Regional December 12, 2011 10:20 PM

Retread Tobe Returning to County Hall as Deputy County Executive

Retread Tobe Returning to County Hall as Deputy County Executive

Erie County Executive-elect Mark C. Poloncarz has appointed Richard M. Tobe to serve as his administration's Deputy County Executive.  Tobe has more than 30 years of economic development experience in the public and private sectors as well as academia.

As a candidate, Poloncarz promised to make job creation a top priority of his administration and in September released a plan entitled "Growing Jobs: Creating an Economic Development Strategy that Works for Erie County."  As part of that plan, Poloncarz's Deputy County Executive will serve as the point-person responsible for coordinating all of the County's economic development tools and agencies and lead Poloncarz's efforts to aggressively attract business expansion from Canada. 

Poloncarz stated, "As I have said, my Deputy County Executive's will focus on job creation and creating a streamlined, sustainable and efficient approach to economic development in Erie County.  This position required an individual that not only had a proven track record of successfully navigating the often turbulent local economic development process but who could also help create a better system for tomorrow. Today, I am proud to announce Richard Tobe will serve in that role.  It is time that Erie County taxpayers see a return on the investment of their tax dollars into economic development initiatives that show results.  Richard's decades of successful and multi-faceted economic development experience in the public and private sectors make him the perfect choice to lead these efforts."

During his 12 years serving the Gorski administration as Commissioner of Environment and Planning, Tobe led the County's successful effort to negotiate a new long-term lease agreement with the Buffalo Bills, and construct the Buffalo Sabres' arena (now First Niagara Center) in downtown Buffalo, while serving as the point-person with New York State and local municipalities on economic development initiatives.  

Since then Tobe has served as an adjunct professor at the University at Buffalo's Graduate School of Planning and School of Law, Vice President of the Community Foundation for Greater Buffalo, and Commissioner of the City of Buffalo's Department of Economic Development, Permit and Inspection Services.

Tobe said, "I am supremely honored to serve County Executive-elect Poloncarz as the Deputy County Executive.  I strongly agree with the County Executive-elect that, for too long, Erie County has been devoid of a cohesive and focused economic development strategy.  I know and love this community and I am confident that by working together with local, state and federal economic development agencies and by leveraging our abundance of resources and strategic location we can realize real, sustainable growth." 

View image

Comments

Leave a comment

Slightly harsh headline.

Spend 5 minutes with Tobe as I did as a student and you'll realize he's technically expert, legally savvy and largely apolitical.

And for those that want to cast him as a villian, track him down and have him talk to you about his feelings about the Scajaquada and whether it was actually lgeally constructed and the negative impact its had.

Good hire.

Score: 14 ( 16 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I'll second that. Tobe is very competent. Talented, bright. Good hire.

replied to GeoBflo
Score: 11 ( 13 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

i'll third that. and i agree that is is a gratuitiously snide headline.

replied to GeoBflo
Score: 8 ( 12 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Retread is a generous term for this guy....There are 1,000,000 people in Erie county, they couldn't find one new guy to fill this position?
Take a look at his career. What has he contributed to the Buffalo and Erie County...Retire....please!!

Score: -2 ( 16 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Byron Brown fired him. That means he's probably pretty competent.

Score: 15 ( 15 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

The only thing I remember about Tobe's tenure in the Brown administration was a report that he was against the creation of a tax free, sovereign, and now delinquent seedy gambling shack downtown.

That was counter to what the administration, demo fans, and high rise dreamers wanted but it certainly looks like the appropriate stance given the now obvious consequences of this sort of "economic development strategy."

If this smart and independent stance is typical of the Deputy Exec, the Tobe appointment looks like a good move on Ploncarz's part.

Score: 9 ( 9 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Maybe he opposed it behind closed doors if the report you recall was correct.
But if AV writer Jackson was accurate, Brown and Tobe did a lot to help along the casino.
http://artvoice.com/issues/v5n22/nine_biggest_lies_about_the_proposed_buffalo_creek_casino
(under what Jackson calls Lie 9) "...when the Seneca Gaming Corporation began the second phase of its downtown destruction last week it was revealed that Brown, his director of development Richard Tobe and the rest of his staff have been quietly helping them along, giving them permits to block off city streets, providing easements, avoiding public hearings and refusing to insist on legally required environmental impact studies..."

So, those of us who favor a casino being allowed for people who like that activity (&/or those of us who don't miss H-O being there) can also find some good in the Tobe hire if he capably did the stuff AV says to help along the Seneca casino.

I also wonder if Tobe helped his prior boss Masiello file suit in court to force the Senecas to locate the casino in Buffalo instead of in Cheektowaga where they had been trying to put it. If so, maybe that's another sign of his talent since the city's side prevailed in court and forced it to be here.

replied to The Kettle
Score: 1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

It that is true I stand corrected. I through I read something about Tobe's dissent on the casino debacle being a factor in his dismissal but I could be wrong.

If what Jackson is saying is correct, those of you who like gambling, dislike grain elevators and are okay with an industry being permitted for one tax free entity but illegal for everybody else can find comfort in this appointment.

replied to whatever
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Yes, "okay with" is a fair description, compared to the prior ban.
The time-limited monopoly that NYS gave the Senecas (in exchange for some faster revenue) wasn't good, but it was a good improvement over the state's previous total ban on private sector casino gambling in WNY.

worst - prior total ban.

would be better - allowing moderately regulated private sector casinos without any Seneca monopoly. Maybe eventually NYS will do what it takes to move toward that approach.

somewhere in between worst & better - how NYS did it.

replied to The Kettle
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I disagree. Forfeiting untold millions in tax and now "exclusivity" revenues, circumventing the NYS Constitution, putting local businesses at a competitive disadvantage, and whoreing out the local Indian tribe seems like an exorbitant price to pay for making what amounts to a token stand for gamblers rights. Especially since there were several non-casino forms of gambling available before these things were built.

Thankfully, many of the pitfalls of this agreement, that should have been obvious years ago, are now apparent to the general public and elected officials. Lets hope the state and voters follow through with the current movement afoot to make casino gambling legal statewide.

Though I'd much prefer the uniquely successful Ontario model of state owned casinos versus the widely unsuccessful idea of lightly regulated private casinos. That will get the public the best return on revenues and allow provisions to protect non-casino businesses in the area from casino competition.

replied to whatever
Score: 1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Personally, I'm impressed that Mark doesn't seem to feel it necessary to conduct a search to fill some key positions -- I've come to believe very strongly that we have the expertise right here in WNY to turn around WNY. It's just a matter of getting the right people in the right positions with the right leadership. Rich Tobe is one of the right people. He should be able to draw on his extensive knowledge, experience, and relationships to help pull some things together quickly. Anyone rushing to apply the "retread" label should give it some more consideration -- I think we'll find the community is better off for Tobe's engagement at the Rath Building.

Score: 7 ( 7 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Whether or not one is a fan of Poloncarz or Tobe, it's interesting to notice Poloncarz shows great interest in publicly feuding with City Hall right off the bat
http://www.buffalonews.com/city/communities/erie-county/article670134.ece
"...And in another example of his strained relations with City Hall, the county executive-elect put the blame for Tobe's departure on Brown. "It had less to do with Rich Tobe and more to do with the mayor, including his executive assistant deputy mayor," Poloncarz said, referring to Deputy Mayor Steven M. Casey." ..."

Could have just said no comment about past history, but nope… Rawr!
Oh well, so much for inter-govt peace making for now, and this from the "nice guy" smiley CE-elect, lol

Score: 2 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Leave a comment