Buffalo Featured in New York Times

Buffalo Featured in New York Times

Story Options

The New York Times, which periodically remembers there is life in New York state outside the NYC metropolitan area, has a lengthy piece about Buffalo and its architectural treasures in today's edition. The author, Nicolai Ouroussoff, hits on all the usual Buffalo landmarks including the Richardson Complex, the Darwin Martin House, the former Larkin Office building, and the Olmsted parks.

In referencing new projects including the visitor's center at the Darwin Martin House and the Burchfield-Penney Museum, the author closes with some interesting commentary:

But how these projects will be forged into a cohesive vision for the city’s future is less certain. The best-intentioned preservationists, however determined, can accomplish only so much. Often developers co-opt the achievements of these trailblazing individuals and nonprofit groups by dolling up historic neighborhoods for private gain. The city’s rough edges are smoothed over to satisfy the hunger for more tourist dollars. Shiny new convention centers and generic boutiques follow. Yet schools, roads, bridges and electrical and power lines continue to crumble.

Buffalo is an ideal testing ground for rethinking that depressing model. Its architectural heritage embodies an America that thought boldly about the future, but believed deeply in the city as a democratic forum. What’s needed now is to revive that experimental tradition

Of course, these issues are debated daily throughout Buffalo - and on this site - but it's sometimes helpful to read an outside perspective. When Mr. Ouroussoff states "but how these projects will be forged into a cohesive vision for the city's future is less certain," he unknowingly offers the understatement of the year from nearly every Buffalonian's perspective.

Rock Harbor

What Others Have To Say

  1. allfit

    2 ratings12345
    Nov 15th 2008, 13:38

    Great publicity, now if we could just get some signs that point people towards these attractions, and maybe some information for tourists who visit them.

    Imagine someone coming from NYC to visit the Richardson complex, what would they think after viewing the overgrown tangles of weeds and bushes from behind a 7' steel fence? What would they think when the police quickly ushered them off the grounds?

    Imagine someone driving from the Buffalo Airport to the Darwin Martin House, how would they find it? (If you look it up on Google, you are sent to 617 Main Street) Given the correct address or driving directions, there are no signs along the 198 or 33 that point out which way to go. There are no signs near Delaware Park identifying local attractions (beyond the Zoo).

    We are not a tourist friendly city.

  2. pontius_pickle

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 15th 2008, 13:47

    Two words. Sea Change

  3. allentowndiva

    1 ratings12345
    Nov 15th 2008, 13:57

    it would be nice to see an article about the growing economy, influx of people and shrinking taxes in the news about Buffalo for a change.

  4. sonyactivision

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 15th 2008, 14:01

    ^ One begets the other.

  5. comptart_lws

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 15th 2008, 14:33

    2 paragraphs on proposed Peace Bridge expansion devastating an entire historic neighborhood — more than our local paper seems to give a hoot about it.

  6. Charger

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 15th 2008, 14:34

    After reading the article please consider using the NYT "E-mail this article" feature to send it to someone else - or even yourself. The NYT features a list of the most forwarded articles and if this one can rise toward the top of the list it will doubtless generate more readers/exposure. The current #2 article is a travel article about Ithaca, so it's not out of the realm of possibility.

  7. Buffalo21stcentury

    1 ratings12345
    Nov 15th 2008, 16:38

    Im not suprised that the natural evolution of thought was to get the current convention center out of downtown's core and build a shiny new 450k sqft convention and conference center and of course hotel and parking garage.

    Buffalo is doing many things correctly and many things terribly but very few things satisfactorily. For instance the master plan for the Olmsted Parks restoration and the reconstruction of the Grotto and Calvert Veaux structures are right on the money.

    Missing are the potential reconstruction of Pan Am Fountains, Band Shells and Gateway Entrances which would be unique and momentus.

    Buffalo is correctly restoring the Martin Complex, Roycroft and the Larkin Warehouses (even the FLW gas station and the FLW Boathouse and FLW Davidson House) but NOTICE HOW THE ADMINISTRATION BUILDING REMAINS AT THE TOP OF THE ATTENTION. The Larkin Administration Building should be reconstruction.

    Buffalo is correctly reconstructing the Spaulding Mercantile for Bass Pro and the intersection of the Commercial Slip, Erie Canal and Main/Hamburg. However missing from the reconstruction are canal barges, freight schooners, LaSalles Griffon and Adm Perry's 1812 Warship telling the story of the burning of Buffalo!

    Buffalo sadly has its only remaining historical district between Niagara & Main Street (possibly Niagara & Michigan) excluding the potmarked infill downtown. It is a city that still struggles with neglect and demolition at all levels. The city of Buffalo is 60% empty. Connecting downtown to rail at the Central Terminal and the Airport would be huge...yet...there is no start date.

