Development Update: Club 31
Supper clubs seem to be making a come back. Queenseyes recently let us in on plans for the Scarlet Supper Club on Virginia Place. There,Aeos another one under construction just a few blocks away. Club 31, a 1940,Aeos-style supper club, will be opening next year at 31 W. Johnson Park, corner of S. Elmwood Avenue.
The building is undergoing substantial renovations and joins the West Village neighborhood that is seeing a considerable amount of development including a new office building at 285 Delaware Avenue, The Church, Niagara Center, Statler redevelopment, Buffalo City Tower, New Era Cap headquarters, Dulski Building redevelopment and the planned rehab of the Greystone Hotel into upscale apartments. Mark Croce has talked about recreating Chez Ami, a popular supper club that closed in the 1960,Aeos. The status of that project planned for Franklin Street is unknown. Nostalgia reigns!
Photo Credit: Joe Saccone

Having a tough time deciding on how to spend your weekend? The Buffalo and Erie County Historical Society (BECHS) won’t make your decision making process any easier as they’re offering two great events this coming Saturday and Sunday. December 6th marks their third annual Native American Festival and on December 7th, BECHS will host a Pearl Harbor Remembrance Day that is free to veterans of the armed service. Both days are filled with fun activities and interesting visitors th …
It’s really a shame if you missed the reading series “Poetry at the Tea House” that took place at Tru-Teas! during this past year. Luckily, Trudy Stern didn’t want anyone to miss out and teamed up with Michael Morgulis to produce an incredibly fine, unbound book entitled “Tea Leaves” to commemorate the readings and spread the work of the local poets who partook in the program.
In honor of the publication of this special edition portfolio, Morgulis and Stern are hostin …
I think that I would like to start off this post by commending the three Common Council members who were bold enough to ask for today's bizarre Waterfront Village decision to be tabled. David Franczyk, Mickey Kearns and Mike LoCurto all stuck to their guns when it came to holding off on making any hasty (and potentially tragic) decisions regarding our waterfront. Unfortunately, their headstrong stance was outweighed by the rest of the BURA committee, and the rumors are flying as t …
A development team has been selected for a vacant commercial site in Waterfront Village. Finally. The Buffalo Urban Renewal Agency this morning named Specialty Restaurants Incorporation as preferred developer for the prime 1.4 acre parcel at 10-15 LaRiviere Drive. The owner of the adjacent Shanghai Red’s restaurant is proposing an uninspired, four-story, 100 room Wingate Inn.





Comment Options
helenwheels
This is certainly a welcome business for this area. Added to the mix of the new Termini project at the Graystone, it would seem that South Elmwood will soon have a more desireable look and effect for the city.
Report this
dak
I cannot wait to have supper here! (Though I will sort of miss that fire-engine DJ booth that used to be on Buddy's dancefloor...just kidding.)
Report this
William Zabka All-Stars
Very exciting! Two things:
1) Is this the location of the old Buddies?
2) Can anyone tell me what a "supper club" actually is, other than a fancy word for restaurant?
Report this
dak
When I think of a supper club, I think of tables and/or booths in private rooms with heavy velvet curtains for privacy. Remember that scene in Hello Dolly when Louie Armstrong sings the title song? I also think of big bands, swing or ball room dancing. Somehow supper clubs also make me think of pink champagne cocktails.
Report this
westcoastperspective
ZBAS- Yes, this is the former Buddies location.
Report this
BCB
I have been watching this project closely and it surely has been a major transformation thus far. It's starting to look rather impressive.
Report this
William Zabka All-Stars
WestCoast - thanks for the info.
dak - I DO remember that scene in "Hello Dolly." Nice. But is a supper "club" a private club? Do people have to be members, like with the Buffalo and Saturn Clubs?
Report this
PaulPops
" Can anyone tell me what a "supper club" actually is, other than a fancy word for restaurant?"
It used to be a place open only in the evening, and featuring live music and floor shows. Today, it seems to be just another phrase for restaurant.
Report this
Marilyn R - WVRG
I think of a "supper club" as a "restaurant" with excellent servce, patrons that don't scarf their food down in fifteen minutes or less, music (live or sound system with a low frequency delivery),and provides exceptional plating along with innovative cuisine based on standard fare.
One I have always wanted to go to (but not on my budget) is Buddha Bar in France, where they start as a supper club with low frequency, slow beat ambient music which eventually transforms into a dance club (music level and beat up).
The best one I had the opportunity to go to could be considered a boutique style supper club. Everything was immaculate, the decor set along the 30's to 40's with an academic feel to the dining area.
Service was supreme, and the food - my first bowl of pumpkin -crab soup was there in 2000. I also enjoyed their flash fried calamari rings with a suace of heavy cream, parmesan cheese, and pepperoncini ringlets.
The plating made you feel you shouldn't destroy it by eating.
