Real Estate February 23, 2012 11:00 AM

Hamister Selected to Develop Key Falls Site

Hamister Selected to Develop Key Falls Site

Empire State Development (ESD), USA Niagara Development Corporation (USAN) and the City of Niagara Falls today announced that The Hamister Group, Inc. was selected as the preferred developer in response to the request for proposals (RFP) for development of a key City-owned site located at 310 Rainbow Boulevard in downtown Niagara Falls.  Hamister is planning a mix of retail, hotel and residential space.

The site is located at the northwest corner of Rainbow Boulevard and Old Falls Street, 300 feet from the entrance to Niagara Falls State Park, which enjoys roughly 8 million annual visitors.  Totaling 0.88 acres, the vacant property was recently acquired by the City in conjunction with a larger effort to develop a Niagara County Community College‐sponsored Culinary Institute in a portion of the former Rainbow Centre Mall. 

USAN received seven responses to the RFP, which was due in December.  Of those, Hamister's $22.4 million proposal was determined to best meet the RFP objective of creating a relatively high-density mix of uses with a focus on active ground-level development that would contribute to visitor and resident offerings along historic Old Falls Street.

NFHamister.bmpPreliminary plans include 104 upscale hotel rooms, 24 residential units and up 8,000 square feet of retail space.  Carmina Wood Morris is designing the project.  The development is estimated to directly create 219 construction jobs and 130 permanent jobs.  Construction is expected to start next year and be completed in 2014.

"This is another step forward for a project that is a direct result of substantial investment by the state into Niagara Falls," said ESD President, CEO & Commissioner Kenneth Adams.  "Between the Culinary Institute, Old Falls Street and now the development of 310 Rainbow Boulevard, we are not only reinvigorating the downtown area, but creating new jobs and expanding the tax base."

NF Elevation.bmp"We are thrilled to be selected as the preferred developer for 310 Rainbow Boulevard and to be a part of the growth of downtown Niagara Falls," said The Hamister Group, Inc. Senior Vice President of Business Development Daniel Hamister.  "This project is a perfect example of what can be accomplished when a government agency sets a goal and streamlines the process in order to get the job done.  We are proud of the relationship that we have maintained with USA Niagara throughout the RFP process and look forward to that same positive working relationship with the City of Niagara Falls and Niagara County." 

The Hamister Group, Inc., founded in 1977 and based in Buffalo, is a recognized leader in hotel and healthcare facility development and management.  Its hotel holdings include facilities in Pittsburgh, Knoxville and Louisville.

Hamister also has plans for a key downtown Buffalo site.  The company is planning adaptively reuse the Tishman Building on Lafayette Square as a mixed-use office, residential and hotel property featuring a new Hilton Garden Hotel.  That project is expected to get underway later this year.  Carmina Wood Morris is designing the Tishman conversion as well. 

NFHamisterSite.bmpNFSitePlan.bmpNF Ground.bmp

NFHamister2.bmp

NFHamister3.bmp

NFHamister4.bmpImages Courtesy of Carmina Wood Morris

View image

Comments

Leave a comment

Looks good..I was hoping there would be an article on this. Do people really still build skywalks? Or is it connected to a parking garage?

Its good to see a local company..purchasing land locally and making the investment here..locally..all too often its a purchaser from some far away land.

Score: 1 ( 7 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I had always hoped that Tenant Signage would come to WNY...

Great project! Will really add to Old Falls St. and build more street activity.

Score: 1 ( 9 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Let's see if it ever gets build. Niagara Falls doesn't exactly have a good track record. Plus the union parasites are already talking about prevailing wage and contractor's having to be locally hired. Typical corruption, red tape, politics and incompetence are already in full motion.

Score: 3 ( 25 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I guess they will get use out of those Elmwood Hotel plans after all

Score: -3 ( 21 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Great to see some movement in NF, but this project looks like "everywheresville USA". Could be Boca, could be Phoenix, could be Lauderdale.

