MLK splash pad nearing completion
Comments
Leave a commentSo if the hours end at 7 and it doesnt get dark until 8-9pm who is going to see the lights? Who thought this out? Typical mindless city planning.
Possibly that lighting will help with nightly security against vandalism? The drawing doesn't show any lamp posts except around pathway edges near trees, so that LED lighting at the water jets might be how the splash pad portion of facility will be lit even when closed.
This project sounds fine to me... public $ for publicly owned infrastructure.
Hopefully what ex-716 predicts below about trashing won't happen. Time will tell.
This is one of those projects that if done correctly and works...Then it should of been done at the inner or outer harbor....This project would attract people to an area...I know that this proejct wont attract outsiders to this given area and understand that its for the neighborhood....Looks great...If its sunny and mid day I might bring my child
Well it pretty much is being done at canalside, water feature and ice skating is kinda the entire focus of the development
Unfortunately this will be trashed within 2-3 summers. A waste of money at this location.
The taggers are drooling as we speak.
Nice project. Calling LED lighting and water jets "cutting edge technology" did make me laugh, though.
Great to hear. Any real live photos of the project?
Lets see if the local neighborhood residents take the initiative and actually work together to keep the area clean and maintained. Hopefully it does not turn into a thug hangout with any fighting and gun violence. As soon as that happens it scares off anyone even thinking of visiting the park.
Yes this is in a predominantly black neighborhood, and now it would be wonderful to see a coalition of black volunteers step up to take care of the park, instead of waiting for others to come in and clean the mess. Be proud and take care of your neighborhood and its assets.
It would also be nice if your brain cells formed a coalition and advised you how to properly think through your thoughts before hitting submit.
Are you still pouting about the Bills coach topic? Though you may want to believe it, you are not the smartest person in the room. Again, try to spend more time articulating a well thought out point instead of correcting everyone's grammar.
If I may borrow use of your stale line "Get over it."
Never claimed to be the smartest guy in the room, but at least I'm not an assumptive racist. And to be fair, you were the one pouting in the Bills discussion.
This site is simply amazing. A comment like this: "Yes this is in a predominantly black neighborhood, and now it would be wonderful to see a coalition of black volunteers step up to take care of the park, instead of waiting for others to come in and clean the mess." is voted up. You should all be ashamed; how very assumptive -- and unbelievably racist -- of you all.
Even if your 'guarantee' comes true, it isn't as though the murderer wouldn't have just done what he or she wanted to do someplace else anyway even if this wasn't built, so I'm not seeing what your point is (unless just a random prediction?)
Murders and other violent crimes happen at many different types of place - houses, bars, deli's, sometimes even a nice restaurant on Delaware, or a Metro Rail station,… even parking lots aren't immune.
Anyone who wants to try killing or robbing someone, etc., will very easily find a place for it.
Agreed, but from learning from past events, it seems that these crimes occur in public areas in bad neighborhoods it seems. Just another gathering area for bad elemets. And it is just a prediction. But it is a nice addition to have for the park for sure.
Well, yeah, and some very bad things have happened in Delaware Park, Amherst Bike Path, Cheektowaga's community center in park there, and so on.
On the other hand - as with all of those - this park/pad likely will have a lot of good people who use it too.
Differences in crime rates are what they are. It would be nice if our justice system was less lax than it is, or better yet if more people just decided to not be violent ... but I'm not expecting any noticeable changes in any of those things.
"Well, yeah, and some very bad things have happened in Delaware Park, Amherst Bike Path, Cheektowaga's community center in park there, and so on."
That being said for every bike path rapist there's 100's of killings that happen in inner city minority areas. And the killing at Cheektowaga Town Park two years ago was committed by a black youth from the East Side of Buffalo.
Up, yes, as I said "Differences in crime rates are what they are."
I don't think many people are in denial about it. Some are perhaps, but most realize it.
It would be nice if our state/local judges, DA office prosecutors, legislators, voters, etc. weren't as lax as they are about what you noted, &/or if fewer people chose to do violently criminal behaviors.
Probably neither of those changes will happen in any big way - so everything else in life goes on, when it can.
BR editor - deleting comments is your right of course, but when you fully delete and leave no trace of a comment then you should also do the same with the linked replies others had written under it.