The funny thing is the name, although located in York, PA, it was "The Left Bank."
Report this
David
Is this Club 31 actually calling itself a supper club or is Buffalo Rising forcing the use of this phrase? Is Mark Croce calling his Chez Ami a Supper Club?
"Supper Clubs seem to be making a come back" The use of this phrase seems a little pretentious.
Report this
Se/+/-or
31 is being fashioned after the original supper club. To me a supper club means "No Wife Beaters". Wash your hands before you eat. No chicken wings. Leave a tip. Hang up your coat. Make a reservation. Don't act like a chucklehead.
Report this
Marilyn R - WVRG
Senor! I LOVE IT! Thanks for the laughs!
Report this
dak
This is the actual location of the original 31 Club, is it not? I do believe that the original 31 Club was known as a supper club. Then it closed down, and eventually became known as Buddies.
Report this
Marilyn R - WVRG
Yup, this was the Club 31. As a matter of fact, I'm waiting for the spirit of the former owner of my home to get wind of this. She normally starts making herself known during the holidays and recently, during WVRG Committee meetings as she was quite the socialite that attempted to revitalize the area back in the '70's.
Have to tell this story...
Last week during a WVRG meeting I noticed a shape out of the corner of my eye along the stairway and front door. Of course, I looked up and then asked if anyone else had seen anything. One of our members saw the same wispy gray shape and I had to assume it was Mrs. Wooley. She loved to have the neighbors over but her husband felt the house was too small to accomodate everyone.
Once she hears her old stomping grounds is back, she'll definitely attempt to get ready "to do lunch." And, I'll have a few extra "wisps" in my sight , again.
Report this
William Zabka All-Stars
So a "supper club" is a place that has "excellent service," "good music," "exceptional plating," "innovative cuisine," "no wife beaters," "no chicken wings," and is a place where you "leave a tip" and "hang up your coat"... that's it?
I've heard of places like that. They're called "restaurants." Have you people ever been to Left Bank? Toro? Tempo? North End Trattoria? Vado Pazzo? Any other number of restaurants in and around the city?
Sounds like David and PaulPops have the right idea - "supper club" just happens to be another (somewhat pretentious?) way of saying "restaurant."
Report this
Baby Teeth
is Cecelia's a Supper Club?
Report this
STEEL
I think you are required to have a martini with diner at a supper club
Report this
Baby Teeth
ah yes a martini...one's finest M Wile suit....prime rib rare..and valet parking for the leased Escalade. Nice
Report this
Ft. Nickerdale
I have been to the Buddha Bar in Paris. Did not know that it was catogorized as a "supper club". There is also one in NYC now. Cool place, great music.
Report this
mmmmunchies - SVRG
I'm headed down to the Jim's Steakout Supper Club right now. I'll be sure to leave my "wife-beater" at home.
Report this
Marilyn R - WVRG
Ft Lauderdale - cool, when did the NYC location open? Is it in Manhattan proper?
Report this
Marilyn R - WVRG
Oooops, sorry, Ft NICKerdale...
Report this
fill
I, too, have wondered about this term "supper club". I rather agree with the writers above who associate live music with such a venue. I think, for example, of a 1940's swing band with singer or singers. The use of the word "supper" rather than "dinner" suggests that lighter fare was served.........Not snack food, of course, but lighter than a full course dinner. I'm thinking here of "Sunday supper", the lighter evening meal following the main dinner served on Sunday early in the afternoon.
Report this
Bizzles
I hate the word "supper" for some reason. It really rubs me the wrong way and I always get annoyed when I hear it. I feel the same way about "meal" too. Weird.
Report this
fill
Bizzles, I don't think it's weird at all. "Meal" has bad associations - we use the phrase "mealy mouthed" as a derogatory description of someone who refuses to speak his mind in plain terms. And then there's McDonalds who taught me to associate "meal" with terrible, unhealthy food ! "Supper" sounds vaguely blue collar and declasse.
Report this
Gabrielle Bouliane
Really, I thought it was more "dinner and a show" kind of thing, round booths with candles, and a bunch of performers doing short skits, very "Cabaret". Now THAT would get me out of the house for longer than just a great meal on fancy china.
Report this
Marilyn R - WVRG
BTW - sorry, wcp, I just noticed the address given - it is N. Johnson Park vs. W Johnson Park.
And, can you believe that a former owner of one of the vintage MDs on the Park actually had a buzzer system installed outside the building that says Johnson Parkway? Now, that's someone who could care less about the properties he had purchased or the history of his buildings.
Report this
Lenny Lambert
WOW!Thisis really a super supper idea. What's your connection, Tony?Please let us knowASAP. Lots of good luck. Happy Turkey and have a wonderful and healthyholidy season. Love,Miki and Lenny
Report this
troy
NYC's supper club: http://www.thesupperclub.com/
Report this