Share, , , Google Plus, Reddit, Pinterest, StumbleUpon


Posted in:

Allentown Pizza

There’s a new Buffalo-style pizza business opening at the corner of Allen and Elmwood. I spoke to co-owner Joe Mahiques who told me that he’s inspired by the recent success of Cantina Loco and is looking to emulate the same sort of vibe that he sees across the street. “This will not look like your typical pizzeria in town,” Joe told me. “It’s going to be warm and it’s going to have character. We want people to come in and sit down. It’s going have the same sort of appeal that you would have seen from a restaurant in the 30s and 40s… old school.”

The vegan and vegetarian crowd will be pleased to hear that Allentown Pizza will cater to them as well. “We’re going out of our way to make sure that the health-conscious crowd will have plenty of things to eat… we’re not just making pizza, we’re going to have wraps and other offerings to appeal to a wider audience. We’re making all of our own dough in-house, and we’re ordering the freshest ingredients. Allentown Pizza will be open seven days a week for lunch and dinner. We’re going to be open late too – 1am weekdays and 4am weekends. This is a family-run business. We want to be open mid August.”

With Jim’s SteakOut so close, Allentown Pizza is sure to land some spin-off business. Also, the crowd that formerly frequented NY Pizza will have another option close to the bar scene. I love the big windows where the activity inside will be visible from the street. This is the ‘most walkable’ corner in Buffalo, and also ranks nationally in the same category. It deserves to have lots of activity on a regular basis. I’m looking forward to this pizzeria generating the proper buzz that this corner building deserves.


Written by queenseyes


Newell Nussbaumer is 'queenseyes' - Eyes of the Queen City and Founder of Buffalo Rising. Co-founder Elmwood Avenue Festival of the Arts. Co-founder Powder Keg Festival that built the world's largest ice maze (Guinness Book of World Records). Instigator behind Emerald Beach at the Erie Basin Marina. Co-created Flurrious! winter festival. Co-creator of Rusty Chain Beer. Instigator behind Saturday Artisan Market (SAM) at Canalside. Founder of The Peddler retro and vintage market. Instigator behind Liberty Hound @ Canalside. Throws The Witches Ball at The Hotel @ The Lafayette, and the Madd Tiki Winter Luau. Other projects: Navigetter.

Contact Newell Nussbaumer |

View All Articles by queenseyes
Hide Comments
Show Comments
  • RaChaCha

    Great news!  I predict they’ll make a ton of dough at this location.
    But…what is “Buffalo-style pizza”?

    • sbrof

      RaChaCha Just Mister anything not features on BRO is typically Buffalo style. thicker than  NY style thinner than Chicago. The perfect balance of dough sauce cheese… and of course Cup-N-Char peperoni. None of the flat, flavorless kind…

    • TreborNeroht

      RaChaCha thicker than ny style, thinner than chicago style!

  • elmdog

    This is exactly what the area needs, but it a bigger space…A pizza plant esque style restaurant….Cozumel location would be ideal….I am sooo tired of the pizza, gross pick up and go style that is seen all over Elmwood and Allen….Just Pizza, Mister Pizza, Zettis(needs a much cleaner rest), Ginos….A friendly inviting space where people can get pizza, a beer , sit down and enjoy…..Good luck

  • If they do an outstanding job designing the interior, the food and service are good, and the prices reasonable, it might just stick around for 21 years…

  • Jones7986

    If there is vegan options for pizza I will be there! Soggy veggie pizza hold the cheese just not cutting it on the Elmwood strip

  • Ivan putski jr

    I’m not sure where Joe, the owner…came up with the name for his pizzeria…but I love it!!!

  • Cam33r4

    “Buffalo-style pizza” is really hit or miss.  I hope they can do well with this one.  Also, I assume this isn’t going to be like Vera and have a bar?
    Either way, it’s nice to know that that corner will no longer be an eyesore!

  • DruBonic

    My sober self is indifferent… my drunken self is amped

  • elmdog

    I must of missed the article about Europa buying its own building on Connecticut street….Congrats to one of the coziest, coolest restaurants on Elmwood…..But….This just opens up one more eye sore on Elmwood and people have stated on here not to be worried about the vacant spaces on Elmwood…….???? EVA, the city of Buffalo….Someone do something about the continued vacancies along what is supposed to be the most vibrant neighborhoods in town….Ambrosia, Louies hot dogs, Mode, Noodle Bar, Europa, Cozumel…..embarrassing

  • rcgalbraith

    Oh good, they’ll have healthy options like wraps.