City November 29, 2010 9:30 PM

ECHDC Takes Action on Modified Canal Side Plan

ECHDC Takes Action on Modified Canal Side Plan

The Board of Directors of the Erie Canal Harbor Development Corporation (ECHDC) today voted to approve the modified Canal Side General Project Plan, with amendments that will ensure that the proposed public canal system will follow the historic path of the Erie Canal. The Board tabled the proposed underground parking ramp at the Aud site, citing concerns that had been expressed by the community during the recent public outreach period. In addition, ECHDC Chair Jordan Levy announced a series of steps that will be implemented over the next several months in order promote activity and improve conditions on the Inner and Outer harbors this summer.
 
"After several weeks of listening and learning, we have heard a lot that we agree with and will now incorporate into our planning," said Jordan Levy. "We are excited and enthusiastic about this new and improved design, and hope that the community will respond favorably as well."

Canal Side 2.0 B.jpgThe new design for the canal will match the alignment of the original Erie Canal as it came through downtown Buffalo, culminating at the Commercial Slip. The canal will be one continuous body of water, lined by towpaths on either side. The goal is to capture the look and feel of the original Canal District, with some small compromises to deal with the Skyway, the Hamburg drain, security concerns and Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) requirements. 

Canal Side 2.0 C.jpgThe underground parking garage that had been proposed on the north side of the Aud block has been tabled, pending further study and review. Reservations about the garage had been cited by  members of the public during the comment period on the MGPP, and today's action by the Board was in response to those concerns. "Our goal is to work on developing the district, expanding opportunities and events for the public. If, down the road, it becomes clear that additional parking is required, the board will be able to revisit the issue at that time," said Levy.
 
ECHDC conducted a series of meetings, hearings and outreach efforts over the past several weeks, in order to gather input and ideas from the Western New York community regarding waterfront development. These sessions indicated that, in addition to wanting to pursue longer term, historically accurate development on the waterfront, the public is eager to embrace a series of "lighter, quicker, cheaper" proposals that can be implemented this summer.
 
These low cost/high impact actions will include:

DSC_0702c.JPG1. The establishment of three sub-committees, tasked with studying the Historic District, the Buffalo River and the Outer Harbor. These committees will be chaired by Jordan Levy, Julie Barrett O'Neill and David Colligan, respectively. ECHDC is pursuing a broad spectrum of community participation, reflecting the diversity of the Western New York community and including many of the individuals who have been vocal about the previous direction of the project. These committees will be responsible for issuing their first report to the ECHDC board of directors by February's meeting, with the objective of making things happen this summer on the waterfront.
 
2. Retaining the services of Fred Kent to assist Canal Side's architectural firm, EEK, with planning for all three sub-committees and to assist with summer 2011 programs. In particular, the idea of a market using temporary tent structures was an idea that received broad support during the recent comment period. ECHDC will seek to implement such a market space in the historic district this summer.
 
3. Working closely with Buffalo's preservationist community to explore the necessary steps towards the construction of a canopied pavilion on the Inner Harbor. The 2004 Master Plan called for such a structure and ECHDC embraces its development.
 
4. Committing half of the necessary funds (up to $2 million) for the creation of Lakeside Meadows Park on 120 acres of Outer Harbor land and working with the NFTA and the Olmsted Parks Conservancy, with the park opening this coming summer.
 
5. Working towards adding additional boat slips and marina services for this summer's boating season, including washroom, shower and laundry facilities, so that Canalside can become a destination for boaters from all parts of the Great Lakes.


Canal Side 2.0 D.jpg6. Working with NFTA to transfer ownership of Outer Harbor land to ECHDC this spring, so that the redevelopment of this important parcel of land can be added to ECHDC's planning process.
 
7. Entering into a study with the NFTA about the feasibility of converting Gallagher Beach into a sand covered swimming beach.
 
8. Partnering with the Buffalo Lighthouse Association and supply funds to restore the historic Buffalo Lighthouse in time for the 2011 Annual Conference of the Historic Trust.
 
9. Providing funds to enhance and maintain the newly developed Outer Harbor Parkway. This important new resource should be sustained in an interim period before sustainable revenue resources become available as a result of new development. To this end, the corporation will seek to engage the services of a non-profit with relative expertise and experience to enhance and maintain the landscaping and other amenities.

