East Side Hidden Treasure
Comments
Leave a commentfantastic building. wash off the blue paint and it'll be a stunner.
I think this is the building Nate Benderson bought for the salvage value of the beer bottles. The purchase started him in the business of being a landlord. Can anyone verify that it was this building?
if beer bottles had that much salvage value, all of the canners (i think of them as bottle gleaners) would be millionaires by now.
This is the first commercial building Nate Benderson ever bought. He bought the building for the brewery equipment which he then sold off. The beer brewing equipment netted enough to recoup his investment, so he ended up with this place for free. That's what started him on real estate.
The beer bottle story comes earlier.
Nate Benderson was 15, living at home, which was an upper flat off Hertel. His father eeked out a living recycling bottles. Nate found a brewery that was going out of business. He made a deal to buy all the bottles (which he intended to sell to other brewers). The owner of the brewery told him that, due to his age, Nate's father would have to co-sign the deal.
Nate's father refused. He'd lost their house in the depression and refused to ever again take any credit. So Nate Benderson, instead of giving up on the deal, gassed up his jalopy, drove to Rochester, Syracuse, Binghampton, Albany and sold all the bottles to other breweries. Then he returned to the brewery seller, showed him all the contracts he had to sell the bottles, and told him: "Look, you've got to sell me the bottles. I've already sold them!". They guy saw the contracts were legit and was convinced Nate could then pay him the money the contract called for, so he sold his bottles to Nate and Nate then went about deal making until eventually buying this building for the beer making equipment and ending up with the building, which started him on commercial real estate.
thank you. these stories always get mangled over time.
This is a very cool looking building. I'd love to see something done with this. If we could revitalize the Broadway Market, and get something nice here, it could be a good beginning to turning around some of the East Side. Unlike a US-Canadian-split stadium on no-man's island, I feel this may actually not be so much of a pipe dream, either.
I don't know which will see an upswing first, the city of Niagara Falls or the East Side of Buffalo. Both in terrible shape, and neither looking like they will ever snap out of it.
The Broadway market is hanging on by a string, and if it wasn't for Easter, Thanksgiving and Xmas, would have folded up shop a long time ago. While this brewery building has some history, I am not sure what business you think is going to go in there that will help turn the neighborhood around.
True. But I guess I just look at how portions of the West Side has been turning around little-by-little for the better, and now some of it is becoming a pretty up-and-coming area, and it makes me think about maybe there is some hope for the East Side as well.
The West side also has the best housing stock in all of Buffalo too. The East Side, not so much.
This is the building. I kept looking and found an obituary online that mentioned it.
Who owns it? What are they doing with it? Is it for sale?
William & Donna Tarr. Owners' address is on the Erie County tax payment site.
Doesn't seem to be in use or for sale, and wasn't on this year's auction.
"I don't know which will see an upswing first, the city of Niagara Falls or the East Side of Buffalo. Both in terrible shape, and neither looking like they will ever snap out of it."
One house at a time, one building at a time, one street at a time, one neighborhood at a time. It's a long process, no question.
Stories like this help expose potential retrofits to potential buyers.
The City of Niagara Falls will never rebound; not in our lifespan, as the cohesive force that you find in various corners of Buffalo does not exist in Niagara Falls and probably never did for that matter.
The East side is definitely a challenge.
However, in the interim, this building may be ideally suited for a not-for-profit agency such as Habitat for Humanity or even PUSH Buffalo if and when they decided to cross over from the west side to the east side.
That would make a great Brewery or microBrewery or Distillery
I could really see something incredible happening where people would go to the East Side to patronize.
If we could only put more traffic on the streets rather than on the expressways...that would help the eastside so much.
And I disagree with the previous poster who said the best housing stock is on the westside...thats incorrect. Humboldt Parway prior to the Kensington Expressway was considered on par or better than Elmwood...that would include Masten and the neighborhoods surrounding Humboldt Park.
