Canal Side Plans Expected in December

Canal Side Plans Expected in December

Story Options

Much-anticipated plans for the Canal Side development at the inner harbor should be unveiled soon. Benderson Development is expected to present its master plan and model for the project at the Erie Canal Harbor Development Corporation's (ECHDC) December meeting, tentatively scheduled for December 9th.

Benderson and a Canal Side committee formed by ECHDC have been working with Ehrenkrantz Eckstut & Kuhn on project details. The planning and design firm has been under contract since early 2006 to create design guidelines for the Inner Harbor and Cobblestone Districts.

Canal Side will be anchored by a 150,000-square-foot Bass Pro store that will be constructed on the site of Memorial Auditorium. Demolition and site restoration work, once it begins, will take six months. A contract for the demolition of the Donovan Building should be awarded in January. Clearing the Donovan site will take 60 to 90 days.

Benderson is expected to develop 200,000 to 250,000 sq. ft. of retail space; 60,000 to 80,000 sq. ft. of restaurant and entertainment space; 15,000 to 30,000 sq. ft. of office space; 75,000 to 125,000 sq. ft. of hotel space; and 40,000 to 75,000 sq. ft. of residential space. The exact mix of uses and their locations will be flexible to adjust to market conditions and tenant interest.

Once the plan is released and the scope of the project is defined, the environmental review process will start. Preparation of an Environmental Impact Statement is expected to take six to eight months. Ground breaking for Canal Side and Bass Pro is anticipated for next fall.

In the spring, the City will begin work on nearby street improvements. Plans are also moving forward on a $16 million new parking ramp adjacent to the Marine Drive Apartments. Though design work has not been completed, the facility could be under construction next summer. It will provide parking for Bass Pro, the Inner Harbor and existing Marine Drive residents. The ramp may be one structure with segregated parking or two structures on what is now a surface parking lot parallel to the Skyway.

DSC_0299.jpg

Rock Harbor

What Others Have To Say

  1. wizardofza

    3 ratings12345
    Nov 19th 2008, 00:41

    Bass Pro will never happen. We're in the midst of a major economic depression ontop of the fact that this plan was ridiculous from the get go.

  2. Dangelo23

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 19th 2008, 00:45

    If the auto industry goes, who is going to drive here?

  3. Assaroni

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 19th 2008, 01:57

    once again Buffalo is late to the party...should have done this project years ago when credit was available and projects were greenlit

  4. Dangelo23

    1 ratings12345
    Nov 19th 2008, 02:20

    But what about the "Studies", we had to do the "Studies" on the land, the soil the roads, the birds, etc. ....Before we can do anything in this town.

  5. littleacorn

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 19th 2008, 06:05

    Reading this Buffalo Rising just confirms what I think is personally wrong with the City of Buffalo's and our regional political leadership. Who is anticipating this is what I would like to know? Is it the developers who are going to receive borrowed cash from the local, state and the federal governments. Are they combined with the elected officials who are salivating over the chance to stand at one more PR event in which they will not be held accountable for the financial mess that results five or six years down the road? This is money that none of elected politicians have and will just be borrowed from people who are working, thus incrementally putting the who system more under government debt? The same elected officials who are pushing this project, are the same ones who have managed to take the Empire State and the federal government and bring them to financial turmoil. Years ago, I heard an economist from the University of Chicago speaking about sports complexes in which he concluded his talk by saying that in these public projects it takes only a basic accountant to total the liabilities but a creative politician to total the revenues. I wish that I was a intelligent person but I do not see any pragmatism in this plan except for getting rid of the auditorium.

  6. jamesbflo

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 19th 2008, 06:07

    it better happen or some people have alot of answering to do

  7. Sitler

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 19th 2008, 08:08

    While the economy definitely worries me, I'm excited about their intentions down at the Erie Canal Harbor. Luv the fact that they are going to incorporate canals into the plan. I say make all of downtown Buffalo canals! Onward.

  8. al-alo

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 19th 2008, 08:42

    I just hope that all stakeholders we consulted during the creative process, including potential businesses, the preservation community, the city, the NFTA's port folks, the National Park Service, etc. No need for additional holdups that cost everyone money.

    if you try and get buy in from the beginning, everybody is a lot happier. . .

  9. onestarmartin

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 19th 2008, 09:16

    I believe this project will come to fruitation, but the time frame will be several years longer than expected and some major changes will occur. In this economic climate, credit is tight for funding, stores like Bass Pro will be rethinking business plans, the state and county are announcing major cutbacks in funding and aid. It's a pity Buffalo did not start this plan years ago like other cities did. Even this article states the fact that the plan is "flexable" to accommodate market conditions and tenent interest which goes to show even the developers are hedging their bets on the project at this time. I would love to of seen this finished during my time in Buffalo to enjoy the waterfront even more than I have done in the past few years, hopefully, when I visit in years to come it will be finished and a great detination point!

