City February 8, 2011 1:00 PM

Subcommittees Make Recommendations to Erie Canal Harbor Board

Subcommittees Make Recommendations to Erie Canal Harbor Board

The Erie Canal Harbor Development Corporation's (ECHDC) Board of Directors received initial reports this morning from the three subcommittees charged with initiating activity on Buffalo's waterfront this summer. The committees are: Historic District (Jordan Levy, chair), Outer Harbor (David Colligan, chair), and Buffalo River (Julie Barrett O'Neill, chair.) ECHDC Chairman Jordan Levy called for the creation of the subcommittees after an intense period of public input that included six "Open House" style meetings, a public hearing and hundreds of comments from the community.

Chairman Jordan Levy's Historic District committee recommends the opening of a café on the ground floor of the Naval Museum. In addition, the committee encourages a variety of food vendors on the southern portion of the Central Wharf. Bathroom and shower facilities will be constructed for boaters using the docks. The committee is also studying the feasibility of laying down a temporary asphalt bike lane in order to connect the Central Wharf with the existing bike trail that extends behind the DL&W building and down to Festival Park. Long term plans for the district call for a mixed use neighborhood that is connected and integrated with downtown Buffalo and incorporates commercial, residential and cultural uses. The committee includes developers, preservationists and event planners.

DSC_0671e.JPG"This is the place where Buffalo began, and its reinvigoration will be the key to our future," said Levy. "This area has already made great strides with the opening of the Commercial Slip and the Central Wharf, as well as our successful summer programming. We are going to build on that success with expanded programs, food and facilities."

Board member David Colligan leads the Outer Harbor committee, which brings together entrepreneurs, landscape architects, outdoor enthusiasts, and urban planners. Plans under consideration for the Outer Harbor include the creation of Lakefront Meadows Park, a sand covered Gallagher Beach, opportunities for vendors, establishing a water taxi to the Inner Harbor, and improving the existing infrastructure of docks and breakwalls.

"What makes the Outer Harbor so exciting are the almost limitless possibilities that it presents," said Colligan. "We have the ability to create quality greenspace, increase facilities for boaters, and create opportunities for small businesses - and that's just the beginning."

The Buffalo River subcommittee is headed by newly appointed board member and Executive Director of Buffalo Niagara RIVERKEEPER, Julie Barrett O'Neill. Short term plans will focus on providing support to activities and projects already underway in this bustling corridor. She emphasized the need for branding and marketing, trail connections and heritage interpretation, grain elevator revitalization, activities and programming and bridge interpretation.

"The Buffalo River is the natural connection between the Historic District and the Outer Harbor. What distinguishes this area is the fact that it is a real neighborhood, filled with people who are already working hard to create a vibrant place. Branding this area will help to establish it as a unique destination in the minds of Western New Yorkers and will buttress the work already being done by the residents of the district. In addition, we are looking at ways to improve the signage and wayfinding materials. Finally, looking towards the long term, we are going to convene a meeting of all of the grain elevator owners on the river. These structures will loom large in any long range planning, and dialogue among their owners is essential."

ECHDC President Thomas P. Dee noted that the Cultural subcommittee has received over 45 applications from groups that are interested in participating in programming at Canal Side this summer. He stressed that once that once the Board of Directors has evaluated the ideas from the subcommittees and made recommendations, the staff of ECHDC will work quickly to implement them.

View image

Comments

Leave a comment

Interesting news. I like hearing that the unused potential of the Outer Harbor is beginning to be explored. I also think opening a cafe in the Historic Area is a step in the right direction although I say good luck trying to get any design approved for a new building (bathroom and shower facility) unless it is built to the EXCAT specifications of a building that sat along the water in 1850.

In all seriousness, it is certianly a step in the right direction. Enough with the artist renderings of wonderful proposals that are utimately tied up or killed with red tape. Start small and get the ball rolling to show retailers and restaurants that this location will be a great one to exapand to.

Score: 3 ( 7 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

If you look at the first picture, it is amazing to think of the city without highways choking the waterfront. Looking just above the Commercial Slip sign you can stare directly into downtown yet it feels so removed. I guess it's a good thing we still have those freeways with all the progress they brought Buffalo since the 1950s...i think the city would be half the size without them.

Score: -9 ( 11 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I don't know why but when I read this article two words popped into my head - lame and Hooterville.

Score: -8 ( 14 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I couldn't have said it better!

replied to Sally
Score: -3 ( 7 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

"To many chefs in the kitchen ruins the soup!"

replied to Sally
Score: 3 ( 5 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

All steps in the right direction! These small incremental changes like linking things temporarily until final implementation, branding and marketing, trail connections and heritage interpretation, grain elevator revitalization, activities and programming and bridge interpretation and the concept of FOOD in a place to draw and keep people! All no-brainers and good moves!

Thank you BR for mentioning Landscape Architects in the article!

