City June 29, 2011 6:01 PM

To ECC Board of Trustees: The 2007 plan was the right plan.

To ECC Board of Trustees: The 2007 plan was the right plan.
Bernice Radle, chair of Young Citizens for ECC, today made her case to shift the college's allied health programs to downtown Buffalo directly to the ECC Board of Trustees. The young professionals advocacy group, formed in April in response to ECC's plan to build a $30 million Health Sciences Center for Excellence in Amherst, is keeping the heat on high.

Radle's pitch to the Board of Trustees comes after her group's successful effort to convince members of Western New York's state delegation to support a change in ECC's plans. Young Citizens for ECC points to the college's 2007 proposal, which would have consolidated ECC's allied health programs to its City Campus, as an inspiration for shifting gears on the $30 million project.

Bringing ECC's Health Sciences Center for Excellence to the transit-accessible City Campus, rather than its "isolated" suburban campus, says Radle, couldn't be better timed alongside the growth of the Buffalo Niagara Medical Campus. Here's a transcript of Radle's remarks:

Hello, my name is Bernice Radle. I am here to speak on behalf of Young Citizens for ECC, an organization of young professionals dedicated to the future of Erie Community College. It is in the true spirit of collaboration that I address you today on behalf of my colleagues.

I am here today to suggest a proposal, but not one that is original to Young Citizens for ECC. In 2007 the ECC Board of Trustees put forward a plan to relocate the college's allied health programs to the City Campus.

The 2007 plan was the right plan.

The 2007 plan is even more relevant today than it was four years ago. Since then more than 3,000 new jobs have been created at the medical campus with another 2,000 are on the way. If ECC is to become more competitive, it must become a direct participant in the development of the Buffalo Niagara Medical Campus.

ECC was the first to embrace this approach before setting it aside. In fact, ECC's 2007 plan to relocate its allied health programs to the City Campus was introduced long before the UB Medical School and Health Sciences Charter School were slated to move downtown. It was ECC in 2007 that introduced a progressive, forward-thinking plan to link students directly to the job, internship, and networking opportunities of the Buffalo Niagara Medical Campus.

We believe it is time to pick back up that banner, and do what's right for the region and our young people.

A plaque in the office of County Executive Chris Collins reads, "In God we trust, all others bring data." In that spirit we offer the following datum points to support ECC's original 2007 plan to bring its allied health programs to the City Campus:


    * ECC's mission statement suggests the college "strives toward a future where education is accessible and convenient to all." The City Campus is the most convenient and accessible campus in Western New York by car or by transit, with direct linkages to the Metro Rail, 35 bus routes, three major highways, an intercity bus hub, and 32,730 parking spaces. While the City Campus is more accessible to Southtowns motorists than the North Campus is, transit access at the City Campus is an especially important consideration for City of Buffalo households, 31.4% of which do not have access to an automobile. The place to build is the City Campus.

    * ECC is under-prepared for the huge demographic shift represented by the Millennial generation, the cohort born between 1986 and 1995. RCLCo, a leading real estate market research firm, recently conducted a national survey revealing a staggering 88% of the people of this generation prefers to work and live in urban environments. This makes the Millennials the most urban generation since at least before World War II. To remain competitive ECC must prepare for this major generational shift. The place to build is the City Campus.

    * The Brookings Institute reports the City of Buffalo is falling behind regional gains in associates degree attainment, with a share of the City population with associates degrees at 8.4% in 2009 compared to an MSA share of 10.7%. Young Citizens for ECC would like to inspire the Board of Trustees to bridge this gap in associates degree attainment by investing where the need is the greatest - at its City Campus. If this gap were bridged, and the City's associates degree attainment achieved parity with that of the MSA, the return on investment would be staggering. The Bureau of Labor Statistics reports the annual median earnings in 2009 for an associate degree holder is $7,020 more than for a high school graduate. Increasing the City's share of associates degree holders from 8.4% to 10.7%, therefore, would result in an additional $28,606,500 in new income being generated in Buffalo every year. The place to build is the City Campus.

    * The American Association of Community Colleges reports more than 50% of all health sciences workers in the United States receive their training at community colleges. The Buffalo Niagara Medical Campus is and will continue to be the source of the vast majority of the region's new health sciences jobs. Does it continue to make sense to locate most nursing spots and all dental hygiene, dental assisting, health information technology, medical office assistant, ophthalmic dispensing, respiratory care, dietetic technology, and bio-manufacturing spots at ECC's North Campus rather than at the doorstep of this growth engine in downtown Buffalo? Keeping ECC's allied health programs in Amherst does not help grow the Buffalo Niagara Medical Campus. The place to build is the City Campus.

Establishing a stronger relationship between ECC and the Buffalo Niagara Medical Campus will be vital to making the region's health sciences sector more competitive while ensuring an equal sharing of its blessings. To increase access to a quality education, bridge the degree attainment gap, and prepare the region's young people for the jobs of tomorrow, ECC must refocus its allied health programs to its transit-friendly City Campus, not at its car-dependent location miles away from job and internship linkages.

This opportunity must be seized. We believe refocusing ECC's proposed $30 million Health Sciences Center for Excellence to downtown Buffalo can generate the buy-in and consensus needed to move this project forward. ECC's 2007 plan is the most realistic, achievable, and inspiring. It can be done, and we'd glad to support it.

Young Citizens for ECC believes the potential of the City Campus to re-brand the college and attract top talent is vast and largely untapped. People want to be back in urban settings. The momentum is moving cityward. Let's get it right. The place to build is the City Campus.

