City November 24, 2010 7:44 AM

Hotel Lafayette Shines

Hotel Lafayette Shines
While The Statler idles on Niagara Square, there is another major hotel project waiting in the wings on Lafayette Square. If developer Rocco Termini's lofty renovation of the historic Hotel Lafayette comes to fruition, downtown will have a stunning, fully operational prized jewel in its midst. A walk through the cavernous first floor and basement reveal room after room of ballrooms, banquet areas, restaurant spaces and bar rooms. We've all seen the historic photos of the grand hotel, filled with countless guests enjoying the modern luxuries of the day - Rocco is looking to bring a similar commercial occupancy to the building, and while he waits for new market tax credits for work to get underway, he's in the process of lining up a series of businesses that are clamoring to sign on the dotted line. That doesn't mean that he's going to wait for the residential work to commence - Rocco told me that the renovation of those units will begin on Monday!

As workers begin to transform the apartments, Rocco will continue to solidify commercial leases in anticipation of that end of the financing moving forward. One of the operators looking to occupy space in is Earl Ketry from the Pearl Street Grill and Brewery. Earl has set his eyes upon the former Lafayette Tap Room, and is planning to take full advantage of the newly uncovered architectural features (photo: previously hidden by drop ceilings) in what is anticipated to be an impressive Earl-esque bar and restaurant. Butterwood Desserts is planning on moving its main operation into the basement of the hotel, where it anticipates to operate a dessert bar in what was, at one time, a speakeasy. Woyshner's Flower Shop has reserved a high visibility corner location within the hotel in a large space just off the front lobby. To top is off, Mike Andrzejewski of SeaBar fame is teaming up with Rocco once again, but this time he's not interested in sushi. Rather he hopes to open a steakhouse called Mike A's... now there's a brand.

It only gets better from there. Besides restoring all of the rooms back to their original state, the functionality and flow of space will be restored. Missing and cut off stairways will be reopened and/or reinstalled. The front desk will be converted into a lavish bar that will serve as overflow for an adjoining bar, showcasing much of the original furniture from back in the day. Not all of the original details will be restored however - much of the art deco add-ons will remain intact to show the work of two different time periods of the city and their effects on the building. Drop ceiling after drop ceiling have been removed, exposing detailed ceilings, buried lighting elements, untouched wood and ornamental skylights. Most of the floors have been preserved under cheap laminate tiles - every day there are new discoveries made as chipped paint is scraped off, carpeting is pulled back and wallpaper is pealed away. The hotel may resemble The Titanic (or the Richardson Towers) now, but with the help of historic photos, the plan is to piece together the inner landscape of what will one day be an astonishing renovation.



To walk through the different floors of the building is to walk through what appears to be the set of The Shining - just take a look at the super wide hallways that take up 25% of the space in the building. I was disappointed to find a shopping cart, not a Big Wheel, abandoned just outside of one of the rooms. Then there's the old Lafayette Bar in the Crystal Ballroom... where's Lloyd?... and the elevators that, when opened, let the imagination run wild with images of... well, you saw The Shining. The extravagance of the eras is telling, and there is a great story to be told once more in the rebirth of the Hotel Lafayette - a landmark that is centrally located within walking distance of City Hall, the Metro Rail, The Central Library and even The Statler. 
View image

Comments

Leave a comment

I may be in the minority here but I like the idea of keeping the art deco elements along with restoration of the original design. To me they are both important and intersting periods of history & architecture that are both worthy of attention in their own right.

Score: 7 ( 9 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

"Much of the art deco will remain intact."

What a jewel this is-truly. And, I glad it wound up in Rocco's, not Carl's, hands. This could be one of the most interest boutique hotels in the country, if carried out well (which Rocco does). This is thrilling.

replied to brownteeth
Score: 3 ( 5 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Unlike Croce and the Statler this is one project that is exciting to see happen. With no Handouts to get the project off the ground. Very well thought out.

Score: -4 ( 16 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I believe the Historic Preservation Tax Credit (and the associated 'fix') do indeed qualify as a taxpayer handout.

replied to tom.wonderful
Score: 8 ( 14 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

You are correct, which I am sure Croce will also be applying for. These developers are not asking for taxpayers to shore up the building, they are starting with their own cash. Big Difference.

replied to freestylethinker
Score: 1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I'm excited to see this underway. Also, saving my money so I can move in once it's completed next year.

Score: 2 ( 4 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Rocco for mayor! Thanks for the awesome slide show.

Score: 0 ( 6 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Wonderful!!!!!! As a neighbor, I welcome this project and the new residents it will bring. I also welcome the people the restaurants and bar(s) will bring. (hopefully over 21). Please soon, I would love a market for grocery shopping. I can get the staples, but look forward to shopping in a store again, and I don't mean a convenience store.

Score: 5 ( 7 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I know! I'd love to see Wegman's get on board and get a space downtown. Seriously, not even asking for Whole Foods or Trader Joe's, just want a grocery store!

replied to downtown resident
Score: 7 ( 9 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

i'm really excited for this project. drop ceilings and painting original woodwork pink?! what were these people thinking? the location, size and importance of this building coming back to life is absolutely wonderful news for downtown. what is the status on am&a's?

