City November 30, 2010 9:54 AM

George Pierce, his bicycles, his automobiles and Canalside

George Pierce, his bicycles, his automobiles and Canalside
By Mark Goldman:

I am personally thrilled with the recommendations made by ECHDC Chairman Levy. I am deeply proud of our community and the hundreds of people who stepped up to express their interest and concern about an issue that they felt so strongly about. I am deeply proud as well of our leadership who were willing and able to learn from and listen and respond to those who spoke up. The combination of an informed citizenry and a responsive leadership gives me great hope not only for our waterfront but for the future of Buffalo as well. This is, I believe, a significant day in our history and we should celebrate it.

While everybody knows that the Pierce-Arrow, that fabulous automobile known round the world that was favored by kings and pashas, playboys and bon vivants during the first thirty years of the last century, was made in Buffalo, how many people know where George Pierce (photo), the genius who founded the company that made that car of dreams, opened his first factory? You would be wrong, though understandably so, if you said that the first Pierce-Arrow plant was in that spectacular Taj Mahal of industry that dominates the landscape, towering regally, like Mont St. Michel off the coast of Normandy, over its drab surroundings most prominent of which are three eating establishments--Vino, Papa Jake and the Carriage Trade-- that I am sure the 6000 or so men and women who worked making those cars in that dream-like factory wished had been there then.

George-Pierce-Buffalo-NY.jpgWell, then, if not there, where? Some of you know. Jim Sandoro, founder, curator and empresario of the Buffalo Transportation Museum knows. So too do Carl and Clary Burgwardt who since the early 1970s have created in a 7000 sq foot space in Orchard Park one of the most interesting and idiosyncratic museums anywhere, the Pedaling History Bicycle Museum. And, since talking to them I, who has done as much poking and digging around in the rich fields of Buffalo history as any one, since meeting with these people and visiting them in their establishments, finally know too. So, to end the mystery, to tell you a fact which just might, if you allow it, change your way of thinking about the waterfront, I will tell you. The first Pierce plant was.....you got it...on the waterfront; not anywhere on the waterfront but in the heart of the old streets of what we now interchangeably call "The Inner Harbor" or "Canalside." That's right. Right there, on the new streets that were unearthed and recreated as part of the 2004 plan for the area, at the corner of two iconic waterfront streets--Prime and Hanover--at the crossroads where two of our history's most powerful engines of economic growth--the railroad and the waterfront came together--George Pierce, in the 1880s built his first factory.

At first he made birdcages and then, for a reason that I have not figured out, he made the transition to bicycle manufacturing and by the end of the 1880s the George N. Pierce Company, located right next to the Commercial Slip at 6-22 Hanover Street,  was producing a whole range of bicycles and tricycles for men, women and children. In an 1895 catalog, five models of "Queen" tricycles were offered for sale. The smallest, with a 16-inch wheel, for girls 3-5 years old, sold for $5.00, or $8.50 with rubber tires; the largest, with a 32-inch wheel, for girls 8-15 years old, sold for $12.00 or $18.00 with rubber tires.

The factory, though, was the thing. In a day of small manufacturing companies, with small work forces and small structures, the Pierce plant was a gigantic exception, the first and, with any luck, the last "big box" on the waterfront.  At 25,000 sq feet this five story building, made of brick, wood and steel hovered over this intensely dense and busy part of the city. Everybody wanted Pierce's bicycles and by the time of the Pan American Expo in 1901 they were being shipped, from Hanover Street, by the DL&W railroad whose tracks were just outside the plant's front door, to homes in countries all over the world. The bicycle, produced in that fabulous factory in the heart of what we now call "Canalside", had made Pierce a rich man and had put Buffalo on the map as one of the world's great centers of bicycle production.

