City August 8, 2011 5:57 PM

Creating an Identity and a Legacy for Buffalo

Creating an Identity and a Legacy for Buffalo
By Chris Catanzaro:

On a recent family trip to Burlington, VT and various areas of the Central NY Adirondacks, I realized that many admirable aspects of both areas could be translated into "hot spots" in Buffalo.  The immediate areas that came to mind were Chippewa St. and Canalside.  The likely counterparts were Church St. in Burlington, VT, and The Adirondack Museum in Blue Mountain Lake, NY.  Both areas appear to have recognized their relevance to the communities, targeted meaningful and appropriate avenues to showcase their talents and utilized the most important tool of all... involvement of public feedback/focus.

I have visited the Church St. District in Burlington, VT, many times and each time I wonder, "Why can't we duplicate this in Buffalo?"  The recent debate on closing off Chippewa St. to make it more manageable rang in my head as we strolled past the many cafes, restaurants, storefronts, street vendors (with allowable permits I assume) and finally street performers.  They have closed off the main street way (Church St.), but allowed for traffic from streets perpendicular to pass through a highly visible crosswalk.   The establishments were mostly filled with sizable crowds and the "walkers" measured about 100 or so for roughly four blocks.  Everyone appeared to be enjoying all that Church St. had to offer... and we were there on a late Sunday  afternoon (5ish) when most signs revealed a closing time of 6pm. Our local guide stated that this "slow" crowd usually quadrupled in size on a late weekday and was significantly larger on a weekend night. 

The best part of all was that the crowds varied from the old to the new, families to couples to singles, the "grungy" to the "preppy" and all intermingled as though they each found their own place on Church St.  After various conversations with our guide and some employees of establishments, the consensus was that Burlington, VT, as most of Vermont, provided something for everyone from "all walks of life."  For those concerned for safety on the streets, there was a definite presence of police patrol via foot, bike and squad car throughout our walk.  Burlington, VT, boasted a few colleges nearby, a beautiful waterfront and a varied group walking the streets.  There wasn't  too much of a difference between the geographic makeup of this place and ours.  So, I asked myself again, "Why can't we do this in Buffalo?"

My second adventure took me to a place that is one of a kind, the Adirondacks, but boasted a museum that buffalo could most definitely emulate, The Adirondack Museum.  As soon as I began my jaunt through this gorgeously designed and redesigned museum, I again thought, "Why can't we have something like this in Buffalo?"  Everywhere I turned, there were aspects of the museum that would be great for a museum on our jewel, the waterfront.  The museum was set in a picturesque setting in the backdrop of the mountains and overlooking a wonderful lake.  Beyond that, the entire museum screamed Adirondack culture and history.  And once again, the visitors were folks of all shapes, sizes, colors, languages and personalities, with the same goal in mind... to learn of the wonder of this place.  The exhibits were visually astounding, highly organized, wonderfully described and best of all, highly interactive.  I felt as though I had been transformed to the era of that particular time in history.  Time and time again, I thought of the possibility to showcase our linkage to our waterfront through a collaborative museum. 

Ideas of our canal days, steel industry, grain elevators, weather, leisure, travel and our overall connection to Buffalo history were only a few racing thoughts that I could corral in my mind.  Then we passed though such exhibits that featured types of boats used in the area, the "old ways" of cleaning clothes and a vast history lesson of the region.  All of these parts of the museum were easily transferable to a waterfront museum.  The most astonishing part of all was that my family and I spent 4 ½ hours at the museum and saw perhaps 1/8 of its offerings (2 children under the age of 3 will get you stuck at such things as the giant Adirondack chair and the steam train).  I do know one thing... all 15 "newbies" were ready to go back as soon as possible.  It pains me to spew redundant phrases, but I was again relegated to wondering, "Why can't we have something like this in Buffalo?"   

My words can't do either of these places the justice they deserve.  It is my hope that the leaders of our community travel to places and walk their avenues that showcase hope, forward thinking and acceptance of their identity.  Places like Burlington, VT, and The Adirondack Museum.  It is the times that we are able to step outside our own small worlds that we can then realize the potential for what can be. 
         
