City May 12, 2012 12:10 AM

Preservation Award Winner: Linwood Preservation District

Preservation Award Winner: Linwood Preservation District

Preservation Buffalo Niagara is recognizing outstanding preservation projects and those contributing to preservation efforts at its annual awards ceremony May 30, 11:30 AM in the Statler's Golden Ballroom.  Award categories were established to acknowledge distinguished contributions to our community through preservation activity. Recipients will be recognized in several areas including: preservation craft; rehabilitation/adaptive use; stewardship; neighborhood conservation; planning/reconstruction; and preservation journalism.  Buffalo Rising will profile this year's winners leading up to the May event.

The Linwood Preservation District is being recognized in the Neighborhood Conservation category.

The architecturally significant Linwood Historic Preservation District has, due to the efforts and private financial investment of new owners since the mid-1990s, witnessed the beginning of a renaissance after decades of decline.  This ongoing process has been accelerated by the emergence of Linwood Preservation District & Friends (LPD&F), a grassroots neighborhood association revitalized in 2002 from the remnants of the earlier Linwood-Oxford Association.  Its mission is to "preserve, protect, and enhance the Linwood Historic District" in order to appreciate the historic ambience of the neighborhood and to create a sense of community where residents know one another.

Platted in 1850, Linwood (then Miller Street) was one of the first streets to extend the City of Buffalo beyond its northern boundary of North Street.  As Linwood developed between 1850 and 1930, it became a treasure trove of grand homes built in the evolving architectural styles of each era by successful industrialists and entrepreneurs, creating a unique, living architectural museum.  And elm-shaded Linwood became a grand promenade where residents strolled "to see and be seen."

The declining fortunes of the city from the 1950s through the 1970s, exacerbated by the earlier deprivations of the Great Depression and the austerity of World War II, resulted in a visible decline in Linwood's fortunes and the loss of a number of its mansions.  Linwood was, in 1978, designated a local preservation district to protect the historic architectural fabric from further loss.  But renaissance was more than a decade away.

linwood2.bmp

New owners have undertaken expensive rehabilitations and restorations of interiors and exteriors- most without the benefit of tax credits- that have returned numerous properties to single-family dwellings from the mid-20th century multi-family units, apartments, and medical offices into which they had been converted.

In tandem with the efforts of individual property owners, the Linwood Preservation District & Friends neighborhood association, in the decade of its existence, has become an active force for improvement of the historic district.  One of its first campaigns was to educate residents and the public about the historic nature of Linwood, enhancing appreciation of the district and underscoring the need to protect its historic fabric.  The biennial Linwood Tour of Homes has welcomed more than two thousand visitors to the neighborhood over four tours beginning in 2005.  Funds raised by the tours, supplemented by occasional grants, have enabled the association to plant more than 250 trees, create four floral gardens in parkway lawns, and subsidize the cost and installation of historic house markers for nearly two dozen property owners.  The association has encouraged spirit d'corps by arranging neighborhood social gatherings that include porch parties, children play dates, and annual summer and holiday parties.

linwood11.jpg

The association's monthly general meetings provide a forum for discussion of issues impacting the neighborhood.  Between meetings, its website and list-serve keep residents informed of developments and opportunities.  Eleven volunteer block captains from the length of Linwood Avenue maintain communication with residents, monitor code violations and other problems, provide clean-up resources, and fulfill other self-assigned responsibilities for the neighborhood.

The LPD&F has accumulated a strong record of advocacy on behalf of the district and built relationships with city officials, the police department, housing court, and neighboring institutions and businesses.  A police liaison attends our district police captain's monthly meeting; one or more members attend the Buffalo Preservation Board, Zoning Board of Appeals, and Housing Court sessions whenever a Linwood or an immediate- neighboring property is involved; and a Linwood liaison has been appointed to the Buffalo Niagara Medical Campus advisory panel. 

Through its advocacy, the association has influenced changes to councilmanic redistricting and improvements in the development or expansion plans of several district institutions including the Jewish Community Center, the Elizabeth Olmsted and Ira Ross Eye centers, Delta Sonic, Canisius High School, and Housing Opportunities Made Equal.  The result has been less asphalt pavement, the loss of fewer trees, less light pollution, the rerouting of traffic, landscape improvements, and other changes to improve the neighborhood's quality of life.  It has been acknowledged for contributions to plans for the Kaleida Gates Circle complex and the Buffalo Green Code, all with the aim of preserving the historic nature of the neighborhood.

linwoodgateway.bmpOne of the association's most important and visible accomplishments has been the completion in 2011 of the $600,000, City-funded Linwood Avenue/North Street reconfiguration first proposed to the City by the LPD&F in 2005.  Five years of advocacy and prodding resulted in an intersection that improved pedestrian and auto safety.  In addition, elimination of the sweeping "S" curve from Franklin to Linwood in favor of the "teeing" of both streets at North, has returned the intersection to its historic configuration.  Other long-term goals include creation of a distinctive gateway to Linwood Avenue, development of a community garden, and installation of public art to enhance the streetscape.

The ongoing activities of the Linwood Preservation District & Friends, supported by district residents, have not only preserved this historic district, but improved in aesthetically.  Perhaps even more importantly, working relationships and social interaction have been fostered among neighbors that help to enhance their quality of life.  Friendships have blossomed, including among the children who are now part of the neighborhood family.  The result is a revitalized "real neighborhood" in our "City of Good Neighbors," in which neighbors work and play together, and care about one another and their environment.

linwood15.png

Individual property photos courtesy of STEEL
View image

Comments

Leave a comment

Well, Hurrah for the real American Architecture !! Linwood is many times more intact as a Grand Avenue than Delaware, probably because its owners weren't as desperate as on Delaware, with its gigantic mansions, tax and coal bills. Linwood houses were just the right size for apartments & doctor's offices, while the piles on Delaware defied division.

