Idea For An Additional UB Campus

Idea For An Additional UB Campus

Story Options

Submitted by John Herring:

I am a relatively new transplant to Buffalo, and just wanted to drop a quick note to suggest what might be an interesting story which could combine a couple of issues.

It is my understanding that UB is interested in developing a "third campus," and that there is a preference for it to be more nearly downtown than the Amherst campus. That of course implies a need for a considerable amount of space, which would, ideally, be convenient to relatively low cost housing, public transportation, amenities, grocery stores, and the like.

I suggest that consideration be given to UB taking over the Richardson State Mental Hospital. The building is a serious gem of architecture- perhaps one of the best works of one of the top architects in American history. It deserves to be preserved if at all possible.

Many of the factors which make such preservation problematic actually would work to the advantage of its adaptive reuse as a university campus. The size would become an asset, rather than a barrier to private development. It is close to reasonable housing, public transport, and all the rest.

The cost of renovating the building would of course be considerable- but would it be that much more than the cost of developing the third campus from scratch elsewhere?

Of course not all the facilities of a university would readily fit into one renovated building, but such space eating uses as classrooms, faculty and staff offices, studio space, and even dormitory rooms might well be manageable. And, I suspect that some original thinking would allow for the adaptive reuse to handle some other uses as well. And, of course, it should be possible to renovate in stages, so that the preservation can be started quickly and be done in stages.

Were this to come to pass, one benefit would be that funds for university construction would be doing double duty- also serving as major historic preservation funds. And, of course, UB could end up with a distinctive "signature" building likely to be far more impressive than any new building. Also, of course, the "branding" possibilities are significant.

I hope you agree that this suggestion is worth investigation from both city officials and UB.

Rock Harbor

What Others Have To Say

  1. bison716

    0 ratings12345
    Apr 8th 2008, 15:51

    hmmmm... interesting.

  2. NSphere

    2 ratings12345
    Apr 8th 2008, 15:53

    Its not downtown and UB has already taken strides with new purchases downtown (ie M Wile factory). Sorry, but it doesn't make much sense to me to have two SUNY schools next door to each other either. It makes much more sense for UB to build on their (albeit limited) presence downtown already.

  3. Biniszkiewicz

    0 ratings12345
    Apr 8th 2008, 15:55

    It's pretty confusing to outsiders for us to have two SUNY schools, Buff State and UB, in the same city. Can you imagine if they were next to one another?

  4. Biniszkiewicz

    0 ratings12345
    Apr 8th 2008, 15:58

    NShpere: beat me to it.

  5. sbrof

    1 ratings12345
    Apr 8th 2008, 16:02

    agreed, UB's future is downtown, Richardson is an obvious expansion for Buff state or the next cultural attraction. Thinking about it as a UB campus is foolish when the biggest bang for our buck is to continue to grow and nurture UB+BNMC.

    UB would never ever consider this an option, it only started to think about downtown because of its highly entrenched faculty into all of the medical institutions (roswell, hauptman-woodward, Buffalo General etc.) Without those connections maybe it could have been an option but this is too far out there.

  6. chris69

    5 ratings12345
    Apr 8th 2008, 16:12

    Sorry but I canot even believe this was posted and worth consideration and discussion. Buffalo State is turning down 10,000 students per year and if plans were made to grow Buffalo State in partnership with UB then Buffalo State could easily expand to Forest, to not just Grant but Niagara, as well as Tonawanda and Amherst.

    There was just a post about Buffalo State needing to add 1k to 2k worth of student housing though maybe only 500 will be on campus dorms.

    Buffalo State needs to expand its programs, expand its labs and its small business incubators, etc. The last thing Buffalo State needs is UB sharing its campus......THOUGH THERE IS ONE AND ONLY ONE WAY THAT WOULD WORK BUT IT WOULD NOT BE A UB CAMPUS PURSAY..AND THAT WOULD BE A BUFFALO STATE/UB PARTNERSHIP OR A BUFFALO STATE/CANISIUS PARTNERSHIP IN SAY COMPLEMENTARY PROGRAMS AND COMPLEMENTARY RESOURCES.

