City August 27, 2010 11:57 AM

Project Rudnicki

Project Rudnicki
As of 9:30am the building at 120 South Park was still intact (see history). That was good to see. This morning started off, for me, with a text message from Rocco Termini saying that he would provide one of his engineers to the people behind the preservation effort. Good news. I also received an email of support from Roger Trettel, a developer who is working on a project just down the street. More good news. I found it numbing to learn that various developers had attempted to purchase the old blacksmith building over the years, to no avail.

Tim Tielman is now working on getting the message through to Judge Nowak that there is an engineer who is willing to go into the building in order to conduct a secondary evaluation of the property. Without access to the building there is no hope. Now the issue is in The City's court... as usual. I find it mind boggling that there have been proven developers with excellent track records waiting in the wings to tackle a project at that corner. Not only were they not successful in obtaining the building, the owner refused to do anything but let it fall apart.

The Landmark Preservation Board should be on this case now. The group can help to stop the demo. They can force the owner's hand if they want to. The City has the power to force his hand as well... if it wants to. The City has the ability to demand that the owner shore up the building to make it safe (if a third party engineer gets access), and if the owner does not follow through with the necessary repairs then a lien can be imposed. Maybe that's the loophole that is needed. Make the repairs so demanding (and the lien) that the owner does not want to hold on to the building and would rather sell it. That would be the way to get it out of the owner's hands and into the hands of one of the developers that would actually reuse the structure. 

Unbelievably, things are looking up. There needs to be a tactical plan put together if the stars do align. It looks like we might have the afternoon to get the engineer inside. The engineer is ready to go, and developers are sounding off on the need for a plan if the emergency demolition is averted. More on all of this shortly.
View image

Comments

Leave a comment

beware the weekend.

Score: 3 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

un-freaking-believable. It's old, so it's OK if we tear it down for a parking lot. Nevermind the expense that was made to put back in the cobblestones in the Cobblestone district. Or the success in reusing other older buildings in the immediate vicinity.

This city continues to find new ways to baffle me.

Score: 1 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Email your complaints: Mayor Brown, Mayor@city-buffalo.com, and Councilmember Franzcyk, dfranczyk@city-buffalo.com.

We also need the owner's contact info....if anyone has it, please post here. Let's put on some pressure to stop the madness!

Score: 0 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I would love to see this building saved, and just wish we had done more to get this action sooner.

So, if we successfully save this one, then what is the next building(s) that we should be focusing on? Do we have a list that we can proactively address instead of waiting for the wrecking ball to show up?

Score: 1 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Franzcyk's (Fillmore) number is 851-4138. Other council member numbers are:

Fontana (Lovejoy) 851-5151
Haynes (Ellicott) 851-4980
Golombek (North) 851-5116
Kearns (South) 851-5169
LoCurto (Delaware) 851-5155
Rivera (Niagara) 851-5125
Russell (University) 851-5165
Smith (Masten) 851-5145

Score: 1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Someone, like the city, should make available space on a server for a wiki like application.

Wikipedia is an application on the internet (for those who dont know) that is much like an encyclopedia/dictionary but its maintained by users inputing and maintaining information. Wikipedia only monitors and censors for improper usage.

Buffalo could easily create space for neighborhood associations to upload photographs, put a trigger for endangered or properties in need of inspection, etc.

Heck...it could even be simpler than that...google maps has photos of every property at street level and satellite...so really the only thing an application would need is:
1) a tag for a neighborhood
2) an address link to google for pictures, maps, such
3) tags for whether the property is historic, in a historic district, in-danger, in need of inspection, for sale

Dont ya just love technology...wouldnt it be cool...if city inspectors could just run a search everyday for properties that people in the neighborhood have recommended for city inspection...(in addition to phone calls but there is a big difference between a phone call and an actual visual picture and map of a neighborhood).

What a way to appoint a neighborhood leader and rally a neighborhood together!!!

Hey, just an idea...it may cost the city a little time for server space and a little time to program an application but I think it would yield enormous savings in time. Heck, add the cost to citations from the inspections.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Carr owns www.cobblestonebar.com. HUGE boycott if he goes through with this demolition.

Score: 1 ( 5 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

As far as those citing cost of renovation, look its quite reasonable to shore up the exterior walls and facade while demolish the interior floors.

This is a common preservation feature and actually many developers find it a less expensive option to build new floors and roof on the interior while having the value added exterior remain.

Unfortunately, Buffalo just doesnt seem to get it.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Wow, a boycott. That'll work.

Not that I'm advocating anything stronger than that, but seriously, there must be some reason an owner like this let's a Buffalo relic just rot away. I want to know what that reasoning is (there must be some sort of money to be made by doing so...).


Also, why the hell's it take "emergency demo status" for everyone to make stuff happen?