Despite its lack of repaving since 1990 and consequent plethora of jarring pot-holes, most of Linwood is a pleasant drive and a much more pleasant walk. When I delivered mail to that area, entering or just peeking into the grand halls was a great thrill. I was "caught" looking many times, and almost always invited in to see the woodwork up close. I suspect that the people of Buffalo are unique, in that way.

(Richmond Ave, from start to end, must be the "Longest Most Intact 19th Century Street" in the East, though. Is there one single vacant lot, or any house replaced by post-1940 anything?? It just needs a mile of Princeton Elms & a few horses to complete that claim)

Score: 6 ( 6 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

re: "most intact Victorian street"

fascinating claim. it'd be marvelous if it were true. anyone have any ideas about how to substantiate it?

replied to ForestBird
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Because ForestBird brought up Richmond, I was wondering if anyone knew of an online resource where I might be able to bring up a historic picture of my friend's recently purchased home on richmond near Rhode Island, he is looking to re-do his porch, and I'm positive that it is presently a far cry from its former glory....any info would be appreciated

Score: 2 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Historical Society

replied to buffaloTrek
Score: 2 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Grosvenor Library, Central Library. They have a handy guide pamphlet for researching buildings and properties.

replied to buffaloTrek
Score: 2 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Bring back the ELM Trees and the trees capable of large urban canopies over the streets.

Bring back brick and cobble stone streets in the historic districts.

Put in building codes that new construction and infill must match the architectural styles within that historic district.

This is how you preserve and maintain a historic district.

Further, Buffalo has an enormous wealth of historical features with which it can leverage. The statues, gazebos/band shelters and fountains of the PAN AM alone would make Buffalo the PARIS of the Great Lakes.

The War of 1812 and Fort Porter, Mark Twain, LaSalle's exploration of the Great Lakes, Presidential Libraries for Cleveland & McKinley are other ignored historical features.

Buffalo was not as large as Detroit or Cleveland...so we are limited in what we have to preserve which is why its more important than ever to preserve and restore.

Score: 2 ( 6 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

The trees and cobblestones are easy and fairly inexpensive and add enormously to the value of the streets. Why can't we do those simple things?

replied to paulsobo
Score: 1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

this history is ignored by who, exactly?

the people who put a mark twain room in the downtown library? ever been there? how about the people who put all of twain's issues of the buffalo express online?

http://www.newyorkheritage.org/buffalo-express.php

how about the people who named everything after fillmore & cleveland, including streets, schools, a hospital, a park, and a college at ub? the people who put up statues of both presidents? how about the people who collected all that fillmore stuff at the historical society?

http://www.worldcat.org/profiles/BECHS/lists/1505889

how about the folks in black rock who have been busy putting up war of 1812 markers and organized a burning of buffalo commemoration last december? how about the people in cheektowaga who have a ceremony at the war of 1812 cemetery every year? how about muster in the meadow?

how about all of the walking tours, bus tours, and cemetery tours that do nothing but promote buffalo history and architecture?

if all of these efforts are unsatisfactory, then stop complaining and start organizing what you think is lacking.

replied to paulsobo
Score: 1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

If you check the 1894 Buffalo City Atlas, you will see that very few streets were ever stone or brick. Most Buffalo streets went directly from mud to asphalt, or from mud to "Macadam" (multiple layers of rolled stone) to asphalt.

The failure, the HUGE failure, to replant trees in Buffalo is entirely beyond my understanding. Two or three men, doing just plantings every day, could reforest the City in a few years at very little expense. Oh, but maybe Da Mayor would hafta do without his floor full of expensive toadies. How many unelected "Deputy Mayors" do we need?

We have a parasitic City government, concerned with nothing but perpetuating itself while it sucks every possible penny from taxes, grants, subsidies, and suckers. Our population is only twice that of Amherst, with 20 times (or more?) the bloodsucking vermin. Largest City Hall in America! An outrage.

Score: 3 ( 5 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Brick and Cobblestone Streets allow water to get to the roots for such trees to stay healthy. If you have every driven on a brick or cobblestone road then you know that going over 30mph can be anything but a smooth ride which slows down side street traffic (making it safer) while increasing property values.

Forest Bird...Im not going to argue whether its historically accurate but Im still in favor it for the above reasons.

As far as a bloated city hall and too many deputy mayors...its the same liberals that treat government as the employer of last resort particularly for minorities and bloated political machines that extend patronage...as you say 20x the norm...that killed every great lakes city that wasnt the capital of its region such as NYC and Chicago.

Still...there is always the hope that this machine will pass into history as the rest of the garbage has...

Score: 0 ( 6 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

linwood should be 2-way. as a 1-way street it is an unpatrolled speedway.

Score: 4 ( 10 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Still "blown away" by this street every time. The slate sidewalks set high above the roadway. The individual dignity of the houses. The overall feeling that this is a special place. Never again to happen. Precious for having largely survived.

Score: 4 ( 4 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

In regards to the comment on Richmond being fully intact: there are two homes missing on either side of the former Temple Beth El, on the east side of the street at York/17th. Also, a former home (now apartments) on the west side of the street, 3 south of Connecticut, burned last September (an electrical fire) and the owner has dome nothing to it but board it up. He's probably going to collect the insurance check and let the place go while he feasts in his Lincoln Pkwy mansion. When he "re-did" the place a few years ago, he had a bunch of hacks working on the place.

Score: 1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Leave a comment