    There are only two real options other than the Fruit Belt for a future UB campus (which must be along a future light rail route and close to the city). They would be the warehouse area around the Central Terminal or Lackawanna adjacent to the Basilica and South Park but I would hold the carrot out to Lackawanna that if they want UB and a light rail extension and brownfield redevelopment then they should merge with the City of Buffalo. TO ME IF THERE EVER IS A 4TH UB RESEARCH CAMPUS ON A LIGHT RAIL ROUTE THEN ITS GOING SOMEWHERE IN SOUTH BUFFALO/LACKAWANNA.

  7. sbrof

    0 ratings12345
    Apr 8th 2008, 16:14

    transportation considerations also need to be understood, the lgiht rail already connects South Campus and the BNMC, and ideally could get extended to north creating a unified, efficient and sustainable transportation link between all campuses that can handle the huge amounts of capacity needed now and after UB grows. This would be simply too disjointed to be schedule classes reliably and except that the thousands of out of state and international students who rely on public transit to get to this campus.

  8. LivingForge

    1 ratings12345
    Apr 8th 2008, 16:16

    UB needs to further nurture the BNMC and move from there into the Mid City/East Side area. That way there's a chance that they can meet Canisius halfway, providing something of a link from UB South to Canisius to UB BNMC (with Artspace and Coe Pl thrown in for good measure).

  9. Geomike

    3 ratings12345
    Apr 8th 2008, 16:30

    John nice idea I love it, and welcome to town. Though, to the credit of other posts, it is confusing 2 SUNY Buffalo's, but Buffalo is a bit of an enigma itself. Buff State will never have the capital that UB does to move into Richardson, or else they would have jumped on that by now. Yes UB should be near the BNMC, but for them to move into the fruitbelt would displace residents, and I don't think that would be good for the neighborhood, and it would take away properties from the tax roll. Now the HH Richardson is in a solid community, next to the 198, room to build dorms, gorgeous grounds not like UB Amherst, and it's not on the tax rolls. And if you put UB and BuffState next to each other I'd tend to bet students could take classes from both schools, that other doesn't offer, the professors could collaborate, and the odds of HH Richardson going dark again would be much less than if a thinly funded cultural org. took the space. The BNMC is doing fantastic things and will continue to grow with UB's support regardless of where it's "downtown" campus is. I think we just need to keep all options on the table and keep an open mind. John, if you want to share the idea with John Simpson (UB Pres) I'm sure he'd be receptive to an e-mail or letter with your suggestion.

  10. Joshua

    0 ratings12345
    Apr 8th 2008, 16:55

    Interesting idea, but I don't see UB expanding next to Buff State. It's too close, plus the parking at Buff State can be congested at times.

    UB need to be downtown. Downtown will expand when UB starts work. Students, teachers and guests will spend money downtown. The possibly more expansion will happen.

  11. LastCall

    2 ratings12345
    Apr 8th 2008, 16:56

    whoa, whoa, whoa! Chris69 - Let's figure out the 3rd UB campus downtown before we start to get ahead of ourselves. UB-Lackawanna? Get real. I don't think that UB is looking around at Buffalo and trying to pick places to build up and re-energize(South Park? Lackawanna?). Rather, the whole pupose of this 3rd campus is to link an important part of their school with the medical corridor, not recreate Buffalo's own version of the SUNY system. Anyway, I like John's idea, but I don't think UB is the right school to move in there. It seems like a great scenario for Buff State to take advantage of though

  12. BuffaloRox

    1 ratings12345
    Apr 8th 2008, 16:57

    UB's third campus is downtown in Trico/M. Wile to Buffalo Niagara Medical Campus. Welcome to Buffalo! Next time you might want to run your article by Newell or someone else who's been around. Lots of recent media coverage. Google "UB 2020" to see more about UB's plans.

