The Marble Garden

The Marble Garden

Story Options

Back in October we posted on the possible reuse of marble that had been discarded out along the Outer Harbor (see post). For years this marble graveyard was enjoyed by artists in the area who would grab chunks and turn them into sculptures. When the NFTA came across the ruins from the old Saint Joseph's New Cathedral (see photo), a decision was made to crush the remains. When artist Jane Stevenson discovered that the marble was being dropped into a crusher, she notified NFTA's Executive Director Larry Meckler about the missed opportunity. Shortly after, the crushing was called off and a plan was set in motion to come up with an alternative use for the remnants.

Since that time a model was created that shows the plan for the placement of the marble along the Outer Harbor. The two installations (actually considered one with a solid connection) are positioned next to the bike trail, and a walking path extends from the trail up along the turf base of the project. The intention of the creation is to design a destination for people who walk, jog, blade and bike the Outer Harbor. It's a thoughtful homage to the condemned church while creating a visually appealing stopping point along the water. Along with an un-obscured vista out onto the lake, the project will offer a resting place people. I called Jane Stevenson to ask her about the vision and she had this to say:

3-D-model-of-Marble-Garden.jpg “I drew the design in collaboration with Oscar Traynor, a landscape architect (and licensed architect). I volunteered my time in order to save the marble that so many of us artists were in fear of losing. The scale of the marble in the model is 1":10'. The actual marble will be very large artifacts… Gothic fragments… columns and decorative motifs. A lot of the pieces will have to be reassembled to make up a full column. There will be a 10'x10' freestanding wall with a ‘window’ that will be arranged with two of the marble thresholds from the old cathedral… along with a quatrefoil block. I'm proposing a paving stone path that will connect the installation, but due to funds it might also be gravel… the more solid the better. The path that connects two sites should be expressed with a solid graphic line… that would be an ideal scenario for the marble garden. Along with the trees that will be found between the two stations I have proposed an arrangement of several turf lounging chaises. The marble garden stretches over a distance of 400’ and will create a large area for multiple groups to congregate. It creates a promenade for people to enjoy the lake. It's designed to give people more appealing places to sit, rest or perch other than your typical park bench. I tried to create private spaces and sensual surfaces for people to interact with. Also I framed the views so that the space would lend itself to photographs people might take there. This installation was designed with little or no cost involved since there is no real budget. The NFTA welcomed us to do this and gave us the site plans with elevations. Now we will be taking back the proposal to the NFTA. We’re pleased with the outcome especially considering that the project is virtually cost-free."

digulios

What Others Have To Say

  1. KittyKat

    2 ratings12345
    Jan 8th 2008, 16:07

    What a wonderful reuse for one of Buffalo's architectural relics! Not to mention the shock that it went relatively, if at all, unopposed!

  2. bison716

    0 ratings12345
    Jan 8th 2008, 16:11

    Great proposal! I like it, i say we go with it!

  3. BackInBuffalo

    4 ratings12345
    Jan 8th 2008, 16:44

    excellent idea! beautiful AND room for hundreds of politicians to stand around and knock their heads against the cold marble reality of life in Buffalo progressing without them...

  4. LivingForge

    3 ratings12345
    Jan 8th 2008, 16:52

    I love that the NFTA's response to finding out that people were making use of valuable materials on the waterfront was to immediately send some big equipment and commence crushing.

    If I owned a theatre company here I'd never be able to produce any absurdist plays because the audience wouldn't be able to discern them from realism.

  5. davvid

    1 ratings12345
    Jan 8th 2008, 16:56

    I have never heard of Jane Stevenson or Oscar Traynor and I cant seem to find their websites through google. Does anyone have any info on previous work done by this artist or a link to a website?