You deleted yesterday's comment by MoveAlongPLz which had 'guaranteed' a murder, to which this Jan 10 12:26 PM comment of mine had replied, then others replied to me.
I can understand why you wanted to fully delete MoveAlong's weird comment about murder, but then you left my reply to that one in a way which the context now looks as though I had first brought up the murder topic...
when actually I was replying to what MoveAlong's now disappeared comment before it.
I suggest if you fully delete any comment and leave no trace of it like you did that time, you should also just delete the whole thread of replies to it.
That would mean deleting this portion of the thread starting with my 12:26pm comment and all under it - unfortunate, perhaps - but the whole context of it became twisted once you decided to fully remove the MoveAlong's original creepy guarantee of 'murder'.
Ok, that looks a little better now that you've put back at least the trace of that deleted top comment from Move. Better than how it was when that was totally gone. Thanks.
Just remember that the park is in the poorest section of the city. In winter when ice skating is available make sure is usable for the people who live there. It is also going to to take constant maintenance and supervision because it will be a gathering spot for everyone in and out of the neighborhood. There are several parks in the east side that were built and expected to be maintained by the people who live next door. As for the graffiti comments, you can either be afraid of it or work with it, If it happens oh well. If the fountains are vandalized and broken so they don't work anymore, than that's a different story. I'm not a spray paint expert but how well does it hold up in water?
How 'bout we start thinking differently about the East Side?
How 'bout the East Side starts acting differently? It's like my dad used say when I was growing up, "the reason why you can't have anything nice, is because you can't take care of anything."
How 'bout we think about what's really wrong with the East Side? Lack of quality or skilled jobs to provide for families, poor education and lack of infastructure. I can't believe how many up votes that got, wow.
"Lack of quality or skilled jobs to provide for families"
....or a lack of educated and motivated individuals to fill positions.
"poor education"
Lack of motivation to get an education
lack of infastructure
"I'm not sure what that's even supposed to mean? Last time I checked there's roads on the East Side"
I meant lack of quality infastructure (pretty prevalent throgh the whole city), where there isn't a pothole every 2 feet. I'll tell ya, I live in the'burbs and none exist. No good edu.=no motivation=no job. No good education around=no salary paying job
Perhaps pride of neighbor and neighborhood ought to be exhibited from within the east side first before everyone from outside just blindly chooses to think of it as something it unfortunately is not anymore. Poor doesnt have to mean litter, violence, gang tags painted on buildings, etc. etc. and yet decade after decade we see the same carelessness. I can understand the skepticism about this new investment on the east side and its sad that time after time, example after example, leads to such conclusions. In its hey day, many parts of the east side were NEVER affluent and the homes were modest but the streets were still well maintained and kept up. Neighbors looked out for each other and the majority had a mutual respect for others and the community, taking pride in it. Until that mindset comes back and physical improvements are noticeably made why should anyone change their thoughts on the east side? Sad but true I predict within a week or less there will probably be more gun violence somewhere on the east side and unfortunately can make that prediction for every week of the year. That type of stuff doesnt build community or make someone want to go outside. People become prisoners in their own homes and neighborhoods because its an unsafe mess. I cant make similar predictions in other areas around Buffalo or WNY. Improvement must originate from within just like an alcoholic needs to make a personal commitment to quit.
Why do all the friends of Olmsted Members look like they are all white . It is about time that more African Americans take some pride in their city. Look at the Michigan ave heritage area , it is full of potential but nobody has stepped up to take charge of it.
"It is about time that more African Americans take some pride in their city. Look at the Michigan ave heritage area , it is full of potential but nobody has stepped up to take charge of it."
I think that says more about the African American community than it does about why the members of Friends of Olmstead are all white.
For god sakes you two. Sweeping generalizations. Do you know how ridiculous you sound?
Main Street in Williamsville looks like shit and its a horrible place to walk. It has so much more potential. That really says a lot about the white people there - couldn't they take more pride in their community?
Kenmore avenue looks like shit too - more white people...
"Main Street in Williamsville looks like shit and its a horrible place to walk."
Ummmm I'm not sure how many people you'd get to agree with that?
What a ridiculous comment. Walked down Main Street in Williamsville and Broadway in Buffalo around 2am any night during the summer and get back to us how you feel.
