City June 1, 2011 8:51 AM

5 Cool Cities You're Not Moving To... yet.

5 Cool Cities You’re Not Moving To... yet.
With 352 Facebook shares and 11 Tweets, comprised of some haters and some lovers, The Street (digital financial media company) sent Buffalo some props last week, stating that although this city's population may not be rebounding (yet), there are plenty of reasons for residents to be happy. It was of special interest to me that the short article focused partially on quality of life for young Buffalonians, because over the weekend I ran into a bunch of enterprising youth in the Fargo Estates neighborhood who were in the midst of planting a garden next to yet another newly restored residence.

The motivated group of Westsiders clued me in to all of the neighborhood happenings, including which houses were being rehabbed, who was buying on the street, what was going on at the moment, and what was in store. Their combined energy and enthusiasm coincided with much of what The Street writer Jason Notte liked about Buffalo including, "Thriving art scene with more than 50 art museums and galleries and two festivals -- the Allentown Art Festival and the Elmwood Festival For The Arts -- a system of 20 parks designed by Frederick Law Olmsted, a smattering of music venues and a ton of bars and clubs on West Chippewa Street and in Allentown that are open until 4 a.m. It's so deceptively cool that Forbes put it at No. 18 on its list of the Top 40 towns for singles, ahead of Las Vegas and Miami, but even cooler is that its 7.6% unemployment rate is well below the national and allows more of its residents to see what the other cities are missing."

Also check out Frits Abel's (Buffalo Expat Network) comment at the end of the article, which reads, "I have been away from Buffalo for 20 years, and have lived in first-rate cities. I absolutely love what is happening in Buffalo, which, admittedly, started on a long descent 50+ years ago, but is finally on an undeniable ascent. Young, creative and eager folks see this city, and others like it (Pitts, Cleveland, Detroit, etc.) as a canvas on which to re-invent city living: green, diverse, new industry, mobility, affordability, etc. Are there challenges? Absolutely. Leadership has been terrible, and there has been too little opportunity for the "masses". However, there is hope and reinvention in the air...which goes a long way. And, in Buffalo's case we have some key assets: proximity to Toronto, fresh water, tough winters but gorgeous spring-fall, a generous and kind populace, etc."

With people like the Fargo Estate residents and Frits investing time and money into neighborhoods along the West Side, I'm guessing that In five years the title of another article might read, "5 Cool Cities You're Moving Back To."
 
View image

Comments

Leave a comment

This is why some of us were disappointed with the Buffalo For Real campaign, Buffalo does have a ton to offer but we don't market ourselves very well.

Score: 9 ( 9 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Its amazing how the haters feel the need to trash Buffalo so vehemently.

Score: 6 ( 8 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I've never gotten that either, especially from some of the Toronto media. I mean haven't these people ever been to N. Falls, NY? Using Buffalo as a punchline is simply too easy for the insipid and uninspired.

replied to STEEL
Score: 5 ( 7 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Agreed. It seems too many people want to constantly cry about what our region isn't rather than do something to build off of what the area already is.

replied to STEEL
Score: 3 ( 7 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

It's called an inferiority complex. Those folks are unhappy no matter where they are and feel it necessary to act like they're cooler or better than people who embrace their roots or who make a conscious decision to live in Buffalo. The joke is on them if they want to live in a city like Miami or LA and pay 5 times as much for housing or basic neccessities.

replied to STEEL
Score: 1 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I think the one, former Buffalonian's, comments should be noted-many people do feel that way, unfortunately. It is different to have hateful comments from outsiders, who have never spent time in Buffalo...but to hear it from someone who lived here for many years is disconcerting.

