City December 12, 2010 8:55 AM

Canal Side Cultural Master Plan Released

Canal Side Cultural Master Plan Released

The Erie Canal Harbor Development Corporation (ECHDC) has unveiled a preliminary report on its Cultural Master Plan for the Canal Side project.  The report is the culmination of the first step of what will ultimately be a three stage process in determining the cultural mix on the Inner Harbor.  Lord Cultural Resources and Ralph Applebaum Associates prepared the report after an intensive period of consultation with ECHDC board members and staff, representatives from Western New York's leading cultural organizations, and almost 150 community members.  The report details the research that they have engaged in, provides an  analysis of the museum and performing arts marketplace, sets forth planning principles and advances some initial ideas or "experiential building blocks" for events and activities at Canal Side.

"This report provides an excellent base on which to build," said Maureen Hurley, chair of the ECHDC Cultural sub-committee. "From the beginning, the board of ECHDC envisioned a strong cultural component at Canal Side, in particular, one that celebrates Buffalo's rich history."

The preliminary report stresses the need to avoid duplication of existing cultural resources and competing with performing arts venues in Downtown Buffalo. Development of cultural programming will be implemented in phases, with Phase 1 beginning this summer. This first phase will expand existing programming opportunities with relatively low-cost public programs, events, festivals and other site features at Canal Side.  During Phase 1, Canal Side itself would become the stage on which to tell the "Story of Buffalo" through a series of activities, performances, tours, festivals and markets, rather than a traditional "bricks and mortar" collections based museum.

Suggestions for the first phase of development, to begin this summer, include the following possibilities:

DSC_0677.JPG• Buffalo Story Trails could provide an entertaining, educational journey on the grand stage of Canal Side. Performers tell the Buffalo Story through a cast of fictional and historic characters from different periods in Buffalo's history.

• A Canal Side Public Market could be an ethnic and local farmer's market that begins in a large tent, celebrating Buffalo's pivotal history as once the world's largest grain port and our region's tradition of diverse ethnic foods.

• Cell-Phone Tours could offer self-guided personal tours throughout Canal Side.

• Festivals on the Canal Side Green could build upon the demonstrated success of the many festivals (over 150 annually) for which Buffalo is already known - some could even make their home at this new central location.

• During the winter season, the Canal Side Green becomes a Winter White Park -- a wonderland of colorfully lit ice sculptures and whimsical snowmen. Action Zones give visitors access to ice hockey and figure skating clinics and competitions, sledding slopes, snow surfing, and ice skating.

The next steps of the planning process will involve reaching out to cultural organizations that have expressed interest in being part of the Canal Side project in any of the three phases of its development. Analysis of and recommendations for the most appropriate cultural partners, and their role in telling the Buffalo Story and attracting audiences to Canal Side will be included in the Stage 2 report.

Next:  Big Ideas for Canal Side

View image

Comments

Leave a comment

It could be a win-win to have many of our current cultural attractions have a presence/piece-of-the pie on the waterfront; it would remain to this council to manage the coordination/programming (which would not be a small feat).

It is not lost on me that many arts groups are about to have their funding cut by the ever-limited Collins, and that the Canal Side build-out could be the olive branch to provide funding for many of these effected groups.

Score: 3 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I wonder if they will charge $5.00 per person to visit when all this is done?

Score: -9 ( 15 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

If you want quality cultural tourism, if you want visitors from all over the country and world, if you want a steady funding source, if you want outside resources, if you want good paying jobs - you need the National Park Service to be there.

Its the difference between an ESPN zone, and a corner bar.

Score: 7 ( 13 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I've been to many well-done cultural museums of all genres that were not operated by the NPS; so they are not required to get a quality experience. What the NPS will require, though, is an admission fee. That is on top of all of their funding already coming from our tax dollars.

For this site, a museum that tells our, and the canals', story should be free. Use the public money to create a public attraction. Allow for fees or other on-site revenue generators to support the operation of the canal museum.

That may be a bit idealistic but I feel that for the amount of public money put into this development, the public ought to get access to not just some infrastructure, but one tangible asset that showcases what was largely responsible for Buffalo's rise to prominence.

replied to al labruna
Score: 2 ( 6 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I havent been to too many free museums outside of DC or Europe. Actually, I havent been to any. Considering how the County's cultural budget has just been slashed, Im not sure how you pay for your unspecified other alternatives - let alone one that is free of taxpayer subsidy at some level.