View image

Comments

Leave a comment

Yes, Church Street in Burlington, Vermont, is a successful pedestrian mall with a number of national retailers blended with local shops. I used to visit once or twice a year and the atmosphere is great. The community deserves a lot of credit for making it happen and keeping it going.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

How about a native American museum on the waterfront? I'd love to see the Seneca's parter with the ECHDC to build a world class attraction.

Score: 0 ( 8 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Great idea, maybe they could relocate the shuttered Turtle building from Niagara Falls to the Buffalo waterfront.

replied to Indycat23
Score: 1 ( 7 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

That'd be cool, I enjoyed the Festival on the waterfront this weekend. The weather scared a lot of people off but it was enjoyed by those that went. I think some kind of Native American Cultural Center is very important if we want a full cultural experience.

replied to bobbycat
Score: 3 ( 5 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

LOVE Burlington....used to live there. Buffalo will never be Burlington.....EVER. The area is made up of progressive, free-thinking, active, outdoorsy people who TRULY care about the city. I know that there are a handful of those out there that foot the bill in Buffalo, but only a handful. Buffalo is too immersed in NYS politics and can never be the city that Burlington is. Much like Ithaca (a city planned by the same group who planned Burlington & Boulder, CO), it is ravaged by the powers that be in NYS and is very limited in that respect. It is a great place to strive to be, however, and I wish Buffalo nothing but the best. GOOD LUCK!!

Score: -1 ( 13 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I'm not quite sure why you waste your, and our, time commenting on here-your comments offer no value and your tone is incredibly cynical.

Anyway, I like that this article helps us to expand people's minds, and look at what is working in other locales. However, I caution us to not try to "emulate" any other city, as that is an unfeasable task. Fact is, we are our own city, have our own authenticity, history and dynamics-we should never attempt to directly be another place, it just wouldn't work.

Fact is, Buffalo is changing, and you'd have to be blind (or blinded by cynicism) not to notice. New commercial districts are forming (Black Rock, Lower West Side, etc.), houses and buildings are being restored, young people are eager to stay and/or relocate here, etc. Is the city where it could be, or we want it to be? Not even close. However, it becomes more of an interesting place by the day.

replied to buffalowhatever
Score: 7 ( 13 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Sorry that my tone is not what you want it to be. Buffalo has a LONG way to go. I love Buffalo, I grew up there, but am very realistic about it's current status & it's future. Let people have their own opinions without knocking them and saying they have no value. It is quite condescending. I defend Buffalo on a daily basis (I no longer live there), but everytime I am back I see things getting worse & worse. Maybe I am not frequenting the up-in-coming "Black Rock" & "Lower west side". Maybe I should. But from an outsider ,(former insider), looking in, I don't think that the city has the support in needs to be a city like Burlington, VT. I wish more than anything it did.
Sorry. Didn't mean to offend.

replied to Travelrrr
Score: -3 ( 11 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

You are entitled to your POV, but when you make comments about Burlington with people who actually "care" you are not only being derogatory, but you are not really taking a close look at those in Buffalo changing the city-I think you would be hard pressed to find a populace (notice, I do NOT say politicians ) who care more about their city. And, I do recommend you venture out to some of those up-and-coming areas. There is so much positive movement, one would have to work very hard to not see it. If you care about Buffalo as much as you do, be part of the momentum...not the negativity.

replied to buffalowhatever
Score: 0 ( 10 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

So yet again, the requisite speech is happy talk. Everything the guy said was either opinion or 100% accurate. "F" opinions though unless they mirror your own right? I would agree that some things are changing, mostly for the better, but last time I checked the population is still pouring out of WNY, especially the city. So if someone wants to offer their perspective, I say let them, as things are far from perfect.

replied to Travelrrr
Score: -1 ( 9 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

buff, I don't find your comment offensive and I wouldn't join anybody trying to shut you up.