View image

Comments

Leave a comment

I like the ground level images and the idea of building the structure and letting business fill in.

Hopefully this moves forward and there is no obstruction.

And please no "living wage" talk. No business, not spot coffee, not urban threads, not blue monk, not even walmart would move to an area being told what they must spend on employees.

Score: 13 ( 17 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

BEST coverage I've seen of this today -- great information. Thank you, WCP!

Score: 8 ( 8 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Direct from ECHDC.

replied to RaChaCha
Score: 3 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

"Working closely with Buffalo's preservationist community to explore the necessary steps towards the construction of a canopied pavilion on the Inner Harbor."

Are there any real advocates for Architecture in this town??

With so much new construction in this plan, why is the discussion dominated by historic preservation?

I see planning and preservation in this plan. Where is the architecture?

Score: 5 ( 11 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

We need another Esther Link.

replied to davvid
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

This plan honestly looks amazing. Its exactly what both sides want done. Now someone take Tim Tielman and kidnap him for the next five years.....pallllllllllease! jk

Score: -1 ( 19 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I am sure that Tim Tielman and Bruce Fischer will find some reason to protest and sue over this plan. They epitomize the term obstructionist!

Score: 0 ( 20 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Merry Christmas! ...Now get it done.

Score: 2 ( 4 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I love it.

Score: 1 ( 7 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Overall, I thought this was a most positive development. The best part was retaining the services of Fred Kent of Project fro Public Spaces to work with archetecural planning. I wasn't expecting that. This will help to ensure smart planning.

Score: 1 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Sorry "BurchJP" and "bobbycat" - Jordan Levy asked Tielman to be on an ECHDC sub-committee and Mayor Brown complimented Tielman on some of his suggestions.

Score: 6 ( 14 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I don't see how appointing them to the ECHDC is a good thing. Tielman is not a collaborator, he is a bully. I think this will just stall development. In my view this is an appeasement to get Fischer and Tielman to shut up for awhile but past history shows that this is only a short term fix. I give it about 9 months of nothing happening before Tielman quits the ECHDC and starts whining to the press and threatening lawsuits again.

--------------------------
A turtle was happily swimming along a river when a scorpion hailed it from the shore. "Dear friend turtle!" called the scorpion. "Please let me climb upon your back and swim me to the other side of the river!"

"No," replied the turtle, "for if I do, you shall sting me, and I shall die."

"Nonsense!" replied the scorpion. "If I kill you in the middle of the river, you shall sink, and I shall drown and die with you."

The turtle thought this over, and saw the truth of the scorpion's statement. He let it upon his back and began swimming towards the other side of the river. Halfway across, he felt a sharp pain in the back of his neck.

"Why have you stung me?!" cried the turtle as his body began to stiffen. "Now you shall die as well!"

"Because it is in my nature," replied the scorpion as they both sank and drown.

replied to Daniel Sack
Score: 4 ( 14 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Have you ever heard of the word "appeasement". He's giving him a one way ticket to nowhere position on a board that doesnt matter so he will shut up. By tieing him into the development he is now "the man". So if he has anyone to file a lawsuit against he would be filing it against himself.

replied to Daniel Sack
Score: 1 ( 11 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

"Keep your friends close and your enemies closer!"

replied to BurchJP
Score: 5 ( 7 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Why hasn't Jordan Levy been fired? I don't understand it. It's like Lindy Ruff and Darcy Regier still operating as a tandem. I would think in most jobs when you produce nothing and fail often you would be relieved of your position. Guess not with the ECHDC. Can anyone explain how Jordan Levy is still the chair of the ECHDC?

Score: -1 ( 13 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

It's called Buffalo...people get rewarded for doing nothing...it's like one GIANT Union

replied to LouisTully
Score: 0 ( 10 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Well I've been thumbed down; yet no one is offering anything to refute my comments.

replied to ronburgundy
Score: -3 ( 5 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Buffalo will do the right thing after it exhausts all other options.

Score: 11 ( 13 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

This would be spectacular if it comes to fruition.