Is it so difficult to embrace our unique vernacular?

replied to STEEL
Score: -10 ( 22 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

What unique vernacular are you talking about? What's so unique about it? In NF the vernacular seems to be run - down, post - industrial wasteland. This is a perfectly adequate building in a city that needs it.
Now to see if they can build this thing without someone screwing it up. I certainly hope for the best, but I wouldn't be surprised if NF's usual track record of incompetence screws it up. I mean it's Niagara Falls, it should be a shining jewel, a tourist Mecca. It's not a stretch to think that the place shouldattract tourists, and the fact that it is the embarassment that it is is a testiment to the corruption and idiocy that have been running the show up there for far too long.

replied to Travelrrr
Score: 13 ( 21 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Western New York, and Buffalo in particular, DOES have some very unique vernacular styles of architecture. On the residential front, Buffalo has several styles of homes that aren't really found anywhere else such as 1.5 story gable-fronted Italianate cottages. Many cities of Buffalo's density and vintage are also composed of rowhouses, but in Buffalo, multi-family dwellings manifest as two-family houses with upstairs and downstairs flats. These houses have a very particular colonial-revival style with a gable that frequently features decorative carved panels. To me, they look very distinctly 'Buffalo.'

In terms of commercial architecture, Buffalo has a lot of storefronts that look more like houses and are frequently frame construction. This is a style of commercial architecture that hasn't endured in most places, particularly in cities of Buffalo's size and density and is fairly unique to the area. Romanesque architecture also features strongly in Western New York with a lot of commercial and institutional buildings featuring rusticated red sandstone in some way.

For the scale of this building, I don't know if any of these regional styles could be woven directly into the design, but it is important to consider that Western New York does have a 'look' that should be promoted, enhanced and complimented by new construction. This building is nice, but it does look like a lot urban new builds. Not every building can or should be a masterpiece, but this does look like it could be in Columbus or Phoenix or Indianapolis or Portland. I think a 'tourist' attraction should scream 'Look where I am!" It's relatively easy to pick out a street in New Orleans or Paris or South Beach or Chicago or St. Louis or Boston or Pittsburgh. Niagara Falls and Buffalo should hope for the same.

replied to pampiniform
Score: -1 ( 7 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

uuuuu arreee a FOOOL...as stated above..what vernacular are you talking about? NF was leveled mid century...whatttt areee youuu talkingg about??? Everything has to be old and dirty for BRO'ers..

I'm with Castle though...ya think Buffalo is corrupt...sheesh...if it weren't for Paul Dyster I definately think (local 109 is it?)they would run Hamister all the way down the thruway..this parcel would be vacant for 5 more decades..and then they would throw a party..ya know cause they help the community and all. LOL

replied to Travelrrr
Score: 2 ( 12 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

That's a pretty sharp building. Good to see something like this happening in the Falls!

Score: 11 ( 15 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

It's great to see Niagara Falls, NY finally clean it self up. If more people came to the Falls and stayed longer, they most likely will come to Buffalo as well.

Score: 12 ( 16 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

It be nice if we could develop the classy low key version of the falls, as opposed to Canada's cheesy glitz and glam tourist agglomeration.

replied to Lego1981
Score: 15 ( 19 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

YES. Please.

replied to Tim
Score: 8 ( 12 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Yes, the city gets their act together and then will have something to stand on when they go to the state and say let's fix up the park!

An aLoft hotel here would be great. It is the cheaper version of the W Hotel. Hip but very affordable. Starwood would have a nice footprint down at the falls with the two other Sheratons.

replied to 300miles
Score: -1 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Agree, the American side should not try to copy the Canadian model. We have a much nicer natural environment with better natural features and trails. We have the potential to develop an alternative that could bring much needed investment and tourist dollars to our side.

replied to Tim
Score: 7 ( 9 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

It blows my mind how blighted the City of Niagara Falls is considering the major tourist attraction it sits on. There's so much potential in Niagara Falls development. This is a step in the right direction.

Score: 10 ( 16 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I think the site plan, massing, height, and corner entrance are all good with this project.

That said, on the architecture, I couldn't agree more with Travelrrr. Plop it down in the middle of a parking lot lake, and this building would be at home Anywhere, USA -- especially places that look like the vicinity of UB North Campus or the airport. ANY airport.

There is nothing whatsoever of the Falls in the building's architecture. I tend to be picky on stuff like that -- just ask anyone from the Greenway signage committee ;-) Geology is what Niagara Falls is all about, and many of the downtown buildings have local stone. Even some of the modernist structures in the Falls incorporate stone. That ought to be especially so anywhere near the park -- one of the world's natural wonders, and one of the top tourist destinations in North America. And this site isn't just near the park, it's STEPS AWAY.

