City July 24, 2012 1:44 PM

New Observation Boardwalk Being Installed at Erie Basin Marina

New Observation Boardwalk Being Installed at Erie Basin Marina
Work is underway to construct a new observation boardwalk at the furthest point of the Erie Basin Marina. It can't believe that it was way back in 2007 when I got together with The City to discuss the possibility to have a small beach cleared (see back story). It was at that same time that The City first announced that a boardwalk would be built to play off of Emerald Beach. For a while I wasn't sure if that observation boardwalk would ever see the light of day. I was just yesterday that, while visiting the marina, I noticed construction work being done at the rocky point. 

What we are seeing here is the formation of a new standing, seating and general viewing area - I found one of the original outdated construction drawings that shows where the location is in proximity to the beach. Apparently the configuration of the design has changed, so I don't have an updated rendering to show. The boardwalk has been fabricated off-site and is being installed this week. "The Erie Basin Marina is one of Buffalo's favorite summer-time destinations and continues to grow in popularity," said Mayor Brown.  "With a number of new city-funded improvements, including a $400,000 boardwalk, new security gates for boaters, and new handicap accessible restrooms, we expect the Erie Basin Marina's popularity as a destination to soar even higher."  

Observation-Boardwalk-Buffalo-NY.jpg
Once the observation boardwalk is complete, it would be nice to see a couple more amenities squared away. How 'bout a concession stand selling food at the Outlook Tower? Also, while having limited beach access is nice, it would also be a good move to allow kayakers to launch from the site (they are not allowed to at this point). Or at least put a kayak launch at nearby LaSalle Park (see why). As the popularity of the beach and the boardwalk grow, it would good to see the Army Corps of Engineers take a look at extending the beach, which I believe is possible. Consider adding some natural seating areas among the rocks too. Maybe some day, after the boardwalk is complete, The City might also consider extending a boardwalk all the way down to The Hatch. Now that would be something to see!

View image

Comments

Leave a comment

Great to see this moving along. They had construction equipment there for a couple weeks, but didn't know what project it was for.

I hope it includes shoring up the big boulders facing the water at the outer point. They've been falling off.

Score: 3 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

It's about time. Why do they always start these projects so late in the season? Wouldn't it make more sense to start it in the very early spring so we could enjoy it by late summer?

Score: 13 ( 13 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

This is great news...
But, why did it take 5 years to start?

Why do things take forever and a day to get done in Buffalo?

Yes, it should extend all the way down to the hatch, why isn't it?

Score: 7 ( 9 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Can the city hacks/staffers take 30 seconds to go cut down that gigantic weed that has been growing in the middle of the rocks(the part people walk on) down at the Hatch end?

Instead of getting rid of it completely last year, they cut it back to about 12" above the rocks. This year it started growing back. Is it really that hard to do the job right the first time?

One other complaint, when the flags get blown off the light posts in the marina, can they call the installer back to replace them. It looks like crap, when the flags and/or the support poles are missing.

Score: 3 ( 5 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment


Agreed on the need to pull weeds and perform general landscape improvements throughout the city as the city is not very good at managing or maintaining. I see places at Canalside that need to be weeded, watered, etc. Then again I do believe a lot of it is volunteer throughout the city or very well could be. While well intentioned I do think that once these places are built the city will have a hard time maintaining them and it will be up to the citizenry to get involved.

But this is more good news:

1) AM&AS proposal is going to the IDA by the end of the month although I'm slightly concerned with giving assistance to the development of the One Canalside building; How does that bode for the Webster block a supposed prime parcel.

http://www.bizjournals.com/buffalo/news/2012/07/20/ida-sets-hearing-that-could-lead-to.html

2) There is work beginning on the Grain Elevators across from Canalside and it appears pilings are being driven along Canalside. Anyone have an update on these two.

3)Cars on Main Street - Love or hate it its something.

4) Dredging nearing completion on the Buffalo River. Will someone please buy Buffalo Place a pool skimmer.... and lets not re pollute or newly discovered waterways with Fracking Chemicals.

Score: 1 ( 7 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

The work on the grain elevator is only maintenance being performed by the power authority , I got excited when I saw it too. I called Bryan Higgins and that is what I was told. At least they are maintaining it.but what a great place it would make for a hotel or condos

replied to MikeN
Score: 2 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

"The work on the grain elevator is only maintenance"

Has anyone driven on the Skyway and looked at that grain elevator? There are trees growing on top of it.

Do a Google Map aerial view and you'll see extreme deterioration of at least 2/3rds of the roof.