View image

Comments

Leave a comment

My question to the board of trustees: What happened between 2007 where everyone was on board with the city plan and today? Have they addressed that question? Something seems really fishy about the whole entire North Campus proposal. Thank you Young Citizens for ECC on standing up for the right thing!

Score: 8 ( 14 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Good speech, but it doesn't offer solid imperical data that shows how the school will benefit more from a larger city campus as opposed to a larger north town campus. It only shows how the city and the region will benefit. I hope there was more data to back up the speech...because seeing how the school decided to still put the new medical building out in the suburbs even with prior knowledge of the growing medical campus downtown, I have a feeling that they don't care.

Score: 0 ( 8 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

"Young Citizens for ECC points to the college's 2007 proposal, which would have consolidated ECC's allied health programs to its City Campus"

I asked (without reply if I'm not mistaken) in a comment to the previous BR article for a reference or link to the 2007 document.

Ideally it would be informative to see the full text of that - or if full text isn't available then at least maybe a news report about it at the time or anything at all like that.

Now this article calls it a 'proposal' not a plan - don't know if that's meant as a synonym for plan, or if it means a proposal is less detailed than a full plan?

One big thing that did change at the end of 2007 was Giambra leaving office and the primary voters of both parties had elected county exec candidates (Collins & Keane) who both opposed Giambra's goal of consolidating all 3 campuses of ECC into the city. Erie County legislature elections have never elected majorities favoring ECC city consolidation. That's a major reason why Giambra never made real progress on it. Elections have consequences.

I don't know if any of that's a factor about consolidating all health courses - but being able to see the full "2007 proposal" might objectively help enlighten about this.

And was it intended to be a binding fully thought out decision or just a topic for consideration, or something in between?

Score: 0 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Interesting. Still nobody from Bernice's group of citizens, or BR, or anyone on that side of the argument will share more specifics about the 2007 'proposal' or 'plan' or whatever it was that we're told was so important?

No links to anything about it? No scan of it posted here if they have only a paper copy?
Everybody should just accept their word about what it said?

replied to whatever
Score: -2 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Hey, they're all purposely withholding it from you because they know you can't live without a constant data flow. If I had it, I'd give it to you. Hope you don't crack under the strain.

replied to whatever
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Haha, no strain Paul - all in good fun as always...

It's just odd they won't share it this time or previous, yet *they* keep making a big deal about the 07 thing like it's secular gospel and the ECC board is sinning by not following what it supposedly said back then (see article's headline above).

Funny how 'data' is demanded by opponents of GLF demo and you don't whine about that demand. Nor any complaints when when SadLlama in first comment here demands what you'd call 'data' from ECC board about why they allegedly didn't obey the 07 thing...
yet apparently it bugs you for me to point out what I did.
[shrug]

replied to PaulBuffalo
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Whatever>" Everybody should just accept their word about what it said?"

Don't you think if the 07 plan-proposal did not exist, that this would be brought up in this story, the BN article, or the meeting itself? I think if the young citizens side based their argument on a non existent plan-proposal, the status quo side would call them on it.

Not saying people should be taken purely on their word but the lack of protest from those with vested interests in the N campus site may be an indicator that the plan-proposal in question is legit.

replied to whatever
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Arm, nowhere did I say it didn't exist.

I asked why the YC's who are figuratively (maybe literally too) hand-waving it around as such a big deal won't just publicly post it for all to see instead of just paraphrasing it in a few words.

Yeah, them not doing that makes me skeptical about their paraphrasing, but who knows - they might be objective and accurate about it, or not.

I'd bet you'd make the same point (and without you-know-who complaining about too much data, lol) if for example the PBA or DOT or Carl Paladino kept saying a 2007 doc was super-meaningful about something but wouldn't even show it.

replied to Armchair MBA
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

This is a very smart person.

Score: 2 ( 8 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Bernice makes a lot of sense. She could have made many other points as well, including the many Community Colleges that are expanding in urban areas, including the huge new campus in New Haven.

Score: 0 ( 6 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Why is Quinn even in charge still?????? Time to get a younger more 'WITH IT' person in charge. Move DOWNTOWN where people actually want to be!!!!!!

Score: 0 ( 10 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

This was also discussed a bit at an event I was at this evening -- judging from reactions I think it safe to say everyone present was solidly behind the downtown campus plan.

Way to go, Bernice!

Score: 2 ( 8 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Great presentation Bernice but, I'm sorry, all in vain according to the Buffalo News this morning.

http://www.buffalonews.com/city/article472828.ece

Score: -1 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Will appeasement work? Seems like promises ECC won't keep.

Of course, it would have been nice if public discussion was possible. In the meeting, it was asked if there would be public discussion following Bernice's statement. It was responded with a simple "No" by the chairwoman, and the meeting continued.

replied to john.straubinger
Score: -2 ( 4 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

thank you Bernice for a wonderful speech but where are the men who are class leaders

why does it seem like boys are growing up to be emasculated followers behind female leadership. Has feminism gone that far or have boys been ignored and marginalized so long that no one sees what is happening.

Score: -7 ( 7 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

The comments on the Buffalo New article infuriate me. I don't want to hear one more person complain about parking downtown. Do you know how much parking sucks in Denver and Chicago? It doesn't stop people from going to a place. If the Health Sciences Center was built close to BNMC, there is plenty of parking. Agreements can be made, etc...

Score: 3 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Leave a comment

Buffalo Rising Poll