  13. hamp

    3 ratings12345
    Apr 8th 2008, 17:04

    Thanks for the post. I was thinking that UB and Buff State should just merge, and make the main campus on Elmwood. Then think of the domino effect. UB Main Street becomes Millard Fillmore College and ECC North. Downtown becomes the medical school and all health sciences including pharmacy. The Amherst Campus is converted to a high tech incubator/office park. Done.

  14. mjman4

    0 ratings12345
    Apr 8th 2008, 17:13

    there have been rumors about Buff States interest or lack there off in this property for years. Proximity and value do not always make good bed fellows.... if Buff State were to COMPETE with UB it would be an iconic shift and strategy, but they are the same system, one a college and the other a research university. I have also heard that this would make a good nursing school...as we do have a shortage of nurses, and our nursing intstitutions have closed in recent years, maybe this would fit...

    My vote would be to sink the 100 million into it and argue for the next 50 years on which porgram would best suite Elmwood ave....maybe even rerouting Elmwood so we can have it right on the dang sidewalk!!!

  15. chris69

    3 ratings12345
    Apr 8th 2008, 17:18

    Lastcall, Buffalo is in need of another 1-2 Centers for Excellence which means 1-2 locations for a combination research facility and office/light industrial park that has access to light rail. UB South Buffalo/Lackawanna would not a place to have classes in that sense but would be more like the BNMC campus except non-medical.

    South Buffalo has alot of manufacturing, warehouse, distribution, material science, power generation etc corporations and so its an ideal location for say a COE for Power Generation/Distribution, a COE for Material Science/Nanotechnology, a COE for International Trade & Logistics, etc.

    Buffalo is stupid if it thinks it can build its commercial and industrial renaissance on only one type of Center for Excellence (Medical). Buffalo needs to diversify and grow multiple technologies, multiple paths of research, multiple products and services, multiple industries....

  16. RonR

    3 ratings12345
    Apr 8th 2008, 17:49

    Why not just help Buff State expand on the current site. They have 10k students now, why not find way to have them grow another 5k-10k in terms of enrollment?

    Posted it before, but when ECMC is closed, move the mental hospital there and convert the hospital to a hotel/meeting center and build a hotel management school at Buff State. Push the campus all the way to the 198 and to Forest Ave. and GROW GROW GROW.

    Maybe convert the HH Richardson to a combo of Fraternity and Sorority Housing and Graduate student housing. Not sure if the building could be sectioned off but WOW I would live on campus if that was an option.

    With the pending hopes of UB downtown, D’Youville College needing to expand and Canisius growing at a healthy place maybe the key to the future of Buffalo is becoming "College Town USA" so to speak.

    Provide incentives for Buffalo State and D'Youville to become more of a resident college instead of staying commuter schools and life will flush back into the city. The schools, as they grow, create good paying jobs and bring in educated residents to the region AND these jobs are not on the back of the already over burdened taxpayer.

    In short...LOVE the concept of the expansion but as Buff State and not UB.

  17. NorthBuff

    1 ratings12345
    Apr 8th 2008, 19:06

    UB campus expansion belongs downtown in medical campus vicinity where it should have gone years ago. Buffalo State should expand west toward 198 (tons of vacant land). As for Richardson, all original buildings must be preserved and renovated, level everything else except Birchfield. As for reuse of the Richardson complex, I would love to see an architectural museum and learning center similar to Frank Lloyd Wright’s Taliesin School of Architecture with the remaining property returned to its original green space.

  18. RonR

    1 ratings12345
    Apr 8th 2008, 19:46

    NorthBuff.

    I love any idea on the reuse of the Richardson. Just with a building that grand, don't you think it should be used more. Museum hours are not full use. Housing, while cutting it off from the public, would IMO tie this generation to the past. Who knows what student would be inspired from their time there. At least it would be used 24/7.

