food August 30, 2010 8:59 AM

Visions of Outer Harbor Opportunities

Visions of Outer Harbor Opportunities
You can't say no to Tucker Curtin. Well, you can, but it will just feed the fire which powers the intense energy of this local businessman. Before meeting him, more than one person had told me of his entrepreneurial spirit, which landed him in Seventeen magazine as a teen. Age hasn't tempered his big ideas, and by the time we met one another four or five years ago, he was well known for transforming an old dining car into one of Buffalo's favorite diners and operating The Steer on a stretch of Main Street where many had already pulled up their stakes and moved on.

I told Curtin "no", in a way, about four years ago when he inquired as to how he could bring more local foods into what are now his three restaurants (Lake Effect Diner, The Steer and Dug's Dive). There is no distribution system for local fruits and vegetables, and those chefs who are buying local meat are chefs from boutique restaurants who are willing to break down whole (or nearly whole) animals in their kitchens. At the time, I believed that the kind of volume Curtin needed to do, and the casual dining prices he fetches at his restaurants would make sourcing local a less viable option for him. But he didn't want to  listen, though he was very polite, and I had soon learned that I had severely underestimated him. The handful of phone numbers I had provided him proved a challenge, of sorts, for Curtin, and before long, he was serving 100% local beef burgers in his restaurants, smoking and curing hams and bacon, sourcing local maple syrup and blueberries and wowing customers in droves. Curtin had proven that dedication and the ability to buy and process in large quantities had made "local" a possibility and a viable business venture for his restaurants.

curtin.jpgOn a gorgeous sunny day last week, standing with our backs to the river overlooking the mammoth buildings known as Terminals A & B on the Outer Harbor, Curtin begins to unfold his plan for transforming this part of the waterfront. The idea is an undertaking that would overwhelm most--the scale of these buildings is hard to fathom, even while looking at them. The idea of choosing to be responsible for their success would terrify most. As he talks he points out the breathtaking waterfront view, the rail car lines and the design of Terminal A, with its ability to make the use of natural light and the breeze off the river, both of which make the building naturally efficient. Additionally, the building seems to have a fascinating manufacturing history, which includes names like Ford and Edison. I say, "I'd tell you it will never happen and you're crazy to even be thinking about it, but I know the more you hear that, the more you'll do to prove us all wrong." Curtin laughs.

terminal a.jpgUp until now, the buildings, which belong to the NFTA, have been sublet to handful of businesses who don't come close to utilizing the full extent of the property. Prior to that, Terminal A had spent some time as the headquarters for Nanodynamics. The NFTA has given the ECHDC until mid-September to submit a proposal for the area, but Curtin thinks it is unlikely the ECHDC board has had time to develop a plan for this area when there is still so much work to do downtown. Curtin proposes another idea for the space, a mixed-use food processing plant, apartments and restaurants, think Toronto's Distillery District mixed with the farmer-friendly food processing that Western New York so desperately needs. "We have the talent, we have the product," Curtin says, speaking of our local farmers, "but for many years there hasn't been a demand. Now there is, but we're missing the processing facilities." Canning, freezing, pickling, drying, all of these types of processes would be available to WNY farmers, cooperatively.

Below is the letter submitted by Curtin to the NFTA. We'll let you read it for yourself, but despite the scale of the project, Curtin's enthusiasm and drive are undeniable. Now that he's spent a few years on the front lines of local food sourcing here in WNY, he sees all of the gaps in our agricultural system that are preventing our region from being able to really thrive economically, and to provide healthy, fresh food for our region.

Right now, he is hoping that the NFTA will work to keep the buildings open during the winter. While it may seem cost prohibitive, Curtin fears that a single winter on the waterfront with no heat and nobody inside will result in plumbing issues, moisture problems, vandalism and unreported leaks that could cause long term damage. "It seems like no big deal, but once you close one of these buildings up, it can cost half a million dollars or more to recover. I think the recovery rate on re-opening a building of this size after winterizing is pretty low."

"If the New York Port Authority built the World Trade Center, why can't the NFTA help revitalize the waterfront? I think that this can not only become a success for the farmers and restaurant owners, but the NFTA could even reinvest some of their profit into the infrastructure of the waterfront and downtown. Culturals are great, and we envision some of this project being like a museum in that people will come here to see things and to learn things and we could have tours and works studies and more, but it would also produce a product and create jobs and wealth."