Soon, Pierce made the transition from bicycles to cars and in 1901 The George N. Pierce & Company built two cars,  both manufactured at the Hanover Street plant. By the end of the year Pierce has sold over two dozen autos and in 1904 he unveiled the Pierce Arrow, at $4000 the biggest and most expensive automobile on the U.S. market. It was time to move to bigger and newer quarter and in 1907, Pierce left Canalside, abandoning his factory at Hanover and Prime for his brand new, gigantic really "big box" facility, the building that we know today as The Pierce Arrow Building at Elmwood and Great Arrow.
So, while there is clearly no trace on the old waterfront of George Pierce, his bicycles or his automobiles, maybe there is a way, some way, for us to reference that fabulous piece of Buffalo history in our newly developing plans for the Inner Harbor. Stayed tuned... Next week we will suggest a way.

Photos: BuffaloAH
View image

Comments

Leave a comment

What a fabulous idea it would be to move the Pedaling History museum to the waterfront and include a large portion of the focus to be on Mr. Pierce and his story. It could be located in the same spot as the orginal factory and could tie into the Pierce Arrow museum on Seneca. This could perhaps be the catalyst of a variety of museums/aquarium that could be clustered together to create a toursit destination the same way the museums are clustered together in Chicago and Pittsburgh. Sprinkle in some restaurants of varying degrees, small retail and outdoor attractions (kayak rental place, music stage) and you've got a winner. Why is this so hard for people to see or to accomplish?

Score: 12 ( 14 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

The problem with your "vision," probuff, is that you can't just build something and then hope against hope that Bass Pro / IKEA is just going to move in because the boxes were built. I actually think you're in the minority, probuff. You don't build a $40 million parking garage when there's nothing else there just for the sake of so called progress.

Congrats to Mark and everyone else who fought for the rest of us on this critical issue.

Score: 4 ( 10 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Sour grapes much?

Way to go Mark and COMMUNITY. Probuff, you would have seem that this was hardly a small group if you had made it to a forum.

This concept, and others that have surfaced over the weeks, are authentic to Buffalo...and FAR more compelling than big box retail. Thanks Jordy et al for listening...

Here we go!

Score: 5 ( 7 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

You're right probuff. Mark hasn't been elected or appointed anything ... yet.

But as far as I'm concerned, he could/should be Mayor some day. We need visionaries in out town. All you have to do is look at "who" is making progress (Mark G., Rocco T, etc.) and those that don't (most everyone at City Hall). You must know what we usually do just isn't working.

So to Mark, a HUGE thanks. Thanks for bringing Fred Kent to town, and involving your brother too. With their/your input, this is going to be an exciting place.

Mark, I hope you can get the Burgwardts a chance to locate the Pedaling Museum in Canal Side as the nexus to a Transportation Museum. And don't forget General Mills/Cheerios. Hey, they use ships ... and how cool would it be for them to have their flagship (only?) history museum/store here.

Score: 5 ( 9 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Don't forget the Ira G. Ross Aerospace Museum located in the HSBC Arena behind the Sabres Store that celebrates the contribution that Buffalo-Niagara had to flight, plus they are already a part of the Canalside area.

replied to Tahooter
Score: 3 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

The Ira G. Ross Aerospace museum is very forgettable and very empty. This museum is a total waste of time. A one time visit at best. It is a waste of the $7.00 it cost to get in, I would have been better spending that money on a latte... and I hate coffee!

replied to mp1
Score: -1 ( 5 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Well there you have it folks. The waterfront should be a museum to bicycles and our very own bankrupt car company. What a resounding tribute to Buffalo's history, a shrine to memorialize the once great car company that couldn't adapt to the changing times. I can't think of a more fitting tribute to Buffalo's economic past.

While we are at it, let's make a museum of our rich blue collar past. We could include pictures of who we once were and how our union past killed our future. Let's add a wing dedicated to buildings that we could no longer occupy as our population fled south to find a more hospitable economic climate.

Let's all concede that retail is a dead option for the waterfront. We don't have the population to attract major stores and the little stores won't have the draw to be anything but seasonal souvenir shops. The same can be said for restaurants and bars.