  10. onestarmartin

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 19th 2008, 09:43

    hmm, spell check...deStination

  11. MeliQ

    2 ratings12345
    Nov 19th 2008, 09:48

    I think we should move the Broadway Market down here. No one goes to it in it's present location, it couldn't hurt to try it somewhere else where people feel a greater sense of personal security being out and about. The building could be modeled after a turn of the century building, giving it an old-world feel. No, it's not authentic but more of a representation of our past. It could be expanded to not only include food, but also crafters or artisans to create more mass appeal to a greater audience. It would be something that is open from early morning to maybe 9pm and would not only be somewhat of a tourist draw if done right, but also cater to the Cobblestone district resides and near S. Buffalo. One more thing, we could even showcase our native foods through the market---Weber's mustard on Sahlen's dogs, loganberry, sponge candy, etc. With some creativity, this place could really show off our city's history and be something that Buffalo could be proud of.

  12. sally

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 19th 2008, 10:57

    Look for the initial plans to be 'previewed' in next Wednesday's Buffalo News. Front page, top of the fold.

  13. Colin

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 19th 2008, 13:06

    "Studies" are necessary to do anything not just here, but anywhere.

  14. icecreamsub

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 19th 2008, 13:44

    the skyway looks pretty cool in the top picture.....I hope we keep it and just build another foot bridge for pedestrians to access the other side of the harbor....also, Bass Pro is coming.....just wait

  15. chrishawley

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 19th 2008, 13:49

    The studies are already done. There is already an EIS approved and a plan in place to move forward. We'll be back to square one if Benderson flouts ten years of community planning and ignores the millions of dollars already spent on the Erie Canal Harbor Plan to make dramatic changes that suit them.

    Haven't we already learned? How many more delays are we willing tolerate before storming the Bastille, so to speak?

  16. BackInBuffalo

    1 ratings12345
    Nov 19th 2008, 13:50

    would be nice to live in all the other cities in this country where all that needs to happen for development to become profitable reality is a nose twitch, blink & finger snap. too bad buffalo has to go through planning, studies, approvals, blah blah blah.

  17. meanoldman

    1 ratings12345
    Nov 19th 2008, 13:58

    move the market! what shall we call it? the used to be down dere on broadway market by the lake! bad idea. a market yes, but moving the broadway market makes it just a market.

  18. nick

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 19th 2008, 14:01

    Back,

    Government funded or permitted project has to go through planning, studies and approvals at any location in this country of ours, the problem is when the process is circumvented that delays inevitably occur due to lawsuits. These processes are law.

  19. carlmalone

    1 ratings12345
    Nov 19th 2008, 14:04

    Over my dead body this project moves forward.

  20. SnarkFest

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 19th 2008, 14:17

    Tear down the Aud and put up a parking lot, bop, bop de bop.

  21. kooksapalooza

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 19th 2008, 16:00

    nice knowing ya carl......sorta

  22. maxim6194

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 19th 2008, 16:20

    The Economy may be failing real bad most places else where but not nearly as bad in buffalo. our housing market is still good, our jobs are going to be going on the rise. This will definitely help the area.

  23. gaustad

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 19th 2008, 18:51

    maxim, our housing market is slowing declining....Buffalo always lags the rest of the country....people are backing out of the new condo tower project left and right....prices have dropped on waterfront substantially, many foreclosures in Amherst, Clarence, and cheektowaga. Prices coming down, no financing available.

    Its just a matter of time. Our economy is is very weak.

  24. meanoldman

    1 ratings12345
    Nov 19th 2008, 19:37

    gaustad- you are right. foreclosures in in the RICH SUBURBS!, for over priced dream homes. if you come back to the city there are houses you can afford. i paid thirty thousand for a two thousand sq. ft. house with a full basement and a three car garage! mortgage payment of less than three hundred a month. what do you think that would cost in the burbs you mentioned?

  25. mybuffalo

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 19th 2008, 20:48

    good thing we're all being positive...

  26. sonyactivision

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 19th 2008, 20:55

    Oooh, a model. That sounds nice.