Actually – it says neither . . . what it does say has a lot more to with poverty than race. It is fact (when painting with broad strokes) that you will find more community advocacy groups in areas of greater affluence. As disposable income becomes less of a problem, one has more time to dedicate to communal issues. For many on the East Side of our fair City the day to day struggle of survival is of greater concern than if a park is kept graffiti and garbage free. If one is working multiple jobs to support their family (and please do not counter with some stale comment about lazy welfare recipients – if you spent any time in the Community you would understand that most folks there want to do right by their familial and societal obligations – you know, working, paying bills, obeying the law . . . ) there is little to no time or energy left to expend on organizations in the vein of Friends of Olmstead.
If one really desires to see change take hold in areas of desperate depression (and one should, if one really cares about meeting societal obligations, instead of living off the fat circumstance has so fortuitously thrown in their lap) a true and sincere effort needs to be made to ensure equitable and accessible education. The current system we have in place only ensure mediocrity at best in neighborhoods such as those found on the East Side. The cycle of poverty is perpetuated and becomes “cultural” in places where education has been put on the backburner in the name of budget, benefits, and political ineptitude. The cycle of poverty is perpetuated by government programs that only seek to placate a population with bread and circuses than really invest in their future and goals of self sufficiency. The cycle of poverty is perpetuated by insensitive, shallow, presumptive, and self righteous remarks and attitudes that affirm feelings of inadequacy in the downtrodden. This applies to you if you live on the East Side of Buffalo, South Central LA, or the verdant hills of Appalachia. This applies to you if your skin hue is as dark as ebony or as light as snow. Poverty subverts society, and ultimately, destroys it from the inside out.
It’s damn shameful that as the ship takes on water, the rats – both in the bilge and on the bridge – try to drown one another instead of working as a unit to save their home . . .
you mean no one like the michigan street preservation corporation? do you think all that new landscaping just fell out of the sky? that the nash house rehabilitated itself while no one was looking?
The comments are this article are very unsavory, and thinly-veiled racism in some cases. To me it just sounds like envy that poverty-stricken neighborhoods are getting something nice. And we should not generalize the entire East Side as a place where no one takes care of their neighborhood. When I drive or ride through the neighborhoods near MLK Park or Masten Park, I see plenty of homes that are kept up, with flowers planted, etc. Sure, there are far too many absentee landlords letting their houses rot away, but there are also many homeowners who do their best with very limited resources, and it is unfair to them to ignore them entirely.
This "pull yourself up by the bootstraps" nonsense gets old fast. The implication seems to be that poor (or black) neighborhoods don't deserve infrastructure improvements from city government until they demonstrate the ability to do the work themselves. Do you need to see neighborhood volunteers filling in potholes on their own dime before you'll approve of seeing a city work crew doing it?
Many of the comments on this thread are ignorant and certainly border on racist.
They don't belong on a site called "Buffalo Rising".
We are better than this.
Well said. There is definitely some racist undertones in many of the comments and it's sad. While I do understand the skepticism people have about how this will turn out, it wouldn't be the end of the world if people gave it chance to open and function before counting this as a failure.
It's difficult to get rid of conservatives once the infestation starts.
GTO - it's clear to see how much you're against stereotyping, lol
if i ever come across a conservative who is not a violent anti-american scumbag i will let you know.
Sounds like you skinny jeans are causing blood flow problems to your brain located between your legs. Try getting off the couch
Great but I always thought:
-Humboldt Park had to many roads.
-The Science Magnet should have been built on the border or nearby to Humboldt Park rather than inside the park
-whatever happened to the Science museum decking over the Kensington
would like to know when the existing Calvert Veaux structure that was moved off of Humboldt Park will be moved back and restored.
Great to concentrate on the fountain/splash pad and lighting but any news or report out should really cover the whole picture...because people will read it and want to know more...whats next...when....etc.
With the successes and expansions over at the Life Sciences Campus...Masten Park, Masten Armory, City Honors, Humboldt Park, Science Magnet, Science Museum...these all become MAJOR focal points for attracting investment in the surrounding community.
This is one of the more disappointing dialogues I've ever seen on Buffalorising. MLK park has some great pavilions and some of the nicest tennis courts in the city. I've played there many times instead of watching others play on the crowded courts in Delaware park. I've gotten Ribs from Lee's BBQ and sat and had a nice relaxing lunch at one of the picnic tables.
