City October 31, 2010 10:17 AM

Opportunity Knocks? Will anyone answer?

Opportunity Knocks? Will anyone answer?
We love to hear from our readers, especially when they present ideas that can take a good project to an en excellent one. Many of these ideas come from attempting to turn lemons into lemonade. Say, for example, the Buffalo Maritime Center loses its home out at the Outer Harbor (it just did)... and at the same time various other waterfront advancements are moving forward right around the corner... opportunity knocks? The following submitted by C. Andrle:

"The recent news about the re-opening of the Buffalo Lighthouse next year included information that the Coast Guard will be releasing 4.6 acres around the lighthouse for public use as well as "consolidating/demolishing" several buildings.
 
"The Buffalo Maritime Center, recently evicted from their waterfront space by the NFTA and now in temporary (landlocked) rental space, has previously proposed that the abandoned Coast Guard buildings be reused by the Maritime Center for their boat shop and historic watercraft museum and other programs. The combination of the historic site, lighthouse, and other historic exhibits and signage already on the property would create a critical mass so badly needed on the outer harbor.
 
"I would like to see an article on Buffalo Maritime Center's proposal for the reuse of the soon to be abandoned Coast Guard buildings."

Response from John Montague at The Buffalo Maritime Center:

Yes, the Coast Guard site would be great for the Maritime Center and could be linked by our water taxis to Canalside.  When I saw that the idea that the Coast Guard might leave I immediately sent an e-mail to Brian Higgins' office and resubmitted (now the third time), a proposal for the site (rendering and site concept shown here) I first drew up in 1995. The plan was designed to use the existing structures to minimize cost and to create a dynamic relationship/view with the Hatch site across the water.  I have not yet heard back from Higgins but I'm trying to get a meeting with him to at least discuss it.  I mentioned to Higgins the irony of having The Pier restaurant torn down (at a cost $500,000 I heard) when that building could have been used by the Maritime Center. It would be a shame now to demolish any of the buildings on the Lighthouse site before the possibilities of their reuse are explored.

BMC-lighthouse-Buffalo-NY.jpg
^Click to enlarge
View image

Comments

Leave a comment

WAY to good to be true.
In no uncertain terms..that area will NEVER look like the rendering above.

Score: -1 ( 5 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Most of those buildings already exist. How different than now do you think it looks?

replied to bobbyraz49
Score: 2 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Buffalo is bursting with gorgeous, historic buildings that are crumbling with no future in sight. I am speaking of St. Gerards, Bethlehem St. Admin Building, as well as many historic commercial structures on Buffalo's East Side.

Why not relocate them to Buffalo's waterfront? In so doing, we a) preserve our assets b) build on our authentic heritage and architectural stock c) save money (even building new crap is expensive) and d) cut down on the landfill in which these buildings will end up.

So, my suggestion: find a distressed building, move it to Buffalo's waterfront and house the Maritime Center there. I cannot think of a better way to spend (a fraction of) of the $50M++ that was to be used for Bass Pro. Then, with the money that is saved, the Center can acquire additional assets for their collection which would help it be a draw for tourists.

Score: -4 ( 6 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

The bottom corner of the image shows that this was painted in 1995 lol.

Yea, this is pretty optimistic.

I'd like to see more residential development with a Maritime Square (european plaza, not strip mall).

Score: 1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

It says right in the article that the proposal was drawn up and submitted back in 1995. Have you read the article?

replied to Greg
Score: 4 ( 4 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Actions speak louder than words, and much louder than artist's renderings. I am hopeful that we will see this soon, but I also know that we have been talking about this exact same things since the early 80s. Let's see some real action already!

Score: 2 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I agree! I'm still optimistic that it can happen, but so many projects get too much talk and too little action.

replied to sho'nuff
Score: 2 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I don't think that this project can constitute talk, at least yet. Just an idea.

I like it.. makes sense. I'm hoping a bridge gets put in as soon as possible. I like the non main st option, but really anything will do.

replied to BuffaloByChoice
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

This looks very do-able...and such a great boon to Buffalonians as well as out of town boaters.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I was set to build a sailboat until they got das boot'd.
This would be great for so many reasons. The center needs a great waterfront home and this would be so great.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

sorry buddy -

if your hope is in Brian Higgins you might as well root for the Bills on Sunday - he's a political fat cat too busy looking for a big cut from the PBA and various trucking associations for knocking down all the houses in Colubus Park - doubt he has time for this.

Score: -3 ( 5 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Where is the massive surface parking lot?

Score: -3 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

that is a beautiful picture. I would not mind seeing a drug store or convenience store in there too. I think it was Teddy Rooselvelt that said that a long trip starts with the first few steps so stop complaining about how old the drawing is. This is great news for Buffalo.

Score: 1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Anyone wondering how they drew this up so fast? Its from the 1992 Plan from the Horizons Waterfront Commission, Inc.
"Great Lakes Science Research Center: ... The Great Lakes Science Research Center is envisioned to be supported within a Cultural Park Setting and could include the development of a multi-purpose themed tourist attraction. This 'marquis' project would include cultural enrichment, educational, research, and entertainment facilities." (Action Plan for the Erie County Waterfront page 4-3)
The rendering is included in the commissions' report 20 pages later.
Talk about 'Nothing gets done in Buffalo, there's evidence. a 18 yearold project is still on the drawing board.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I thought the Coast Guard still uses and owns the land and are just now in the process of downsizing and possibly giving back land and buildings.

I really don't know anything about hierarchy in the Coast Guard, are they controlled by the City? I thought the CG was part of the Military, not sure how much control they have over the land they use.

replied to timvanman
Score: 1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Leave a comment

Buffalo Rising Poll