However, your point Buffalo will "never be Burlington" doesn't have any deeper meaning than saying Burlington will never be Buffalo, or Burlington will never be Pittsburgh, or Pittsburgh will never be L.A. (which, btw, has plenty of its own problems recently, along with good aspects too). While I agree with you that being in NYS has some negatives politically/economically, nothing can be done about it so it's like complaining about weather.

If people prefer a certain size or type or state of a city, there's plenty to choose from.

On points of Chris the author - the setting in Burlington (shops, outdoor cafes, etc.) doesn't sound too different from what's also found in Buffalo - not exactly the same of course, but similar - although not downtown here.
As for the idea of banning cars from a street - it no doubt succeeds in a few places and fails badly in others as it did here. If Chris is suggesting Buffalo try it again, I'd wonder where here, and what problem would that be trying to solve?

Can't people from the Adirondack place ask the same question when visiting Burlington ("Why can't we have this in Blue Mountain Lake?"), and couldn't Burlington people ask when visiting the Adirondack museum "Why can't we have a museum like this in Burlington?"
Then if people from either of those places visit Buffalo, they might see things here that they could ask "why can't we have it?".
Is it grass-is-always-greener syndrome?

I just noticed Eric commented something similar below, but I'll submit this anyhow.

replied to buffalowhatever
Score: 1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I used to live near Burlington & Buffalo vs. Burlington, it's not even close, two completely different cities. However, it would be absurd to close any street in Buffalo, they did that on Main and I don't think it's worked too well. Pedestrian malls work in really small towns, like Burlington or Kalamazoo, not Buffalo. Church Street has attracted some decent retailers, mainly due to the ultra-concentrated fairly affluent student population, Church to UVM is only a ten or so minute walk; that's another consideration, everyone walks in Burlington.

Score: 6 ( 8 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Many cities have come up with creative branding but few have as many choices as Buffalo. However, all cities have poured money into their branding while Buffalo/Erie County cannot even secure the Hotel Bed Tax for its intended purpose of branding/advertising/toursim promotion. Your political journey starts there.

Buffalo could be there Paris of the Great Lakes simply by rebuilding many of the 1901 PAN AM Spanish Renaissance Buildings, Fountains, Sculptures, Band Shells, etc.

Buffalo could be a historical mekka with stories of Buffalos role in the French/Indian War, Revolutionary War, 1812 War, Civil War, WWI & WWII, as well as the age of exploration LaSalles Griffon exploring the Great Lakes north of Niagara Falls...which led into the age of pioneering settlement, agriculture, transportation, industrialization and invention.

Culturally Buffalo is a micro-mekka of wine, beer, food and community festivals.

Geographically Buffalo is sandwiched between lakes, rivers, canals and mountains so there is no shortage of diversity, not to mention one of the greatest natural wonders on the planet.

Yet Buffalonians still wont fight for the bed tax, wont fight for a new convention center, wont fight for new centers of excellence and wont fight to rebuild lost architectural treasures which would re-weave our city back into its golden age.

There is alot Buffalo could build a brand...Buffalonians know who they are...and they are proud of their legacy. Buffalonians on the whole would rather be a culturally, historically and architecturally rich city like Boston or a Charleston than transient shallow vapid nuvueau riche midsize city like say Pheonix or Reno or mega city like LA or Houston.

Score: 1 ( 9 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Please stop the incorrect use of Mecca. It is offensive to so many.

replied to paulsobo
Score: -1 ( 9 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Wow, I never heard that before or even considered that it might be offensive. Thanks for enlightening me (us).

replied to Mr. Underhill
Score: 2 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

please stop being a liberal islamo-fascist...everything can be offensive if thats the way you want to paint it.

I find you offensive for being so easily offended

I find you hypocritically offensive for only being offended for Islam and not being offended when Christianity is the issue.