We all know what happens when Mr. Goldman and Mr. Tielman don't get their way, so let's just give in to their demands so we can have something less than mediocre but better than what we have currently.

Score: 0 ( 16 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Bcat, we can pedal pedal pedal our way to prosperity!!! You know the oedaling museum has lines out the door!!!

replied to bobbycat
Score: 0 ( 6 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

The reason Mr. Goldman & Mr. Tielman "get their way" so often is because they're right so often. That translates into substantial grass roots support - i.e. hundreds, oftentimes thousands of people willing to work in support of their (now collective) vision.

If you have a better idea, put it out there, and see if you can attract the same level of support in opposition to their vision. If you're unwilling to do that, please stop whining.

Score: 5 ( 15 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I don't need a large number of supporters, just wealthy ones who run a law firm. That way I can use the courts to stop whatever I might disagree with in the name of historic preservation or anti-gambling. Whichever cause I might choose for the day. There is no need to whine when you can have our legal system bog down progress for a few years. This is a tried and true practice of Tim Tielman, Bruce Fischer, and Mark Goldman.

replied to skarnath
Score: -3 ( 15 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

If I'm not mistaken, the original location of this building would be in the way of the skyway. If you know how to quickly and cheaply move 40,000 cars to an alternate route per day to build a five story building, I'm listening.

I'd be for reconstruction of a partial amout of this structure, so long as it's mixed use and features a larger than normal retail space (made in America store or grocery store in future).

Score: -1 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

ProBuff this is a comment for you. Insulting people that are the growing catalyst for development in Canalside. I don't hear any suggestions on your part. I only hear insulting remarks. What is really up with that?

Score: 2 ( 6 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

There should be enough space on the Canalside waterfront to put little museums such as this along with LOCAL and NATIONAL restaurants/entertainment/retail.

Both sides, Mr. Goldman's group and the others who desire a more "touristy" canalside(which I do beleive is the majority) have somewhat met in the middle. Let the canal be built, build the buildings like in these drawings and it will come together.

Localist ideas such as Mr. Goldman's would be nice attractions and give people something to do ALONG with eating and shopping.

I have attended many events at HSBC arena in my young life and had to watch people wonder where are the bars, restaurants, and activity in Downtown Buffalo is hiding(and Chip is not what they were talking about). This area has the opportunity to satisfy this void. LET IT HAPPEN, we have spent enough time conversing, lets start building.

PS- If HSBC locates on the webster block, watch this area be booming with activity, money, and a brigther future for Buffalo!

Score: 1 ( 5 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

@probuff, Goldman and Tielman didn't stop anything but the transfer of local money to the private benefit of a single corp. Instead of wasting money on pie in the sky retailers who would never on their own accord put a store in Buffalo unless bribed with millions of dollars, we are going to put the money into our own infrastructure and the history to make something interesting that will draw people there, and hopefully retailers as well.

Bass Pro, Ikea etc are more than welcome in downtown \ waterfront but they can do it on their own dime. Our money should go into things we all can use. IE. new sidewalks, canals, unearthed local history, an expanded public space \ boardwalk along the river.

Score: 5 ( 9 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

no money for retail but we're going to have to subsidize all of these museums until they eventually close? how are all of these museums going to pry any money out of chris collins hands? the pierce arrow expansion has already received numerous tax breaks and assistance. i don't see the difference

Score: 1 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Then we can open a Museum Museum.

replied to wnywatercooler
Score: 1 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I was unclear on one point from this article. Is Mark Goldman recommending that we relocate the existing Buffalo Transportation Museum from Michigan Ave to the waterfront, or is he asking to build a new one on the waterfront that would likely compete with the existing one?

I am not sure if anyone has visited the Gilmore Car Museum near Kalamazoo Michigan, but they have a large collection of Pierce Arrow cars on display. They also have a great collection of other cars, from prototypes to NASCAR. It is worth a stop if you are ever in the area.

