City October 8, 2010 7:55 AM

Education Suffers from Cultural Funding Cuts

Education Suffers from Cultural Funding Cuts
By Theresa Woehrel:
 
Thousands of students in Erie County will be amongst those most adversely affected by funding cuts by the State Council on the Arts (NYSCA). With five of Buffalo's arts education organizations receiving no funding at all for education programming, and a devastating 69% decrease in overall arts education funding in the County, many schools have lost a vital educational resource.
 
Folkloric Productions Dance Company, Hallwalls Contemporary Arts Center, Musicians United for Superior Education, Institute for Arts in Education in Western New York and Young Audiences of Western New York lost all funding, while Just Buffalo Literacy Center and the Coalition of Arts Providers for Children experienced substantial reductions.
 
"Western New York has suffered disproportionately," said Cynnie Gaasch, Executive Director for Young Audiences WNY. "Erie County was awarded only 31% of the funding received last year, while Brooklyn received 107% and New York 99.9%."
 
Poetry-Kids-Buffalo-NY.jpgYoung Audiences WNY, like the other arts organizations, presents professional teaching artists who engage young people in creative learning through the arts. Interactive programming, including long-term arts residencies reinforce core curriculum topics including math, science, and social studies, and are designed to build 21st century life skills such as problem-solving, creativity, and self-awareness.
 
"I was amazed with how engaged the students were," said Susan Mikula, a teacher at Holland Elementary School, of her experiences working with Young Audiences. "The children were excited and enthusiastic to learn about world cultures through this creative process."
 
The nine schools directly partnering with the cultural organizations that lost all funding represent over six thousand students. These partnerships with local schools also provide over 50 locals artists with opportunities to earn income, which comes back into the area's economy through taxes, mortgages, and patronage of local businesses.
 
NYswfwfwffwef.jpg"The arts are an economic engine for Western New York. These funding cuts are not only hurting our students but also the financial livelihood of our communities," said Gaasch. "Young Audiences alone provides artists in Erie County and further afield with over $240,000 of earned income each year. In 2009-2010 NYSCA funding leveraged matching contributions that made up $94,000 in earned income for artists."
 
Gaasch encourages supporters to write letters and place calls to NYSCA and their local political representatives for more equitable funding of arts education funding across the State.

Lead image: Jennifer Russo working on Mandalas with Kindergarteners at Holland Elementary

Inset image: Annette Daniels-Taylor with 4th and 8th graders at #43 Buffalo's Lovejoy Discovery School reciting their poetry

View image

Comments

Leave a comment

Sorry, when education funding has doubled in real dollars since 1970 and the public schools are still a joke, my give-a-crap meter for funding scare stories is at an all time low.

Score: 3 ( 9 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I agree. NY spends more than any other state on education without smarter offspring. Schools can simply get more bang for the buck. Consolidate/merge schools and functions, get tough in teacher contract negotiations, make wider use of distance learning and other methods employed by colleges, use volunteers extensively and intelligently, as do nursing homes, hospitals and schools in other areas, do not lay off productive teachers---the ones that actually produce more educated students, abolish tenure rules and use “pay for performance”, lower superintendents salary and benfits, along with direct and indirect support expenses. (Nearly all of the region's 37 superintendents in the suburban, small city and rural communities outside Buffalo broke new ground this decade with annual salary-and-benefit packages that raced well beyond inflation and pushed many into the $200,000-a-year range!)

replied to Jesse
Score: 1 ( 7 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I'll have to agree with the previous comments. Considering NY spends more per student that ANY other state, it's time the schools learn to do more with less.

We can't say that "students suffer" without acknowledging the critical suffering of NY Taxpayers.

Score: 1 ( 5 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

You three are mistaken. First of all, nobody should complain about increased funding for our schools. EVER. It should be our priority.
Second, this money does not go to the schools-- it goes to arts programming and to artists who provide that programming-- and those artists impact schoolchildren in ways that the typical school program cannot.
So if you are talking about getting bang for your buck, THIS IS IT.
Also, take a look at the numbers-- that $240,000 of earned income is JOBS IN WNY. We all want jobs in our community, but disproportionately funding NYC jobs in the same sector while cutting all funding for jobs in WNY -- don't you see something wrong with that? This is MY job as a professional teaching artist that is being affected because of these funding decisions, so yes I am very personal about it.

Score: 1 ( 9 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

daley>"nobody should complain about increased funding for our schools. EVER."

So taxes in WNY and NY state should continue to be raised even higher and higher than they are now - year after year, forever - as long as the money is spent on education? And according to daley, nobody should ever oppose that? EVER?

It's already near highest in all of the U.S. for combined property taxes (school+local+county), says this editorial in today's Buffalo News:

http://www.buffalonews.com/incoming/article214003.ece
"The report by the Tax Foundation measures property taxes against the value of their properties. By that measure, nine of the 10 highest taxed counties in the entire nation are in New York and three are in Western New York. The only non-New York county in the top 10 is Camden County, N.J.

If one or two New York counties showed up on that list, it would be interesting. For nine to appear on it is revelatory. That's not an accident. It's not a coincidence. It's an indictment.
...
And nowhere is the burden heavier than in Western New York, whose population has cratered over the past few decades.

Who can be surprised, then, that Niagara County is the nation's second-highest taxed county as a percentage of median home value?
Or that Chautauqua County is the fifth highest or that Erie County is sixth?

Other New York counties on the list are Monroe, at No. 1; Wayne, Chemung, Onondaga, Steuben and Madison.
..."

replied to daleypromotion
Score: 3 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Cassie, I appreciate your perspective on this, and understand how personal this is to you as you depend on funding from NYSCA in order to book events and promotions for you and other artists and musicians.

I can also understand where the others are coming from, as taxpayers continue to provide more funding to schools with a diminishing rate of return for their investment. Maybe the answer is to combine NYSCA funding with the arts allocations provided directly to schools, so we reduce the overall burden to taxpayers. I am not sure what the best answer is, but I do know that taxpayers and artists are struggling to come to terms with the excessive waste in Albany and we are all paying a very personal price for the lack of diligence from our elected officials.

replied to daleypromotion
Score: -1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

"nobody should complain about increased funding for our schools. EVER"

That is the exact attitude that is wrong with this state. Someone says "It's for the children!" and everyone else is expected to empty their wallets for them. This expectation has to end. NOW.

replied to daleypromotion
Score: -3 ( 5 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

So dead on 300 miles. There is so much waste in education it is mindboggling. Think if just a small percentage of that waste was tackled. Education has more than enough money, it is just spent in an efficient and unproductive manner. Instead we are suppose to blindly accept that it needs more money and not ask any questions. Fuk that.

Score: -2 ( 4 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

"NY spends more than any other state on education without smarter offspring."

Apparently we have not spent enough! As your comment illustrates.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Leave a comment

Buffalo Rising Poll