Score: 0 ( 6 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

The benefits of Buffalo can no longer be ignored. I have lived in four major cities in the USA and I fought to return to Buffalo because of the quality of life, cost of living, very, very stable real estate market and the excellent arts, sports and food scene. People who knock Buffalo have usually never been here before. And I want to tell you, the winters here are not bad at all compared with other cities like Minneapolis-St. Paul and Chicago. Seriously, has anyone ever been to Chicago in January? Have you ever had to plug in your electric oil dip-stick in your car so it would start the next morning in Minneapolis? Ever have your home drop in value to $150,000 when you paid $309,000 for it in Las Vegas where one in every four homes is in some form of foreclosure? Think about it. Buffalo is great and if you absolutely must have world-class amenities Toronto is only 45 miles due north. I love boasting to others that I can leave the United States in five minutes. Going to lunch in another country is routine in Buffalo...Kind of like Europe. So I am not at all concerned about the direction this city is taking because it’s going up. Part of the problem may be our own self image. If I'm at a party and people start trashing Buffalo, I walk away. I'm no longer compelled to defend this town because it doesn’t need it and the benefits of life in Buffalo are now too obvious. For you residents of metro Buffalo who take shots at our fair city shame on you. Stand up for your city. Don’t buy in to all the negativity. Be brave, be bold, stand up for this city. And if you don’t believe me, move away for a while then return. You’ll see like I did.

Score: 19 ( 23 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I agree with most of what you said, and I like your enthusiasm for Buffalo. But you must not go to Toronto very often if you think it's only 45 minutes away.

replied to DOC
Score: 1 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Correction: You said 45 miles, not 45 minutes. Still there are 98 miles between the two cities, so they're close but not THAT close.

replied to NBuffguy
Score: 1 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Right on DOC. I laughed when I read your comments, because I left Buffalo three years ago and moved to Minneapolis. Everything you said about the Twin Cities is true.

The winters here will make you appreciate the comparatively balmy winters of Western New York. Real Estate prices here are laughable, considering the available housing stock. That $200K Elmwood Village house will cost you up $450K here in a comparable neighborhood. Buying a house here would have been a fool's errand.

I recently got the opportunity to come back to Buffalo to work with a new company, so I'm returning to WNY for good next summer. For all of the reasons you mention, and more.

replied to DOC
Score: 6 ( 10 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Actually as the "crow flies" Toronto is close to 45 miles away. Around the goden horeshoe is about 90

Score: 2 ( 4 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

True. But most of us don't travel as the crow does.

replied to r-k-tekt
Score: 2 ( 4 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I worked with a collegue from Boston recently (in Buffalo) and he just could not get over the beauty of Buffalo, the activity in the parks, how nice the people are, the restuarants, colleges, museums and architecture. I kid you not he said he would move in a second if he could.

Score: 8 ( 8 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

This is a fascinating topic and will provide ample fodder for many a debate. After travelling much of the world, living in four countries, and doing much the same domestically. I'm impressed with not only the city's potential, but also what I see on a grassroots level. There's an unmistakeable drive and passion to build on an incredible foundation, which is unique unto the city.

What will be interesting and critical for the next step in Buffalo's rebirth is the need for fundamental change in city politics. Business as usual will give you what you've always had; And, that is exactly what we don't need. I'm hopeful that the vision and passion evident in resurgent neighborhoods finds a way to displace the "old guard", which is thwarting significant change and innovative thinking.

Score: 7 ( 7 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Amen. I am actually a bit concerned that Buffalo WILL become hot, and what has made it wonderful and authentic (architecture, neighborhoods, etc.) will be under attack by development and won't be safeguarded by politicians who lack progressive thinking. Hopefully, the Green Code will enable Buffalo to preserve itself a la Portland.

replied to RetroGrouch
Score: 2 ( 6 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

@Travelrr - You just keep waiting for the city fairy to sprinkle her magic fairy dust to make all those old buildings stay up without occupants. In the meantime I'll be waiting for new businesses, new buildings, and new developments that bring in new people to the city. This is what Buffalo needs more than a living museum of vacant and dilapidated buildings that once looked good.

replied to Travelrrr
Score: -3 ( 9 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Who ever said anything about not encouraging inhabitants, businesses, etc. for our great building stock? That was your extrapolation. Of course we need more critical mass in our urban core-just don't make it look like East Amherst in the process.

replied to bobbycat
Score: 3 ( 7 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Better to look like Baghdad than East Amherst, is that it?

replied to Travelrrr
Score: 0 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Bobbycat, I'm not sure if the city fairy is responsible for this but someone has rehabbed countless old city buildings which have attracted residents and businesses, many of which came from outside the city.

