Theater District Condos Planned

Theater District Condos Planned

Story Options

A Main Street property owner is considering a condominium conversion project. Sean Spurlock, owner of 678 Main Street, tells Business First that he is planning to rehab the building for a mix of uses that is likely to include 10 or 12 condo units "in the near future." The two-story building is fronted by the light rail tunnel entrance and was recently occupied by the Groove nightclub (center, photo).

James Fink has the preliminary details:

Spurlock said he envisions the condos running between 2,100-square-feet and 3,300-square-feet with costs beginning in the $300,000 range.

The complex will have enough parking for the condo residents.

A small portion of the Main Street side of the building may be used for retail or commercial purposes, Spurlock said.

No formal plans for the project have been submitted to Buffalo officials. That may be in the offing, Spurlock said.

“It’s on my immediate horizon, but it also depends on the market,” he said.

Spurlock's 678 Main Street LLC purchased the property in March 2005 for $225,000.

Plans for ten apartments and commercial space in the adjacent Birzon Building at 686 Main have been approved. Work on that project, not a Spurlock project, was supposed to start last year but has not advanced.

prometheus233.com half banner

What Others Have To Say

  1. gaustad

    0 ratings12345
    Oct 17th 2008, 13:36

    Great Idea - all of main st should be nice condos - financing is real tight....

    Judging from the looks of this building, I am sure there will be a problem with preservationsists

  2. kooksapalooza

    0 ratings12345
    Oct 17th 2008, 13:54

    this would be a GREAT location for condos

  3. Dangelo23

    0 ratings12345
    Oct 17th 2008, 13:57

    This is old news just coming out of the woodwork again, So is it happening or not?

  4. nick

    1 ratings12345
    Oct 17th 2008, 14:07

    The developers don't complain when they get 20% historic tax credits from the preservationists.

  5. Dangelo23

    1 ratings12345
    Oct 17th 2008, 14:20

    The preservationist like to complain and have it their way or no way at all. Better not think about putting any awnings up.

  6. KenS

    0 ratings12345
    Oct 17th 2008, 14:37

    Is there no demand for smaller less "luxurious" condos in the 125-150K range or is this an unreasonable price range for a condo in downtown Buffalo?

  7. TroyT

    0 ratings12345
    Oct 17th 2008, 15:46

    I have to agree with KenS here. How many condo projects are currently in the works in downtown buffalo and it seems like most of them are way over the $200k range. The reality is that there aren´t that many people in buffalo that can afford a condo for $200k but there are hundreds of if not thousands of people that would love to live downtown but not at these prices. At $200k I would just buy a house. If you want to revitalize downtown Buffalo drop these prices and get younger people down there that will spend the money they make in the establishments around dowtown. It seems like there are condos for the rich and low income apartments in downtown and I don´t see either of these groups spending a ton of money back into that area. Who is going to buy all these condos for $250 - $350k?

  8. livesintheburbsworksinthecity

    0 ratings12345
    Oct 17th 2008, 15:53

    It may not be feasible financially to do these types of projects with less expensive condos. It costs a ton of money to renovate these old buildings, it may be that the only way to make any money is if all the resulting condos are high end.

  9. livesintheburbsworksinthecity

    0 ratings12345
    Oct 17th 2008, 15:54

    It may not be feasible financially to do these types of projects with less expensive condos. It costs a ton of money to renovate these old buildings, it may be that the only way to make any money is if all the resulting condos are high end.

  10. kooksapalooza

    0 ratings12345
    Oct 17th 2008, 15:54

    ^^ i assume before a developer spends millions to develop a place they do research to make sure people are going to be able to purchase their properties

  11. Assaroni

    2 ratings12345
    Oct 17th 2008, 15:56

    it costs $200 per square foot to renovate these...they have to recoup costs somehow

  12. NorPark

    0 ratings12345
    Oct 17th 2008, 15:56

    I guess the same type of people who buy the expensive waterfront condo's are the same people who can afford condos downtown in the 250k-300k range. I would like to think the people who build these types of housing have done they're research first, as opposed to building something and hoping maybe there is a market for these.

  13. TroyT

    0 ratings12345
    Oct 17th 2008, 16:09

    LivesInTheBurbs - probably a valid point. i think a lot of these developers want to get their money back quick so they jack up the prices but I think long term if there were more reasonable prices in the city you would have tons more people moving in and it would work out for everyone but since nobody wants to wait 10 years or more to get their money back we will continue to have condos for sale in the $300k range

  14. KenS

    2 ratings12345
    Oct 17th 2008, 16:29

    assaroni...if your numbers are correct($200 per sq. ft renovation costs), how is the developer above selling the condos starting at around $300k for a 2100 sq ft condo instead of $420k using your numbers?

  15. carl

    0 ratings12345
    Oct 17th 2008, 16:52

    So...did this guy hear of the credit crunch, or did that news just sail right past him?

    When you look at $300,000 condos in downtown Buffalo, with out much in terms of amenities, then you figure in the high per square footage renovation costs, and the economy (locally and nationally) this project makes almost no sense.

    Even if he sells out, (which i doubt given the size of the market), how is he going to make money on this?

    Condos are sooooo 2005.....

    I agree with TroyT, people want to move downtown, but the market developers are trying to corner is limited....try to cast a wider (and younger) net, and you will see these projects thrive.

  16. Andrew

    3 ratings12345
    Oct 17th 2008, 17:02

    What a giant bunch of crap. I'm the most pro Buffalo person in the world and this SOUNDS like an A+ but this guy is starting to look like Bashar Issa II. He made a little ruckus with the adjacent building 3 years ago and he hasn't done anything with it even in the height of downtown Buffalo's mini loft conversion boom. Especially in today's economy I don't expect anything but more but the same with this proposal. Sorry for being negative but (from what I've read) this guy is unproven and I don't want to get my hopes up just to get disappointed. I'm putting all my warm fuzzy feelings towards the AM&A's warehouse conversion.