  19. Downtownjunkie

    2 ratings12345
    Apr 8th 2008, 19:49

    I think this is a wonderful idea definitely worth exploring more. The synergy college students create in urban areas cannot be underestimated. When national developers consider huge lifestyle shopping areas in urban areas the major thing they look for is the amount of students located around the area. I mean you can see it with Buff State students and Elmwood avenue. Locating the majority of UB in Amherst is always looked at as such a bad mistake mainly because the thousands of students are isolated from everything. Instead of shooting this idea down rite away look at some examples of vibrant urban areas..not just huge cities but vibrant livable cool areas around the country...what is the one variable Boston, Philly, Burlington, Columbus and many more i cant think of off the top of my head have??..they all have not just a couple thousand but tens of thousands of students from many different colleges and universities all clustered within the same area. These students have disposable income that they woul dlove to spend at trendy stores clubs boutiques etc...as of now teh tens of thousands of UB students are relegated to shop at the Galleria... I know there will be many negative remarks toards this post but i think if anything I would love to see this conversation discussed more in depth especially with maybe some insight form area leaders and especially Robert Shibley and John Simpson from UB and others.

  20. Downtownjunkie

    1 ratings12345
    Apr 8th 2008, 19:50

    I think this is a wonderful idea definitely worth exploring more. The synergy college students create in urban areas cannot be underestimated. When national developers consider huge lifestyle shopping areas in urban areas the major thing they look for is the amount of students located around the area. I mean you can see it with Buff State students and Elmwood avenue. Locating the majority of UB in Amherst is always looked at as such a bad mistake mainly because the thousands of students are isolated from everything. Instead of shooting this idea down rite away look at some examples of vibrant urban areas..not just huge cities but vibrant livable cool areas around the country...what is the one variable Boston, Philly, Burlington, Columbus and many more i cant think of off the top of my head have??..they all have not just a couple thousand but tens of thousands of students from many different colleges and universities all clustered within the same area. These students have disposable income that they woul dlove to spend at trendy stores clubs boutiques etc...as of now teh tens of thousands of UB students are relegated to shop at the Galleria... I know there will be many negative remarks toards this post but i think if anything I would love to see this conversation discussed more in depth especially with maybe some insight form area leaders and especially Robert Shibley and John Simpson from UB and others.

  21. impressingagent

    0 ratings12345
    Apr 8th 2008, 20:47

    buffalo state needs to find a way to split some of this property up, its large enough to have a war on.

  22. InTheBuffalo

    0 ratings12345
    Apr 8th 2008, 21:35

    I think if any school should move into the complex, it should Buffalo State and not UB. One idea that that I think UB should look at is moving the Law School to downtown. That way law students would be right there with all the courthouses(including the Federal Courthouse which is currently under construction) and major law firms. In addition, it would bring hundreds of pre-professions into the downtown core, many of whom may stay upon graduation.

    As I understand it, the Law School used to be located downtown, but moved to Amherst when North Campus was built. It's time to move it back downtown. With UB's student population expansion plans the space on North Campus could easily be used for undergraduate classes. UB Law school should be part of reemergence of Downtown Buffalo and with the ambitious UB 2020 plan under way the time is right to get it done.

  23. lanie4545

    3 ratings12345
    Apr 8th 2008, 21:46

    InTheBuffalo, I disagree that the law school should be moved downtown. Who wants a bunch of drunkard law students bumbling around downtown; we have enough chaos. Plus, I doubt law students would add much to the economy aside from late nite boozing and late night food. We should put the medical and pharmacy schools downtown. These students will be more respectful, and create a positive atmosphere. Also, these students' incomes will be much higher than those who study law in the end.

  24. cpm6

    0 ratings12345
    Apr 8th 2008, 21:59

    I don't understand. Everyone agrees that Buffalo State should expand into the Richardson. It makes perfect sense almost every way that you look at it. But why doesn't Buff State just do it or at lease propose to do it. Personally, as an architecture student, I feel that architecture and planning should be moved to downtown. The large spaces in the old warehouse builds would be amazing studio spaces for every year of study. Also a very urban environment would be great inspiration. Also if anyone knows us arch students, we are up at all hours of the nights, and this would give downtown its 24 hour aspect with lots of students living and working downtown, at least during the semester.

