City November 16, 2010 11:27 AM

Get Your Activism On

Get Your Activism On
This is a shout out to the 35 University at Buffalo students from department of urban planning that I met with this morning to discuss the climate of the city. A short while ago I was contacted by Ramzi Farhat, Ph.D., Department of Urban and Regional Planning, who asked if I would be willing to come out to talk to the class. "The class is meant to introduce our students to community development and the city of Buffalo," Ramzi wrote to me. "And is designed around having guest speakers join us to discuss their thoughts and experiences." Instead of heading off to UB, I offered to host the students at The Eights on Main Street. A deal was struck, and this morning I found myself surrounded by the students, some from WNY and many from outside of the area. I was happy to see that the majority of them took the Metro Rail.

After speaking for longer than I probably should have, from Buffalo Rising to Navigetter to the Elmwood Festival of the Arts, I decided to ask the students if they had any questions. Now I've fielded these types of discussions many times before and the question is always the same. "How do we get directly involved with shaping Buffalo?" These are not students that are required to formulate a question for brownie points - rather these are young people who are truly interested in learning about Buffalo through volunteering for important projects.

Yes, we have the colloquiums where the collegiate and university students are required to interact with organizations in the city. But where does a student go who just wants to join in on progressive projects. I suppose there are internships where students can learn about the industry that they are about to embark upon. That's obviously important. There has got to be more opportunities for these people to join in on. A place that is a living think tank where the ideas flow and the people whom can help to orchestrate the ideas are present. We see fleeting instances of this with Brad Wales and Harvey Garrett. How could we develop an organization that literally takes the motivated young people and places them into the hands of the innovative people of the community?


View image

Comments

Leave a comment

Cool Newell. For one, hold monthly Activism & Eggs breakfasts, to which volunteers and non-profits that seek volunteers can come. Support the breakfasts with social media: listserve, etc. Consistency, information-sharing and commitment goes a long way in getting something like this going.

Get these "kids" some hammers, nails and paint brushes and send them over to the East Side to start work on dilapidated buildings.

Score: -1 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Get these "kids" some hammers, nails and paint brushes and send them over to the East Side to start work on dilapidated buildings

They (or anyone interested) can go to http://habitatbuffalo.org/ to sign up for a worksite this week.

replied to Travelrrr
Score: 3 ( 5 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I did a presentation and lecture series for this group in the Washington DC area last year. I'd love to see us pick-up something similar in Buffalo.

http://www.hotsalsa.org/

Score: 2 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Why not have them join an existing organization (like Preservation Buffalo Niagara) and breathe new life into it?

Score: 2 ( 6 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

As for the question "where does a student go who just wants to join in on progressive projects" I would have to ask in return "what's keeping them from jumping into the already vibrant non-profit and activism scene?" If I were a UB Urban Planning student interested in housing issues, I would be clamoring to help out with PUSH. If interested in gardens and greenspace, we have everything from Grassroots Gardens to Olmsted to MAP or the Queen City Farm. Transportation? Buffalo Blue Bike. All it takes is the willingness to devote time.

My other thought is that I have heard of Planning departments starting classrooms in city downtowns to allow others to brainstorm with them. I don't see why UB wouldn't be interested in setting up a program like that.

Score: 7 ( 7 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

could not agree with you more, goblin. These students are WAITING to be invited to the table? UB Planning is asking "how to get our kids involved"? Something is not right with this picture...GO, DO!

replied to goblinthebamf
Score: 4 ( 8 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I believe Buffalo CarShare was created from UB students. Yes, I do believe so.

replied to goblinthebamf
Score: 2 ( 4 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I think I understand what the students are getting at. Being a UB student, I notice the disconnection between students (most of whom live in Amherst) and the city. I would love to see a volunteer fair of sorts at North Campus in the Student Union. It would be a nice way to showcase our efforts to revive the city. You have to remember that to people from Buffalo, UB north campus is a bubble world, its own municipality. But for people from out of town, north campus is Buffalo. People don't understand the great work people do in the city because they don't realize they aren't "in" the city.

