Circles Soften A Streetscape

When the turnabouts were replaced on Richmond Avenue a few years back they brought with them pieces of the city’s long-missing street grid. They slowed traffic, while making the neighborhood more visually appealing. The flowers and the reproduced light standards draw your eye both during the day and at night.
Gates Circle has a flowing water fountain, with benches and globe lighting, that guides people around the circle. Of course Niagara Square has a dramatic center where visitors stop and pay homage to McKinley Monument. Martin Luther King Park has an enormous circle that acts as a congregation area for neighbors who want to relax.
There are a few urban street junctions that come to mind when thinking of the dramatic changes a circle can bring. Then there are junctions like the one outside Forest Lawn Cemetery where asphalt spreads out to all five corners. This is a section of Delaware that could use some ‘softening’ when it comes to its streetscape. There is a lack of greenery as far as the eye can see… and it’s the Delaware entrance to our magnificent Forest Lawn Cemetery. It’s also within eyeshot of Gates Circle. In essence, this should be the pre-entrance to Delaware Avenue.
Then, if you take a look at the main entrance of Forest Lawn at Main, you will see a very similar situation. On the southwest corner sits a strip mall and on the southeast corner is Canisius’ mysterious blue wall that keeps the community at bay. In the middle? An asphalt and concrete jungle. It’s too bad that Forest Lawn has somehow attracted this type of development to its doorstep. It would be nice to see the cemetery’s entrances brought back to their aesthetic roots.

As we mentioned in our previous post, we’re in the process of changing the Buffalo Rising site. We’re almost there as we expect to launch the new site on Friday, December 19th.
In the meantime, posting will be light as we log new stories in the new publishing system which will only be viewable when we launch on Friday.
As always, we appreciate our users’ patience as we make this transition but we promise it will be well worth it. With faster load times, a comment view …
Caroline Kennedy was in town for a visit with our mayor yesterday. A possible choice to succeed US Senator Hillary Rodham Clinton, Kennedy's name has been mentioned along with that of Attorney General Andrew Cuomo (son of former New York Governor Mario Cuomo) and our own Byron Brown, among others.
Certainly, Kennedy has "been around politics" all of her life, which is to say she was born into a family of politicos and lived in the White House--neither of which would necessarily f …
Free light rail rides on downtown's above ground section could be derailed thanks to the Niagara Frontier Transportation Authority's budget mess. That is the news coming out of a Buffalo Place meeting this morning. Facing a budget shortfall and reduced State operating assistance, the NFTA is scrambling for new revenue sources and is contemplating charging for rides along the lengthy downtown pedestrian mall.
Well it is Christmas time in the city and the NFTA helped put people and especially children into the mood in a very festive and fun way. One of my favorite memories of childhood was taking the train downtown with my grandfather. I would gaze out the windows and watch the tunnel speed by. It always felt like we were going a million miles an hour.
Then there was the ability to stand up and walk around during the ride without the need to be strapped down. It was always a fun time … 




Comment Options
al-alo
im a big fan of that restoration.
but what id really love is to make colvin a parkway to the city line. its a wide enough street, and frankly, colvin needs to be made more appealing, otherwise home owners will continue to leave the neighborhood. nobody wants to live on such a busy street, and it seems like there could be some real trash could be making a beachead. i think it could make or break the neighborhood.
and dont give me "youre a racist" bunk. i dont care who is my neighbor, as long as they are realitively quiet and keep up the property. race has nothing to do with it. ive meet plenty of multicolored trash.
Report this
Talkin_Proud
"It would be nice to see the cemetery’s entrances brought back to their aesthetic roots."
Were there circles there that are now missing, or would this be entirely new?
al-alo -- Interesting thought about Colvin. I think the larger problem is and will be Humboldt. Who wants thruway front property?
Report this
UrbanBody
I don't believe a roundabout or landscaped island is the best solution for the dreariness/predicament that is Delevan & Delaware. You've got two gas stations, (poorly maintained) Metro stops, billboards, a drug store, and a huge volume of multi-cross traffic patterns opposing the beautiful Forest Lawn. Smart land use planning decisions should have come into play a long time ago. Now we're certainly stuck with the above for the foreseeable future.
Delevan at Delaware, on the gas station and drug store sides, had large (big enough to block a linebacker) concrete "flower planters" until this spring. I wasn't sorry to see them go because they only contained weeds and tons of litter. I was doing every-other-day cleanups in that area in May/June...and just when I figured that the City?/a block club?, etc. wasn't going to plant them, I was making plans to do it myself ....but then the planters were removed! (Not sure where they ended up.)
My point: Even when softening opportunities are in place---they oftentimes aren't maintained. That district's land owners (Canisius High down to Forest Lawn store) should unite to place flower pots & hangers (and litter barrels) to provide the softening and eye-pleasing scape Queeneyes desires.