I wonder what it would have really set them back to do a design that incorporated local stone in even the smallest way -- even as facing on some surfaces, like the corner entry tower, base course, etc. And did no one even think of doing a "waterfall" window at the top section of the corner tower--? Well, whoever designed the new visitors' center did -- and it works nicely in that design. They could also have gone in a different direction for local design inspiration, incorporating some terra cotta and/or art-deco elements that reference the United Office Building, the best part of the NF, NY skyline. Perhaps with Native American motifs. Elements like that might add to project cost, but not necessarily a huge amount in comparison to the overall budget.

But instead of borrowing from ANY local theme whatsoever, as Travelrrr rightly pointed out, the architecture seems borrowed from "Everywheresville, USA". And on probably the most important streetscape axis in WNY (aside from Court Street, Buffalo).

Sorry -- as much as I admire CWM, this architecture is just not good enough.

Score: -5 ( 15 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Wait, so the grain elevators are the perfect architecture for Buffalo, but this building is too "anywhere" for Niagara Falls. I can't believe you people.

replied to RaChaCha
Score: 0 ( 16 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I admit you totally lost me there when you went all grain elevator.

replied to pampiniform
Score: 2 ( 4 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

It's always great to hope for the best buildings possible, but sadly, NF simply doesn't have much of an architectural heritage to work with. The cathedral-like power plants are gone, the chemical plants are an eyesore, and at this point, anything that isn't a boarded-up derelict or crack house is a vast improvement.

NF also has something of an advantage... People come for the falls and the parks and the attractions, the buildings are a distant contender. Even mood lighting tops architecture in importance for visitors. Being an international attraction, it is also somewhat of a good thing to utilize 'anywhere' designs to help foreign or middle-American visitors feel more at ease.

If this was being plunked down in the middle of downtown Buffalo, we'd have reason to be disappointed. But it's going on an empty lot surrounded by empty lots, abandoned buildings and an ugly parking behemoth. This is one case where "it could have been worse" is still a vast improvement, and has the potential to spur something a little better the next time.

replied to RaChaCha
Score: 2 ( 6 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

it is emphatically -not- an anywheresville building. most suburban zoning codes would forbid this kind of building.

for one thing, it scores high on urban functionality. it is built up to the sidewalk instead of being fronted by parking. it has a genuine, at grade corner entrance (super high points for that!). it has a cornice. it has ground floor retail. it has sidewalk cafes overlooking actual sidewalks rather than parking lots.

the only thing i'd wish for that is not present is balconies overlooking the street. and no #$%*&! dry-vit. but we can't have everything.

Score: 6 ( 8 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

from the material list on the 3rd photo, it doesn't look like they'll be too much stucco. Most of the facade looks like brick and wood.

replied to grad94
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

It looks good and will bring some much needed density/shops to the main tourist area in the falls. Ultimately, the outcome of this project will determine whether or not it's worth it to start developing downtown NF again. After decades of mob-like intimidation and feet dragging, if this does well, expect the other vacant parcels to go quickly. Now if we can get the Schumer to force absentee landlord Howard Millstein to sell off his land at half price.

Score: 1 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I worked in the falls for 10 years and my wife grew up in the North End. It is true that the historic downtown core was a victim of urban renewal and has been demolished but the city still has pockets of quality buildings and homes. Main Street in the North End is still fairly intact with many old brick and stone buildings, some dating to the 1850's. There are also many fine old homes in the North End, the DeVeaux area, and parts of downtown. Many of these pocket areas are only a few blocks like Park Place and 4th Street in the downtown area but they are as nice as anything we have here in Buffalo. The beauty of the City of Niagara Falls is not always apparent from a drive by, need to look beyond the usual tourist areas to see the real city.

Score: 5 ( 9 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Niagara falls has a few unusual relations. I think that the fact that it is more so a city places some unique challenges. They need to solve the battle of land mass. And I like the theory behind the Louvre pyramid. to be continued...

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I'd love to see the day when people from buffalo are traveling to Niagara Falls double or triple the rate at which they currently are.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Leave a comment

Buffalo Rising Poll