Downtown Buffalo's Revitalization: A Progress Report from the Trenches

Downtown Buffalo's Revitalization: A Progress Report from the Trenches

Story Options

By now most of you who read this are aware that our oft-maligned city has been undergoing a dramatic rebirth in the last few years. As a Commercial Real Estate Agent it has been exciting to watch and participate in the revitalization process and I thought it would be interesting to give you a report from the trenches, literally.

First though, for those who need a quick refresher course, Buffalo has been a city mired in a spiral decline dating back to the end of the great steel mill era. A steady loss of population and decades of bad press badly bruised the psyche of all those who dwell here and hope was in short supply. Nothing typified the region's ills more than the downtown area itself: sparsely populated and generally deserted after the 9 to 5-ers hit the road to the 'burbs, downtown stood as the symbol of the desperate region.

Fast forward to the present, where the tangible evidence of progress is unmistakable. There has been a veritable explosion in the apartment market with many still in the works. Public outcry for condominiums has developers scrambling for sites to fulfill the demand. Several major projects are also underway such as the rehab of the regal Statler Towers and the former AM&A's Building, fueling a steady rise from the ashes.

chris_wrap.jpgThe most notable result of all this activity has been the increased amount of people calling downtown their home. People make up the fabric of any city and finally Downtown Buffalo has enough of a healthy population to take revitalization to the next step, the development of service and retail infrastructure in order to sustain these new settlers. For now downtown is lacking in many of the perceived essentials, including a large supermarket type food store, retail shops with clothing, a home improvement store as well as simple daily-life services such as dry cleaning or auto repair. With the many new apartment buildings in the works these missing elements will seem more dramatic in the near future. The question is will there be new entrepreneurs to come fill these gaps and if so where will these new business' go?

The most obvious answer for new retail development is Main Street. Not only does it shoulder the majority of the foot traffic, but it also either holds or skirts the bulk of the new apartment projects, old and new. There are many spaces available here for sale or lease, however most that remains are in varying states of blight. The good news, though, is that there are many available programs to help with funding for these projects including Empire Zone benefits, low cost loans (through the Community Preservation Corporation) and various other avenues too many to mention here. These can help ease the developer's burden when it comes time to "crunch the numbers" and decide if a project is feasible.

Of course not all attention needs to be focused on Main Street, as Buffalo prides itself on the wonderful architecture found in it's many busy secondary arteries such as Pearl, Franklin, and Washington Streets (to name just a few) which I feel would also be great places to also land new retail shops (By the way, developers' are also looking into these areas for the next wave of apartment conversions). These smaller streets may also provide the opportunity for specialized areas such as a market or clothing district. The wildly successful Chippewa Entertainment District, for example, illustrates the power businesses can achieve if they band together in a specific geographic area providing similar services.

In summation, it is truly exciting to see Buffalo take its first baby steps towards recovery but there is still a long way to go. While talks of a casino and the beginnings of waterfront plans slowly progress, I feel it is important to service the one area of tangible success the city can boast about, its new residents. Keeping them happy, safe and comfortable will bode well for the long-term success of the Buffalo downtown area.

Chris Malachowski Hunt Commercial Real Estate Corp. 716.880.1914

The above originally published in a recent edition of New York Real Estate Journal. Reprinted here by permission. Founded in 1987, the Journal reaches over 30,000 subscribers weekly. Photo credit: CitySky Photography by Nate Farnsworth.

digulios

What Others Have To Say

  1. jeffrey

    1 ratings12345
    Feb 9th 2007, 08:29

    Good article, Chris!! I agree with you that Main Street should be where businesses locate and then the other streets surrounding it. The sucess of this depends if having cars sharing Main Street will bring postive results. It would be interesting to see where the lofts and other entertainment activities are concentrated.

  2. sbrof

    5 ratings12345
    Feb 9th 2007, 08:50

    said it before, I am still not going to hold my breath that for some reason cars will save downtown...