  25. Quaker

    0 ratings12345
    Apr 8th 2008, 22:08

    lanie4545, I'm sorry you had a bad experience trying to get into law school, but do you really have to take it out on the law students? I'm not a law student but I feel as though such an gross exaggeration may call for a suit on the premise of libel. Having law students downtown will add more youth to the city, and, last I checked, drunkards help out the economy as well (they buy drinks).

  26. buffalostan

    1 ratings12345
    Apr 8th 2008, 22:17

    why don't buff state and UB split the thung up and make a double school campus?

  27. reflip

    0 ratings12345
    Apr 8th 2008, 22:18

    Watch out for the unfrozen cavemen law students. But remember - they're actually more afraid of you than you are of them.

    Also, I've seen lots of pharmacy students bumbling around downtown. But they bumble heavy.

  28. InTheBuffalo

    1 ratings12345
    Apr 8th 2008, 22:48

    lanie4545, that was one of the most uninformed statements I have ever read. I for one am a law student, who doesn't drink, and does spend a lot of money in the city of Buffalo. I have too much work to do with school and a job to waste nights getting drunk and the the next day hungover. I don't know how you can characterize an entire population in such a way. I don't know if you had a bad expirience, but all the Law students I know act in no way similar to way you described.

    Also, you don't think that the law school should be located downtown because you think the medical school be. I also feel that the medical school should be located at the Medical Campus downtown. That, however, in no way precludes the law school from moving downtown near the courthouses. Last time I checked the City of Buffalo needs any high paid professionals it can get. That includes doctors, pharmacists, researchers, architects, and Lawyers etc.

  29. RisingDamp666

    1 ratings12345
    Apr 8th 2008, 23:05

    The University of Lackawanna has already put in a bid on the site, as has Tonawanda State. East Aurora Women's College passed, over security concerns. Perhaps UB will show some interest but their psychiatric facilities are much newer than this and already serves a much larger population.

  30. RonR

    1 ratings12345
    Apr 9th 2008, 01:20

    How are the chicks at EAWC damp. I hear they are HOT HOT HOT!!!!

  31. SLEEPL8

    1 ratings12345
    Apr 9th 2008, 09:22

    I think it's quite obvious that UB is looking to expand on the Buffalo NIagara Medical Campus. The Richardson complex is in close proximity to Buffalo State and it would make no sense to have two campuses on top of eachother. Also, with the expansion to the BNMC this move would create a fourth UB campus which is not the goal.

  32. SLEEPL8

    1 ratings12345
    Apr 9th 2008, 09:31

    I think it's quite obvious that UB is looking to expand on the Buffalo NIagara Medical Campus. The Richardson complex is in close proximity to Buffalo State and it would make no sense to have two campuses on top of eachother. Also, with the expansion to the BNMC this move would create a fourth UB campus which is not the goal.

  33. magnum

    2 ratings12345
    Apr 9th 2008, 10:34

    ROFL all these double posts, when is the site going to be fixed. At the very least, how about a statement indicating that your message has been recieved and there is no need to click again. This site, like so many things in Buffalo, only required a simple fix, yet for some reason, it doesn't get done.

  34. RonR

    3 ratings12345
    Apr 9th 2008, 11:16

    Magnum,

    Are you a developer? From what I can see BRO is either run on a custom CMS or a hack on a base CMS. The features that make this site work are not standard. If you want to see standard, venture over to WNYmedia. They are based on Joomla and Wordpress and have a HORRIBLE load time.

    I also do not see a charge for this site or a request for development funds. Are you willing to pay for the time to "fix" the bug? The advertising is done tastefully and IMO barely noticeable. Do you want pass windows or pop ups like those found on the national news sites?

    Like so many things in Buffalo, there are a lot of people who bitch about what is broke but very little who do anything to fix the issue other than point out what is wrong.

    Just saying..........

