Of Bicycles, Neighborhoods and Banks

Of Bicycles, Neighborhoods and Banks

Story Options

Think Financial Student Loans

Commuter biking in Buffalo? For some people, the idea seems completely bizarre. But for those forward thinking people, (or those without a car), commuter biking is not a wacky notion. There are reasons, in the general sense, as to why this is smart. For those whose commute is relatively short, it's cheap, convenient, and carbon footprint free. There are reasons, specific to living in Buffalo, that this is smart too. Regrettably, Buffalo's transit system is woefully unreliable. I can get to my destination quicker by bike than I ever could by bus... yes, even in the winter.

But there is another reason, irrespective of its practical advantages, that makes commuter biking in Buffalo an interesting experience. You get to know the city and its neighborhoods in a way that car travel can never match. Such has been my experience.

For almost all my commuter needs, I used a bike to get around. Traveling to unknown neighborhoods either for work, school, or shopping afforded me the chance to think about what the concept of neighborhood really means. Being from Toronto, cycling through downtown and near downtown neighborhoods has always been an enjoyable and engaging experience. On the bicycle, you feel a connection to the streetscape, because you actually become part of the life of a neighborhood, even if you're only whizzing by it momentarily. You can't say that about traveling by car, which only isolates and barricades you from your surroundings.

Perhaps, therefore, it's from years of cycling through Toronto's streets that I've come to appreciate that sense of connection I feel with neighborhoods, even if I don't know them well, or may never re-visit them again. Perhaps too, that's why I found a sense of intrigue, and curiosity about traveling through Buffalo's forgotten neighborhoods.

On the bike, you are more sensitive to the neighborhood environment around you. You're made to think about it more because, unlike being in a car, you're completely exposed to its atmosphere. This, I believe, is why I began thinking more about some of the neighborhoods through which I traveled. What moved me about two of them in particular, were the common elements they each shared. What inspired me to write about them was the images I conjured up of their vibrant past lives, and why I still have hope for their revival.

Living in Elmwood Village, I would frequently bike over to Guercio's to do my shopping. From there, I would often continue down Grant as I made my way to D'Youville College, where I was attending school. As I headed south along Grant, I would imagine what the street looked like circa 1942, 1955,1963 - arbitrary years I've chosen when this neighborhood was teeming with retail, foot traffic and vibrancy. I had the same apparitions when on two occasions I had reason to cycle up to the corner of Tonawanda and Ontario streets. Sadly, an empty, but still surprisingly intact shell of what was once the busy and beloved Riverside Men's Shops sits there waiting for a new life (or not if the developers knock it down as part of a Rite Aid expansion). Again, I imagined it being 1951, with a constant stream of people passing in and out of its front doors; men in fedoras, women wearing matching hats, coats and gloves.

And while it's true, we can't go back, we can look to the future. And while to some it may seem somewhat of a stretch, I do see a future for these two neighborhoods. Here's why. Both along Grant Street between Delavan and Ferry and along Tonawanda north of Ontario, there is still signs of retail… not a lot, bus some. Grant has Guercio's, a Rite Aid at Ferry, a Rainbow store, and Prish Moran and her investments shoring up the corner of Lafayette. Tonawanda St. also has a Rite Aid north of Ontario. Sure, these are not the stores of 50 years ago, nor the stores that indicate any pending neighborhood renaissance. But they are retail nonetheless. And existing retail is an indication of life... of neighborhood purchasing power and of neighborhood stability. Perhaps the greatest proof of that is that both Grant St. north of Ferry, and Tonawanda St. north of Ontario still support M&T bank branches.

To me, nothing indicates a greater belief in a neighborhood than the presence of a bank. They are anchors. They make a statement. They say, “We believe in these communities, and they are worth our investment”. Think about it. M&T would have long ago closed up their Grant Street and Tonawanda Street branches if there weren't enough depositors locally to justify the bank's existence. M&T is not a charity. Banks are in the business of making money. Therefore, the presence of M&T at these locations, in my opinion, is a good barometer of the viability and survivability of these two neighborhoods. And an indication of what might possibly be a healthy future.