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Labruna's right about the weekend. Imagine my surprise when the topic name popped up (I had an uncle Ed Rudnicki but no relation to the blacksmith!)
Hope it can be saved. Also for you old building lovers I've been trying to get someone to try to save the original Bethlehem Steel office building on the Hamburg Turnpike. Seems after years of the owners neglecting the property without Lackawanna City hall trying to save it by citing them for violations (A ****load of blue tarps on the roof would have worked) the city was willing to give the owners $2 million plus to demolish it. The original portion (nearest to the Turnpike) should be saved and used for the Steel Plant Museum. The rear portion that was added on later could be removed. Don't you just love the politicians!!

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Keep fighting the good fight Queenseyes!!! Just emailed cousin Byron!

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

This is how all these situations should be handled, get everyone involved, like rolling a snowball down a hill. City hall is just a lame duck. This would make great office or lofts and add to the Canalside's original irreplaceable architecture of the era..

I may be wrong but I do not believe so. Carr is not owner of record, James M. Downing is.

Correct address:
110 S Park Ave corner Illinois St., Buffalo, NY 14203-3019

Owner:
James M and Maryann Downing
PO Box 1428
Buffalo, NY 14213

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

good work derby.. can i ask how you went about finding this information? I am surrounded by 2 vancant houses that, according to housing inspector Jim Gilmore, the city is unable to find the addresses of the owners, so therefore nothing can be done. City Hall at its finest, let me tell you. I'd like to find these owners myself.. help me out? thanks.

replied to derby98
Score: 1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

You can search on Erie.gov for property information (search for the address)
http://www.erie.gov/ecrpts/webprop.asp

James & Maryann sold the property (110 S. Park Ave) to Darryll Carr on 10/23/2009

And looking at the Buffalo News real estate transactions, the property was sold to Carr for $500,000

replied to derby98
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

And 118 S. Park Ave was sold by Edmond & Cecelia Rudnicki to Darryll Carr on 12/18/2001

replied to brfitz22
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Call to lodge a complaint with Carr directly:
Cobblestone Bar and Nightclub
130 South Park Avenue
Buffalo, NY
716-848-1930

replied to brfitz22
Score: -1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

There is a simple solution to this situation - buy the building from the present owner.

Have any of the commentors been inside this building? Or any of the building you so vehemently try to save from your couches?

They can all be saved - just save up some cash and buy them!

And then deal with NY State and their asbestos fees (fees that must be paid just to TELL NEw York you have asbestos). And then rebuild or preserve to your own liking or to the liking of the preservation board. It's that simple!

Some of these buildings are in bad shape. One bad roof plus a couple Buffalo winters can destroy a building. Sure everything can be fixed - and it only takes money.

Score: 2 ( 12 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

It also takes an owner that is willing to sell the property.

replied to LastManIn
Score: 2 ( 6 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Byron Brown needs to stop this demolition.

Someone needs to remind him that the National Trust is having their national convention in Buffalo next year, and one of the attractions they expect to see is the Cobblestone District.

Score: 1 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

http://www.buffalonews.com/city/article173870.ece

Dun, dun, dun... another one bites the dust... so sad!

Score: 1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

The lawyer for the owner has an "expert" who claims contamination from an un-named substance as a result of "foundry work" (it was a brass casting foundry) but doesn't name the contaminant. Bricks being a somewhat ceramic material likely have no more contamination than any other building in the area. A test for lead, the only real hazard possibility, is pretty simple. A quick sandblasting of the brick would likely clean anything found, maybe even just a good power washing would do.
Pretty sad that the city doesn't have someone on the payroll who's paid to do this sort of inspection (or perhaps they do.)The expert didn't even bother to write up a report yet its likely that the judge will grant their request. Pretty sad.

replied to sho'nuff
Score: 0 ( 4 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

On the issue regarding historical buildings that are literally falling down, there needs to be more of a focus on the owners. These people often hide in the weeds hoping for some gov't. agency to bale them out or to shamelessly profit from some concerned citizens' group as they try to save the building. Photos, bios, track records often reveal the ugly truth behind these parasites.

Score: 0 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

It's a great building, can be easily restored. Just one more example of Buffalo Greed. Property exploitation needs to be criminalized here. How about a little help from our legislators for those of us with the gumption to actually take on theses difficult restoration efforts.

This guy wants lots of MONEY for doing NOTHING. The PIG! should be run out of town.

Score: -1 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Does anyone remember when they built the arena? Do you know why they didn't touch these buildings? Because they were contaminated! Not because they were of any historic significance.

It was a foundry. Do any of the preservationists out there ever consider the environmental issues NYS forces us to remediate first and foremost?

If this is such a historically significant structure, be a hero and buy it. I am sure the owner will sell. Everything has a price.

Score: -1 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Leave a comment

Buffalo Rising Poll