    The Richardson moves forward at a glacial pace even though the surrounding community desperately needs it completed. BECHs, Conference Centers & Presidential Libraries and Offices could make immediate re-use of Richardson space. Yet the pace is glacial. Its huge and grand size and scale bring down the entire surrounding community...Buffalo State could move non-core services like Booktores to Grant Street or expand entrepreneurial incubators and dormatories but doesnt. The result is the continued decay along Forest, Grant, Tonawnda & Amhrest.

    The Science Museum needs a restoration of its main entrance facade...yet nothing.

    The city pothole ridden streets, curbs, sidewalks, treeless streets, industrial urban lighting and litter say alot about the condition of the city and do alot to retard investment and jobs.

    Buffalo continues to spend its money on Albany dictates, unions, patronage and insider business deals rather than those that would bring business, jobs and industry to our city.

    Im glad that Buffalo is getting its recognition but as with all lights...it also shines upon our ignorance and failures.

    There is one thing I will bring to the attention of all fellow Buffalo Rising readers. The financial collapse in NYC is rapidly turning the eyes of NYC (&BOSTON) to TORONTO and that is going to force a rethink of Buffalo! BUFFALO IS THE GATEWAY TO TORONTO!

  8. PBK

    3 ratings12345
    Nov 15th 2008, 16:41

    There is an army of unsung heroes in Buffalo who all of us should be praising for their devotion to Buffalo past, present and future. I personally am grateful that they have remained undaunted by the constatnt pounding they receive from The Buffalo News, The Public Bridge Authoriy, The Buffalo Partnership and others like Congressman Brian Higgins and Senator Chuck Schumer. Suddenly, yesterday's "obstructionists" are tomorrow's visionaries.

    At last their day has come on the back of the National Trust for Historic Preservation. The NTHP fell head over heels in love with Buffalo and they have tirelessly promoted the beauty of Buffalo's architecture ever since.

    Isn't it amazing how wordly people like Ouroussoff and the lens of a total stranger can view the future of our city as an exciting opportunity to develope a cultural tourism economy while power, money and politics continue to promote multi-million dollar projects that benefit few and will strangle our greatest resources; water, architecture and cultural heritage.

    Hopefully, The Times story will give pause to some of the worst government funded projects scheduled to come down the pipline like rebuilding Route 5 instead of freeing up access to the waterfront, the Peace Bridge expansion project poised to be the first eminent domain seizure of 45 acres of property since Rt.198 and Rt. 33 gutted Delaware Park and Humboldt Parkway, and the Mayor's 5 in 5 demolition program that will leave many city neighborhoods looking more like swiss cheese than a desirable urban community.

    Perhaps someone in Albany or Washington can figure out that there are other ways to infuse the economy around here beside tearing up highways, pouring concrete and firing up the bulldozers.

  9. cherokee

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 15th 2008, 16:53

    I agree our tourism signage is weak. Why we can't invest in signs on 33, 198 and parkside for the Martin House. It can only be a result of some environmental impact study that says having too many people drive directly to the site and spend money would be negative to the neighborhood?. If 60000 people visit the zoo, I bet 90% don't realize they are only a few hundred feet from the Martin house.

  10. TomServo0

    2 ratings12345
    Nov 15th 2008, 20:28

    Allfit, not to criticize, but Google Maps listings can be edited (I just submitted a correct address for the Martin House). Step one in promoting tourism begins with local citizens, not tourists, companies, or government. I wonder how many visitors came to the wrong building this summer because nobody cared to fix the map?

  11. TomServo0

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 15th 2008, 20:29

    Allfit, not to criticize, but Google Maps listings can be edited (I just submitted a correct address for the Martin House). Step one in promoting tourism begins with local citizens, not tourists, companies, or government. I wonder how many visitors came to the wrong building this summer because nobody cared to fix the map?

  12. allfit

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 15th 2008, 20:50

    Tom - Thanks for taking the initiative, but I think you missed the bigger picture. We have elected leaders, a paid Convention and Visitors Bureau, State Leaders, For Profit and Not-for-Profit organizations, that are doing very little to actively promote tourism in Buffalo. They are missing out on the basics, like maps and signage, correct information on the internet, and up to date web pages. These are the things that we should take for granted, instead we get excited when one of these entities actually does something the right way.

    Step One is to have these organizations take an active roll in promoting themselves within the region. When was the last time you saw a mention of the Darwin Martin House on the "something to do this weekend" section of the paper or on one of the local news channels? Why do we take it for granted that everyone in the region is aware of these attractions?

    So not to criticize, but I whole heartedly disagree with you. It is the responsibilty of the Companies, Government, and local agencies to promote tourism, both within the region and to those from outside the region.