Every park in almost every municipality has vandalism at some point. I'll tell you how you don't cut the risk is by not investing in the facilities and people taking a stance that they won't go there.
I plan on going to check this place out in all seasons. The naysayers can keep empowering this small minority of trouble makers by hanging out in their safe havens telling everyone whats wrong with the world. This should be a regional asset we can all be proud of, its all our choices what it becomes, not just those in the surrounding neighborhoods.
They were supposed to have finished this last summer.
"up and coming", are you really?
There is nothing about Buffalo that I find more repellant than racist comments from ignorant white people. It is honestly the worst part of coming home. I can accept the lack of wealth, crime, retrograde style, broken sidewalks (or no sidewalks)and overall bleakness but I can't stand the racism that I notice when I'm there.
This story (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VdwSJIbomAw) about the arson fire in the First Ward really disturbed me. A refugee comes to this country only to have his home burned down because the dumb fucks of the First Ward are violent and obsessed with race. And now to read a person who calls himself "Old First Ward" on this blog make the first racist comment after an article about a pool, it makes me think of how much room for improvement there is in Buffalo.
First off why would you say I'm white? That sounds like racial profiling to me. Which makes you just as guilty as the guy in the video. Also, until we face racial issues in this country and stop hiding behind being "politically correct" we'll never address the core issue. The truth is that racial stereotypes are very much a reality, in black and white culture. I'll say this much. My mothers lived in some of the most dangerous/black areas in Buffalo (Best St Goodyear etc) and always dated black guys and had a black step father growing up, who I liked more than my own father most times. That being said, I lived with my father mostly, who lived in a 99.9 percent white area. I had two black kids and one hispanic kid go to my school in the whole four years I was there. So needless to say I've seen both sides of the coin. That being said, stereotypes run both ways, white and black. Blacks think whites are soft, unathletic, stuck up and born with a silver spoon there mouth. Whites think every black person plays basketball, has robbed someone, or know somoeone who's robbed someone in there life. So lets cut the self-righteous crap and get real.
Changing views is impossible. The change starts with you, with me. Drop the perpetuation of stereotypes--it goes a long way.
Stereotypes often borden on reality my friend.
Read this. I find it interesting to look at perspectives from both sides of the aisle.
I didn't guess your race. I guessed that you are not actually up and coming.
The other separate thought was that there are certain things that will make me not take you seriously and not want to be near you. One of those things is ignorant racist comments. I hear more racist comments in Buffalo (always from white people usually about black people) than anywhere else I have been so far. Its embarrassing. And its so obvious that these comments are coming from ignorant and isolated people who ignore the broader reality of racism in America and instead choose to dwell on anecdotes about the east side of Buffalo. If we want to discuss closing the achievement gap or reducing poverty, then talk about that seriously. Its not about being politically correct, its about being correct and constructive.
"There is nothing about Buffalo that I find more repellant than racist comments from ignorant white people"
You actually did. Your comment above was a direct reference to my comment.
Dawid, What I'm about to say should not be interpreted as an endorsement of BurchJP-UpandComing's racism, his silly I-Can't-be-racist-because-I-have-black-friends out clause, or the ongoing insistence that his and others subjective views should be considered "reality" simply by repeating the R-word whenever someone calls him out.
That said, I have to disagree with your take that Buffalo is somehow more racist than other places. Yes we have our own talk radio nation that, among other things, likes to make self-indulgent and racially charged comments on stories that involve "that part of town." But other places have this element too. It is a negative quality that persists throughout the US, and doesn't seem to me to be more or less prevalent in Buffalo.
I would imagine that you are right. There must be other places where people are so openly prejudiced. I would guess that there is similar behavior in Southern states but I didn't hear any of it while I was there. I grew up in South Buffalo and my family's roots are on the East Side, so its quite possible that I'm getting a heavier than normal dose of white grievance bull****ing when I'm there.
"I-Can't-be-racist-because-I-have-black-friends out clause,"
If I was racist I wouldn't hang out with black people and have black friends of all socioeconomic backgrouds. So yeah, it actually does.