  6. bison716

    1 ratings12345
    Jan 8th 2008, 17:34

    This is all I found. Nothing much. http://www.ap.buffalo.edu/architecture/people/critics.asp

  7. 300miles

    0 ratings12345
    Jan 8th 2008, 18:50

    What a cool idea ! :)

  8. zenfur

    2 ratings12345
    Jan 8th 2008, 18:57

    This made me think of the great Odette Sculpture Park, along the Detroit River in Windsor. Its very narrow, but extends a few miles with pavillions, benches, a biking/running trail, and dozens of huge sculptures.

    I love the idea of many sculptures along the trail!

  9. buffaloed

    0 ratings12345
    Jan 8th 2008, 21:16

    Delightful! This is such a cool use for these discarded materials. Next time we demolish a church we'll call in Michael Gainer from ReUse to take it apart. Now here's the big question: If someone demolished a cathedral and the contractor dumped the stuff at this location, could there be other relics of Buffalo's architectural history buried here too? What if Erie County Savings Bank was located here too? The Larkin Building? The original pergola, conservatory, and carriage house from the Darwin Martin House? The possibilities for excavation here are endless.

  10. sbrof

    0 ratings12345
    Jan 8th 2008, 21:24

    sounds perfect...

  11. al-alo

    0 ratings12345
    Jan 8th 2008, 21:51

    two airports, one metro line, a bunch of busses and now pompeii.

  12. ntdrew

    0 ratings12345
    Jan 8th 2008, 22:19

    great idea!!!

  13. chris69

    0 ratings12345
    Jan 8th 2008, 23:57

    the cathedral was huge.....do they think that all their going to find and salvage is single digit pieces?

  14. RisingDamp666

    1 ratings12345
    Jan 9th 2008, 00:47

    I would rather see something more "Southern Gothic" be done here: a secret garden overgrown with ivy and briars with these remnants tucked away to be discovered as a kind of mystic ruin. I don't get the connection between rubble and manicured paths and these bizarre tableaux. It would be like carefully placing saved columns from the World Trade Center along the Henry Hudson Parkway. Less emotional, but just as weird.

  15. nonono

    2 ratings12345
    Jan 9th 2008, 05:17

    i didnt read a word of this story and i dont really understand any of the posts but GREAT JOB NEWELL !!! ;-)

    and less negativity from everyone else please!

    Q> will this stone hedge be inside or outside the parking area of jim kellys retractable doom stadium?

  16. icecreamsub

    0 ratings12345
    Jan 9th 2008, 08:15

    I believe a marble bust of a shirtless Jim Kelly will be erected just outside the entrance way to the new stadium.....and what about all that sea glass out there on the shores? what can we do with that?

  17. nonono

    3 ratings12345
    Jan 9th 2008, 08:36

    shirtless Jim Kelly erect on the beach???? i think we all know what you wanna do with your marbles.

  18. nonono

    3 ratings12345
    Jan 9th 2008, 08:37

    shirtless Jim Kelly erect on the beach???? i think we all know what you wanna do with your marbles.

  19. icecreamsub

    0 ratings12345
    Jan 9th 2008, 12:58

    keep your mind inside your zubaz, nonono

  20. MJWorthington

    0 ratings12345
    Jan 9th 2008, 17:03

    drag the remnants of the front of the Aud down there to in some form. We can create a walk of high quality material facades that we tore down. Go steal Baird Point back from UB North too. You'll be taking the only thing of significance off the campus, put I don't think anyone will care.

    Anybody racing through on the redone elevated Rt 5 can give it a quick acknowledgment.

  21. RisingDamp666

    1 ratings12345
    Jan 10th 2008, 01:19

    Create a dynamic underwater park for snorkelers by throwing the marble remnants into the lake. Invite the Discovery Channel to turn the festivities into a documentary. Gain 3 minutes of national exposure and notoriety. Follow with forty years of moist-eyed angst over "lost Buffalo". Repeat...with Coit House.

Would you like to subscribe to this conversation?

Enter your email below, and you will receive an alert each time someone leaves a comment on this post.

What Do You Think?

Text Links