Score: 1 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Wegmans coming through with a half or full size store in the downtown area would be a huge victory for the region

hopefully in the next few years we can make the case for why there should be one with all the new residential downtown.

Score: 11 ( 13 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

i've been thinking about this. for wegmans or tops to open a regular or even half size store downtown there must be parking. you don't like it, i don't like it, but that's the way it is. there isn't the density like in europe where you have three grocery stores on every block. that said, the best and most economical situation i can think of is a grocery in main place mall. lots of open, unused space and the underground parking is already there. it would take some investment but it could be done. not like the space is getting much use as it is. plus the draw from a grocery store could bring regular shopping back to downtown. office workers who are already parked the the basement or a few blocks away can do all their shopping at 515 and skip the rush hour traffic home.

the other option is several smaller, european size grocery stores (about the size of the lexington co-op or about 3x bigger than a wilson farms.) something like that carries all the essentials and doesn't have the convenience store mark up. that, probably on main st, could work because it's close to downtown residents and day office workers.

these are my thoughts

replied to jim1234664
Score: 11 ( 13 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Tops recently built a small, city-friendly store on Seneca st with parking. That type of grocery store would be a good fit for downtown.

replied to Andrew
Score: 1 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Wegmans will NEVER do this because Wegmans is the most anti-urban grocery store in America. Just ask someone in the Wegman family what they think of building an urban store and they'll begin talking about how they employ lots of "urban youth" at their Pittsford store and boy does it change those kids' lives.... As a company, they don't quite understand what the word "urban" means (and they have a serious case of the white man's burden, but I digress). Their business model reflects that. Their growth model is massive, upscale suburban stores in affluent suburbs. That's it. And, of course, their business model is working, so they have no impetus to change the way they think. Good for them. But give up on the "downtown Wegmans" bandwagon forever. It's a waste of time. None of us will ever see a small-format, urban Wegmans - ever.

When it comes to urbanity, Tops is far more progressive than Wegmans. I think we'd have better luck trying to land a small-format Walmart grocery store, believe it or not.

replied to jim1234664
Score: -5 ( 11 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

One of the original Wegmans stores is in the city of Rochester on East Ave.
It is one of the busiest Wegmans. They are expanding the store.

There is no comparison between Tops and Wegmans.
Tops is week.

replied to reflip
Score: 4 ( 4 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Do you mean weak? Or am I missing a pun?

The Wegmans pandemonium and cult following is getting old. Real old. It's the Abercrombie & Fitch of grocery stores. They have incredible selection, but their prices are high. I'll shop wherever the deal is, but this fervent obsession with Wegmans is lame-o.

replied to rb09
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

This is great news. While the Statler is in limbo, the redevelopment of some of Buffalo's greatest buildings continues. If Croce really wants to redevelop the Statler, he should team up with Termini to get the ball rolling. He clearly knows what he's doing.

Score: 1 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Main place mall > grocery store is a pretty good idea.

I also wouldnt mind the evil of parking (I mean come on we already have a ton of surface parking dt anyway) as long as it was at the back of the building and we're not leveling anything to make the lot

Score: 5 ( 7 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Right now it would take big time tax abatements etc. to bring in a regular grocery store. Is everyone willing to pay that price?

A grocery store will come when the market demands it. The fact remains that not a lot of (or not enough) people live downtown to warrant a store.

Target would be perfect for the main place mall.

replied to jim1234664
Score: 0 ( 4 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

a restored lafayette hotel has to be one of the most eagerly anticipated improvements to all of downtown. we're rooting for you, rocco!

ditto the idea of a grocery store in main place mall.

Score: 4 ( 8 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I do like Wegmans better than Tops, but Tops DOES have a downtown location on Niagara Street. Why can't Wegmans?

Score: 3 ( 5 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

A downtown Wegmans is something will start to really talk about in 10 years and not see until 20 years.

That's how Buffalo works. Unfortunate, but true.

Score: -4 ( 8 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Has anyone considered a grocery store at Canal Side? Talk about attracting daily foot traffic :)

Score: 4 ( 4 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I can only picture a grocery store taking up the empty space in the Main Place tower along Church St. @ Main St. Great location, highly visible.

Score: 1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I would love to live downtown. But the biggest barrier is the lack of facilities such as a grocery store. The one on Niagara is too far away from proposed and developed projests.

Score: 2 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Enough of the downtown Wegmans already. I wouldn't think urban dwellers really give a crap about a full service grocery store. I live in the burbs and it is a 15 min drive to the nearest grocery store, when I lived downtown I was at Tops in 2 min or Wegmans on Grant in 8 min...you know that URBAN wegmans on the West Side. Urban living doesn't really jive with the big weekly visit to the super grocery, not like these apts have pantrys and double wide fridges. The fun of living in the city is stopping at the different artisanal markets to get your goods. More meals are ate out, delivered etc. A market no bigger than Co-op is all downtown will ever need.

Score: 0 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I remember at one time before there was the University district I think in the early 90's the Co-op was right on main st st in the University district. It was like the hippy store. When there was Statlers and Twin Fair in the city when there was bigger population in Buffalo those stores went out of business. I live in the city off Hertel and cant stand Wegmans. I like small mom pop shops. Give me stores with Guercios concepts.

Score: 2 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Leave a comment

Buffalo Rising Poll