  27. DPH

    1 ratings12345
    Nov 19th 2008, 20:57

    Maxim, Guastad are both correct. Buffalo is not as bad off as much of the rest of the country. Buffalo's housing problems are 2-3 months out, especially if the auto workers experience a chap 11 situation where their who life planning changes in a heartbeat. Suddenly a huge demographic in WNY will now have to unexpectedly pay their health insurance (like most of us) and either lose their pension or have them significantly reduced. My point is that they will have to come up with money to compensate that loss and many will have to leave their homes or the area. But back to the topic; The project is going to happen it already is. But true, the new economy will impact the speed of the building components. The days of building on speculation are gone, therefore each lease building will need a significant anchor tenant to trigger that specific building's construction. In fact the program / planning could be modified based on demand or lack of, whereas the 'ideal' plan would have driven the bus and tenants would follow. Today the tenant will drive the bus and the developer will adjust to market conditions.

    The sucess of the waterfront as a whole will depend heavily on what happens on the outer harbor. As a concerned citizen, I would be much more concerned about the NFTA land than how Benderson is handling the Inner Harbor planning. Money is being spent (a lot of it) on the inner harbor, but the outer harbor is lacking activity.

    Don't expect a project of this size to pop up over night. It will take years. So watch it evolve (which you are) and stay active and participate in a positive way. It is going to happen, it is, whether you are for or against it. There is no sound reason for being against this project unless you simply do not want Buffalo to grow and succeed. For years we all heard everyone complain that we don't do anything with our waterfront (as the Pier stood out there all alone), and today we are moving ahead in a serious significant way, and now we hear people complaining about it. Doesn't make sense, who could not want this to happen? (don't answer, I'm just saying..)

  28. Buffalo21stcentury

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 19th 2008, 21:27

    The outer harbor has its own dynamic. Of course it would have been nice if Barilla Pasta came to Buffalo next to General Mills instead of Rochester but thats water under the bridge.

    The Lakeside Commerce Park is growing, Nanodynamics is growing, the Freezer Queen plant has a new owner, the Bethlehem Steel Site has a something called Lackawanna Clean Energy, the Seneca Rail Yards that used to feed Bethlehem Steel are now the auxillary transhipment facility for the Port of NY/NJ, Riverwright is finishing up on its ethanol/biodiesel plant and the GBNRTC has consultants telling them to create a port authority to bring shipping back to the outer harbor.

    The big picture for the Inner Harbor is as follows:

    1) Get the Lift Bridge to Furhmann Boulevard

    2) Get the Light Rail Extension to the Airport, relocate the NFTA maintenance bays from the DL&W to the Central Terminal and incorporate the DL&W into the Inner Harbor plants which would extend the Inner Harbor development all the way to Michigan.

    3) Put the Convention/Conference Center at the Ohio Basin on the table.

    All of which would enhance the dynamic of the Inner Harbor Wharf District, promote the regeneration of the First Ward Cobblestone/Warehouse District and the Outer Harbor.

  29. impressingagent

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 19th 2008, 22:00

    This is a huge public interest project and it needs to educate our tastes and reinvigorate our history.

  30. tonyarmani

    1 ratings12345
    Nov 19th 2008, 23:51

    im pretty sure obama can change all of our problems away

  31. gaustad

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 20th 2008, 01:23

    "Benderson and a Canal Side committee formed by ECHDC have been working with Ehrenkrantz Eckstut & Kuhn on project details. The planning and design firm has been under contract since early 2006 to create design guidelines for the Inner Harbor and Cobblestone Districts."

    What does this mean?

  32. gaustad

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 20th 2008, 02:18

    stock market is crumbling because Wall St and big businesses are afraid that Obama will redistribute wealth to the poor.

    All of you who voted for him, need to check your 401k statement or, better yet, your parents 401k statement....you may never see those retirement funds again

  33. Buffalo21stcentury

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 20th 2008, 16:16

    gaustad, Obama is NOT going to do s**t! Look at what Obama is doing. He chose Rahm Emmanuel who has dual citizenship with Israel and is rumored to be a former Israeli Mossad agent and fought in the Israeli Military and whose father was an Israeli terrorism to control the white house as chief of staff...the rest of the cabinet level appointments are former Clintonistas.

    A replay of history....as soon as Americans reallize the Obama/Clinton plan the next 2 year election will bring back the Republicans.

    (That is if the republicans have figured out who they really are because americans arent going to elect an Israeli warhawk like McCain or a warhawk fascist list BUSH/CHENY...the republicans have to go back to the NEWT GINGRICH and EISENHOWER and Ron Paul Traditions...they have to abandon free trade,open borders and deregulation for starters...moving towards school vouchers, bringing back glass steagal separation of banks and replacing production/investment taxes with consumption taxes)

    That aside..I think the harbor project will get built and I think the light rail will get extended to the corridor....thus allowing the wharf district to extend all the way to Michigan. I think that the DL&W could yet again be a downtown train station. I wouldnt be suprised if plans to rebuild the passenger concourse were considered in the future.