No Burch. Your claims of who your friends are do not make you a non-racist. Not making racist comments make you a would do that, at least overtly.
Funny that the "I-have-(insert minority group)-friends" pretend racist immunity clause is mocked so often I didn't think anybody would seriously try to make that point. I guess I was wrong.
Old First Ward and Up and Coming – This is a resubmission of a quote that I directed to a very negative commenter on another issue regarding the Eastside. In its brevity it says so much about your baseless indictment of the MLK neighborhood, the Eastside and its residents-at-large.
There is nothing more dangerous (or tiresome – my note) than sincere ignorance and conscientious stupidity. (Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.)
My comments were not an indictment but a well wishing and a call to action. Meanwhile, while you were micro managing posts looking for racism in buzz words you forgot to call out that moron davvid who was calling white people ignorant racists and Old First Ward residents "dumb F*cks." well before you posted.
But its not surprising that your criteria didn't fit those harsh comments. Which only goes to show that your agenda of being offended only applies to blacks.
I stand by my comments, and I hope that all the kids of that neighborhood enjoy that water pad. For that park to thrive and the community around it to prosper, black residents need to volunteer, and get into their community and work harder and organize to make it a better place. Unemployment may be high for some, but volunteering is free and fulfilling.
With that I leave to you a quote back, from Thomas Jefferson:
Determine never to be idle. No person will have occasion to complain of the want of time who never loses any. It is wonderful how much may be done if we are always doing.
-Thomas Jefferson
"Determine never to be idle."
That was easy for Thomas Jefferson to say when he had more than 200 slaves doing all the hard work for him!
Who wants to take bets on how long it will take for the first drug related arrest? Or dead body found around the basin? Dont deny it, you were all thinking the same thing.
I need more information before placing a bet. Will you be visiting the area often?
Oh please stop the liberal drama.
People make statements based off experience, word of mouth (ie other people experience) etc.
People behave differently individually and as a group. This is a socialogical and psychological fact.
Fact: Lower incomes have lower test scores.
Fact: Generations of poverty can create a cultural norm of poverty
Fact: Poor neighborhoods with less intact families have lower test scores
Fact: There are certain cultural norms in the african american community where the norms are against academic achievement. Proven comparing African American test scores to test scores from immigrants from Caribbean and immigrants from Africa show markedly less difference with caucasion and other minorities.
Move an individual into a different area and they will adjust to and take on the norms of the majority.
Move a group into a different area and they will either stay to themselves isolated or they will conflict/change the norms of the majority. This is why people fear groups will cause change.
You just cant stick your head in liberal ignorance and expect to inculcate people away from their experiences and perceptions.
This argument about race ignores the fact that institutional racism was the foundation for the problems that still exist today. When I was growing up racism was blatant and in your face, now it is more soft and covert but still limits progress and potential. Poverty is the other driver, African Americans have historically have been less able to accumulate wealth due to a history of being oppressed and limited in opportunities. I know some will argue that is no longer the case but generations of this oppression has considerably impacted the lives of African Americans to this day. It takes generations to build wealth and to provide the grounding necessary for success. African Americans have not had the same opportunities or base of mentors and role models that white Americans take for granted.
There is also a real problem with a culture of violence that some in the African American community embrace. This is by far a minority of people but their impact is great. Some claim this culture was adopted from their roots in the south where violence was and still is much more prevalent.
I wish there was some easy fix but the reality is until we address the issue of poverty in a meaningful way we will be unlikely to make much progress. Racism thrives because many equate the problem of poverty with race, the only way to change tht perception is to reduce poverty.
"There is also a real problem with a culture of violence that some in the African American community embrace. This is by far a minority of people but their impact is great. Some claim this culture was adopted from their roots in the south where violence was and still is much more prevalent.
I wish there was some easy fix but the reality is until we address the issue of poverty in a meaningful way we will be unlikely to make much progress. Racism thrives because many equate the problem of poverty with race, the only way to change tht perception is to reduce poverty"
Very well put.
"Some claim this culture was adopted from their roots in the south where violence was and still is much more prevalent."
Some claim the most violent city in America is Detroit, which is firmly NOT in the south. I think your idea that the south was and still is much more violent is questionable.
Modern day Detroit is pretty bad, but I believe he meant farther in the past; the Jim Crow South. As for North vs. South violence statistics, I don't know the answer to that one myself.