"Our community is always looking at other successful projects and saying, 'why can't we have that here', like Faneuil Hall and Seattle's Pike Place Market, but this is an opportunity to lead the way and to capitalize on our region's commodities. Our area is famous for harnessing the river and creating wealth from electricity, maybe it's time that we harness our harvest."

Anyone interested in speaking with Tucker Curtin about this project should email him directly.

termial a 1.jpgHere is the letter sent by Curtin to the commissioners at the NFTA.

The objective is to form a cooperative of food processors and local farmers to process, store and sell their commodities under one entity. Terminal A could be divided into different incubator spaces, each specializing in their prescribed food products.

"The Butcher Block" could be a section devoted to the humane processing of local beef, chicken and pork. The block could have many diverse tenant/members that could include sausage makers, European and Kosher butchers and similar type purveyors of artisan meat products.

A Produce section would feature a year round market open to the public. It would be equipped with a processing area for washing, canning and freezing of the local seasonal harvest. Among the tenant/members could be vegetarian restaurants and producers of fruit and vegetable based foods such as soups, sauces and baby food.

A Bakery section featuring locally milled wheat and other grains with specialized products such as pizza, hand made pastas, breads, cakes and candy makers. Baked goods and confections could be sold wholesale, to the public as well as individually quick frozen for future sale. Production areas would be glassed in for public inspection and entertainment.

The facility lends itself well to different types of restaurants that can be exposed to the waterfront as well as the ability to create within a streetscape with a mall type open air feel during the more inclement months. A focal point, such as a village square, could feature a gathering place for weekend cooking demonstrations and a live music/theater venue.

The list of potential tenant/members from apple pie makers to wine makers is too numerous to list. The ability for local farmers and small food producers to bring their products to the mass market through cooperative methods will allow tenants/members to share services, marketing, processing equipment, byproducts and knowledge. The local farmer can and will continue to increase production knowing that there is processing and storage capacity for the commodities farmed. Products produced would be sold to other cooperative members, the general public, local specialty stores and supermarkets. Commodities could also be shipped via truck and rail widening future markets and lowering costs through bulk purchasing and shipping amongst tenant members.

The cooperative would be committed to green technology and efficiency through environmental responsibility. The facility could also employ hundreds of people with jobs paying $10-$25 or more per hour. The location could also act as a conduit providing seasonal rural farm jobs to the inner city unemployed through job temp services. The Terminal could be a waterfront attraction for tourists as well as becoming a catalyst for year round outer harbor development. Vendors could accept food stamps allowing the poor access to local wholesome foods at reasonable prices. Projects such as this could be financed through the US Department of Agriculture and could qualify for many grants and subsidies. The Cornell Cooperative currently has resources and expertise in this type of initiative that would promote rural farming and the processing and storage of local agricultural commodities.

There exists a tremendous demand from the farming community to have more USDA processing facilities so that they may grow more products and feed more people. The consumer currently has gone back to the basics acquiring an insatiable appetite for wholesome nutrition. The demand and market share for these type products continues to claim its rightful share in the marketplace.

Please consider this request to further develop our waterfront.

Sincerely,

Tucker Curtin

P.S. Louis Fuhrmann was a four term Mayor of Buffalo. He was raised poor and worked at the Elk Street Terminal cleaning stalls and eventually worked in Kansas City at a meat packing facility. He married into a Buffalo meat packing business and worked his way to the top. He became successful and very wealthy in the food industry before and after his public service. His
accomplishments as Alderman and Mayor include the construction of the outer harbor wall, electrified city street lamps, improvements to the Buffalo River and the construction of the Hamburg Turnpike to name a few. Fuhrmann believed that the people of Buffalo should utilize all our natural resources and capabilities for the betterment of its citizens
.

 

View image

Comments

Leave a comment

You go get 'em Tucker.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

rebuilding a local economy one "worthless" old building at a time!

Score: -1 ( 7 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment


Worthless? I don't think so. This building has great potential.

Score: 0 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Hence the scare quotes in grad94's comment.

replied to hamp
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I think grad94 was being sarcastic, and is pointing out that buildings like these have been deemed worthless by many, but in fact may be the key to our economic revival. But that's just my hunch, based on grad's typical comments. Grad may not have meant that at all.

replied to hamp
Score: 2 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

exactly, christina. the quotation marks were intended to mean 'so called' or 'supposedly.' as jane jacobs said, new ideas need old buildings.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scare_quotes

so-called worthless buildings are essential habitat for entrepreneurs, but people like andrew rudnick believe, contrary to all the evidence smacking them in the face, that if we just demolished a few more of them, dollars would rain down upon our fair city.

oh, and al labruna is correct. those diners never rode the rails once they were manufactured and delivered (by rail) to their permanent locations.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diner

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Oh, is that what those quotation marks mean? Irony, I get it.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Like the idea a lot, but I have reservations. I would love to be able to shop at a real market for organic, wholesome local foods. A center like this is very attractive, but . . .