Is the queen of diamonds here?...off with his head! Now where are the mad hatter and that rabbit...we are late for tea.

replied to Mr. Underhill
Score: 2 ( 4 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I'd find it offensive if you used the name of any holy land like you do with Mecca. Don't matter if I am Baptist, Catholic, Hindu, or Buddhist because it is still offensive. Your ignorant remarks back to my point just shows that you are a bigot and whats worse is you probably don't realize it.

replied to paulsobo
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I truly believe if we find a way to reuse the Grain Elevators, it would put us in the world eye. Other places have reused silos in different ways but we have so many left it could be an incredibly unique experience.

I really hope the bridge happens sooner than later. One way or another this should give a major chance to the Connecting Terminal, the one across from the Central Wharf, to become a Restaurant. Imagine the view, overlooking the River on one side and Lake on the other.

The ones on Childs could be mixed use, with a Distillery/Brewery, residential, Shops, Action Gym (climbing wall, wind tunnel, obstacle course. etc)

Ok I know I'm totally dreaming, but we can take small steps like the plan to have a path go around the River. I think as more people discover the area more people will be willing to invest in it.

Score: 1 ( 5 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I vote for teh Dinosaur BBQ at the Grain Elevator by the bridge connecting the outer harbor. They like to locate in unique type of buildings. Doesn't get any more unique than that.

replied to JM
Score: 2 ( 4 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I don't understand the tone of this article. Buffalo already has a legacy and an identity, and a much richer one than Burlington, VT. There are over 50 museums and galleries in Buffalo, a grammy award winning orchestra, dozens of theatre companies, arts festivals, chamber music, a voluble literary culture, etc. The historical cosmopolitan character of Buffalo dwarfs Burlington's.

Score: 5 ( 7 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Eric, was the writer comparing cosmopolitan qualities? I don't think so. Just because Buffalo and Burlington are two very different places, it doesn't mean that Buffalo can't learn from Burlington or any other city, town or region. We all share and learn from each other, right?

replied to EricOak
Score: 1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I just don't get the article. There are already museums and interesting places to walk here, so I'm puzzled by the writer's urgent tone--that something is deficient in terms of "legacy and identity" in Buffalo. We may have problems, as all cities do, but legacy and identity are not two of them.

replied to PaulBuffalo
Score: 3 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

This is also what I thought when I read the article. Buffalo already has a pretty amazing identity. This article doesn't really address the nature of community identity directly and whether its something that even can/should be created by an urban planner or museum curator. A fine museum or public space could provide an opportunity to reflect or amplify a community's identity but I wouldn't say that it creates identity.

We should also be careful not to dismiss Buffalo's low brow tendencies and institutions.

replied to EricOak
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I don't see why a pedestrian mall couldn't succeed in Buffalo much like the commons succeeds in Ithaca. It would be a perfect fit.

Score: -1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Have you been to The Commons recently? I was there a few months ago and my main thought was "thank god this thing is only 2 blocks long."

Most of the vibrant business activity was located just off the commons along auto-accessible streets. Though I understand they are in the process of redesigning the commons, hopefully that will help. But its hardly a shining example to follow.

replied to LI2Northpark
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I agree with townline about that. I've seen that car-free section of Ithaca be a lot of empty non-vibrant space. It was especially dead after dark on a weeknight last time I was there - shops closed, a few bars & restaurants open but spread out among the whole thing.

Probably there's some days when it's a good setting if an event is happening, but why not just block off car traffic for those occasions?

replied to LI2Northpark
Score: 1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

It surprises me that theres talk of a pedestrian mall in downtown again after the disaster that was Main Street that most are now agreeing should be returned to at least some traffic. I like the concept of a pedestrian mall as long as it is done right and in Buffalo I think done right would need to include a heated surface for the winter months simply because the winter season is long. Perhaps something like the pedestrian mall in Knoxville, TN or Charlottesville, VA with heated concrete or brick added, etc could work if done carefully with good landscaping and public arts but otherwise I just dont see a pedestrian mall as the right thing in downtown Buffalo. Buffalo has enough challenges to reverse past transportation system screw ups including the Main Street pedestrian mall and disconnect of Genesee Street, and Eagle Street.

Score: 1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Leave a comment

Todays Events

Buffalo Rising Poll