This is exactly why the opening of two more banks along Elmwood (Evans National Bank @ current Elmwood Taco and Sub location and Bank of America at former Pier 1 site) is very good for Elmwood. People have lamented on BRO that the banks will only produce foot traffic during banking hours. People have lamented that banks are not places where people will spend their money locally. But it's important to think big. Banks are a symbol of stability. Stability attracts new investors to a community. Neighborhoods, like EV, like Grant/Ferry, like Black Rock are all seeking new investors. And unlike flashy stores that can come and go in a neighborhood, banks are often there for the long haul... helping to keep some neighborhoods currently afloat like Grant/Ferry or Black Rock, and helping others like EV to downright flourish.

It's interesting how this story would have never even been a thought, had I not been on my bike. Another reason why biking is not only good for your body, but for your brain as well.

digulios

What Others Have To Say

  1. ChristaSeychew

    1 ratings12345
    Feb 25th, 19:37

    Welcome back, Lorne. Nice post!

  2. al-alo

    2 ratings12345
    Feb 25th, 19:38

    you know what would have been great there instead of a bank? a pier one.

  3. Dasein

    2 ratings12345
    Feb 25th, 20:26

    You know what would be great there instead of an empty building? A bank.

  4. al-alo

    0 ratings12345
    Feb 25th, 20:37

    oh Dasein - you so crazy!

  5. RisingDamp666

    0 ratings12345
    Feb 25th, 21:23

    It's that fugazzi 'second floor' that is frightening the villagers.

  6. BROKEEPSBLOCKINGME

    0 ratings12345
    Feb 25th, 21:24

    Faux second floor? what a disgrace, we cant even get a newbuild right...

  7. FunGuy

    1 ratings12345
    Feb 25th, 21:38

    Geeeez, enough with the bike crap. All the Boyz just love a giant. Makes them wonder.......

  8. sbrof

    1 ratings12345
    Feb 25th, 22:33

    I bike all the time to and from places around the city and totally agree with Lorna but a quick story was my father. He started a couple summers ago commuting from his riverside home to downtown for work. Riding along the bike path, down Niagara. He isn't someone who hides in one section of town or another and probably knows more about the ins and outs of the city than most but even to him, riding to and from work many days showed him a lot of what he didn't notice before. Life along streets that he didn't realize existed. You hear people talking, music playing, the rumble of tires the wind in the trees. There are a lot of little but wonderful aspects of places that people often don't realize.

  9. gaustad

    4 ratings12345
    Feb 25th, 22:45

    Bikiing is not such a novel idea when it is -9 degrees with snow and sleet pelting you in the face. Unless you are a panhandler on Elmwood riding a huffy ten speed.

    Having said that, I am impressed to find out that Evans is moving to Elmowood as well. There will be several bank branches on Elmwood. that is a good sign and is good for the community. Hopefully they can finance some retail stores.

    Elmwood desperately needs a Gap or Old Navy....somthing along those lines to start out with.

  10. oldtimeconstruction

    1 ratings12345
    Feb 25th, 22:49

    The advantage of Grant Street is that prices are still low enough for a lower margin business to own it's location. That can be a savings over having to carry a blood sucking, boutiqueified Elmwood landlord's profit margin in one's overhead.

    I bought a building on Grant because I see it's potential to be the Elmwood of 1979 when I bought my first house on Lexington. A place where one can get services and goods they really need, rather than a retail street dominated by things I can easily live without.

    My Toronto model for Grant is Gerrard East, the little India neighborhood, without the pigeons. On Gerrard one finds neighborhood services, an ethnic Indian grocery, restaurants, immigrant owned businesses, not chain stores. On Grant it is Somali Star and a coffee shop, G&L Flooring, Guercio's, the locally owned pharmacy, the Hallal market, Russ's Bakery et al. This is a mix of products and services which give one reasons to keep coming back.

  11. chris69

    2 ratings12345
    Feb 25th, 23:33

    You want alternatives....then put the NFTA (bus and light rail), the Port of Buffalo, the Airport, the NYSDOT, the GBNRTC and Rail under a single consortium. Demand that the gas tax be distributed for light rail, bus, bicycles and commuter rail as well as for transportation for cars and trucks. You want alternatives...then demand local control and local priorities for all local projects to be decided locally instead of albany or dc! You want alternatives....put the public oversight into all these albany dictatorial agencies.