You can't help but stare at it while crossing the bridge. Talk about a driving hazard. Fix it for that reason alone.

replied to Rcc
Score: 3 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Even just a restaurant on the top part, the view would be a destination, Lake, City and River.

replied to Rcc
Score: 2 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

>it appears pilings are being driven along Canalside.

Those are the new floating docks being put in extending to the Skyway Pier. Not sure if the docks will be installed this season or not but they will be ready first thing next year, and are making arrangements for the tall ships like the Brig Niagara coming in September.

replied to MikeN
Score: 2 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

It would be nice to see a picture of the original Boardwalk ( which I think was called Front Street?)

If the Army Core wanted a really interesting project, we would ask to move the lake wall farther out into Lake Erie.

The Port of Buffalo is tiny compared to other downtown harbors and tiny compared to other downtown beaches.

Why not push the entire Break Wall further out into Lake Erie? If you do that then the Outer Harbor and LaSalle Park could have Beaches, docks etc.

There is so much Buffalo needs...where does one even begin. If only Buffalo had a wish list that the public could vote on or civic leaders could devote their priorities...instead of what we have right now...last minute demolitions and priorities dictated by Albany or insider patronage/unions

Score: 2 ( 8 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

A wish list would be good but we would probably talk ourselves into a standstill.

I would take a central location of information relating to progress at some of these sites and or projects. What are they, how near are they on beginning, completion etc. This site is a good place to start at as far covering the "moment" and current activities. For instance, the ECHDC website hasn't been in my opinion updated enough; Or maybe I'll catch the article of the Parisian cafe opening on Main and maybe I won't. It would be nice to go to a single place if there ever was an "oh yeah" moment to look up the progress. Yes I can spend an hour or so researching on the internet. Then again maybe this a bad idea as this project took 5 years.

replied to paulsobo
Score: 0 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Dude, it's the Army "corps", not "core".
It's like colonel; not kernel.
Carry on.

replied to paulsobo
Score: 4 ( 6 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Too funny...typos from typing to fast

replied to 14213
Score: 0 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I was just down there today and noticed the work. Thanks for this update, did'nt know what they were doing.

Score: -1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

MikeN ─ Yea for the crescendo of good news!

Re: Will someone please buy Buffalo Place a pool skimmer....

Hopefully, they will also buy brooms and rakes to remove the considerable amount of dead leaves that line the area where the trains go down-under across from the Sid Birzone building.
Litter has also been an on-going problem on the weekends.
(Many Shea's patrons park next to that building and it's shamefully noticeable.)

The same mess exists in front of the building which Sue's restaurant relocated from and renovation is in progress.

This may seem minor, however, window washing (at renovation site) would enhance its current face in a "Theater District." (Thankfully, the tattered paper was removed.)

Score: 2 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I was by the grain elevators across the river from Canalside earlier this week. There is a Cerrone construction banner on the fencing, but it is hard to tell what is being done. I went to their website, but their is no information on this project.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

All That is being done is general work by the power authority because pieces were falling off , read above . I was hoping they were at least going to light it up .

replied to KenS
Score: 1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I saw your response. What does the power authority have to do with it?

replied to Rcc
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

about maintenance issues: dan will correct me if i am mistaken, but all municipalities have to keep their capital and operating budgets strictly separate. just because you can find a pot of money or a grant to build something (donors -love- getting their names all over new projects!) doesn't mean that your operating budget has automatically expanded in order to take care of the new project.

nobody funds operating expenses. nobody. it is up to us taxpayers. the more successful we are at cutting our supposedly burdensome taxes, the less money there is for maintenance of this or any other city property. be careful what you wish for, you may get it.

Score: 1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

postscript:

(donors *and elected officials* love getting their names all over new projects!)

replied to grad94
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Exactly. At some point all of this will have to be "monetized" to provide its own operational budget or it will have to be not profit endeavors much like an adopting of the highways.

The Feds can only borrow money from China for so long.
The State I don't imagine is a whole lot healthier.
The County even with the Canadian shoppers appears to be looking to close a budget gap - we don't need to debate the because or why - politics of either party has a lot to be desired.