If the eastside is to come back...then it will be from leveraging its unknown and forgotten jewels.
oh yes..and you can count on me favoring the 1890s Broadway Market over the current 1950s Broadway Market. My suggestion is to take a long look at the facade of the 1890s facility and remodel the facade all the way to the sidewalk and flickering gaslights.
A microbrewery setting up shop here would be pretty cool. Flying bison should be trying to replicate what Great Lakes Brewing is doing in Cleveland. Offering tours along with a large brewpub/restaurant and a nice little gift shop. I'm not saying they are gonna be able to do the same thing and be successful.
My hobby has become traveling to various places and touring breweries. I've met a bunch of people from all over that do the same thing. We got a nice little beer culture coming back to Buffalo/WNY. Flying Bison and Community Beer Works in the city, Southern Tier and Ellicottville in the southern tier region and many between here and Albany.
You want to generate tourism this is a piece of the puzzle. People will visit to see these breweries and give another tourist destination as well as increase sales of their products which means more tax revenue.
The more we have to offer the more types of people we attract to visit our city and region. If you want to push the history of Buffalo, lets not forget our brewing history. Cheers!
A few brewers have already look at the building, the roof requires more money then the repaired building is worth, without a grant of 100k+ no one can get near it. Its too bad but there is no money around to pay for it, and the tax credits don't help since you still have to front all the money and even then its 40% back, you still wouldn't breakeven and no one will mortage it without the repairs done first. Thats assuming you could get it on the historic buildings list. Its a real bummer.
Thanks to biniszkiewicz for clearing up the beer bottle story. I did some more digging online: In 1933 Benderson bought 1.8 million beer bottles from the Phoenix Brewery which he quickly sold for a profit. After buying the Schreiber Brewery in 1951, he sold the beer, the bottles, trucks and the equipment. He kept the building for development.
1951... coming up on 62 years of development. Should be able to sell the dust it cultivated for like .0000002 cents a pound.
Cool true story though and this building looks really cool. Would be awesome if a business like Flying Bison or another start up brewery occupied/restored it. Craft brewing is blowing up all over the country and the world and there is always room for another talented beermaker. Havent been to Flying Bison but they or anyone looking to start up a new brewery/tasting business should check these guys out in Orange County, CA(doing gangbusters... people drive from over an hour away from all over SoCal to go to their tasting room events)http://www.thebruery.com/ They don't have "walk ins" they have "drive/walk/crawl from all over the place and pack the house ins". The point there being if you build it they will come no matter if it's on the eastside. People who are craft beer snobs and foodies are not afraid of going out of their way for a unique and superior product/experience.
It's nice to know that an attractive, well-planned and executed mural exists in Buffalo, even if it's indoors where few can see it.
Leave a comment
Sponsor
Recent Comments
Sponsor
Interested in advertising on BuffaloRising?
E-mail John C. Powell
or call John at 716.602.0200




Instead of focussing efforts on things like the remnants of the Erie Frieght House PBN ought to be foucing on heritage opportunities such as this before it detriorates any further.
Agreed. If Fillmore/Broadway can be preserved and revitalized ala Elmwood, the East Side suddenly becomes a very potent economic opportunity.
I know Flying Bison needs a new, larger location. Would this suffice?
That's a great idea. That tasting room is a great place to start and end a tour. One issue they may face is reduced walk-in traffic. I'm not sure if it's even significant now, but I know their current location pulls in lots of people from North Buffalo and Ken-Ton, where the East Side location probably wouldn't.
That's not how it works. You wait until the building is hanging on by a thread, then you throw a hissy fit. PBN isn't going to waste its time being proactive.
Really? The way I see it there are thousands of buildings in the city that are well cared for and others restored and lovingly tended. There are others for which the opposite is true. In those cases the people who see the value in keeping them who sometimes arrive at the last minute becasue they are leading their normal life. The idea that people who see the value in saving irreplaceable historic heritage should either shut up or just drop everything in their normal lives and somehow force people to take care of their buildings before they allow giant holes to develope in teh roof is silly. Should I start listing all the buildings saved at the very last minute because they did show up just in time?