  34. fill

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 21st 2008, 13:14

    onestarmartin -- Additional spellcheck: flexible

  35. rb66

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 21st 2008, 13:14

    This would be a great location for Dinosaur Bar B Que.

  36. flyguy

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 21st 2008, 16:28

    Planning and studies are hardly exclusive to Buffalo and to be honest I must say that doing something 100% uninformed is ridiculous. Without some sort of pre scoping we end up back in a situation where the "Triangle Shirtwaist factory" fire again becomes commonplace. The fact is there needs to be some sort of control or we as a society re-live all the things society collectively recognized needed to be fixed. Planning and pre approval studies do have value and its good to know what the impacts and implications of a project on things like demand for public services- like transportation, solid watse collection, water, sewer, parks, libraries, schools, etc. will be. If things are done without thinking they may result in significant unintended consequences to the social, property, environmental realms that nobody wants.

    With that said though, at some point it is important to realize that paralysis by analysis and reanalysis 300 times over decades does no good for the community either. People are only on this earth for so long and 30+ years of thinking about the same piece of land with no action should not be tolerated. My god life is short as it is. Buffalonians should not have had to wait as long as they have for something to finally happen while watching tens of thousands of relatives and friends move away and watch as other cities grew, prospered and boomed.

    And by the way a system where a tiny little group of people hold all the cards and whord a ridiculous sum of cash while a middle class shrinks away and become increasingly poor and have to accept increasingly lower level positions in poorer paying industries and watches as their life sustaining jobs are shipped overseas and quality of life continually dwindles isnt exactly a good system. The middle class in this Country in many ways held on to their American Dream and lifestyle via insane. Only now will we know how truly screwed many of the people in this Country and truly poor people are, who had the rugs pulled out from underneath them under the system of "globalization is great". Globalization is great to those who profit from it yes. Those are also the ones in power who hold the cards and forced this on the majority of American people who are slowly losing theior shirts. I'm not talking about people who sit around all day using the system, rather the people who bust their ass and arent paid a decent wage for what they do. The pay scale in this country is all screwed up and priorities insane. We actually have entertainers and athletes pulling down money that would make the president of this Country cry. When we have single earners making as much in a year that the sum of 1500 or more middle income families live on yearly theres something just a bit off. The stock market was on course to fall apart well before Obama was elected president.

  37. flyguy

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 21st 2008, 16:31

    Planning and studies are hardly exclusive to Buffalo and to be honest I must say that doing something 100% uninformed is ridiculous. Without some sort of pre scoping we end up back in a situation where the "Triangle Shirtwaist factory" fire again becomes commonplace. The fact is there needs to be some sort of control or we as a society re-live all the things society collectively recognized needed to be fixed. Planning and pre approval studies do have value and its good to know what the impacts and implications of a project on things like demand for public services- like transportation, solid watse collection, water, sewer, parks, libraries, schools, etc. will be. If things are done without thinking they may result in significant unintended consequences to the social, property, environmental realms that nobody wants.

    With that said though, at some point it is important to realize that paralysis by analysis and reanalysis 300 times over decades does no good for the community either. People are only on this earth for so long and 30+ years of thinking about the same piece of land with no action should not be tolerated. My god life is short as it is. Buffalonians should not have had to wait as long as they have for something to finally happen while watching tens of thousands of relatives and friends move away and watch as other cities grew, prospered and boomed.

    And by the way a system where a tiny little group of people hold all the cards and whord a ridiculous sum of cash while a middle class shrinks away and become increasingly poor and have to accept increasingly lower level positions in poorer paying industries and watches as their life sustaining jobs are shipped overseas and quality of life continually dwindles isnt exactly a good system. The middle class in this Country in many ways held on to their American Dream and lifestyle via insane. Only now will we know how truly screwed many of the people in this Country and truly poor people are, who had the rugs pulled out from underneath them under the system of "globalization is great". Globalization is great to those who profit from it yes. Those are also the ones in power who hold the cards and forced this on the majority of American people who are slowly losing theior shirts. I'm not talking about people who sit around all day using the system, rather the people who bust their ass and arent paid a decent wage for what they do. The pay scale in this country is all screwed up and priorities insane. We actually have entertainers and athletes pulling down money that would make the president of this Country cry. When we have single earners making as much in a year that the sum of 1500 or more middle income families live on yearly theres something just a bit off. The stock market was on course to fall apart well before Obama was elected president.

  38. sonyactivision

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 23rd 2008, 01:49

    ^ Elliott Spitzer was the guy who "whord a ridiculous sum of cash". And we're only talking about s few shops here, not the Future of the Human Race.

Would you like to subscribe to this conversation?

Enter your email below, and you will receive an alert each time someone leaves a comment on this post.

What Do You Think?

Text Links