City April 27, 2012 9:06 AM

A Spark Leads to Fire @ Long Forgotten Urban Park

A Spark Leads to Fire @ Long Forgotten Urban Park
If I were to tell you that Fireman's Park in Downtown Buffalo was about to get a makeover, what would you say? Would you say "Where the heck is Fireman's Park?" I guess when there is a lackluster park in our midst, it's bound to be fairly obscure, mainly because of its derelict nature. Fireman's Park has been derelict for many years. It's the public park that is bounded by North and South Division Streets in Downtown Buffalo. It's the one that has an inoperable modernist fountain and is usually inhabited by vagrants. It's the first property that anyone sees when coming to Buffalo by bus. It's also a park that should be a prime destination for ECC students. Unfortunately, Fireman's Park has been out of sight and out of mind for far too long - an open parcel of public land that I once wrote, "In order to get to this park, one must play a real life game of frogger."

Today is the day that the dismal image surrounding this park may finally disappear. ECC Students and faculty will be spending the day beautifying the grounds, as the college's Service Learning, Building Management and Maintenance, and Architecture departments are putting a plan (developed hand in hand with The City) into action. While much of this park's problems stem from the large traffic volumes that are created by the highway-style streets that envelop the park, the beautification steps taken by ECC in this Phase 1 project could eventually lead to bigger and better results. As we have learned over the years, it's the squeaky wheel that gets the grease, and if nobody takes the the lead on a project, then train of thought tends to be 'Let sleeping dogs lie'. 

Thankfully, and I might add that it's due time, a neighbor with a vested interest is taking the lead on this project. Not only does the college's curriculum allow for immediate and longterm (hopefully) action, The City now has a vested interest in helping to maintain the property thanks to a critical partnership with ECC. I would think that a regular foot patrol would go a long way towards sprucing up the park's image, but that would be asking for a small miracle. As for the anticipated work that we can expect from the initiative, the fourteen wood benches will all be restored and the broken fountain will be converted into a multi-tiered flower garden. In years to come, more ideas will surface (add yours in the comment section if you have a good one), as future classes will add their own distinct improvements to a park that is still dedicated to our city's firemen. It would be great to see a firetruck arrive to water the flowers on occasion... talk about an impressive salute! Ideas that have been floated include a public work of art, enhanced overhead lighting, and flower beds. Now, if The City would only convert North and South Division Streets into boulevards rather than the disruptive inner city highways that stand today. One step at a time I suppose. Finally the first step has been taken.



View image

Comments

Leave a comment

If you're arriving by bus, chances are you're not going to care what this park looks like. In fact, you may be spending the night there.

Score: -24 ( 56 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Your statment shows how little you know about the way other people travel. I have taken the bus between NYC and Buffalo dozens of times, and I very much care about the way this park looks. Sure I could drive to NYC, but I don't really want to have my car with me when I'm downstate. Amtrak is a slightly better option, but only so slightly better. The cost difference isn't really justified, in my opinion, especially when there are so many more options on the bus schedule as compared to the train schedule. There are plenty of people, in all walks of life, who travel by bus, not just low-lifes. We're not all as dependent on our cars as you appear to be.

Score: 15 ( 29 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

For real travel, I'm not dependent on my car at all. I'm rely on airplanes! This way I'm not dealing with an element of society that's been relegated to Greyhound travel. I'm sorry that you're one of them. Picture this: I return home from work one day and exclaim, "Hey gang, this year, instead of going to Europe, Mexico, etc., why don't we hop on the Greyhound and head down to Scranton?!? I hear it's really beautiful there this time of year!" How do you think that would play out?

replied to NBuffguy
Score: -21 ( 35 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

i would not want to sit next to you on an airplane, with all that sh+t in your beard and stuff.

http://www.theonion.com/articles/30-miserable-lives-lost-in-greyhound-bus-crash,2339/

Score: 2 ( 10 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Yes sir, YesSir. Thank you for illustrating my point in such a humorous way. Case closed.

replied to YesSir
Score: -13 ( 17 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

How do I think that would play out? I suppose that would depend on how narrow minded you are, and as a result, how narrow minded you've taught your "gang" to be. I never said that I rely on buses for traveling to Europe. Of course not; that's just silly. For those trips, I too rely on airplanes. But some people need to go to places like Scranton, and not always for Spring Break vactions. Some people travel to those places to visit family, interview for jobs, etc. And in those cases, flying doesn't make much sense, and taking the bus is a viable option for people who aren't afraid of the "element of society" to which you're referring.

Score: 7 ( 9 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Oh. My. God. Please see YesSir's link to the Onion article above. We're done here.

replied to NBuffguy
Score: -12 ( 12 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I read The Onion piece, and I thought it was funny. You don't have a good grasp on satire, do you?

Score: 8 ( 8 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

NB, I'd only wonder why for Buffalo to/from NYC, Amtrak is even a "slightly better option" than Greyhound?