In Downtown alone their are several retrofitted buildings housing apartments and office space with more on the drawing board. This happened in spite of protests from "realists" who made similar claims that nobody would pay top dollar to live or work in this environment.

New buildings that incorporate the existing urban fabric are great but they should coexist with the old.

replied to bobbycat
Score: 3 ( 5 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Twenty -five years ago Toronto was building their arts culture; young people with fresh ideas. Just about everything was turned into an art subject. We attended a multimedia art extravaganza celebrating the fiddle head fern. Of course the chefs prepared food with fiddle heads but also a big band orchestra composed songs in swing mode about fiddle heads while a fiddle head movie played and women in artful fiddle head hats paraded around. At the time I thought it a little weird but it drew crowds. Now I see the the point, when everyone puts their shoulder to the wheel great things can be done. I do now hear some grumblings from those early artists about how the big money that moved in is spoiling things. But Buffalo has to go that route to find out. I do think the Buffalo city administration here is willing to change things to respond to peoples demands. Thumbs up on that.

Score: 1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

It seems there has been a preoccupation of buffalo's potential ala "how can we get people to move here." Or an endless quest for external validation whether it be a Forbes article or some other insipid source. How about Buffalo for Buffalonians? screw marketing..we know what s good here

Score: 8 ( 10 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Nice article and a really thoughtful and inspiring quotation from Frits Abel. But I wish we could drop the blurry high school word "cool" from our vocabulary, especially when talking about the complex chemistry that makes cities like Buffalo beautiful and satisfying places to live.

We might also be wary of over-emphasizing youth in the attributes of a city. Diversity also means age spectrum, and being young does not reflexively mean being creative and inspired. The most interesting and fascinating people I know in Buffalo are much older than I am; their vision, blending history and hope, is often the most profound and most wise.

Score: 2 ( 8 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

That was cool, Eric.

replied to EricOak
Score: 2 ( 8 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

glad to see your byline, eric oak. missed you.

replied to EricOak
Score: -1 ( 7 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I know that I will get bashed for this, but it is par for many of the personalities on this website. I am a born & bred Buffalonian. I lived here until I was 23 yrs old and have spent the last number of years living elsewhere. We decided to move back here after living in many metropolitan cities. We are leaving after only a short time here. I was some how hoping that things were better here. I have been shocked at what has become of this city. There is graffiti EVERYWHERE, more and more vacant buildings and businesses, and a general feeling of uneasiness. I wish I was writing how great I think it is here. I wish I had seen a local government that gets things done. I wish the waterfront was what it should be. I wish that Buffalo had become the great city that it could be.

Score: 0 ( 4 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

No bashing here; I can appreciate your position. I'm ambivalent as well. Some days the city really jazzes me; other days, I'm packing my gear and heading back to the pacific northwest. Odds are, I'm heading back west... that said, I'll hold onto great memories and speak fondly of the area.

replied to buffalowhatever
Score: 0 ( 6 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Wishing doesn't make things come true. Hard work does. Anyone can go to a city that other people worked hard to make great. Stay here and make your own mark. Thats how you make a place great.

replied to buffalowhatever
Score: 10 ( 12 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

So TRUE!!! I wish more locals here would stop complaining and actually DO SOMETHING to make it better. If you don't like something, DO SOMETHING about it!! Otherwise don't say nothing, because your allowing what ever you don't like to carry on by not taking action.
In relation to the story. I think Buffalo is a great city. I see the changes and life coming back to many areas that were once quiet.

replied to Penn Station
Score: 2 ( 4 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