Olmsted Conservancy and Elmwood Village do great jobs within their boundaries. The challenge is to get MORE dedicated participation by all business districts/associations to beautify and maintain their districts. In the absence of the above, individuals and ad hoc groups will need to keep up the long, hard fight.
When Uniland gets going with its Gates Circle Tower, I hope it is the catalyst for this part of "The Avenue" to return to its elegance of yesterday.
Report this
al-alo
ah humbolt. what a beauty. do we bury it, a al boston -minus the leaks, bring it back up to grade and make it a parkway (irony anyone?), or just keep the trench that halves the community.
id say another circle at delaware and delavan isnt the craziest idea. though, whenever i run errands on the west side, i already get a little dizzy.
but that corner gets to a urban plannig problem. all of our street corners are deemed to be good locations for gas stations, walgreens and wilson farms. now instead of a building at any corner in the city is occupied by a parking lot or pumps. an easy remedy would be to require any new construction to be faced to the sidewalk on both streets. that rite-aid would be less offensive at the corner of delaware & delavan if it were actually ON the corner, and the parking lot was in the rear.
for that matter, we should just tax the heck out of parking lots placed fronting streets. the parking areas on Norwalk, Forest or Utica all are hidden (for the most part) from street view. imagine how much dead space they would have created if they were entirely fronted on hertel or elmwood. think of that kmart on hertel near delaware! aaaaaaaaaah! what a wasteland!
Report this
Dave
The roundabouts on Richmond are just beautiful, nice lighting and great landscaping. They make Richmond Ave.special again. What ever happened to the idea of a circle on Elmwood near the gallery?
Report this
lulu
I also like the roundabouts on Richmond, but am perplexed how some have yield signs and others have stop signs. To me, a stop sign on a round about defeats the purpose of the round about (regarding traffic patterns only, not aesthetics) so I make it a practice to roll safely through rather than fully stop. A rebel, I know!
Report this
freakster
Please, not another traffic circle! As a cyclist who lives around that corner, I feel that it would just be another hazard for pedestrians and bicyclists to negotiate. In my experience, car drivers often neglect to look for bikes and pedestrians in traffic circles. I cannot count the number of near misses I've had in Gates Circle and on Richmond. Until we can educate drivers to be more careful in general, breaking up the neat street grid on Delaware and Delevan is just asking for trouble.
Report this
Denizen
To those who actually think Humbolt Pkwy will be decked, buried, or re-parked anytime soon, y'all are dreaming. Such a project would require a massive federal transportation subsidy. Buffalo is way below most fed's radar and the actual economic benefit of such a grand project would likely be seen as nil. The lofty goal of "reconnecting one part of the ghetto to another in a has-been city" doesn't exactly bring the big bucks home.
In other words, w'ell be stuck with "the scar" for quite some time to come.
Report this
queenseyes
Point taken freakster. But have you ever tried to cross the street to get into Forest Lawn for a bike ride? It's tough. Yesterday we b-lined it to Saybrook instead of trying to navigate our way to Gates Circle. Forest Lawn has some of the best bike trails in Buffalo, yet getting their is like playing a game of frogger.
Report this
Andrew
I love Richmond and its circles just make it look even better. Delaware & W. Delavan could be an amazing high density intersection if a developer came along and bought out the existing businesses. And Delavan and Main would look a lot better if Canisius allowed local artists to paint murals on that big blue wall.
Report this
Toad
The roundabouts look great and slow down the traffic but people in Buffalo do not know how to drive in them. The Gates Circle rotary is so dangerous. If you are going North on Delaware into the rotary and want to go left onto Chapin Pkwy you almost always take your life into your hands with the cars going south on Delaware into the rotary. I have had almost 4-5 near side impacts of cars that run through the Yield sign going South. I have asked the previous councilman to look into have signs posted that say "Cars in the rotary have the right of way" as they do in the New England states. I see cars in the rotary that have the right of way, stop their cars in the rotary because they are confused by the onslaught of cars entering the cat and mouse game coming from all sides.
A few years ago I saw a small compact car going south on Delaware enter the Gates Circle rotary and hit a big SUV broadside and flip it onto the SUV's roof. This was Thanksgiving Day about 4 years ago.
Someone is going to get killed and I have notified the city about this problem. How much does a sign cost and why can't the police help manage the traffic on the very high traffic circles at 8am and 5pm.
The rotaries are beautiful and historic looking though if you can just survive the trip.
Report this
chris69
We must rebuilt some of the many beautiful fountains and scupltures of the PAN AM EXPOSITION to complement these planned rotaries.
Report this
Spoiled
The rotaries are beautiful tombstones. They are pretty but difficult to cross on foot. Plus they should be single lane. We need to go back to Gate's circle and do something about that mess. People getting off Delaware and staying on the inside lane think they can automatically turn right on the other side to Delaware even if someone is in the outer lane and turning down a different road. People need to read the rules again.
The one on Richmond is pretty too. but have you seen the school kids racing to get across before the cars hit them. The drivers aren't watching and neither are the police.