Greyhound is often a faster trip since it uses a more direct route than Amtrak, is more often on time closer to its schedule than Amtrak, and is usually a cheaper ticket.
Icing on the cake is Greyhound has many more departures throughout the day.

replied to NBuffguy
Score: 1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

A food truck and a coffee/ice cream truck, with tables and chairs set up daily in summer would be cool and nice hangout for students, or even a permenent kiosk like shake shack in NYC. Concrete chess tables a small news stand. Ice sculptures and designer lighting in winter.

Score: 9 ( 13 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

The Whole Hog truck used to set up there almost daily; it was sort of their standard spot. Not sure if they still do.

replied to The Boss
Score: 1 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Does this mean, those of us who work and live downtown can actually enjoy this little park without avoiding it due to the areas homeless and drug addicts always occuping it?

Score: 6 ( 14 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

The fountain should be seen as the park's best assets & be restored to operation. The white noise of water falling would enhance the overall ambience of the park more than gutting it and turning it into planters would. But it is not my money being spent. At the very least, something is being done.

Score: 9 ( 13 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I think this would be a great place for H.H Richard's unused triumphal arch design. Richardson was originally awarded the commission for the Civil War Memorial in Lafayette Square. He designed a Romanesque arch with a large freize of sculpted soldiers. Unfortunately, it was never completed due to lack of funds. They later chose a new architect and a different design. However, Richardson's design later went on to inspire the arch in Washington Square Park in Manhattan. This may be a good opportunity to revisit and utilize that concept. It could be an arch celebrating Buffalo's history, prosperity, beauty and diversity. Rather than soldiers, the freize could instead depict notable Buffalonians or just try to encapsulate the spirit and history of the city.

I'd also suggest removing the parking lot just north of the ECC main building. ECC's other property at Oak & Division could also use a refresh or be displaced for more parkland.

Score: 6 ( 12 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Nicholas Tyler Miller, what an inspiration you are for your vision.

I agree. That would be an incredible addition to Buffalo's cultural and architectural heritage.

How can Buffalonians make that happen? I wish we had a list for Buffalo that we could pick say 1 project every year or every 5 years....

Score: 3 ( 7 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

One of Downtown's under used green Spaces,I agree the fountain should be restored and hopefully the activity will drive away the Riff-Raff..

Score: 5 ( 11 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Right! Just like in "Fighting Back" starring Tom Skerritt.

replied to forest
Score: -15 ( 23 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

This is a nice little park that sucks because of where it is not because of its design or even because of its lack of maintenance. It sucks because there is no reason to have a park here. This should be buildings with people in it like it used to be before the "green space" fetish took over urban design.

This park is stranded in a sea of asphalt. No one goes there because they have no reason too. The very successful urban open space at M&T Plaza and Cathedral Park are well used because of beautiful design and accessibility.

No amount of maintenance and patrolling is going to get people to use this park unless they need a place to sleep. The fountain is actually quite nice when it is running. turning it into a garden will just make this park more of a joke and an insult to the buildings that were needlessly removed in an effort to turn this part of the city into a sprawl wasteland.

http://www.buffalorising.com/2011/02/parks-greenspace-and-vacant-properties.html

Score: 12 ( 20 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I agree. You can't improve this park without addressing the parking lots and low-intensity buildings that surround it. The park needs to be surrounded by buildings that define the space and provide a reason to be in the area. This park is really the front lawn of ECC's campus. It really could be a very dynamic urban space. If ECC could be convinced to utilize the AM&As building, this would likely be a cross-roads of the student life.

A similar discussion has been going on in Cleveland in regard to Public Square. People wonder why it isn't as utilized as much as they feel it should be. So, the city decided to solicit design ideas. Many great designs were submitted, but no one took issue with the enormous parking lot adjacent to the square. That parking lot also has the unfortunate side-effect of isolating the vibrant Warehouse district from the rest of Downtown. In my opinion, that's the biggest design flaw, not the aesthetics of the actual park.

replied to STEEL
Score: 4 ( 12 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

hearty agreement from this corner.

the cure for bad urbanism (gap-toothed street wall, vacant lots, massive surface parking, deep setbacks, blank walls, single-use-single-story econoboxes) is not imitation ruralism.

the cure for bad urbanism is good urbanism.

replied to STEEL
Score: 9 ( 13 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

What would they do in Chicago Steel?

replied to STEEL
Score: -3 ( 15 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I am not clear on what you are asking. What would Chicago do about what? Do you mean by Chicago the City of Chiocago government? What is the point of your question?

replied to ladyinwhite
Score: 2 ( 6 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I think Steel hit the nail on the head. We could spend millions on this park and it would never really be used by people because it's surrounded by busy roads. The Gates Circle fountain park is like this too.

Could they narrow both Division streets down to one lane on that block to make the streets more cross-able.