Score: 3 ( 9 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I think things are looking pretty good down there. I like the progress. I would love to see a Buffalo Childrens' Museum at the Harbor. We really need to draw families downtown. A Childrens' Museum would be unique to the region (which means it will draw people from all western NY and southern ON.) People could afford going to it and schools could use it. But I think a big plus for it is to get the next generation familiar with coming into the City and enjoying it. If the kids of this generation get a positive experience of being downtown, that will carry with them as they grow into adults.

Score: -1 ( 7 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

If you want to go to a Children's Museum head down to the Thruway and hour and you will arrive at the second largest in the nation, the fully funded Strong Museum. Buffalo does not have the resouces to compete with the Strong and should not even try. If you want to attract visitors from a wider circle to not make poor representations of what they have far superior versions of - it will just fail.

replied to ranjekna
Score: 2 ( 4 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

How many of the families living in Buffalo go to Rochester often? I have a membership to the Strong Museum, and I can't make the trip as often as I like. They get a great deal of their funding from corporate sponsorship. Why couldn't we? I could see a museum/science center highlighting Buffalo's history, hydroelectric power and contributions. I think we need to focus on drawing people from Western New York downtown. It could just be a piece in the puzzle.

replied to Sally
Score: 0 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Everyday it is becoming more clear to me that Jordan Levy cant handle this at all and it is becoming more of a sh** show with nothing much happening at all....We still have ugly fences and empty buildings and big pits with nothing in them....It will look like this in 3 years from now as well.....

Score: -1 ( 5 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I agree with 50% of your statement jjcefa. It is beyond frustrating to see little progress being made while all of these shovel ready sites sit idle. However, everytime a plan is announced or set for approval a group steps forward and says that it cannot continue.

At some point the obsrtuctionists, whether they are trying to preserve every minute historical detail or pushing for a big-box mega attraction, need to realize that by dragging their feet in the mud they are doing nothing but halting progress for everyone. Ironic one of these groups is called a campaign for a greater Buffalo but they have done nothing but keep things from moving forward.

It is high time that things start moving forward towards a permanent solution. Tent cities and temporary attractions will not build the type of waterfront we want and have envisioned.

replied to jjcefa
Score: 3 ( 5 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

........the only thing you will get is a flee market by the water.

replied to ozzyop33
Score: 2 ( 4 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

All too correct Burch. The way things are progressing you will see temporary structures put up in the summer so people can sell knockoff Bills and Sabres t-shirts.

You hear grumblings that Dinosaur BBQ could be put on the water and if you were to put something like that down there and pair it with a set up like Crocker Park or Legacy Village in Cleveland - in period buildings, of course - you could start building a retail/entertainment district that would positively impact the arena and draw people year-round.

replied to KangDangaLang
Score: 1 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I dont mean to pick on Jordan Levy entirely,because all in all it is the groups that impede the progress...I just dont think he has the balls and command to direct these idiot groups;(preservationists and so on); to do what he wants. I have no idea who does have the savvy but its not him...
I definitely understand why some of these groups were formed but taking it a little too far is killing everyones hopes

replied to ozzyop33
Score: 0 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I hear you on that one. If there was a single body to make decisions in regards to development I would imagine we would be a few steps ahead of where we are now. Instead, we have four different groups working "together" towards a common goal. The only problem is that each group has a different goal that has the same name "waterfront development".

Perhaps Levy isn't the man for the job. Perhaps if he had control over the ECHDC and didn't have to worry about working alongside other agencies there would be more progress made. It seems like it has become a too many rods in the fire situation pertaining to who is making decisions and who can effect the decisions being made.

replied to jjcefa
Score: 1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I'm with ozzzy, I am interested to see if there any plans for "spec. space" (I think thats what they call it). Its done all the time in the burbs with smaller strip plazas, they build first and wait for leases 2nd.

Couldn't you start off with a few smaller buildings/collections of buildings (period) that offer small floor plans for restaurants/bars/fake tshirt sellers maybe even apartments or something first?

(legacy village in cleveland is real nice, great mix of dining/retail in my opinion)

Thus getting something accomplished and adding some life to the area while the rest of the plan is getting worked out. I know you need anchors, but you'd have to be a huge dummy to not realize that these small spec. buildings would fill quickly. Thats ignoring the fact that this is public/private and not just private with todays capital constraints... come on man lets get something going here.

Score: 2 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I think a handful of buildings would really get the ball rolling. Take a look at what Savarino did on Mississippi St. If you put one or two bar/pubs in that area to draw fans before and after Sabres games and you then draw a strong restaurant (Dinosaur), or two, you will have a great foundation to begin drawing visitors off of.

In the winter you would have two additional restaurants and two or three extra bars a stones throw from the arena while you would have the ability to sit out on a patio and watch the water and action in the summer.

Why does it make sense to everyone but the people who are forming the decisions or railing against them?

Score: 1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Leave a comment