  3. parkview

    1 ratings12345
    Feb 9th 2007, 08:58

    Chris great article, there is currently a few options for car care downtown, Broad Elm on Broadway and Russo's Auto Service on Oak. Good things are starting to happen.

  4. StreetcarSuburbanite

    3 ratings12345
    Feb 9th 2007, 12:16

    "Public outcry for condominiums has developers scrambling for sites to fulfill the demand." WTF, Am I reading this correctly??

  5. Biniszkiewicz

    4 ratings12345
    Feb 9th 2007, 14:47

    Good work, Chris!

    Streetcar: as another commercial real estate broker, I can verify that yes, indeed, there is a scramble on to identify and develop condo sites downtown. Condos are more difficult than apartments to build profitably. A substantial reason for this is that funds such as tax credits are not available for condos, but sometimes are available for apartments. Development costs, NOT including acquisition costs, seem to be near $100/square foot for most of the projects I've seen lately (nice apartments). It can be hard to make money builidng condos in Buffalo at that price once you add in acquisition costs of the site, but many are seeking the places where it can make sense.

    When City Center was built, the condos sold dismally slowly. Not so anymore. There is a national trend to move back into urban centers. Buffalo is simply getting hit by the same wave other downtowns have been hit by before. Like always, we're a little behind the times compared to the trendsetters, but like always we eventually succomb to the same fashions regarding urbanism and suburbanism. Urban cores nationwide have gotten interesting to those living near them.

    For those readers who think they'd like to try living downtown, a few of the listings Chris has which were highlighted a few days ago in the 500 block would make a great places to set down roots. Specifically, the Stewart and Benson building is interesting: it has 2,000' per floor (three floors), an elevator and full sprinkler system. Especially for someone with a business, this property could be a home run. Great views, good bones, modest size. the Happy Garden building is also a great opportunity. Others are a bit large for most budgets, even if acquisition costs are Very reasonable ($450k for 28k', in the heart of a real downtown? common. That's a Steal!).

    For what it's worth, I have the listing on the old Burger King next door. the owners prefer to lease, not sell. I've heard some complain of excessive rents. Not so. The BK is almost 6,000 square feet. It can be rented for $2,500/mo. plus real estate taxes. That equates to $5/square foot/year net rent. That's cheap. It's less than a quarter of what some office or retail space demands.

    I would add only that we should be enthusiastic not only about downtown, but nearby neighborhoods and Main Street as well. I'm very bullish on Main Street. I honestly think that the whole street, from the Buffalo River to the Amherst border, can be turned around from 'seen better days' to 'OMG, I can't believe how good everything looks'. I do forsee the day when a suburbanite from Clarence Hollow can go to Shea's using only Main Street and feel good and safe the whole way. When that day comes, Buffalo's image (at least in the eyes of local suburbanites) will be significantly boosted.

  6. ALREADYGONE

    1 ratings12345
    Feb 9th 2007, 15:06

    the addition of big box type retailers that evryone seems to want will most like kill all the smaller retailers that the city is relying on to rejuvinate the down town economy. a tops will kill off 30 or 40 smaller food and specialty shops that are the lifeblood of a downtown area non corporate mom and pops are what make a downtown unique. a depot or lowes will kill most home houseware supply bussiness that might have a chance with with the new population influx. and a walmart and you can kiss just about evrything that makes a town unique good by. support the little guy in the food,retail,and home supply..and the city will be that much better off. if big boxes have there way theyll for matt the city into a congested verion of the suburbs only with older houses and smaller lots and evryone will move the f right back to the burbs. i moved away some years back .but am looking at buying a place downtown and i can tell you for sure its not so i can go to home depot. still love buffalo keep moving forward,just remember bigger isnt always better..