    Your never going to get rid of cars and biking is never going to be a year round alternative. However, what we Buffalonians need to be is pragmatic and realistic in funding all alternatives. Right now the only real funding we have is for cars, trucks and airplanes....so those are the only viable alternatives. Yet everyone knows that there are worthwhile alternatives that need funding and consideration and inclusion.

  12. Quinn

    2 ratings12345
    Feb 26th, 09:19

    I try to take different routes to check on the progress of people's gardens, repairs and improvements. I also find that walking and biking to work offers an added bonus - I have an opportunity to actually say hello and good morning to people I do not know and with whom I do not work. I know that sounds corny but its a nice feeling.

  13. doc

    0 ratings12345
    Feb 26th, 09:58

    " Regrettably, Buffalo's transit system is woefully unreliable." I have to disagree with this statement. I enjoy riding my bike but I also take the subway and transfer to a bus when needed. The bus takes me to the head of my street and I Iive in one of the near-suburbs (Snyder). I have a brief walk to get to my home. I have found the trains and the busses to run pretty much on schedule so I am not sure what you mean when you say "woefully unreliable." Good news for Elmwood development. We've come a long way in that regard and I hope the banks foster new growth and investment in the area. I recall the day I bought a Coffee from Starbucks when they first opened and then proceeded to walk down Elmwood to do some shopping. I entered an antique store and the proprietor greeted me with "I see you wasted your money on a three dollar cup of coffee." He was expressing anger that I would shop at Starbucks (a national chain) when I should have bought my coffee at Cafe Aroma (local enterprise). If I recall correctly there was a movement to actually block a Gap store from coming onto Elmwood. I see the mentality has changed and that's good.

  14. thinker

    0 ratings12345
    Feb 26th, 11:09

    Well, as someone's who's wrote an academic work on the development of a bicycle program in Buffalo based around the notion of commuting to work, I can only say GOOD LUCK WITHN THAT? At every turn, from evbery possible person, agency, department and group, it is seen as laughable, impracticle, and expensive to plan for bicycles in an aging community where hardly anyone rides when it's nice out, much less in the cool and cold months.

    Save the rants about the environment, energy, etc. I've made th arguments, fought the fight and took the ridicule defending the idea. It's great that people commute on two wheels. But the reality is that in today's hyper fast world, it's only an option for a microscopic portion of the population and that doesn't make politicians and private employers to invest money in overcoming the Three Ss... Sweat, Safety and Security.

    Sweat: Getting to work all swaety and hot and needing an at-work shower and lockerroom. Safety: On road and off road bicycle lanes and paths to ensure a safe commute Security: A secure place to leave your bicycle while at work.

    It's the few and the daring who do!

  15. scsa35

    0 ratings12345
    Feb 26th, 11:10

    I know plenty of people who ride their bikes to work, even in the cold, snowy weather. Just this morning, with snow on the ground and continuing to accumulate, I saw a neighbor get on his bike to ride to work.

  16. KernwatchMN

    3 ratings12345
    Feb 26th, 11:24

    As a deeply impoverished city, transportation by bicycle is an obvous affordable resource to improve quality of life for poor households.

    Sadly, poor minorities too often view biking as an admission of poverty, when it could empower them and stretch sharply limired disposable income. And it would improve the grim heath profile in poor communities.

    Minority leaders, & all city leaders, should promote biking as "cool'.

    One improvement is definitely needed. Without bike racks on busses, it is too often a gamble to bike any distance. In winter, especially one leg of the trip could become untenable.

    I now live in Mpls where every bus has a bike rack, making it simple to bike one way, or part of one way & bus the rest.

    For the elderly in Mpls, it becomes extremely cheap to run errands or visit freinds. The non-rush hour fare is 50 cents & a transfer can be used in all directions for 2 1/2 hours.

    Bflo needs bike racks on all buses.

  17. carlmalone

    0 ratings12345
    Feb 26th, 19:04

    Thinker. I think you pretty much sum up all this noise regarding the bicycle. They are great in summer and on vacation, but not a viable form of transportation for enough of the population to justify public expenditure in our region, the answer is simply no.