Someway somehow increases in collections of local sales taxes (state/county), property taxes, rents, hotel stays, fees, tours are going to need to begin covering the annual maintenance. Preferably from Out of Town money - tourists. I would hate to see us in 5 years asking "oh sh*t, how are we going to afford to fix this or that" or think that every year Higgins will get some money in a bill. Although this is liable to just be moved to a general fund like everything else.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

mike & grad -

For combined property taxes as of 2009, Erie Co residents are already in the top 1% nationally for highest tax bills as portion of home values. (#6 out of the 792 most populated counties in U.S.)
In total dollars of combined property tax bills, Erie Co residents are in the top 15% highest property-taxed anywhere in the U.S. (#122 out of 792 counties)
http://interactive.taxfoundation.org/propertytax/

Our sales tax at 8.75% is in the highest 20% of U.S. major metros (#17 out of 107)
http://taxfoundation.org/article/sales-tax-rates-major-us-cities

NYS is #8 out of 50 states for average income tax rates at 6.2%
http://www.tax-rates.org/taxtables/income-tax-by-state

The gasoline tax in NY state is the highest of all 50 states, at $0.49/gallon (which doesn't include the $0.18 federal tax)
http://taxfoundation.org/sites/taxfoundation.org/files/docs/state%2520gas%2520tax%2520rates%2520jan%25202012.pdf

People can feel this state or area should be even higher in any or all of those high-tax rankings. No doubt many of our fiscally-left politicians (of both parties in NYS) might make it happen. But it's hardly the only possible solution. Other spending could be reduced. Some other places manage somehow to be at the national average for these kinds of tax rates and I'd bet all those don't have noticeably worse govt services than here.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

To Whatever, that was the point of both of our comments.

1) Poor service provision within the City.

2) Its easy to build, harder to maintain. There is no "flash" for benefactors and/or politicians in maintaining - only building.

So the question is how does all this infrastructure on the waterfront currently funded mostly by government money maintain itself once the government build money dries up.

How does this investment payback to create money for maintenance budget and become self sufficient and not another "cultural" competing for dollars.

Well as we have now: ice cream sales may result in additional sales tax revenue for state and county. But that is a lot of ice cream to sell in 4 months. Rents or fees for waterfront docking, ferries. Again only really 4-6 viable months down there currently. Hotel occupancy, well the one hotel is a bit aways. Real estate taxes via higher priced real estate (no need to increase rates) but all other new builds developers will say I need such and such an abatement so probably not much there as far as new developments leading to new sources of revenue. And preferably we would want the majority to be new money coming in vis a vis tourism, new residents to offset all the income that gets siphoned off at the box stores regionally. Circulating already here dollars doesn't really help this region- yes there is a multiplier effect but not as large as new money.

So while its nice to dream about the boardwalk going from one end to the other, lets just keep it in reality and make sure we can afford the maintenance of all these new projects to keep it a destination along with all the other "needs" of the area.

replied to whatever
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Mike, while I agree with your points 1 and 2, I disagree with what your previous comment said that tax increases are truly *needed*.
This part -
mike>"Someway somehow increases in collections of local sales taxes (state/county), property taxes, rents, hotel stays, fees, tours are going to need to begin covering the annual maintenance."

Some politicians and voters might favor that approach - and it very well might happen - but there would be other possible ways. The vast majority of places in the U.S. find ways to have lower taxes than what WNY & NYS in general has, and as I said I doubt the services here are noticeably better as a result of ours being higher.

replied to MikeN
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Again I didn't say tax increases I said increased collections.
People spend more money that's more revenue in sales tax collected without increasing the sales tax,etc. No one said increased tax rates. Now that we have that settled we can get back to the second point which was questioning the poor service provision regardless of taxes.

So the city's ability to fund and maintain the developments once the $ is all gone since I do not think that the Harbor area itself generating (not talking grants, gifts, governtment financing) enough currently to maintain the development. So it will either be forced to compete within the overall budget with other culturals and/or rely on volunteer.

Check out the load of garbage floating in the slip during your peak visitor time. Weeds etc. You could argue that oh we are so busy with all the other development aspects we don't have time for details. But if I was dropping that amount of money into a destination, it better be well maintained.

replied to whatever
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

mike, sorry for thinking you meant raising rates, but while growth in sales tax revenue collection is helpful (in years when it happens) it's still a pretty small portion of the city budget - well under 1% of spending. Sales tax revenue grew around 4% in 2011 vs 2010 and the control board is predicting 3% growth each of the next few years. Since sales tax revenues are around 15% of Buffalo's city budget, 4% of 15% is a little over half of 1%.
So unless the city decided to dedicate a lot of that portion to better maintenance of Erie Basin Marina, it probably instead gets spread around to all the many different things the city spends on. Some would advocate to spend more for schools, public safety, etc.

I think the bigger issue is priorities of what they choose to spend on and how they do it.

For example, as it does with public parks being maintained by Olmsted's private sector workers, maybe the city could outsource maintenance of Erie Basin Marina instead of using city public employees for it.

replied to MikeN
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Leave a comment