  7. ALREADYGONE

    1 ratings12345
    Feb 9th 2007, 15:07

    the addition of big box type retailers that evryone seems to want will most like kill all the smaller retailers that the city is relying on to rejuvinate the down town economy. a tops will kill off 30 or 40 smaller food and specialty shops that are the lifeblood of a downtown area non corporate mom and pops are what make a downtown unique. a depot or lowes will kill most home houseware supply bussiness that might have a chance with with the new population influx. and a walmart and you can kiss just about evrything that makes a town unique good by. support the little guy in the food,retail,and home supply..and the city will be that much better off. if big boxes have there way theyll for matt the city into a congested verion of the suburbs only with older houses and smaller lots and evryone will move the f right back to the burbs. i moved away some years back .but am looking at buying a place downtown and i can tell you for sure its not so i can go to home depot. still love buffalo keep moving forward,just remember bigger isnt always better..

  8. chrismal

    2 ratings12345
    Feb 9th 2007, 15:10

    Just a slight clarification, 472 Main is listing at $399k and is 28k sq ft. 283 Pearl sits behind 472 and could be made part of any project there for additional sq footage, not to mention Pearl Street access. 283 is 12k sq ft and listing at $150k, but the owner is packaging BOTH properties together for $450k, with a grand total of about 40k sq ft.

  9. chrismal

    2 ratings12345
    Feb 9th 2007, 15:11

    Just a slight clarification, 472 Main is listing at $399k and is 28k sq ft. 283 Pearl sits behind 472 and could be made part of any project there for additional sq footage, not to mention Pearl Street access. 283 is 12k sq ft and listing at $150k, but the owner is packaging BOTH properties together for $450k, with a grand total of about 40k sq ft.

  10. MikeJ

    1 ratings12345
    Feb 9th 2007, 17:00

    I am just about to buy a house near Richmond and I hope to move from there in about 5-6 years, to a downtown condo...as a 23 year old college student born and raised in Buffalo helping in Buffalo's rebirth is a dream. This is the goal I have set for myself and I know it can be done!!

  11. kelly

    0 ratings12345
    Feb 9th 2007, 21:05

    a tops will kill off 30 or 40 smaller food and specialty shops that are the lifeblood of a downtown area non corporate mom and pops are what make a downtown unique.

    Seeing as how the mom and pop shops you describe tend to overcharge low-income customers for check-cashing and sell a pathetic selection of foods of dubious quality at prices that are beyond insane, I don't necessarily see this as a bad thing.

    You mean people without cars may be able to get a box of Barilla for $1.50 instead of Aldi-brand pasta resold for $3? Or something that resembles fresh veggies instead of a dusty selection of cans? How horrid for the city that would be.

    Guercio's isn't far from the Tops on Niagara or the Tops on Elmwood, they're doing just fine. Globe market isn't hurting. The only businesses that will be hurt by a major grocery store in an underserviced area are the shady "corner stores" plastered with advertisements for beer and cigarettes.

    And shoot, if the opening of Latina's on Elmwood is any indication, they won't hurt too bad, either. The three corner stores within five blocks are still around (and that's not even counting the Wilson Farms). Their lifeblood isn't groceries, it's smokes and alcohol after the groceries have closed.

    I agree, the last thing we need is, say, a Super Walmart on Main Street downtown. But don't lump grocery stores in with that, it's an entirely different situation.

  12. Charger

    1 ratings12345
    Feb 9th 2007, 23:59

    There is actually a dry cleaner downtown, in the Statler. Also several local dry cleaners, including Elmwood-based Urban Valet, offer delivery throughout Downtown.

  13. karma007

    0 ratings12345
    Feb 10th 2007, 09:54

    I would like to add that a computer services outfit is about to open at 715 Main Street. And that’s a section of Main that you can park or walk right in front of the building.

  14. MRodgers

    0 ratings12345
    Feb 10th 2007, 18:57

    Great artile! And, Kelly - you are SPoT On! The mom/pop stores of today are far from the mom/pop stores of the old days. They push lotto, beer, looseys (cigs), and other items rather than truly service the nutritional needs of the surrounding communities.