I hope that we can get the same quality of museum in Buffalo. If we are going to do it, then we need to do it right.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

i'd love to see the bicycle museum move downtown.

oh, and i could be wrong, but maybe pierce made the leap from birdcages to bicycles because the same machinery that bent wire for cages could bend wire for bicycle spokes.

Score: -2 ( 4 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Well what's your idea of an attraction?

Refrain from saying hipster/hippie museum.

Score: 0 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

hello don paul's weather museum.. where do you play into this?

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

wow, deleted all my comments??!! way to be fair and balanced...

Score: -1 ( 11 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I don't think I've ever read a BRO policy to provide for fair and balanced treatment towards consistently jaded and obnoxious ignorance...

replied to ronburgundy
Score: 0 ( 6 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Sorry assaroni-ronburgundy. Take your crybabying somewhere else if you dont like your garbage be ing deleted.

replied to ronburgundy
Score: -1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I, like a lot of others, am hoping for the "new" waterfront to be more business-oriented and lively - restuarants, shops, entertainment... wasn't there any aquarium in the mix? But this sort of livelihood isn't at odds with historical attractions. Bass Pro is gone - is there not enough space for a museum AND commercial attractions? The waterfront is fairly expansive, I don't think compromise is out of the question.

Score: 3 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

That sounds correct - Kimon's point that there's plenty of space. The conflict seems irrelevant between people seeking museums vs. the people seeking a new retail/entertainment district.

I predict neither of those alternatives will happen in any big amount, for different reasons (lack of business interest to operate an entertainment district, lack of long term funding for museums, aquarium, etc.)

Regarding big retail, I commented here a few weeks ago that Levy and Quinn would soon have no serious choice other than to give up on that as soon as the "10" supposedly-interested anchor retailers all said no as did Bass Pro very slowly and Ikea very fast. Since Levy made no further mention of the "10" from what I saw reported, we can presume that's what happened (if 10 even existed) and their Plan B was giving in to some of what Teilman's supporters wanted.

I don't see why small or medium retailers would consider it a smart location either, even with a few cobblestones and a historically-faithful canal segment. We'll see. The real canal still runs through several cities in Upstate. How much spin-off in retail, etc. happens next to it in those places?

replied to Kimon
Score: 1 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

'I don't see why small or medium retailers would consider it a smart location either....'

You're right and a number of us have said this on BRO for years.

It doesn't mean that we're negative about Buffalo and it's not because retailers aren't interested in Buffalo. The demographics don't yet exist for a specialty retailer to make an operating profit there.

There are those that comment on BRO that still believe specialty retail and tourists will magically appear if something -- anything but a park -- is built. I understand the local frustration but it's just not going to happen. Small steps will lead to better long-term success and a more inviting environment.

replied to whatever
Score: 0 ( 4 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Paul>" t doesn't mean that we're negative about Buffalo and it's not because retailers aren't interested in Buffalo. The demographics don't yet exist for a specialty retailer to make an operating profit there."

Meh. A lot of self styled oracles said the same thing about downtown housing 10 years ago and now there are plenty units in the central business district.

replied to PaulBuffalo
Score: -1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

You're comparing housing to retail?

Specialty retail doesn't need an invitation. If the conditions were right, retailers would be downtown and interested in the waterfront now.

Get more residents living in the downtown area then retail will arrive.

replied to Armchair MBA
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Im not sure this is really a museum, per se. As far as I understand it, its more of a private collection that is open for visits - much like the Transportation Museum.

True museums are public institutions governed by state and federal laws, as well as American Association of Museums guidelines. I would be hesitant to suggest a public investment in an institution not so governed.

Score: 2 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

i think you're right. the bicycle collection owner made some noise before the economic downturn about selling the collection out of town but apparently the buyer backed out.

since i don't want to see the bike collection leave town, i wish the owner would incorporate as a nonprofit and establish the proper governance that you mentioned.

replied to al labruna
Score: -1 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Realdeal got blocked?

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

The real question is will your comments be here in the morning?

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Someone needs a shoulder to cry on...

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Leave a comment

Buffalo Rising Poll