Where did you get that he meant farther in the past, or in the past at all? He said, "...in the south were violence was AND STILL IS much more prevalent." He clearly was talking about the past as well as the present.
The south is and historically has been the most violent region in the United States. http://crimeclt.blogspot.com/2011/04/south-most-violent-region-in-nation.html
Institutionalized racism in the job market, hampered blacks and kept many without careers for generations. This combined with shitty schools today fuels the internal culture of despair. Don't believe the "lazy" B.S.
And so being poor forces a person to throw their old furniture and trash on their lawn and spraypaint local businesses? It's about self respect and sheer laziness not economics. No one is forced to behave in a certain manner by their financial circumstances....thats lazy thinking and scapegoating.
the corkscrew in delaware park over the 198 is a chronic graffiti magnet, and it is spreading onto the lincoln parkway bridge, but i don't see anyone blaming it on the affluence of the surrounding neighborhood.
How to end the poverty problem in Buffalo:
1) Go to school everyday, and graduate from high school.
2) Upon graduation, get a job. Any job (and there are plenty of jobs out there for people who have few skills but an excellent work ethic and attitude).
3) Do not get pregnant while you are single. It does not take rocket science to figure out how not to get pregnant.
4) Get married. A couple with high school degrees and several years of work experience should be easily earning $35,000, which is decent money in Buffalo.
5) Rent the cheapest 1BR apartment you can find in a safe area. Save up for several years.
6) Then have a baby.
That's it. 95% of poverty in Buffalo would be eliminated, with no government assistance!
if only it were that simple.
if it only was that simple.
Rubagreta - There would be poverty in Buffalo and across the entire US even if every person had a master's degree and everybody was married before they had children.
Actually, a glut of degrees would contribute to that circumstance, since the abundance would greatly devalue them job-wise.
My Dad used to live in this neighborhood. If I remember correctly this isn't as much a new addition as much as it is returning it to what it was before it was trashed by residents.
And it's too easy to chalk things up to economics. It was a low income area back then as well but people had the self respect and motivation to take care of what belonged to them and what was around them. Income and education has nothing to do with it. Whether poor or rich you can clean up and care for your surroundings. Growing up my parents didnt make much money and we had some lean years financially but we respected what we had enough to actually take care of it.
I hope I am wrong but, while I am all for improving the area, until the mindset of the area changes it will just be another structure that will fall into disrepair over time and dismantled.
Is there any irony that one commenter is repeatedly making a stereotyping negative generalization about Buffalonians based on his anecdotal personal encounters?
davvid>"I hear more racist comments in Buffalo (always from white people usually about black people) than anywhere else I have been so far."
Now, if anyone on here stated that same kind of negative generalizing but substituting some other behavior and group of people, all based on personal anecdotal experiences with individuals of some group... well, the reaction might depend on the group.
And he didn't retract it when Spock disagreed with it … only "guessed" there's other places where people have similar behavior as Buffalonians, still assuming a lot based on a small sample size of Buffalonians he's met.
Also, we see another commenter GTO's repeated negative generalizing against people of a political philosophy with which he/she disagrees.
Yet in this long thread nobody condemned either of those two.
WTbasketball and I joked about GTO, and Spock politely disagreed with davvid, but nobody's reaction was to condemn or criticize with words like "ignorant" or "unsavory" as were said about some others.
Maybe I'm the only one who sees some irony in all that.
I'm not saying these things are all exactly the same, and I'm not assuming anything either way about what any commenters in this thread, those I mentioned or any others, really deeply believe.
I can't see into anybody's soul the way Bush said he could with Putin's.
But it's interesting to notice similar patterns along with differences in reactions.
If we ignore history or the racially motivated arson last year, then a disparaging remark lobbed from the First Ward at the East Side doesn't really mean much at all. Maybe then you'd belong to the Michael Scott/Stephen Colbert club of ironic white men who conveniently claim to not see race. It would be convenient for a white male in 2013 to imagine that all groups are the same and that the problem is simply about generalizations or negativity instead of the broader issue of racism.
My views are of course informed in part by personal experience but also by research and debate. I don't think institutional racism is a myth. I see it in my own small world but I've also heard people much smarter than I state the statistics about poverty, education, incarceration etc. and make the case again and again.