    I say this fully cognizant of the destruction the vehicle causes on our lives, health and well-being. Nothing has been more destructive to us as a society, than maybe say the spread of liberal curriculum in higher education.

  18. harry

    4 ratings12345
    Feb 26th, 20:29

    I'm so glad I discovered this web site! I truly enjoy the constant dream-like state that produces so many wonderfully impossible ideas. Maybe we should flood the streets and boat to work! And in the winter we could ice skate or sled! Oh, it would be so so cool and so green! We would be the envy of the most pie-in-the sky thinkers everywhere!!!! Please, no boo-birds, it's just an idea.

  19. simcoe

    1 ratings12345
    Feb 26th, 20:40

    Harry- Keep the humor coming, it's so original and creative. I mean really, did you come up with that on your own?

  20. harry

    2 ratings12345
    Feb 26th, 20:58

    Why thanks, Simmy. No, not so original I'm afraid. Lots of other realists just like me share the same tragic yet pragmatic and sardonic sense of humor. Hey, we love Buffalo as much as the dreamers, we just prefer to not grasp at clouds. Always a difficult call, the separation between what could be and what is fantasy. We must be just as persistent in separating the wheat from the chaffe in these endeavors as we are in pushing for a new and better Buffalo.

  21. bridgebum

    2 ratings12345
    Feb 26th, 21:08

    Simcoe, I don't think he's kidding. Think about it. D'youville wants to take houses to build parking lots. No problem. The Peace Bridge wants to take houses to facilitate transportation and help the area grow and Chris69 wqnts to throw himself off of the bridge. D'youville wants to build in Prospect Park. No problem. The Peace Bridge boys want to remove the access roads in the front Park and they are condemned. The village people want to reduce the Squajaquada Expressway to 35 mph, remove the I190 and reduce Rt 5 to a parkway. And you think that we will attract busnesses to come here. Maybe a blacksmith to shoe the horses. Most of the people on this site should live in Mumford, NY. - back into the dark ages.

  22. WholeLottaJibbaJabbah

    1 ratings12345
    Feb 26th, 21:20

    really gaustad? An Old Navy or a Gap? That's the last thing the Elmwood Strip needs. Do yourself a favor, get a bike. Hop on it, ride up West Ferry till you reach Bailey. Take a right. Go down Bailey till you hit Walden. Make a left onto it. Keep on riding until you reach this GIANT BOX in the middle of Cheektowaga. You'll find all that and more.

  23. reflip

    2 ratings12345
    Feb 26th, 23:04

    There will never be an en masse switch to bicycles as the dominant mode of transportation in Buffalo so long as the earth continues to rotate on its current axis.

    Nevertheless - just because people will not commute via bicycle doesn't mean they shouldn't ride bicycles or that the city shouldn't encourage bike ridership and try to make Buffalo a more cyclist-friendly city. Getting more people to pedal to their destinations, wherever they may be, rather than drive cannot be a bad thing no matter how you slice it.

    While driving around Ottawa proper last summer, I noticed quickly that I had to pay very close attention whenever I wanted to make a right hand turn on a green light (which we usually take for granted) becuase cyclists were everywhere, infesting the city like a plague of locusts. I was in an SUV. They were on bikes. Instead of thinking, "I should run over this commie pinko liberal Canadian" I thought, "God bless 'em for trying...eh." So, what's wrong with that? Why shouldn't a cold weather city be bike-friendly in the summer? Who's got a problem with that? Please, someone, state the case against bicycles.

    This article really captured the spirit of the thing nicely. That is, riding your bike can be enjoyable. I remember riding around as a kid and enjoying it. Maybe I should try it again (it's been a long time).

  24. gaustad

    2 ratings12345
    Feb 26th, 23:46

    Wholelottajibba - if I take that route, I don't think I will make it there alive! What are you trying to say?

  25. WholeLottaJibbaJabbah

    1 ratings12345
    Feb 27th, 08:42

    I am saying, there is a place where these stores already exist in a giant box (The Galleria Mall), and they are not needed on the elmwood strip. Not sure if you caught that first part of my post. Besides the quality of those clothes from those stores are terrible. I am pretty sure anything that comes out from the Old Navy store is set to self-destruct after a week of use.