  35. stitchsaidso

    0 ratings12345
    Apr 9th 2008, 12:19

    an idea i had in design school where we redesigned portions of the city was to encorperate a ecc master campus on the vacant land west of buff state or to the south on the old hostpital......an art institute facing elmwood?. the mental institutions elmwood facing side would be great place to do that and have an entire cooridoor of art museums college space, right at the mouth to elmwood villiage....consolidation of the parceled lands along the 198 and blocks of abonded homes or homes below the 10,000 dollar price tag could be consoldated into master area of buff state ecc master campus and a possible art institute. this would boost propert values and give home woners new choices in teh demographics they rent to slowing or stopping urban decay as well as give a huge boost to the elmwood villiage. p.s. theres room for an above ground subway line to run the back portion of buffstate along niagara street to downtown...since it would cost too much to run one underground down any main street, just a fleeting thought

  36. nb3004

    0 ratings12345
    Apr 9th 2008, 12:29

    my guess with the double comments would be because people are double-clicking the add your comment button.

  37. InTheBuffalo

    0 ratings12345
    Apr 9th 2008, 12:46

    Whatever happens, part of the plan should be to knock down that ugly brick Buff State building whick blocks the view of the Richardson Complex from Elmwood Ave.

  38. tormaplf67

    0 ratings12345
    Apr 9th 2008, 12:59

    Very Interesting discussion. As many of you are aware UB is in the midst of a very comprehensive and rightly ambitious strategic planning process called UB 2020. Yesterday, President Simpson addressed a gathering at Alumni Arena to provide an update to the process of where UB is and where it hopes to go. I have lived in this area for twenty years, and for the first time I feel that projects affecting the region might actually come to fruition.

    I have heard no mention of UB proposing a merger with Buff State. Yet such a merger could contribute to at least two other centers of excellence: Education, and the Arts. UB may have great programs and facilities, but imagine what a combined program could look like housed in the Museum District.

    UB also has proposed growing by up to 10,000 more students. There seems to be an economy of scale, or size matters. But this increase is going to become perhaps more challenging as the number of high school seniors begin to decline in the next several years. So if Buff State and UB were combined into a single entity, could there not be benefits to both as well as the region?

  39. mpfaix

    0 ratings12345
    Apr 9th 2008, 13:55

    The Richardson Center Corporation is holding a public meeting next Wednesday, April 16th at the Buffalo and Erie County Historical Society. Please join us for updates on planning and stabilization efforts for the Richardson Olmsted Complex. The master planning work is now beginning, both for the entire complex and for the Architecture and Visitor Center.

    Updates on the Historic Structures and Cultural Landscape reports will be provided by architects Goody Clancy. The selected master planning firm will be present to outline the course of the master planning process for the next 10 months. Combined, these two important documents will provide a foundation and roadmap for the Richardson Olmsted Complex.

  40. SLEEPL8

    0 ratings12345
    Apr 9th 2008, 16:04

    sorry for the double posts

  41. SLEEPL8

    0 ratings12345
    Apr 9th 2008, 16:07

    sorry for the double posts

  42. Biniszkiewicz

    0 ratings12345
    Apr 9th 2008, 16:11

    mpfaix: what time on the 16th?

  43. ToughintheStreets

    0 ratings12345
    Apr 9th 2008, 16:35

    off topic: What is it with the hatred on this ite for any demographic that may or may not frequent chippewa and the distaste for that street in general?

  44. AtwaterLouse

    2 ratings12345
    Apr 9th 2008, 17:15

    RonR - People are doing BR a favor by pointing out the recent severe sluggishness of the site. Just because you haven't noticed it doesn't mean it's not happening.

  45. mpfaix

    0 ratings12345
    Apr 9th 2008, 21:23

    Richardson Center Corporation public meeting next Wednesday, April 16th, 6 PM at the Buffalo and Erie County Historical Society. Thanks for asking about the time.

Would you like to subscribe to this conversation?

Enter your email below, and you will receive an alert each time someone leaves a comment on this post.

What Do You Think?

Text Links