If I am totally off base, please enlighten me. I haven't read anything on this thread yet that really challenges my views.
davvid - my point wasn't saying anyone should ignore arsons or ignore any racial bias no matter where it happens, and I'm not saying anything is a myth.
It was about what looks to me as your attributing those disproportionately to Buffalonians (relative to residents of other places) based on a small number of anecdotal events to which you referred.
For example, if anybody had denied that Buffalo has some extreme racists among 260,000 residents - then of course it would've been responsive to that claim for you to cite an arson and/or attitudes of Buffalonians who you've met.
However, it looked to me that you went way farther in generalizing that Buffalonians are unusually bad in this regard - which looked to me not very different from GTO's generalizing based on him/her never having personally met anyone of a certain political view who aren't violent scumbags, and things UpAndComing said in various comments based on personal interactions or the shooting in Cheektowaga.
In all 3 cases, someone's comments relayed selected events and personal observations in ways which readers could interpret as negatively generalizing about many thousands of people in the groups being commented about - Buffalonians, conservatives, African-Americans.
Is there any big difference I'm overlooking in the analytical approaches all 3 of you were taking?
In regards to GTO's comments that went unchallenged, it doesn't seem like it's worth the effort to engage someone like that.
Second, I found the racist comments a bit strange. If I found myself in the company of people making racist comments, I'd find new friends (or do with out).
I may be greatly over stating in the next bit here... but I think those on the right are a bit overwhelmed by the leftward shift our leadership is taking. They won, that's fine. So rather than argue, I think there's a bit of withdrawing that's taking place. Economically, I think it's bad for the country. You see it in the various financial markets. The right has kind of picked up their toys, and gone to their room.
The left needs the right. The right...well, not so much. I'm all for BRL saying there needs to be a bigger middle class. But in this environment, I don't see it happening. I'm in a position where I'm involved in hiring, and we will bend over backwards to automate something before we'll consider bringing in another body.
It's almost as if we've been told by the left long enough that we're greedy bastards, that we're beginning to act the part. We argue that to create wealth, you need to expand the pie. The left says, no, we want a bigger slice. Rather than argue about it, we're protecting our slice, and not being too proud of it.
Ben- Our leadership is not shifting left, it is moving back to the center where most Americans reside. Trust me, I'm squarely on the left and we don't see any real strong movement by leadership at all. I do see a sea change in the grass roots, people are more liberal and more tolerant, the conservatives are losing these voters in droves.
The pie is plenty big enough, it is nothing more than greed and manipulation that results in 50% of Americans sharing just 1% of our nations wealth. That is obscene, they do indeed need a "bigger piece of the pie". How can we have a civil society where one half of our citizens have no real investment? Our public policy should empower and advocate for the public, not for a small minority of the wealthy and powerful.
My success has little to do with public policy. I like what I do, and I do it 16 hours per day. I'd prefer to create wealth for others, but that's not the system that won this past election. I (or people like me) can grow the pie, but we've been told were not needed. I'm fine with that. Let's see where we are after 8 years of this.
All business benefits from government, you must know the infrastructure, rule of law, and structure provided by taxpayers makes your business possible. Big business requires even more public resources, we all subsidize capitalism in one way or another. I have no problem with that provided there is some basic fairness, presently that is not the case.
On the election, it is ridiculous to make the Romney claim that voters choose the free lunch. The majority voted for fairness, for tolerance, and against the far right crazies that have come to define the Republican party.
Great, more of the 'you didn't build that'.
Listen, I'm conceding, your side won. I'm part of the 'far right crazies' ...really? I pay taxes (part of a small local business that pays millions of dollars in taxes), don't take any subsidy (of which I could qualify), have created good jobs, have nice apartments I rent to happy tenants in a building that was abandoned before I purchased it. But I don't have any idea what I'm talking about.
You won. Now go fix poverty. Go create jobs. Build the middle class. I have an idea how our side would do that. I hope you know what your doing.
Chris Christie will make a strong candidate. So, chin up.
Leave a comment
Sponsor
Recent Comments
Sponsor
Interested in advertising on BuffaloRising?
E-mail John C. Powell
or call John at 716.602.0200




So glad to see this. What a nice addition to the park!