The other idea I've discussed with friends at UB who are involved in volunteer work is the addition of a volunteer requirement for college graduation where a coordinator matches students with organizations.

An education in Buffalo should be about volunteerism and selflessness. It is the essence of being a Buffalonian. The idea of helping to shovel your neighbor's driveway.

Score: 6 ( 8 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I am serious. Keep the bureaucracy down on this for now-just get the students working. Create a social, networking event where students can meet non-profits who come with clear, internship descriptions in hand.

replied to Greg
Score: -2 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Why force it? I don't see the level of philanthropy and selflessness that you are describing. This happens on occassion but is far from the norm for all Buffalonians. The majority of people who work downtown could care less about the overall city, regardless of whether or not they live in the city. There are a lot of people that I know who work at M&T, HSBC, Delaware North, Keybank, and even the Buffalo News, who rarely venture past their office and parking lot. It is a stretch to get them to meet me out for lunch on Allen or to even take a walk for lunch on Main Street.

Activism and volunteerism is generally local. I don't agree with forcing students to volunteer in order to graduate. This tends to backfire on organizations that would prefer committed volunteers who are dedicated to their cause instead of a group of reluctant participants who are forced to be involved just to check the box in order graduate.

Students, and others, have to see the benefits offered by volunteering. They need to understand the community impact they are creating. This is where differences are made.

replied to Greg
Score: 4 ( 6 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Warren Buffet and Bill Gates and Oprah Winfrey and several other billionaire job creators are liberal. On the flip side we see the many right wing bankers who have caused massive job losses in this country. With that in mind I don't really understand your comment.

Score: 0 ( 14 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Too bad Buffet doesn't want to pay his fair share of taxes. Typical liberal says to raise the rates for others because he can shelter his own income from the tax man no matter what the rate is. Buffett's wealth is tied to stock, that he controls and does not pay dividends. His other assets are invested in tax free bonds. He then pays himself just $100,000 annually for running one of the most successful companies in America. Nothing is stopping Mr. Buffett from adjusting his holdings into taxable investments and pay a great amount of his income to the Treasury. Nothing that is except his personal greed. Typical limo liberal Warren "do as I say not as I do" Buffet. Same type of crap we hear from the other elites Gates, Gore et. al.

replied to STEEL
Score: -6 ( 16 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

hahah. Yeah, Bill Gates and Warren Buffett are the worst - they give billions upon billions of dollars away so they can get out of paying taxes on the money! Those greedy bastards! Man, you're beyond delusional, aren't you? Because they both still have the majority of their wealth tied up in their company's stock, that means they are greedy, double-faced liberals? Do you even comprehend how hilarious you sound?

replied to Sally
Score: 6 ( 10 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Warren Buffet = Buffalo News. Last paper to get an offset color press in the USA. Staff cut to the bone? Greedy?

BTW Buffet take most of his income out in offshre countries, pays no US dividends on his companies stock to avoid US taxes and only "PAYS" himself $100K per year out of US coffers to once again avoid paying taxes. The man's picture shows up under hypocrite in the dictionary

replied to jag
Score: -2 ( 8 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Reuters' Rolfe Winkler wrote:

A good chunk of [Warren Buffett's] fortune is dependent on taxpayer largess. Were it not for government bailouts, for which Buffett lobbied hard, many of his company's stock holdings would have been wiped out.

Berkshire Hathaway, in which Buffett owns 27 percent, according to a recent proxy filing, has more than $26 billion invested in eight financial companies that have received bailout money. The TARP at one point had nearly $100 billion invested in these companies and, according to new data released by Thomson Reuters, FDIC backs more than $130 billion of their debt.
...

