HOK's Winning Ideas- More Renderings
Comments
Leave a commentI disagree. I think it's a bold/contemporary architectural statement that this area needs. Though, I'm fully aware that the final product may look incredibly different since it's merely a design concept meant to represent the direction HOK will go in.
I find it interesting that the renderings show the small houses butting up to the back end of the building. I don't think anyone really expects them to be there when all is said and done.
I don't think anyone really expects them to be there when all is said and done.
I'll take that bet. Why dismantle these small structures? They have been very well-maintained and utilized.
There's plenty of 'bold contemporary' architecture in the medical corridor. But it's a jumble of different styles and visual vocabularies. Too much of that cacophony diminishes, not reinforces the value of this stuff. Not that every building should look the same but a little more consistency, please.
The new stuff has actually been quite consistent in style and scale. And in any neighborhood that is evolving as fast as the BNMC you will see a stark contrast between the very old and the very new. Look at old photos of downtown Buffalo and you'll see houses and small commercial buildings contrasting with the large new buildings of the time like City Hall or Ellicot Square.
AMAZING! But, is the completion for the first phase 2016, or both phases?
What I love the most about it is how they built on top of the street allowing a pass-thru for traffic and pedestrians of rather than building on the street and destroying the street grid.
Now encourage further buildings deeper into the Fruit Belt and towards the Kensington so this campus doesnt become a suburban strip mall.
(Thats a better strategy than Roswell and others have demonstrated as their plans destroy the street grid).
Also, this location and density is excellent for its proximity to our Lady of Lourdes. I think it increases the possibility something positive will be done with it so it doesnt have to be demolished.
Its also good for the Masten Armory, City Honors, City Fields, Masten Park, Science Magnet, Science Museum and Humboldt Park areas which I can see gentrification as this gets built out.
Now THINK BIG! End the Kensington at BEST Street and make Best the eastern entrance to the Life Sciences Campus rather than Goodell, Elm & Oak. Downgrade the Kensington back into Humboldt Parkway entrance to downtown!!!
It looks like its 10 stories tall. Its not a skyscraper but its a good size building for our downtown.
Its al
This could give Allentown a much needed boost as med students might start looking in the area for housing. Johns Hopkins in Baltimore is a good example of this. It sits atop a hill on the edge of a sketchy part of town, with the higher end neighborhood of Fells Point on the other side, several blocks away, and at the bottom of the hill along the harbor. In between is a neighborhood called Butchers Hill, which used to be quite rough, but has since come a long way thanks in part to the Johns Hopkins students who moved in. Butchers Hill is becoming so marketable these days that realtors have given the neighborhood a new name, "Upper Fells Point." This all happened because of the recent $1.1 Billion expansion of Johns Hopkins Medical Campus, which in a way reminds me of the Buffalo Medical Campus expansion.
More reason why the Campus needs to grow towards the Kensington Expressway and have only a limited footprint on Main Street.
actually if that is the goal desires growing closer to the highway would have the opposite effect because people wouldn't need to venture far from the exit ramp to their destination, so there would be no location for private infill developments (like cafes, housing) that people could use or frequent.
Very nice land use and like the way the strip of public space in Phase 2 runs into the public space at Roswell Park.
The building's facade is a bit much and where are all the students and faculty going to park?
It may be insignificant in the grand scheme of things, but what of the HSBC (now First Niagara) branch at Main and High? Maybe incorporated into the new structure?
The plan shows that the architects understood the very strong need to sew the city back together after years of stupid car based decisions
Is that why Allen St was extended into the drawing to make vehicular traffic easier?
Not really. Its a medical campus. If you look at UB North all the academic buildings are packed close together (though yes, an urban island surrounded by endless parking lots).
They did this to suit the needs of the campus itself, not the needs of the city.
it's mutually beneficial...addressing both the city and campus. Smart planning. The medical school care very much about the character of the neighborhood.
Do we know what is happening with the public housing lot on the Medical Campus? I thought that was where the med school was to be relocated?
I hope the final product does actually look close to the renderings- I think they're great!
Would Women and Children's Hospital be just to the north (other side of High)? Is there a timetable for that?
If you pull up a google map of the area, if they leave the older buildings on Washington, there really isn't that much area for them to work in. It would seem to necessitate them going higher.
I really think this Medical school project will be a big boost to this section of Buffalo. It's a very exciting project! Can't wait to see it completed! I hope that the brick building on the corner of Main and Allen gets some much needed attention. It is currently a bit of an eye sore but has a lot of potential to be developed into apartments, offices and businesses. Right now though it is the main blight on that section of Main St. Hope this project will spur much needed investment there.
With all that glass I am hopeful it turns out better than the new courthouse.
The renderings in the previous article are showing a lot of copper colored opaque material.
What happens to Washington St. All this emphasis on "reconnecting" Allen St. & Washington St. is gone. What is Allen St. being "connect" to? Sacrificing the street grid should not be an option here in light of comments on how Roswel Park erased & ignored so much of it.
Allen Street was never connected to Washington. Not sure why many believe that Roswell Park was the major player in the street grid being altered on the Medical Campus. Over the years Roswell Park took a block of Elm and a block of North Oak. Buffalo General took 2 blocks of Elm and a block of Goodrich. McCarley Gardens took a block of Oak and realigned the rest of Oak, 2 blocks of Elm, 2 blocks of Burton and realigned Virgina St from Michigan to Ellicott.
Actually, Allen Street is not being "reconnected" to Washington, because Allen Street was never connected to Washington in the first place.
HOK's design backs up to Main Street. Further isolation of the street from the medical campus. Allen St. gateway is a pigeon hole and not inviting to a sensitive, low desnity scaled community. Turn it 180 degrees and you may have something.
Time to beat a dead horse.
DS&R's departure from this competition is so unfortunate. They just unveiled the proposed design for Columbia's new Medical and Graduate Education Building. It blows HOK out of the water.
Leave a comment
Sponsor
Recent Comments
Sponsor
Interested in advertising on BuffaloRising?
E-mail John C. Powell
or call John at 716.602.0200




I like the way the structure cozily fits into the footprint of the area; however, the first image seems like it was designed by Donald Trump. I hope future renderings won't make it seem as gaudy.
I think the gold in that image is meant sunlight reflecting off the glass... at least I hope that is the case.
I think these renderings are much more useful than the white light emitting structures that were posted earlier.