Score: 2 ( 4 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Jordan Levy owns. Bring Tim on, bring on Fred Kent, kneecap the opposition.

Score: -5 ( 7 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I think this plan looks great a mixed use of Shops, Second Floor Offices and Upper Floor Housing can only insure the areas use for many years to come.

These areas thrived because the population density had the Butcher the Baker and the Candle Stick Maker all close which made a community work. As seen in the Elmwood village, folks can walk to the district and get the bare necessary living items while being able to dine when life is so busy doing busy people things!

I'm happy to see this area receive so much thought as in Europe these Canal Districts still after Hundreds of Years are sought after Residential Mecca's!

Please Let's Build the Buildings to last for Generations to be proud of not tooth picks and glue!

Score: 2 ( 6 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Now this is cool. I was under the impression from the 'rally' people that they did'nt want ANY canal's. But, I like this new option.

Score: 2 ( 4 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Am I being too redundant in saying that NOTHING will get done there as long as Levy is in control and Quinn is a player?

Score: 1 ( 7 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

No. I don't understand why Levy's job has not been brought up. I don't understand why no one is calling for him to be replaced. There hasn't even been a vote of confidence in him to do the job by any leaders such as Brown or Higgins after his many failings. Higgins had to step in and do his job for him how many times. Someone please explain to me why he still has his job.

Score: 3 ( 5 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Bravo to the folks who stood up for the community and averting a potential disaster ala the ECHDC. I absolutely love this plan!

Now how about using some of that $35 Million Bass Pro money and put the Skyway demolition on the fast track along with building the replacement bridge. The longer it sits there the more expensive it will be to take down; especially if there will be new development already in place within the surrounding areas.

Score: 2 ( 8 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I agree. The skyway is a major fly in the ointment of an otherwise good plan. If Byron Brown truly wants to leave a legacy in this city, it would be pressuring the DOT to knock down that monstrosity before Canal Side is built.

replied to SadLlama
Score: 1 ( 7 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

SO much potential at Gallagher Beach to turn it into a great swimming beach. Great size, not sprawling, but not too small. Already has a boat launch, a pier that extends into the water 20 feet above it. Dug's Dive is right down the pier...add in a few more restaurants and some retail strands (maybe I heart Buffalo t shirts?) in the summer...great little spot.

Score: 4 ( 6 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

perhaps we are experiencing the funnel effect? The project starts off as a grand idea and then by the time the money is spent some people are more impressed with their profit margin then the actual "history" of the project.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

two things I got to say. My Nonni were immigrants but I don't like the idea of anymore coming in especially to Buffalo where work is hard to find and here we got a special place for immigrants to come, this will keep tourists away. Number TWO. Everyone was so crazy about the Bass Pro why hasn't anybody said nothing about bringing Dicks or Gander Mountain down there. The Dicks at The Galleria is amazing architeture styling. It would sure show up Bass Pro woouldnt it?

Score: -10 ( 12 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

What are you talking about? Did you honestly mean what you wrote, or are you just randomly throwing words together? You actually used the word amazing to describe something at the Galleria Mall, and it was Dick's sporting goods. That's unbelievable. The only time amazing should be applied to the Galleria Mall is to say it is an amazing monstrosity. Your comment is so ridiculous I can't even chuckle at it.

replied to jimmythesicilian
Score: 0 ( 10 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

haha are you joking. most of the galleria is just ok but have you really even seen Dicks, it's not like the most of the rest of the structure, it's all glass and steel beams, kind of modern architecture, it would be a decent attraction downtown. but whatever, you guys already have your minds made up to put up aquariums, ice cream shops and trendy clothing shops. good luck with that!!

replied to LouisTully
Score: 0 ( 6 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Dude, you're delirious if you apply positive architectural aesthetics to a sporting goods store (architectural is the word you were looking for). There aren't many similarities one could draw between the Galleria Mall in Cheektowaga and anything in downtown Buffalo. And the idea of other sporting good stores has been brought up for quite some time, ie Cabellas. That has been deemed a lame-o idea as well.

replied to jimmythesicilian
Score: 0 ( 4 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

What a waste of time this is. I for one officially don't care about this any more. Time for us to move on to the next 10 year project that won't happen. It's been a little while maybe we should go back to focusing on the Peace Bridge.

