mepolo, i did read the article. by the time i finished the article the sign remained ugly. and we prefer to be called debbie downers. not negative nellies.
mepolo, i did read the article. by the time i finished the article the sign remained ugly. and we prefer to be called debbie downers. not negative nellies.
I agree with Rez: it doesn't belong, period. Glad it looks better in person, but it would look even better gone.
In addition Olmsted Parkways were not designed to be places for signs but places that bring nature to the residents of the city. To erect a sign in an Olmsted Park is like putting a freeway through the park. This is an affront to art. It is like editing out sections of a directors film or words in a writers book, or painting upon a canvas of a master.
The highest form of ugly is when one tampers and/or makes changes to a master piece. Olmsted if he was alive would be raising cain about signs in his parkway.
right now this sign doesn't make much sense to people walking/driving by. I'm still not 100% sure what the sign is for and what it is doing there after reading this article.
YUCK, THATS AWFUL. It looks like a cheep sheet of plywood painted green. Get rid of it. Tacky…
mepolo...by simplicity, do you mean not putting up an ugly looking sign? if that's the case, i am all for simplicity!
As a resident of this street I am not opposed to the idea but PLEEZE can we have something a little more classy? And I am too a bit confused about it. Also,our block is becoming Festival/Protest Central and it's becoming tough enjoy the beautiful area we upkeep ...and pay such high taxes for.
The only thing that FUGLY sign is missing is a tribute to Byron Brown as Mayor and any other politician who wants their name added to the sign...Please take it down!
I know if I posted the same thing everyone else did about the sign's appearance, I'd be one-starred to Cheektowaga and back.
So, I'll try this. Buffalo doesn't need those overproduced, understated and professionally crafted signs like what would be displayed in such plastic, sterile cities as Charlotte, Phoenix and Denver. This sign is more authentic, genuine, and real. Elmwood Market, Buffalo Beer Merchant, and pond hockey.
Five stars, please. Thanks, and GO BILLS!
For something that is meant to represent the arts...palease! The only statement it makes to me is "under funded"
Did anyone actually READ the article, or did you just look at the picture, and immediately start spouting out the negativity that has become so popular around here lately? I imagine most of the commentors to this website to be people miserably stuck in their jobs in a cube with nothing to do all day but be negative. "The granite engraved Walk of Fame brings the arts to the street on a permanent level. In about two week a couple of evergreens will be planted by the sign and ten new names will be added." - I think that explains what it is all about......and what will be added to the sign to make it more appealing. As for the last comment....this is one man doing this on his own to help promote the history of this city.....it doesn't have to be flashy or over the top to represent the arts....sometimes simplicity is the best way to promote something. This man is doing alot more to help this city than I see anyone of the negative nellies doing around here......
The question is not whether the sign is ugly or beautiful. The question is whether the City of Buffalo is being a good steward when it comes to Bidwell Parkway. Based on the size and number of events they allow to take place, it would appear that they do not care about the appearance of Bidwell or the opinion of the residents. I wonder if there was a permit application for this sign? If so, who reviewed it? Who approved it?
I can't imagine living in one of the beautiful homes on Bidwell, paying the high taxes and in the summertime, having difficulty getting to my home because of the festivals, markets and protests....much less the noise and the trash that is generated. I sympathize with newscat but I also have to say that I do go to the farmers market and I do love to see the people using the parkway and I certainly enjoy the free concerts during July. I guess what we have to do as a community is respect those homeowners that own property adjacent to public spaces and pick up after ourselves and be mindful that what is music to us may be a migraine for others (the bongos).
If anything, Bidwell needs more festivals, farmers markets, bongo drummers, and protesters. Let the people who are concerned about property values, taxes, and permits go live on Lincoln or Oakwood for all I care. Mr. Griffasi here is obviously trying to honor Buffalo's contributions to the arts, and in doing so bring more attention to our neighborhood.
That sign is pretty FUGLY though.
the like the sign. reminds me of Allegany State Park. good call on the drum circles imadiva......the warmer temps means that it won't be long before the hacky sack toejam and freedom sucking will once again be invading Bidwell pkwy..god those hippies are funny.
wholelotta....debbie downers it is then! ;-) My whole thoughts on this were that there are alot of people who feel entitled, not only to their opinion, but to having their will done, based on their opinion. The comment to have the sign taken down, simply because some people consider it ugly, while others are perfectly fine with it....is an example of that. I applaud phenimore...while considering the sign ugly....is at least offering to help do something about it, rather than simply complaining.
For the sake of doing things yourself, please know your limits. Hire a professional to create the sign next time.
"One of the granite markers will even go in front of Cole's Restaurant - Chauncey Alcott is the artist who wrote My Wild Irish Rose"
Chauncey Olcott is best remembered for the lyrics to "When Irish Eyes are Smiling." Any reason why the stone is planned for Cole's?
This sign was stolen from Dollywood Amusement Park in tennessee and they want it back. Get your own damn "cultural walk of fame" sign.
It seems overly big for what it needs to say.. is there going to be more to this sign, some sub-areas. Otherwise it looks like a magnet for graffiti.. Large, smooth, blank / single color = canvas for some... Think about all the angles before you put lots of these things up.
Great idea though and I whole heartedly agree that going to plays, and exposure to the arts as a child is paramount to liking and supporting them in the future. I remember going to the Franklin Black box theatre in 4th grade I think. One of the best and most fun experiences I had in school and one of the main reasons I still enjoy going to plays today.
The sign is ugly.
Why should trees be cut down to make signs like this?
The people resdiding on Buffalo streets should have the ultimate and final decison on how their streets will be used. Residential streets are not intended to be places of commerce. Excessive signage on residential streets errodes quaity of life for those who live on those streets.
Stop D'Youville College from closing off Fargo Avenue. This is far worse than the signs but is no different to how the self determination of people on their streets are being wrongtfully taken away for projects neighbors do not want. The D'Youville College land grab is dangerous!
"OH ...MY... GOD..." had I known about the two evergreens I never would of slammed the sigh!
I think we can all settle down.
I went out last night, like I mentioned before, and what we are looking at is a really bad picture... The sign in question is punched metal and not a crappy looking jigsaw cut piece of plywood. There is a patterened gold leaf placed behind the letters. It's not nearly as bad as this picture makes it look.
It's ok, not great imho, but it's far from the horrible thing I thought it was going to be.
I like the thought of making a more physical attachment to cultural icons in the city, but the image of this sign is pretty bad (I hope it doesnt look that ungainly up close).
It's silly to complain about something like this without offering any alternatives. I would be more than happy to design, construct and paint a new sign. I'll go check it out today and try to get in touch with Charles and offer my help...
For the muckrackers on this, did you read the final quote?
If anything, Bidwell needs more festivals, farmers markets, bongo drummers, and protesters. Let the people who are concerned about property values, taxes, and permits go live on Lincoln or Oakwood for all I care. Mr. Griffasi here is obviously trying to honor Buffalo's contributions to the arts, and in doing so bring more attention to our neighborhood.
That sign is pretty FUGLY though.
Report this