UPDATE: Our Lady of Lourdes Auction

UPDATE: Our Lady of Lourdes Auction

Story Options

Back in December of last year I wrote a history of Our Lady of Lourdes Church; my brother Paul also provided additional photos which are on my website. Now that I'm in town preparing to relocate back to Buffalo one of my first stops was my old family church at Main and Best--and now I see the church is going to be sold at auction September 13.

Some of the boards over the massive windows are gone and I see one of the roof dormers has been damaged (no doubt from last winters windstorms), but the exterior masonry still appears sound. I went to the auctioneer's website which lists the details of the property:

- Architecturally Significant Building

- Sq. Ft. : Approx. 10,950

- Lot Size: 82x243 (.45 Acres)

- Assessed Value: $135,000

- Formerly used as a Our Lady of Lourdes Church

- French Influenced Romanesque-Renaissance Facade Remains

- Surfaced parking in rear of Church

- Bio Medical Campus nearby

- Taxes Approx. $4,320

I took a walk around the building and was surprised to see something I'd never notice before: Four cornerstones on the Main Street side of the building, showing the church's history:

Our Lady Of Lourdes 1898

Notre Dame De Lourdes 1898

St. Pierre's 1850-1898

St. Peter's 1850-1898

Lourdes was boarded up and its members reassigned to other parishes in 1993; a salvage company gutted the interior removing the quarter-sawn oak paneling, marble floors, and wooden pews. The statuary now rests at a Catholic cemetary in Hamburg.

I feel this is a magnificent structure in a prime location that must be saved...a fabulous opportunity for adaptive reuse.

Complete details are on the auctioneer's website.

digulios

What Others Have To Say

  1. Sal

    0 ratings12345
    Aug 16th, 08:33

    This article hits home so I'll start off with a positive comment. An auction is the best idea for this property at this point. The owners have chosen an experienced auctioneer that will get a fair price. Hopefully someone buys it.

    This was my grandmother's parish. Without getting into a lot of detail, let's just say she struggled to put my mother through school at this parish. Her early 1950s graduation picture is still on display in the living room.

    Fast forward to my vivid recollection in 1992 as a newly re-established Buffalo resident. Having learned of the demise of this building, I called the Catholic Diocese. Back then, my demeanor was polite. After all my elementary, high school and college education was all Western New York Catholic, basically from this corporation I was contacting. The answers the Diocese gave back then rose to criminal activity in my opinion. They were selling the windows my family paid for and we had no right even to make an offer. The Diocese was giving away the stripped building and taking back a large mortgage, knowing full well that no one would be able to pay it. The Diocesan attorneys were pretty sharp back then as their client escaped any financial liability, housing code violations, etc.

    Our Lady of Lourdes was not unique. St. Francis de Sales (575 Humboldt Parkway at Northland Ave) went down the same way. The school was torn down, I bought the rectory at a foreclosure sale, and the church remains a crumbling reminder of our Catholic heritage.

  2. benfranklin

    0 ratings12345
    Aug 16th, 12:21

    A few pieces of information from Cash would be helpful. It's not advertised as absolute. At what minimum price will it sell? What are the terms of the owner financing?

    Will the space be available for viewing any time prior to the day of the auction?

    My comment would be, if it's not open before the day of the auction, and it's not an absolute sale, then the current owner is just fishing for a buyer (nothing wrong with that, but don't be fooled into thinking this is going to change hands, just because they hang an auction sign.)

  3. buffaloweiner

    0 ratings12345
    Aug 16th, 14:36

    This has got to be part of Artspace.

    The marble and panelling are gone and so are all the religious artifacts. However the masonary is still beautifully intact. Its just the roof and windows that need work.

    That means that for a roof and clear glass windows, artspace could have a perfect large, open floor plan for art and sculpture.

    Gothic and Romanesque architecture is becoming more rare every passing day. Buffalo is blessed to have as many examples as we have but as we have pissed away our downtown and our near urban residential communities....we must not let these anchors of the community needlessly be lost.

    If there is anyone from artspace....please put this church up on the radar.

  4. stewie

    0 ratings12345
    Aug 16th, 14:40

    Sal, just curious have you done anything with the rectory? Why wasn't the church part of the deal too? Thanks

  5. buffaloweiner

    0 ratings12345
    Aug 16th, 14:56

    one only has to look at the montante center over at canisius to see how easily Lourdes could be utilized by Artspace.

  6. sonyactivision

    0 ratings12345
    Aug 17th, 16:07

    Or someone could buy it, restore its vital elements and rent it out for weddings and other such functions. The idea of couples being wed in this impressive structure again would mark a turning point of sorts.

  7. Sal

    0 ratings12345
    Aug 18th, 15:14

    stewie - After putting a lot of time, money and effort in, I sold the St. Francis de Sales rectory last summer. The new owner plans to rent out the building as student housing. The former church building no one ever wanted because it needed too much work and was designated a local landmark, making rehab cost even higher.

    These former religious buildings are really pretty but pretty doesn't pay the bills.

  8. Joshua

    0 ratings12345
    Aug 18th, 15:25

    The pictures on the auction site are useless. I wonder if Buffalo as an Arch Museum has pics??

  9. Joshua

    0 ratings12345
    Aug 18th, 15:35

    I'm having a difficult time finding pictures of église de Notre-Dame-de-Lourdes. Has anyone been inside in a while?

  10. georgethomasapfel

    0 ratings12345
    Aug 19th, 01:53

    Josh, I wasn't able to find any interior pictures when I researched the history article, but Chuck LaChiusa does outline the Landmark Society's proposal for the area with the Midtown Renaissance Project: Organic Revitalization - Artspace Buffalo

    This is a clear-span structure, as the 1898 Buffalo Morning Express article describes: "The body of the church has no pillars which are a nuisance in so many churches in the city."

Would you like to subscribe to this conversation?

Enter your email below, and you will receive an alert each time someone leaves a comment on this post.

What Do You Think?

Text Links