It would be good to post a sign saying cars in circle have the right of way, in NYS. Many think the on coming traffic has the right of way.
If the drivers are not smart enough and the police not watchful then rotaries should not be used.
Unless...wait I get it...it is a way to make sure the different neighborhoods don't mix!!! because it is too dangerous to cross...I get it.
Report this
TheNextMayor
Nice article.
There are significant differences between traffic circles and roundabouts. Buffalo has neither in pure form. Gates circle is a modified traffic circle. The Richmond circles are modified roundabouts, which partly explains the stop signs located at Ferry Circle. It's too bad the City didn't follow the code and build a true roundabout. At least Olmsted has landscaped them well.
The State DOT has recently built a true roundabout built to code in downtown Niagara Falls.
Statistics show they are safer, are cheaper to maintain, and raise property values. That's why Howard Zemsky would like to build one outside the Larkin Building. He understands the value of them.
Report this
knowledgedableone
Not sure what folk are referring to as they say "circles slow traffic"? Actually the purpose of a roundabout is to speed the flow of traffic (releasing cars from the necessity to yield as you would in a traditional right angle . and allowing the collection of cars to move a t a faster pace. I would imagine that folk are referring to the fact that circles have the ability to slow individual cars.
Although I used to live on Richmond and many a honda all tricked out zoomed up and down the street with rapid frequency. Another one of those quality of life issues we had ought to be wasting police time and capital on!
Report this
RaChaCha
This is just the kind of cool item and idea I love finding on Buffalo Rising, and which Buffalo Rising was started to spark and promote. It seems to me that additional traffic circles would fit right in with the "re-greening" strategies discussed in "Blueprint Buffalo"--a great document (available online) that your Neighbors To The East have looked at adapting for our own fair city. The key is that it's been shown that--all other things being equal--properties located near green features such as parks, parkways, boulevards with planted medians, planted traffic circles, etc. have higher property values. This extends to a degree into surrounding neighborhoods, and such projects can also build community because people have to come together to plan, fund, build, and maintain (just talk with folks from the Kleinhans Neighborhood or WSCC and notice how proud they are of their traffic circle projects). This potential gives a clue to how additional traffic circles could be established: a TIF (Taxpayer Increment Financing) or BID (Business Improvement District) could be established in the project area to raise funds in anticipation of resulting higher property values--making well-thought-out community improvement projects self-financing to a large degree. New York law allows this, but it's hardly ever used in Upstate--we need to change that! So...like-minded folks could get some foundation funding, get involvement from UB planning/architecture, and take a look at the benefits of traffic circles. Such a study could identify some potential locations--like the ones in the posting, or the one proposed for the Larkin District--for some new traffic circles, and also look at issues affecting cyclists, pedestrians, and ADA issues. If the study proves favorable, then do the TIF (or BID), do a pilot project, then lather, rinse, repeat. Perhaps a dozen potential locations spring to mind, so an organized, focused effort could have projects in the works indefinitely, and over time have a measurable impact on the quality of life--and property values--in Buffalo. Best of all, it's building community revitalization on what's uniquely Buffalo! If I hear about such a thing in the works, I'll roll up my sleeves and help.
Report this
zenfur
Richmond roundabouts are lovely, move traffic faster than Elmwood or Delaware lights for sure, and in my experience safe. Maybe the safety is because of lower traffic, maybe because they are usually used as 1-laners....but:
I whole-heartedly concur that the Gates Circle traffic circle is a disaster. Motorists driving on the inner loop routinely cut off drivers directly alongside them. I avoid that circle as much as I can.
Downtown's cirlce in front of city hall is even wider (3 lanes) but there doesn't seem to be the dangerous driving associated with it like Gates. Perhaps because of the mulitple stop lights?
But either way, I agree that Gates needs to be fixed. Someone is going to get killed.
Report this
Martin
so many people do not realize these are 4 way stops, they zoom around them, i love the looks but sometimes they scare me!
Report this
MJWorthington
They are only 4-way stops if marked such. Otherwise you just yield to traffic already in the circle.
Dumbing down the population is not an excuse to not impliment more of these. As mentioned above, add an aditional sign explaining the right of way for those who have forgotten the rules.
They are also safer by removing the number of actual crash senarios, and when one does happen it is usually at a lower speed and smaller angle (no head-on or t-bone impacts.)
Report this
MJWorthington
oh....and paved corners should be outlawed....nothing kills an intersection like that. Let use some imgination people so both pedestrians and drivers both get what they need and everyone was something nice to look at.
anyone see Kensington/Wherle/Harlem in Cheektowaga lately? What use to be a cool intersection in now all asphalt with new drugstores and parking lots at every corner. It now loks like a big empty waste land.
I was certain at one point a circle was supposed to go in there. Imagine if that did happen with a requirement to built up to the street with hidden/side parking. Something nice and unique would have been created instead of big empty lots which will start fading and cracking in a few years.
Report this