    But please prove me wrong Mr. Spurlock!!!

  17. RonR

    0 ratings12345
    Oct 17th 2008, 18:48

    As for the $125k per unit range....I am not sure it can be done in Buffalo. Not that there isn't a market to buy these but rather a realistic budget to convert something for this?

    Even if the cost was zero for the property, doing a 2,100 square foot condo for $125k works out to $60 per square foot. I just do not see the math.

  18. Colin

    3 ratings12345
    Oct 17th 2008, 20:26

    "If you want to revitalize downtown Buffalo drop these prices and get younger people down there that will spend the money they make in the establishments around dowtown."

    Revitalizing downtown isn't the goal for a developer. The goal is to make money on the project.

  19. Sal

    1 ratings12345
    Oct 17th 2008, 20:56

    I'll let you in on a little secret - the model unit at The Whitney Condominiums is getting appliances delivered on Monday. At 1093' the six units are priced between $129,000 and $149,000.

  20. TroyT

    0 ratings12345
    Oct 17th 2008, 22:54

    I think it goes without saying that anyone that opens a business (condos or other) is in it to make money for the most part. However if you don´t think about the market that you are trying to sell to inevitably your business will fail so the revitalization of downtown has everything to do with their ability to sell these condos and to as you say ´make money.´ If you put a high end restaurant in a low economy neighborhood you probably won´t sell a lot of food. Downtown Buffalo is not Manhattan so you need to meet the needs of the market or at least the market that is most willing to occupy those condos.

  21. RonR

    0 ratings12345
    Oct 17th 2008, 22:56

    Sal

    So that is around $118 to $136 per sq foot at the Whitney. That is in the same ballpark as the price per sq ft here. What is the secret and what was your point?

  22. Sal

    1 ratings12345
    Oct 17th 2008, 23:16

    RonR - yes, The Whitney is in the same price per square foot, but not in the same price range as any of the 2 bedroom units out there.

    I'm really speaking to those who state that an affordable project can't be done. We're days away from completion and I think we'll have a great product.

  23. PaulBuffalo

    0 ratings12345
    Oct 17th 2008, 23:42

    After having lived in NYC, I became used to smaller spaces. Is it a given that condo space in Buffalo is expected to be in the 2,000 to 3,000 square foot range or are there opportunities, as Sal mentioned above, for smaller spaces that are more affordable? I know younger folks and older folks who would find 1,000 square feet adequate for their living space.

  24. Assaroni

    0 ratings12345
    Oct 18th 2008, 14:04

    kens,,,,its called grants and incentives...the only way anything can get donw in this hellhole...ask Rocco Termini and David Burke

  25. skarnath

    2 ratings12345
    Oct 18th 2008, 14:07

    Developers generally take the path of least resistance, and look for the higher profit margin projects first. But the city can help change the equation through proactive zoning. Minimum and maximum floor area ratios for buildings and minimum and maximum densities per acre can be used to force developers to build a wide variety of different size units.

    And again (apologies to those who are tired of this rant) - Norstar proposed some small (600 sf) high end condos on the waterfront in the $150k range ($200/sf to build) but were wrongfully pushed aside by Paladino in an inside deal with the Masiello administration. And unfortunately, many of the homeowners on the waterfront don't want young people able to buy in at $150k when they have paid over $300k for their units. They may think the cheaper units will devalue their properties, but the only difference is the size of the units - construction quality and amenities are the same.

  26. Hospitable

    0 ratings12345
    Oct 18th 2008, 18:25

    Cheaper condo's will definately not look like this building nor anyother historic building in Buffalo.

    Buildings that don't "mesh" with our rich architectural heritage don't make it past the planning stage in this town. (Unless you're Carl Paladino)

    Request cheaper condo's you're asking for a cheaper looking building... man I could see it now

  27. TroyT

    0 ratings12345
    Oct 18th 2008, 21:12

    You can have less expensive condos or empty buildings, take your pick...

  28. skarnath

    1 ratings12345
    Oct 18th 2008, 23:08

    Hospitable & TrovT - what both of you are saying is simply incorrect. Construction costs are a square foot issue. High end condos can be built for $200/sf. A 600 sf condo would cost $120,000 in hard costs. Add 33% for soft costs & profit and the unit sells for $160,000. You want a similar 2000 sf condo and the cost is $532,000. If you're paying $300,000 for a 2000 sf condo, you may want to carefully check the quality of construction.

  29. TroyT

    1 ratings12345
    Oct 19th 2008, 05:20

    Anything can be built it just depends how quick you want your money back and they don´t have to be ´condos´persay, they can be apartments, the point is that less expensive living can be built in downtown and simply has to be or all these buildings will remain empty or unsold. Skarnath can throw all the numbers he/she wants around in an attempt to sounds smarter than everyone else but it really doesn´t matter because you are not going to get an influx of buffalonians to pay those higher prices any time soon. That´s it, plain and simple, nobody is talking about square feet or high end condos or luxury units blah blah blah, the point is that buffalo does not have enough people willing to pay those higher prices so build less expensive units, whatever you want to call them, and get the people who are willing to live downtown in those units, renting or otherwise. In any city if you want people to live there you have to have different priced living units not only overly priced condos. How many people actually live down downtown and you want to tell me you can only build high end condos, give me a break,! It can and has to be done or Buffalo will continue to have virtually nobody lving downtown.

Would you like to subscribe to this conversation?

Enter your email below, and you will receive an alert each time someone leaves a comment on this post.

What Do You Think?

Text Links