Buffalo's Other Mansion Street

As we all know Buffalo was once chock full of Millionaires who left behind an amazing legacy of streets filled with mansions in a wide swath from downtown to Hertel Avenue. Some streets such as Delaware of course, along with Linwood and Richmond, are famous for their mansions. These streets conjure instant images of big elegant houses. Less well known for its history of high end living is Elmwood Avenue. Today we think of Elmwood for its shops and restaurants but give little thought to the mansions that still line the street at many places.
Before it was a commercial strip Elmwood was thought of as one of the city's best addresses. A large percentage of Elmwood's original mansions still exist but are often hidden behind an add-on storefront; sometimes the house has simply been converted to a store as is. Converting residential buildings to retail use is not uncommon in the US. Boston's elegant Newbury Street row houses are almost 100% commercial today as the street has become a premier shopping destination.
As cities grew, commercial pressures made streets such as Elmwood less desirable to the well-heeled who then moved to newer even more elegant streets. Businesses and apartment dwellers moved in to fill the void. Some houses were replaced by larger apartment buildings, while others were chopped up into small apartment units and still others became office space. There are very few single family houses left on the street today. Take another look at Elmwood. You might be surprised by what you find.
Check out a few more images of this beautiful block of Elmwood between Bryant and Summer here: http://www.skyscrapercity.com/showthread.php?t=685094

Having a tough time deciding on how to spend your weekend? The Buffalo and Erie County Historical Society (BECHS) won’t make your decision making process any easier as they’re offering two great events this coming Saturday and Sunday. December 6th marks their third annual Native American Festival and on December 7th, BECHS will host a Pearl Harbor Remembrance Day that is free to veterans of the armed service. Both days are filled with fun activities and interesting visitors th …
It’s really a shame if you missed the reading series “Poetry at the Tea House” that took place at Tru-Teas! during this past year. Luckily, Trudy Stern didn’t want anyone to miss out and teamed up with Michael Morgulis to produce an incredibly fine, unbound book entitled “Tea Leaves” to commemorate the readings and spread the work of the local poets who partook in the program.
In honor of the publication of this special edition portfolio, Morgulis and Stern are hostin …
I think that I would like to start off this post by commending the three Common Council members who were bold enough to ask for today's bizarre Waterfront Village decision to be tabled. David Franczyk, Mickey Kearns and Mike LoCurto all stuck to their guns when it came to holding off on making any hasty (and potentially tragic) decisions regarding our waterfront. Unfortunately, their headstrong stance was outweighed by the rest of the BURA committee, and the rumors are flying as t …
A development team has been selected for a vacant commercial site in Waterfront Village. Finally. The Buffalo Urban Renewal Agency this morning named Specialty Restaurants Incorporation as preferred developer for the prime 1.4 acre parcel at 10-15 LaRiviere Drive. The owner of the adjacent Shanghai Red’s restaurant is proposing an uninspired, four-story, 100 room Wingate Inn.





Comment Options
sbrof
So true. Great post.
Report this
wizardofza
From the perspective of a pedestrian, this block is painfully long.
Report this
Dan
An underrated, seldom-acknowledged element that makes Elmwood Avenue a great street is the residential buffering that is proided between the various commercial nodes along the street. This reinforces the human scale of Elmwood Avenue, and makes it a great street for a long stroll; it's not an endless corridor of boutique after boutique, but rather a string of interesting subdistricts, each with their own character. Thanks for putting a spotlight on the residential aspect of Elmwood.
Report this
STEEL
I do wish there was fewer breaks in the retail portions of Elmwood. In some ways these residential stretches hamper the street. But that being said the houses that are there are quite spectacular.
Report this
EricOak
Nice article, Steel. I agree with Dan's astute comment. Elmwood never seems "boutiquey," and I think that gives it more class and character than a saturated retail street. If you walk its entire length, say from the Albright-Knox to City Hall, you'll expereince one of the most interesting urban streets in the country--for architectural mix, socio-economic diversity, and variety of moods. It's our most well-known and successful street yet at the same time one of our most underrated and underobserved.
Report this
iamBuffalosfuture
ah reminds me of the atwater house, thanks pano
Report this
buffaloweiner
Those days are long gone for Elmwood....(the atwater house proved that no one cares about elmwood residential unless its an apartment building or mixed use apartment/retail) and the few houses that remain on elmwood are embarrassments to their former with no sign a gutter cleaning less of restoration
However, the real forgotten manson streets are the cross streets that run East-West such as Ferry
and of course....the long lost mansions of the cobblestone and the eastside of which only a rare few remain.....
Report this
11111inBlo
Please have more posts on the history of Elmwood Avenue. Elmwood is strange in that you always here things about the history of almost every other part of the city, but from a historical information POV, it almost seems like Elmwood appeared in the last 20 years from our of no where.
Report this
buffaloweiner
Elmwood didnt appear out of the last 20 years....
The Elmwood we know actually started to appear in the late 60s and early 70s during the peak of the sububan exodus to places like Kenmore, the Tonawandas, Grand Island, Amherst and Cheektowaga from the West Side and Eastside.
At that time the only thing keeping Delaware, Elmwood and Richmond alive was Buffalo State students and the el cheapo hippie shops that catered to them.
Now Delaware and Linwood and Richmond are back. Elmwood is the center and its struggling to go upscale but with no help from the property owners large swaths of Elmwood still remain unpainted unmaintained eyesores. Buffalo State still has a minority president that has more commitment to her hair than she does to managing and growing the college and integrating it to the surrounding community. The college stores and apartments on Elmwood should have moved to Grant long ago. If only Buffalo State expanded the college instead of refusing 10,000 applicants a year, letting private developers build off campus dormatories because she cant manage the responsibility to build them, much less labs, small business incubatos and expanded program curiculae. Yes Buffalo State to a great degree saved Elmwood and the surrounding neighborhood.....but Howard has no comprehension of Buffalo State or her job as president.
Report this
heathersmiles
11111- I agree completely, no one really talks about Elmwood in the days before the Psych Center was closing. There was an interesting and sometimes scary group of people on that street that gave it a very gritty urban feel. I loved hanging out there in the 80s, and the street was a far cry from what it is today. It is almost as if the EVA would like to forget that past and their roots and just focus on becoming a village that is separate from the rest of the city.
I see that it didn't take long for us to return to President Howard's ethnicity as grounds for her not appeasing Buffaloweiner's / Chris69's grand vision of the school. Maybe he was in the running for the President position and lost it to her?
Report this
Brette
Pssst Heather, didn't you hear, Howard broke off their engagement. Just between us, nkay?
Report this