He even traded the bailout, seeking morally hazardous profits in preferred stock and warrants of Goldman and GE because he had "confidence in Congress to do the right thing" -- to rescue shareholders in too-big-to-fail financials from the losses that were rightfully theirs to absorb.
...

replied to jag
Score: -2 ( 10 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

You're completely uneducated on the issue. Buffet propped up Goldman Sachs. Did he do it without the expectation of making money on it? No, at least i hope not, since that'd be illegal of him to use Berkshire shareholders money that way. He was part of the bailout and, like the US govt., made money off of it. I have no idea how your small mind has twisted that into some sinister liberal action. I don't understand what you're mind's thinking - Buffet's greedy because he makes money on investing when others are fearful? Aren't you one of the crazies that calls all of us socialists? How does that add up in your head? You hate him because his money is still tied up in his company? And you hate him because his company doesn't pay a dividend (like almost all companies)? It's a conspiracy for him to save money on paying taxes when he donates tens of billions of dollars...out of greed? Beyond psycho.

replied to Sally
Score: 3 ( 9 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

holy hell are you a moron. Buffett advocates for higher taxes on wealthy people by raising the capital gains tax.
http://thehill.com/homenews/senate/58129-buffett-to-meet-with-senate-dems

He pays no dividends because he believes he can generate better returns for shareholders by leaving it at Berkshire - something he's proven to be the case for 30+ years.

Oh, and he's giving virtually all of his net worth to charity when he dies so yea, you really caught old Warren - what an intolerable bastard he is.

replied to Sally
Score: 3 ( 7 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Your continued assertion that all Conservatives are greedy heartless bastards who only care about themselves and their fortunes, while all Liberals are altruistic, giving, and compassionate community minded souls, is just plain comical.

You continue to entertain me with your polarized thinking and your unwavering defense of your political ideology.

I just wish you could be a little more objective and open-minded in your articles and editorials. I now fully understand that this will never be the case.

replied to STEEL
Score: 3 ( 5 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

As one of "these kids" (We're all graduate MUP candidates) I'd like to say that a majority of us are actively engaged in our communities and spend what little free time we have working towards the causes we believe in. I think this question stems more from students who see a disconnect between the work/volunteering that they are doing and the change that needs to occur. When a group of us volunteered a few weekends ago with Habitat for Humanity on the East Side we kept asking ourselves questions like "Why are we building new homes on a street where half the houses are burnt out shells and the other half are in serious disrepair?" "Why is there no comprehensive plan among the city's housing agencies to focus this kind of investment in targeted areas where it'll have the most impact?" and "Why are we putting subsidized new builds onto an already over-saturated residential market, which just caused further vacancy and community destabilization?"

And thank you for the invite Travelrrr, you're too too kind :)

Score: 13 ( 13 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

You ask: "Why are we building new homes on a street where half the houses are burnt out shells and the other half are in serious disrepair?" "Why is there no comprehensive plan among the city's housing agencies to focus this kind of investment in targeted areas where it'll have the most impact?"

Why? Because we don't have quality people like you in office, and we have had generations of people fleeing the city...as opposed to investing in, as you are doing. Keep up the good work. Oh-and do report back if you get an answer to those seemingly logical questions...I'd like to know too (hint: check out the connection between City Hall and pastor developers, for one.)

replied to DTK2OD
Score: 4 ( 8 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

The option for the students really boils down to working with an existing organization in order to reach common goals or to take the initiative and think creatively on new and exciting ways to approach the questions that Urban Planners seek to answer. Questions on Sustainability, Development, Transportation etc, etc. Many of these questions are addressed at a conversational level either here at BRO or at town hall but few take the initiative needed to thoroughly research these topics statistically.

Score: -2 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

connecting students with internships isn't rocket science. lots of ub departments maintain a registry of internships, volunteer opportunities, practicums, whatever you want to call them, but a little digging suggests that the planning school isn't one of them.

all they have to do is develop a form for any community organization to submit an internship or volunteer opportunity and have an online directory of said positions for students to browse.

Score: -2 ( 6 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Grad94, as a graduate of the School of Architecture and Planning, I can assure you they definitely keep a list of internships available for students. Internships can also be done for credit, and are coordinated through an adviser.