I think Nicolas' idea of a larger monument has potential too. Because it's something that can be viewed from a distance... A park to be looked at instead of a park to be used.

Score: 4 ( 6 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Some sidewalks along North and South Division can also help, to keep a pedestrian friendly traffic flow along with easing traffic on those streets so it does'nt feel like an expressway which kind of keeps pedestrians away (deserted park). Just an idea.

Score: -1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

agreed. if we cannot have good urbanism there, at least we can have a genuine urban square. the landscape design conventions established by olmsted are now so obligatory that it would help our thought process immensely if we distinguished between a park and a square.

we shouldn't try to shoehorn naturalized wooded landscapes (i.e. parks) into the heart of downtown, just like we should never have shoehorned bad forms of urbanism (highways) into our olmsted parks & parkways.

lafayette square is a fine model. it has sidewalks on all sides, regularly spaced trees which (very important!) do not block sight lines into and out of the park. it has narrow traffic lanes with on-street parking, which provides some measure of traffic calming. it has plenty of flexible seating (you can sit on any side of the monument and face any way you want).

this park lacks the sense of enclosure provided by an unbroken street wall but it does have a central focal point, the fountain, just as lafayette square has its monument. so it doesn't need a complete tear-out and re-do.

if i could wave a wand, i'd narrow the streets lining it and add sidewalks on all sides. i'd thin out the trees and other plantings and replace with a hardy native fruit trees in regularly spaced rows. why not provide edible "green space" for the people who hit you up downtown saying that they need a meal?

replied to Lego1981
Score: 3 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

The headline had me hoping the park had burned down.

Score: 0 ( 4 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

It's great when the City needs the aid of a local college to hold its hand in fulfilling its obligation to the public and its own property.

Did I miss why the broken fountain can't be repaired?

I doubt a fire hose would be a very good way to water a garden. Unless the aim is to obliterate it.

Is there any reason the lot Greyhound uses to stage its buses needs to be an entire block?

Score: 3 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Buses are the size of buses.

replied to LouisTully
Score: 2 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

On Richmond ─ I echo your opinion that the fountain is a big asset and should be restored.

Perhaps support dollars could be solicited from the public and businesses via an on-line campaign. Maybe a matching dollars component could be included.

Also, my impression is that the park needs a better feeling of openness. It has a state of isolation in its core, in spite of the location. If my recollection is not foggy about the trees, thinning them could be a good start.

Looking forward to this becoming a special space in downtown.

Many salutes to ECC!

Score: 1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Every feature of "Downtown" suffers from the exact same fact: not enough people go there, because they don't want or need to go there. I have a recurrent errand, twice a month; Winter, Spring, Summer or Fall, I can park a mile away & walk to and back without passing a single person on South Elmwood. Downtown Buffalo, like most "downtowns", is essentially dead. The reality of our car-culture makes the vision of a 1900-esque Downtown/SmallTown Main Street into an impossible fantasy. Either most people travel by public transport or "Downtown" is impossible. Central City America existed (for a short time) while people either walked or rode streetcars; the automobile has made centralisation obsolete.

ps - Planting trees all over ANY part of Buffalo is a good idea.

Score: 0 ( 4 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Well the namesake of this park, "Firemens", should seek out some assistance from the Buffalo Fire Department and it's members or even any County fire companies to help in procuring some sort of memorial for this park. Hell, even those of us in EMS (Emergency Medical Services)would benefit to assist in this park, as there is no memorial to OUR sacrifices or our emergency profession. Something simple like an old fire truck, refurbished (which the city has many sitting idle at the Dart Street impound yard or the South Park Lift Bridge) could be used, similar to military monuments. While I would love to see the Civil War arch of Richardson's that was never built, I think something simpler would warrant in this park.

Simple changes to the streetscape, such as lessening the lanes of travel, making it more pedestrian friendly and vanquishing the bus parking from the middle of the roadway would be a first step. Repairing the broken water fountain is also a must.

For example, simple memorials in parks serve purposes to various organizations. The Buffalo Police Reserves still have a memorial at the intersection of Genesee Street and Best Street in the area of where Police Precinct 12 used to stand before it was demolished by a church to become.....a parking lot. The BPR meet there every Memorial Day still though. Even the simple Police Memorial on Franklin Street & Erie Street serves a purpose.

The comment regarding foot patrols. You could possibly (due to it's proximity) enlist the assistance of the Buffalo Place Rangers. While I would support the utlization of the Buffalo Special Police for "patrols" like this, the Buffalo Police have made sure that this volunteer auxiliary never sees the light of day again.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Bulldoze it, auction the site to a private developer and develop the site. The park is useless, get rid of it. Get it on the tax roll and hopefully it goes condos.

Score: -1 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Just seen what they did today. They put dirt and flowers in the Fountain. Can't wait to see the mess we'll have by the time summmer begins with no up keeps.

Score: -2 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Leave a comment