As far as the Park Service being necessary for a quality experience - well of course. However, I have been to a number of pretty weak locally operated museums, I have never been to a weak NPS site. In any case, its the Park Service arrowhead that draws in out of town visitors, not Joe's Erie Canal Museum and Poorly Interpreted Chotchy Emporium.

replied to bflorox
Score: 4 ( 6 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I believe the National Park Service already runs the Erie Canal Museum in Syracuse. That museum has been open since the early 60s.

replied to al labruna
Score: 3 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I believe the Erie Canal museum in Syr is not an NPS run site, although some affiliation does exist. One can get an NPS passport stamped there, but there are no "rangers" or the other trappings of a federally administered site.

replied to sho'nuff
Score: 1 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

You are correct, it looks like the National Park Service has put together the Erie Canal way National Historic Corridor, and they do operate a few sites along this corridor, but they don't actually operate any of the many Erie Canal museums.

Here is a link to the various museums and points of interest on the NPS ECWNHC.

http://www.eriecanalway.org/get-involved_passport.htm

The National Park Service operates 25 sites in NY State. I looked into their requirements, and we would have to sign over the rights to the land and buildings to the National Park Service in order to get them involved.

http://www.eriecanalway.org/get-involved_passport.htm

replied to al labruna
Score: 2 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

sho'nuff - of course it doesnt necessarily require much land to build a museum.

replied to sho'nuff
Score: 2 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Al - You are probably right. I really have a difficult time getting excited about the waterfront because I have been listening to the same ideas and seeing very little happen. I've heard the same ideas bantered around since probably 1978. Sure, there has been some development, but it took us far too long and cost us far too much, to justify what we actually got.

I feel like the ECHDC, NFTA, and City of Buffalo have starved us for so long that we feel that the stale crust they threw to us is a veritable feast. We should be able to expect so much more, but unfortunately our expectations have lowered to the point that a market on folding tables under a temporary tent is seen as a major breakthrough.

I have lost faith in this project and don't believe that Buffalo has the leadership required to make anything substantial happen. We can dream about building a waterfront destination, but our lack of leadership will leave us with a fly by night flea market on rebuilt cobblestone streets.

replied to al labruna
Score: 1 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Authentic canals and an impressive museum to showcase their significance that are accessible without a cover charge would provide the cornerstone for regular and significant foot traffic. Entertainment, dining, retail, hotel and parking establishments that set up shop within the CanalSide footprint to primarily cater to that foot traffic could support the museum with a percentage of their proceeds. More traffic = more businesses = more support = more traffic...

It's funny you used the term "Chotchy Emporium" because that's, unfortunately, what I remember most about the NPS's Gateway Arch site. It felt like more space was dedicated to "retail" than the story of westward expansion.

I really don't care if the NPS is involved or not. I just feel that, at this particular site with all the public money that's being thrown around, the centerpiece of it all should be free for all to enjoy.

replied to al labruna
Score: 1 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

further, there are free NPS Sites. Check out Women's Rights.

replied to bflorox
Score: 1 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Well it seems that the Naval park just lost $20,000 in funding while politicians claim it is time for the park to stand on its own. Do not expect another "Historic" idea to much different.

replied to bflorox
Score: 1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

The NPS is like a franchise, and not in a good way. I believe they even have the same actor for all their pre-recorded presentations. I'd rather have more creativity.

replied to al labruna
Score: 2 ( 4 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Dagner please explain: How do you want to make history more creative? Video podcasts? NPS does it. Living History? NPS does it. Virtual museums? NPS does it. Canal boat rides? NPS does it. Walking tours? NPS does it.

Youre concerned about voice overs from orientation films (which arent really used much anymore)? Is that a real museum critique?

replied to Dagner
Score: 2 ( 4 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I want to AVOID pre-recorded presentations. As far as not being used much anymore, have YOU been to the Teddy Roosevelt site? The well-meaning "docent" presses a button which gives the presentation. Its one of the few Buffalo locations I don't encourage visitors and locals to attend.

I've been to many NPS sites around the country. There is a bland, canned, sameness to them. It may be unavoidable when managed by a large central organization.

replied to al labruna
Score: 2 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Just to clarify, you dont really seem to state what you want. You dont like pre-recorded films. Ok, what do you like that the NPS isnt doing somewhere? Further, what arent they doing that a cutting edge museum IS doing that you would want to incorporate?

