but it's as charming within as it is from the street. There's a double parlor with double marble fireplaces, 12 foot ceilings, lovely plasterwork and a fine tall pier mirror anchored right between those two arched front windows. Graceful wood valances crown the tops of the windows. It's a very handsome place.

    Your argument for the heritage and cohesiveness of our urban fabric is music to my ears, but it's worth noting that people and communitites can have widely divergent interpretations of what that means. Take the recent arguments about the new condo at Gates Circle. You know I respectfully disagree with you about the value of that buidling-- economically, aesthetically, symbolically and otherwise, for the very reasons you mention above. The design for that building does not seem to understand its surroundings, and I doubt that the motives for erecting it have anything to do with enhancing the urban fabric at that site, and everything to do with making the building a smart commodity. Gates Circle has been sadly desecrated much more than nearly perfect Irving Place, but it's an extremely complex site--the intersection of parkway, sculpture, domestic architecture, vehicle traffic, and water. It has been compromised by heterogenity, not enhanced by it, and it's one diamond ring I'd be wary of tossing into the market without vigilant respect for its setting.

    But great post--keep them coming!

  2. qbll

    1 ratings12345
    Mar 18th 2008, 13:56

    Thanks for the beautiful picture of our house. It is better inside that outside and the secret garden is an oaisis. We feel honored to be temporary residents of this wonderful home.

  3. Biniszkiewicz

    1 ratings12345
    Mar 18th 2008, 14:00

    Steel, I look forward to your articles most of all.

  4. coolrobc

    0 ratings12345
    Mar 18th 2008, 14:16

    I love that house, it reminds me of a farm house around the corner from where I grew up. It still had the full front porch though...

  5. RaChaCha

    1 ratings12345
    Mar 18th 2008, 15:44

    Steel, this is indeed a fine Italianate house - and with the delightful way you have it framed one can almost imagine it as a Charles Burchfield painting. One of the great things about this house is the integrity of its Italian Villa style it presents to the street, despite having substantial additions behind and - as you say - modifications in front.

    And you can see to its left the beautiful Stick-style house - actually this whole street is a richness of 19th-century styles like Second Empire, Chateauesque, Queen Anne, and Tudor. But not just the rich diversity of styles, but the textures as well make strolling on this street a rich experience: brickwork, stonework, iron fencing, 19th-century brick and stone pavers here and there, trees and gardens. Many of these streets around Allentown, such as Irving Place, Park Street, Mariner, Derutte Alley, etc. provide an uncommonly rich visual environment for strolling - as found in few other places, anywhere.

  6. chris69

    0 ratings12345
    Mar 18th 2008, 16:41

    Driving thru all sections of Buffalo, most houses that had driveways had a Port Cochere and it would be wonderful if Buffalonians could expand their penchant for restoring the front porches of our urban homes to also restoring the Port Cochere as well.

  7. sbrof

    1 ratings12345
    Mar 18th 2008, 18:41

    It is little experiences and views like this that make me love the city. Every time I take a walk around the city you run into little moments like this. My most recent was of the Alleyway off of Porter right in front of that Church near D'Youville. I thought about how the view along the alley with the church at the end must have been done with some intention.

    Great shot and article.

  8. Colin

    1 ratings12345
    Mar 19th 2008, 01:01

    I own the house at the end of that alley -- Cobb alley. The view of the church at the other end is pretty sweet.

  9. Colin

    1 ratings12345
    Mar 19th 2008, 01:02

    I own the house at the end of that alley -- Cobb alley. The view of the church at the other end is pretty sweet.

  10. Mrrealestate

    0 ratings12345
    Mar 19th 2008, 05:16

    Nice Photo...very nice

  11. Martin

    1 ratings12345
    Mar 19th 2008, 08:45

    I don't think one could be bored in a lifetime of walks around the city. No matter how many times you walk down even the same street, there is something new to discover in the archecture these homes.

  12. Rebecca

    0 ratings12345
    Mar 19th 2008, 12:50

    The view down Cobb Alley from Jersey Street to Holy Angels Church on Porter Ave is quite lovely.

  13. RisingDamp666

    1 ratings12345
    Mar 20th 2008, 02:41

    Splendor, thy name is Buffalo.

  14. MichaelFranco

    0 ratings12345
    Mar 20th 2008, 09:19

    Walking north on Norwood toward Lafayette, the view of the red door belonging to St. John's Grace Church, is a great sight.

Would you like to subscribe to this conversation?

Enter your email below, and you will receive an alert each time someone leaves a comment on this post.

What Do You Think?

Text Links