    Unfortunately, one comment is unfolding at this very moment. It seems Latina's on Elmwood is due to close. Now, if we could only tak Guercio's into another location...

  15. StreetcarSuburbanite

    1 ratings12345
    Feb 11th 2007, 01:41

    Latina's to close? Where did you hear this from?

  16. kelly

    0 ratings12345
    Feb 11th 2007, 13:31

    It wouldn't shock me, the other locations have mostly closed, and every time I go there it looks like I arrived three hours too late for an end-of-the-world sale. Bare shelves as far as the eye can see.

    I've gone back to shopping at Tops or Wegmans half the time just because I'm sick of needing to make a trip there anyways to get the things I needed that Latinas didn't have in stock. Shoot, I went there a couple weeks ago and they didn't even have any mozzarella cheese in the entire store. No blocks of cheese, no fresh, no processed, no shredded, NOTHING. I couldn't believe it.

  17. MRodgers

    0 ratings12345
    Feb 11th 2007, 14:45

    RE: LATINA'S: A friend of mine that absolutely depends on the location of Latina's on Elmwood experienced the same as Kelly with empty shelves, but also noticed the staff missing a few folks here and there and inquired about what was going on. He was basically told that it is experiencing a slow death.

    To be honest, I was excited when they first opened. But the service level and the product slowly crept back to the days of the end-times during Gay Bells (sorry - that's how I knew it) and Quality (what a contradiction in terms!), so I wasn't surprised when he told me.

    At least Wegman's is somewhat local, being from Rochester, and they do provide excellent service and product. The only issue is getting there for quite a few folks in the area of Latina's. Many have various disabilities that create a hardship compounded by the need for public transportation - and - if they want one or two items, it also presents a problem. People should not have to pay extraordinary prices due to their inability to be mobile. Especially since this group is, on average, of a lower income level.

    If we could only have a full service grocer in that location...that's why I thought it would be great for a second Guercio's. Their clientele comes from all over, including outlying areas like OP, East Aurora, etc. It would hardly impact their current business in a negative fashion. Ever notice their prices are excellent as well as their product? Great local business, indeed!

  18. kelly

    1 ratings12345
    Feb 11th 2007, 16:07

    It's unfortunate... I had such high hopes for them when they opened. My family's Niagara Falls Italian and has been shopping at their smaller import stores for three generations now. I remember going there with my grandmother and mother and being promised a torrone at the checkout counter if I was good. Shoot, I got the jordan almonds and antipasti salad for my wedding at Latina's!

    I just hope they're only scaling back to the smaller stores and not going under completely.

    And Quality... good lord, what a mess that place was. I'd went there a few times, but refused to go back even though I lived only a few blocks away. Ground beef in the cooler case should not have the same shade as a zombie in a Romero film. ugh.

    What is it about that location that can't support a grocery store?? It seems like it would be a sure success!

    I'm fortunate, even though I don't have a car. I can always stop at the University Plaza tops on my way home from work before switching to the train, or even split the $10 return cab ride back to Allentown from Wegmans or Aldi with my roommate if we feel like doing some serious grocery shopping. It just stinks for the people who aren't as mobile as we are, or may be more financially stressed.

  19. MRodgers

    1 ratings12345
    Feb 11th 2007, 22:03

    I think it all comes down to service and product delivery. I'm sure you noticed the customer service level dropped consideralbly after the initial opening. Surly cashiers too busy talking about what they did over the wekend than to pay attention to the customer in line. Now, that's fineif the product you have is top notch (at least for some), but the product line seemed to decline, as well. Then there are the security guards that seemed to pay more attention to a visiting buddy than their duties. It's a shame.

    I think Wegmans should come up with a mini-store concept. Tops has Wilson Farms, but Wegmans could do it much better - and still have their name attached to it rather than using a "ghost."

    Nice taling with you, Kelly.

Would you like to subscribe to this conversation?

Enter your email below, and you will receive an alert each time someone leaves a comment on this post.

What Do You Think?

Members Who Bookmarked

Text Links