Further, though you may not like it, NPS sites attract lots of visitation.* Or if you have a alternative that is also self funding (like a federal site), Id like to hear that too. Cause I dont think this County Exec will fund a new nonprofit.


*See http://www.nature.nps.gov/stats/viewReport.cfm

replied to Dagner
Score: -2 ( 4 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I simply do not understand why so much attention and focus is being given to the historic aspect of the waterfront. If someone wants to learn of the history of Buffalo or its waterfront they go online, buy a book or go on youtube and watch a video about the history of Buffalo. This is 2011 and we need 2050 ideas to bring in a new age. Does anyone think that a historic walk down the waterfront via cellphone tour is much better than just reading or watching a video? Do you think any of these ideas would draw tourism? I do not.

The focus in my opinion needs not to be on the historic rise and fall of centuries past but rather on building a bright new future for Buffalo. I am really very bored with all of these suggestions and agree with you Al Labruna that national park involvement would make a huge difference. Ive said it once and I will repeat myself once again. The city of Buffalo needs a draw for large scale tourism that is self perpetuating with the possibility of offering exponential growth.

The way I see it as it stands is that some brainless politicians hired an incompetent consulting firm to sell us their own dull ideas rather than listening to what the people want. I want big, I want bold, I want the FUTURE of Buffalo to be as bright as its past rather than just focusing on the past. Its easy to be a historian its difficult to be a futurist. We must not settle on dwelling in the past. It is unappealing and does nothing for the future. I have suggested in the past that art, architecture and interactive opportunities offer the greatest draw in my opinion.

Please lets leave the past in the past and move on!

I do like the ideas of ice hockey in the winter that makes perfect sense.

I do not like the ideas of historic walks, Ice sculptures (which would cost money to maintain)or Performance art (I do enjoy performance art but our politicians choose not to fund it) this idea is void. I simply can not understand how a so called consulting firm is so dull.

replied to al labruna
Score: 4 ( 6 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

With out anything being there, it's a waist of time. All we have right now is a few cobblestone streets, a small canal and one old style building. Not much to draw in big crowds.

Score: -1 ( 5 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I love it! Awesome idea. We lack a public communal area as a city, which is ironic seeing that we take pride as being a city of good neighbors. It will be a long time before the area in front of city hall is more pedestrian friendly and lafayette square isn't big enough. Stop trying to build crappy shops on the land and let Buffalo's rich culture do the work! Not saying that stores shouldnt be allowed near Canalside but do we want a corporate face on a place designated to be the future of Buffalo? I mean Im already imagining the possibilities. We have burmese, somali, iraqi, congolese, and other these pocket ethnic communities just waiting to be displayed on top of our already rich irish, italian, german, african america, and of course polish communities. You could actually keep friends visiting Buffalo IN downtown Buffalo and not have to bring them to Elmwood to show a happening place. Call me a romantic, but this is the best idea Ive heard for Canalside.

Score: 0 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I think it would be nice to be guaranteed a performance of some kind every friday and saturday regardless of season. Doesn't matter who or what, but the guarantee would be nice.

Ethnic groups getting together would be nice. I'd like to see the Italian festival down there or Irish Fest moved there. These groups would be both somewhat near the original location of the Italian and Irish immigrants.

Just an idea though about the ethnic groups. Some groups get a little touchy about that.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Guaranteed performance art every Friday. That sounds familiar.

replied to Greg
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

The farmers market and festivals sound great, snowmen and cell phone tours? Really?

Score: -1 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Is it just me or does most of that crap sound utterly cheesy?

Central planning. Catch the fever!

Score: 3 ( 5 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Its not just you. So far I have not heard any suggestion that anyone is trying for a "home run" with this waterfront project. Every single plan, render and message is so contrived. Its fine that they want some activities for kids and unintellectual seniors. Now what about the rest of us?

I also agree with you that it shows a weakness of central planning.

replied to Jesse
Score: 1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

A historic walk, Really??? Maybe they should have a wrecking ball exhibit and show all the history they've destroyed within the last century. Come on Buffalo, Think out of the box, stop trying to resurrect the Whammy Weenie. At this point its laughable. I can't help that think with our shrinking population, There are people who truly believe in the future of Buffalo, and yet there are people who still drive the delorean trying to go back to 1955. I agree with slowrollin99, stay away from the past, look to the future. The City is better than that, and so is our citizens.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Leave a comment

Buffalo Rising Poll