Or maybe in a year when this garbage is about to get started I'll protest with 20 people stating that I wasn't included in the process and start the entire thing over again even though it's a total lie.

NEXT!!!

Score: 0 ( 8 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Nice concept, although I hope planners take into consideration that canal waters like this tend to be stagnant in nature and will start to smell like a sewer, especially in the hot summer months.

Score: 3 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I believe they will since they already took that into consideration when doing the commercial slip, hence the waterfall at the end.

replied to Greg Blakowski
Score: 1 ( 5 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Actually the waterfall at the end did nothing to mediate the rotting stagnant sewage that still remains in the hot summer months..FAIL

replied to brownteeth
Score: 0 ( 6 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Well I was wondering what they meant when they said they weren't using lake water for these canals.

replied to urbanboarder
Score: 1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

The plan looks great but it is rather generic for what will end up there. I have a fear it will just be an area full of water and nothing to do on it, kinda like a bigger version of what it is now. I would have liked to see some sort of attraction or things to do like higher end bowling, a legit music venue like House of Blues, etc.

Score: 3 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I hope people on here realize that the success of this project in contingent on Main St going back to two way traffic and a bridge being built to connect the inner and outer harbor. Lets not loose sight of things that actually matter, not just the size of one mans "canal" compared to anothers.

Score: 0 ( 6 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Losing the train is a step backward - although most people oppose the train, we now need more parking and position the city poorly for the future by not having anything to build off of (except a terrible bus ssytem that nobody can use anyway)

Having light rail to take people downtonw alleviates the parking needs and makes for a much nice, more filled in downtown

replied to BurchJP
Score: 1 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I never said loose the train, a train is still needed. But more than anything cars need to return to Main St. Keep the rain just like they do in Toronto on all their streets, but let cars drive on Main St also.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I'm glad to hear they finally got over Bass Pro and surprised to hear they are no longer pursuing a big box retailer. At any rate I will be happy if they take it slow and build this up organically. Could you imagine if this got rushed 5 years ago? We would be stuck with a Niagara Falls looking district half vacant with the rest being gift shops. At this point just do it right even if it takes 5 more years.

Score: 2 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Good luck with that.

Score: 0 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I think the ECHDC and Citizens for Whatever and So On should que up another 35mil and begin the process of spending it slowly over the next 10 years; wouldn't want to rush anything, want to get it just right

Score: -1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

see Goldman's industrial island.

replied to bhorvath
Score: -1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

It's to bad the underground parking is gone, it will be needed one day when it is to late and we will see an above ground garage built. Zero foresight.

Score: 4 ( 4 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Dear Sheeple, in Buffalo-ease (you people are sheep)
This wont happen, ever, Tielman and the obsturctionist gang who took down the Casino and any hope of development will put the stick in the spokes...BTW the Casino would tie in nicely with this plan if it ever were to happen. Bye sheeple.

Score: -4 ( 10 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Isn't there a casino downtown? And isn't the Buffalo Creek Casino project still alive? The reason it's collecting dust isn't because there are evil people who don't like Native Americans or keno, it's because the interest rate on their loan went through the roof when the economy tanked. But that's probably the Democrats fault, right? BTW, the skeleton of the Buffalo Creek is about a half mile and 6 surface lots away... not sure how much that could tie in with this plan.

replied to ronburgundy
Score: 1 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

To bring this full circle, didn't Jordan Levy recently take a job with Seneca Holdings?

replied to LouisTully
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

looks great. I always thought this area should look like it used to, like the historical paintings and pictures on the first floor of Pearl Street Brewery.

Score: 0 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

i just have my reservations that the neo traditional won't become stale. the architectural interest is not enough to over come the ruffians of social ambivalence. from this location, they need to consider how to create a strong interest in the rail system. they also need to expand upon the quality and character of the hsbc arena's volume of temperament. Of course the vision should be ever lasting water, but lets not assume that this project couldn't give us the kind of social conditioning that only seems to be attempted through individual acts.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Leave a comment

Buffalo Rising Poll