Buffalo wins IBM Smarter Cities Challenge Grant
Comments
Leave a commentBut we still cant sync a street light on Delaware!
more good grantwriting!
will this ibm team meet and talk to anyone outside of their city hall hosts?
Or I wonder if for a program like this maybe IBM chooses the dumbest sounding grant applications - figuring those city govts are most in need of help to become smarter?
I cant wait to here what proposals come out of this, seems like a pretty good thing
irishkwh - that was my exact thought! But you have to expand that to Porter, Elmwood, ...
...Colvin, Starin...
Elmwood's lights were synchronized last year.
And syncing traffic lights is usually bad for cities. It turns streets from places that encourage small businesses, sidewalk cafes, strolling, etc., into places that are simply optimized for speeding automobile commuters through and out of the city.
What you're saying makes sense. But when is it too much? The lights on Delaware at Great Arrow and Amherst are INSANE! Better shot at winning the lottery than making it through both.
I was mistaken with Colvin and Starin, btw. I was thinking of another complaint, the lane-and-a-half/create-your-own-lane scenario on many streets in the city.
Here is a novel idea...that maybe the genius's at IBM could tell us. Its what other cities like Rochester do routinely.
Create a council or consortium that includes local business in the Buffalo Niagara Region and local high schools, colleges, universities and trade schools in the Buffalo Niagara Region.
Tailor the degree programs and curriculae to degrees that suit local the local business community so we are not paying to educating our people to leave.
Find out the GAPs in our work force skill level and gaps in our local industry and gaps in our local R&D and work to bridge them so local business has what they need to expand locally and dont feel pressured to leave because Buffalo Niagara doesnt offer them the talent and support system they need.
Buffalo tends to go it alone rather than cooperate. It took the city going bankrupt to get local business out of their office to be the stewards that they should have been all along.
There are things that Buffalo can do that require changing how we communicate and partner...
Sorry to be a cynic, but is there any connection between the prospective Buffalo $Billion and IBM's sudden interest in Buffalo (and, that another consultancy was chosen to help Buffalo allocate the money....)?
Well Travelrrr, there actually is no real tangible Buffalo b-word. And McKinsey already took whatever token cash handed out, so let that buttress your anti-business mantra.
We need new progressive leadership and maybe more other empty cliches..
"Anti-business mantra"? You got the wrong joe, Joe. I'm not anti-business--I'm anti-cronyism and, yes, am a bit skeptical of IBM's sudden interest. I'd be happy to be proven wrong on this...
I'll agree with Travelrrr. I was thinking man this and we got that Billion "dollars" from the state...hey wait a minute.
To get a different perspective will be nice but I'm more worried that city hall acts all receptive to their suggestions then files them away.
I'm very happy Buffalo won this. HOwever, I'm skeptical that outsiders can swoop in and solve problems. I hope I'm wrong, of course, and they might suggest some really good things that others have not noticed previously. I hope they actually bring in money to upgrade technology where it's needed. I hope that the upgraded technology doesn't include future payments to IBM for servicing and whatnot that lock the city into every increasing payments.
Be careful -- not everything that is free is actually free. Sometimes it can be very costly.
what worries me about the fetish for outside expertise is the time it takes to educate every new consultant over and over and over again.
when you start a new job, are you better at solving the problems that you've been hired to handle when you're two weeks on the job or two years?
having said that, i'm still glad we won the grant.
First, it's almost always a positive thing for the city to win a grant like this. It puts the city on a 'list' - whatever that list might be - that keeps the city current and in the minds of a wider audience. That alone gets at least a few points.
Second, a group of 'experts' coming in for three weeks really won't make that big of a difference. I've lived and breathed and understand traffic in East Africa. They say that IBM made a difference in Nairobi's traffic? No way. The people that made a difference in Nairobi's traffic are the Kenyans clued into ICT innovations that used the technology to improve the traffic situation. It's happening, and it's being led by local talent.
Finally, Buffalo has it's own collection of local talent. Some of them are already living in Buffalo. Most of them are still outside the region. The big challenge (which isn't impossible because of widespread intense pride and love for the region) is mobilizing these talents to identify solutions for the city. A bunch of IBM experts won't solve Buffalo's problems (and the grant doesn't even identify any kind of tangible collaboration with local 'experts' for knowledge transfer!).
Buffalonians - native, expats, and transplants - are the key to unlocking the region's future. IBM is great, but I'd take a Buffalo-born tech-expert over their talent any day.
As a quick follow up to my first message there - around the world there are issues that have been 'solved' by a team of experts visiting for a few weeks. But these solutions are not really sustainable in a long-term sense. This is a structural issue with international development and one of the big reasons interventions like the kind that IBM is bringing to cities don't usually endure (check out the Syracuse edition here: https://smartercitieschallenge.org/city_syracuse_ny.html). It's great that Syracuse has this tool (and I wondering what 'gift' Buffalo will receive) - but I wonder how much it will actually be used in the long-term. Better for IBM to engage directly with talent that have strong ties to the region to facilitate solutions - initiatives are more likely to endure when there are people on the ground pushing for it to do so.
Leave a comment
Sponsor
Recent Comments
Sponsor
Interested in advertising on BuffaloRising?
E-mail John C. Powell
or call John at 716.602.0200




Speed up the permitting process by using digital files for submission and clarification on plan review questions. This would help us in the development world immensely. Hopefully this whole study doesn't amount to nothing more than a dog and pony photo opportunity. Hopefully Mayor Brown will dedicate some resources to recommendations and findings.
Agreed, right now they have only 1 person reviewing plans in the fire prevention bureau and he's only allowed to work 4 days a week so everything bottlenecks in that department. I've had to wait upwards of 7 weeks for a permit for a small $30k project. If your project is weather dependent you better submit in early spring / late winter if there's any hope you'll be able to work in the drier/warmer weather.