    Is this on the agenda of our County Executive, Mayor, or Common Council? Is intraregional tourism part of the CVB agenda? From what I have seen, they are falling seriously short on all aspects of promoting tourism. So don't blame the citizens, go right to the root of the problem.

  13. eliz

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 15th 2008, 21:19

    Great article and images! I do have to put in a word for the hard-working PR people of the Martin House and historic and architectural sites--those that have staffs and are open to the public. They do promote themselves quite vigorously. If they're not in the things to do section of the paper (and actually they frequently are), it's not for lack of trying.

    I receive their press releases regularly.

  14. TomServo0

    1 ratings12345
    Nov 15th 2008, 21:30

    Allfit, Step One is to be part of the process. The bigger picture is that not enough people take the initiative to participate in government, for-profit and non-profit organizations.

  15. Charger

    2 ratings12345
    Nov 15th 2008, 21:47

    TomServo0 is right on many levels. We must all be part of the process. In fact it seems that it is ordinary citizens who are accomplishing much of what is getting accomplished, particularly when it comes to Preservation.

    Here's a minor example, but since Buffalo21stcentury brings it up.... Potholes. The City is honoring its commitment to repair potholes within 24-hours of notification. So when you see a pothole get out your cell phone and call it in to 851-4890. If you don't, and the pot hole is still there next time you drive down the street, then it's on you.

    What the people mentioned in the article - and countless others - have done is take the initiative. They're making a difference.

    By the way - this article is now #16 on the Time's most e-mailed list.

  16. allfit

    3 ratings12345
    Nov 15th 2008, 21:49

    Tom - Get off your high horse already, there are hundreds of people (like me) who have spent countless hours (like me) working on the Darwin Martin project, and countless other volunteer activities in Buffalo. The bottom line is that these people are working more than the government and some of the agencies to promote tourism, we need the people who are in charge of these entities, we need the government leaders that we elect, and we need the worthless CVB to become more engaged in this process.

    I would say that the Martin House is an exception, but they still don't do enough. The issue with Google is one example, the board runs the restoration, they should ensure that the website and searches are correct. They should also work to establish better signs and maps (back to the original point) either by bringing their cause to their local leaders or by doing it themselves.

    We have accepted so much mediocrity in this area.

  17. blackrocklifer

    2 ratings12345
    Nov 15th 2008, 21:52

    TomServO- Your advice is right on, Here in Black Rock we learned a long time ago to take the initiative and usually others (including government) will follow. Democracy is in the streets and requires the effort of citizens to affect real change.

  18. sonyactivision

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 16th 2008, 07:45

    All this plus the [real] chatter about Brian Higgins being tapped to replace Hillary Clinton in the Senate if she gets the Secretary of state job.

  19. Buffalo21stcentury

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 16th 2008, 12:22

    Let me say this publicly so everyone hears it.

    The county hotel bed tax is supposed to take care of tourism. Its not that Buffalo spends less than say Detroit, Cleveland or Pittsburgh...cities it likes to compare itself BUT BUFFALO SPENDS SIGNIFICANTLY LESS (LIKE 50%) OF WHAT ROCHESTER AND SYRACUSE SPEND! NO THAT IS NOTHING LESS THAN PISS!

    So where does the county hotel bed tax go? It goes into a general fund where it mysteriously vanishes into a myriad of county programs and albany mandates.

    They county refuses to take this off-budget and devote it exclusively to tourism promotion for everything within Erie County. Infact the Bed Tax should be collected for Niagara County and everything tourist related marketed together.

    So blame Collins & Giambra and past administrations! If albany has unfunded mandates or if the county has union or patronage issues then tourism should not be held hostage via the bed tax!

    Nuff Sed!

  20. Assaroni

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 16th 2008, 15:37

    who cares, there are still no jobs, and we still have the highest taxes and gas in the coun try...SO WHAT!

  21. STEEL

    0 ratings12345
    Nov 17th 2008, 01:06

    Because there is more to life.

  22. heathersmiles

    1 ratings12345
    Nov 21st 2008, 15:43

    GOOD NEWS! Hillary Clinton accepted the Secretary of State job so we may actually have a Senator who is working for us instead of working for her bid for President.

    Let's hope that Brian Higgins doesn't forget where he came from when he gets to Washington!

  23. heathersmiles

    1 ratings12345
    Nov 21st 2008, 15:48

    GOOD NEWS! Hillary Clinton accepted the Secretary of State job so we may actually have a Senator who is working for us instead of working for her bid for President.

    Let's hope that Brian Higgins doesn't forget where he came from when he gets to Washington!

Would you like to subscribe to this conversation?

Enter your email below, and you will receive an alert each time someone leaves a comment on this post.

What Do You Think?

Text Links