In addition, the graduate planning student association is traditionally very active in organizing their own volunteer opportunities.

replied to grad94
Score: 1 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

great! then help us out. ub's management school has a page devoted to internships. i couldn't find anything comparable for the planning school.

http://mgt.buffalo.edu/career/students/opportunities/internships

where can the planning school's standards for internships be viewed by community organizations (so that graduate students aren't exploited as free clerical labor)? where can organizations see the internships being offered? where can organizations submit internships?


replied to TranspoGuy
Score: -1 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Why doesn't Warren give some of his money to the people he under-payed or laid off over the years? He squeezed everything he could from his employees.

ps Americorp is a pretty great organization (Politics aside) to be mentioned with PUSH, Habitat, etc working together with these and many other nonprofits.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Companies Buffett is invested in generally have higher employee retention rates than similar competitors. Costco, for instance, has a 25% turnover rate compared to WalMart's 50%. Hell, they have to pay Buffalo News staffers to get them to leave. So what is your evidence that he "squeezed everything he could from his employees?"

Also, it's underpaid, not under-payed, you know-nothing dolt.

replied to JM
Score: 0 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

A story about community activism denigrates into a conservative-liberal argument. Just another day on Buffalo Rising. Not much different than how things generally go in Buffalo. Way to get it started, 'Why'.

Score: -1 ( 5 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

As another MUP student who attended today, I think part of the problem, especially for people from out of town like me, is that it takes some time to adjust to the new surroundings in order to build the knowledge and capacity to actively participate.

I decided to attend UB not only because it is an excellent planning school, but also because I believe that the people of Buffalo are at the forefront of reshaping the American city into an urban community that is equitable, sustainable, and vibrant.

Buffalo is a fantastic city with friendly people, inspiring energy, outstanding urban landscapes, and world-class cultural amenities that are enough to astound anyone from any walk of life, not just a planner. The bold innovation of dedicated Buffalonians breathes new life every day into a city that has struggled from decades of hardship many cities touted as 'successful' have simply never known.

There are many challenges that lie ahead for the city of Buffalo, and it is our duty as planners to help our community achieve solutions. So don't worry, you'll be seeing us around town soon enough, if you haven't already.

Score: 14 ( 16 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

jackdaug, i wish buffalo had planning jobs for you and a hundred like you.

i was thinking about your remarks in the context of the ibm smart cities grant featured elsewhere on bro.

buffalo doesn't lack for brains or solutions, it lacks the will or ability (political, financial, whatever) to implement them. city planners usually have the least clout of any professionals in a given municipality (not just buffalo). if this were different, buffalo would be different. and we wouldn't need to compete for smart cities grants.

replied to jackdaug
Score: 0 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Here's another idea: what about an urban planning club which meets outside of school time and undertakes projects in Buffalo. That would create an entity which organizations could approach for assistance needed, and it would allow for a student-led effort..which could be more fun and less bureaucratic.

replied to grad94
Score: 1 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

100 % agreed!

As an urban planning student at Buffalo State, I am actively engaged as much as I can throughout the community which includes working in sustainable real estate development and interning as well.
Unfortunately, Buffalo has a limited job market. If we want to succeed in the field and to stay here after graduating than we need to continue to take on different responsibilities by utilizing internships, jobs and volunteer work to have a competitive advantage in the planning world.

We realize that it is our duty as the younger generation of urban planners to continue to preserve history and promote dense, sustainable, walkable, mixed use cities and Buffalo is the perfect candidate. I just hope I can advance my career AND live in Buffalo.

BTW, just so you all know, the kids at UB (and now buff state!) are doing an amazing job with the new Green Code zoning. It amazes me to see the City of Buffalo taking such a progressive stance on zoning and a comprehensive look at our cities growth over the next 20 years. We all should be thankful that they are here working diligently to provide buffalo with a progressive, sustainable zoning code that is so desperately needed.

For more information on the new green code - www.buffalogreencode.com

replied to jackdaug
Score: 2 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

i like it. but there still ought to be an easy online mechanism for community organizations to solicit planning interns.

Score: -1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Leave a comment

Buffalo Rising Poll