  26. gaustad

    1 ratings12345
    Feb 27th, 10:15

    Good point, if Elmwood could attract an Armani or Apple store, I would have suggested that.

  27. mmjazz

    0 ratings12345
    Feb 27th, 10:29

    Gaustad, that's a great point. Apple would be a tremendous fit. Even a Starbucks would be ok. I know people will hate that; but, it does keep the atmosphere, and its symbolic of progress--a small one wouldnt hurt. If you are into real estate: starbucks and bank of america's are signs that more people are "buying" into an area--great idea on APPLE, what a great idea--the thing would kick butt down there, no question.

  28. MJWorthington

    1 ratings12345
    Feb 27th, 12:48

    What's so difficult about giving options? When redoing a road, add a bike lane. What's wrong with giving people options? I had my most freedom riding my bmx prior to getting my first car. I never had to worry about gas money, I always noticed a lot of cool things along the way that I could always easily stop and check out, and I remained healthy doing it.

    I still ride my bike in the summer. As said above, it gives you chance to be a part of your surroundings and interact with them and other people. Transit road exists for those that want an isolated life in a steel box wandering amongst asphalt praries. Why not develop Buffalo to give an alternate option to what the county has way too much of already?

    I always thought the old rail right-of-ways would make an excellent bicycle "highway" system. I used to use them extensively crossing from neighborhood to neighborhood as a kid. Even in my early 20's when I lived in the Village of Lancaster and rode my bike back and forth to the Gold's Gym on Seneca near Harlem in West Seneca I mostly used abondoned railway lines.

  29. WholeLottaJibbaJabbah

    2 ratings12345
    Feb 27th, 17:17

    mmjazz, there is a Starbucks on Elmwood. Between Delevan and Bidwell Parkway. I wish people would stop thinking that bringing these Corporations to the Strip is a good thing. We should be embracing Businesses like the Elmwood Beer Merchant, The Co-Op, Urban, Sweet & Dirty, I can go on and on. But what I am saying is the small local businesses are what you need. Thats how the Elmwood strip began to turn around in the first place. Small little shops popping up here and there, and now we need Apple? or the Gap? Screw that, although I love Apple. Its not needed on the strip. THINK LOCAL FUCK GLOBAL!

  30. ChocolateShake

    1 ratings12345
    Feb 28th, 09:03

    WholeLottaJibbaJabbah,

    When did Bank of America become local?

  31. ChocolateShake

    1 ratings12345
    Feb 28th, 09:38

    How much capital has many of those "local" Elmwood Village business interests received from "global" banking interests? Should Buffalo just sit in a circle jerk and pretend that global economy doesn't exist? Oh wait, we have done that for the past 20 years and thus a declining region. Get yer head out of yer arse and look around at the world. Think global and watch Buffalo grow.

  32. MJWorthington

    1 ratings12345
    Feb 28th, 12:44

    Actually it's buy local, sell global....keep your money here and bring outsider's money in ;)

  33. sbrof

    0 ratings12345
    Feb 28th, 12:49

    I would argue that we spent the last 20 years throwing money away into national and international companies. The big suburbanization that the region went through not only strained our resources but sent much of the money out to corporate headquarters in NYC, Atlanta, Tennessee etc etc. We need to work with the global economy to sell as many products as we can to other markets. But once that money gets here. We need to keep it as long as possible. We watched the global economy ripe the heart and soul out of our economy because on the global scale of things we are not that important.

  34. WholeLottaJibbaJabbah

    0 ratings12345
    Feb 29th, 09:34

    yeah chocolateshake, thanks to your wonderful global economy we have a beautiful strip of land rotting away full of rusted metal and toxic waste hugging Lake Erie from South Buffalo through Lackawanna and into Hamburg. Yeah when jobs are exported else where you're kinda screwed. As the last 2 post's said. Bring the global money here, and not have outsiders come in and squeeze more money out. MJWorthington, the last line about thinking local and F*ing global. Its from a song, I was getting a bit passionate, so to re-correct you. It's still THINK LOCAL, FUCK GLOBAL.

Would you like to subscribe to this conversation?

Enter your email below, and you will receive an alert each time someone leaves a comment on this post.

What Do You Think?

Text Links