No bashing here either. I also moved back and gave it my all for 4 years and then left again. A few things are happening here and there but over all I felt it was on a downward spiral and visually/mentally depressing at almost every turn. We spent a small fortune renovating the home of our dreams, but a house is not enough. If it was not for the heart of Elmwood village what a grey city it would be. I am happy to see the likes of Pegs Park and the Avante along with start up company's such as the English meat pie Company, but sometimes it's to little, to late.

replied to buffalowhatever
Score: -2 ( 8 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Did you tap the cultural blood of the city? The philharmonic, the chamber music, the galleries, the theaters, the innumerable smaller arts movements? If you did, I'm not sure how you could have felt mentally depressed at every turn. And if you felt visually depressed in Buffalo, the problem may lie in your lenses.

replied to onestarmartin
Score: 5 ( 5 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

buffalowhatever>"graffiti EVERYWHERE, more and more vacant buildings and businesses, and a general feeling of uneasiness"

I'm no cheerleader so I won't bash you either, but those criticisms seem based on unrealistic standards.

Are you saying compared to similar cities in this region of the U.S. you think there's more graffiti here and more 'uneasiness' here?
I doubt that's true. Graffiti and uneasiness are very common in a lot of places.

Regarding vacancy, yes Buffalo's percent of vacant housing is above average, but a lot of it is a consequence of having had nearly 600,000 people 60 years ago. Yeah, it will be a positive when a lot more of the won't-be-saved vacant houses are removed. This current mayor has smartly made it a higher priority than his predecessor did, but much remains to be done.

How could any city drop from 580,000 to 260,000 residents over 60 years and not have a lot of empty buildings at that point?

replied to buffalowhatever
Score: 2 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

There's graffiti all over Venice too.

replied to buffalowhatever
Score: 5 ( 5 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I am from Toronto; with traffic takes 90 minutes to Buffalo; and yes I believe Buffalo is on it's way up. I visit the city often and amazed by the continued progression in renovation of those beautiful homes in conjunction with the improvements in the neighborhoods; some feel almost Norman Rockwell, something which just can feel or attain up here. I have been visiting the city since the 80's and have always been enamored by the incredible inventory of architecture which quite possibly has benefited by the economic stagnation of your fair city which is now a blossoming renaissance of gentrification .Buffalo in some sense reminds of the Toronto of 40 years but with a more genteel and faded charm making it authentically more alluring than my somewhat contrived but urbanesque Toronto. Buffalo now and in the next few years will be a city to watch!

Score: 5 ( 5 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

A near perfect rendering of the city...thanks!

replied to defender110
Score: 2 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I couldn't care less what outsiders think of Buffalo. I like it here, I've made a decent life, and I can live at my own pace. It's relaxing, and I have a higher quality of life than any other city I've lived in.

Screw the outsiders...more space for us!

Score: 10 ( 10 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Hard to believe that my home is on its way up, when people get their brains blown out within 400 feet of my home & while I can see and hear that. Or are we thinking that the West Side is not becoming totally infested with drug gangs, shootings, and vermin from the East Side? I live here, and I know what I see - Buffalo still has a long way DOWN to go. Yes, it's "cheap" compared to the suburbs - I'd need to come up with over $100 more per week, to pay the taxes in a decent place like Amherst, Clarence, or even North Tonawanda. Avoiding one's own brains shot-out might be worth that much, yes? Oh, but then I'd "miss" the "VIBRANT!" qualities of the Elmwood Strip, where I've been mugged at gunpoint. Yeah, babble on, stoners.

Score: -2 ( 14 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

After living in Brooklyn, I do declare that Buffalo has a WAY better quality of life! It just does. We're New York state's best-kept secret. And I'm okay with keeping it the secret because that's how I was able to buy a gorgeous Arts and Crafts house in an urban (but leafy and family-oriented) neighborhood for $115k. And I've never been shot at. Imagine that.

Score: 11 ( 11 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Be careful what you wish for. When and if any significant upturn occurs, everything will change. Everything.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Leave a comment

Buffalo Rising Poll