Why not do this in the sprawling food terminal complex at Clinton Bailey, across from the farmer's market? I shop at Willowbrook's two stores there (beverages and restaurant supplies). There are a few other tenants (sausage makers, some others). But much of that complex is vacant. Tucker's concept seems a natural for piggybacking on the farmer's market. Besides, you wouldn' need to move heaven and earth to make it happen. Those buildings are already food grade, the landlord already wants more vendors and customers already come to the complex. Developing a farmer's market in the NFTS's former Ford plant would spell the doom of the existing farmer's market/food terminal, imo. Would the change in location be all that beneficial?

Score: 2 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I agree - the Clinton Bailey market would be the natural venue for this kind of thing (and I think it has a lot of historic precedent there).

replied to biniszkiewicz
Score: 1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Tucker is better suited to answering these questions, but I will try.

We talked about the food terminal and the Broadway Market. Here's the thing. Tucker's vision is too big for both of those places, and livestock processing is unlikely to be welcome in either of those neighborhoods. Additionally, restaurants with a view and Distillery District appeal aren't likely to happen there either based on the conditions of the surrounding neighborhoods and access to major thoroughfares and people. The Outer Harbor offers STUNNING views.

The Outer Harbor is also a blank slate of sorts, easily accessible to downtown and greatly improved due to recent roadwork. It is also of the appropriate size. We are talking about two *huge* buildings that offer more than 500,000 sq ft of enclosed, heated, well-maintained space, loading docks and a parking lot for 2,000 cars. Of course there would be a marketplace, but there is a lot more to Tucker's plan than a public market.

replied to biniszkiewicz
Score: 3 ( 3 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

While I can certainly appreciate Mr. Curtin's attempt to match the desire for more diverse food sourcing and protecting a potentially valuable asset Im inclined to agree there may be more appropriate ways of accomplishing both.

Establishing a food terminal and pubic market on the outer seems to create more issues than it solves. First, like others have said, it is duplicating some of the raison d'etre of a the food terminal, the Broadway Market, as well as the new venture in the old horsefeathers.

In all those cases, there is likely sufficient additional capacity to handle expanded businesses. Even if there was not, there are rightly sized warehouses (or churches) all over the city that could be utilized, most gotten for a song. It seems to me, that smaller public markets developed throughout the area that could serve the same goals *and* serve as neighborhood redevelopment in the more urban sense while eradicating a food dessert or two.

Furthermore, while this site's location may seem like an asset, it really seems like it could have some serious drawbacks. Primarily, this location is far from any existing developed areas, is not easily accessible by mass transit, and could potentially drain some customer bases away from its more densely located counterparts. Such a site will only serve to further dilute Buffalo as an urban center.

Very frankly, development of the outer harbor seems like a long term goal, to be pursued after other more urban parts of the city have been developed. Aggressively pushing for large tracts of land to be added to the sizable glut of "shovel ready" sites seems likely to further depress the market.

Now what to do with a giant warehouse?

If not tenant is found, I say advertise free space available for businesses expanding or new to the region. Hell, it was good enough for Bass Pro.

Score: 2 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I am privvy to several projects of this sort (or similar) being discussed for several different locations across the region. Anyone who is willing to give it a shot gets my vote.

As a person who has seen farmers forced to through away tons and tons (literally) of product with no buyer. As someone who has been begged by local hospitals and elementary schools to find them year round sources for local, pesticide-free food, I say to the first man or woman who makes real headway on this effort- more power to you!

I have worked closely with the crew working on the stellar Horsefeathers project (and consider them friends), as well as spending the last year or more in talks with ECHDC's consultant for their version of a public market, and those are just two great projects of the six or more I am aware of. None of the projects I know about are as great in scope as Tucker's vision. They are all worthwhile, and in my perfect world they would all be built, without question, but none of them has the ability to process cattle, or IQF freeze 400 tons of cherries, etc.

I will continue to offer my services to anyone who dreams up a local food project and seems to have their wits about them. I will also continue to tell their tales here, no matter how far-fetched, as it is a great way to talk more about our harvest, our opportunities and our needs.

As far as giving free space to new business, the space isn't free. Tucker's plan asks the NFTA to keep the building in good shape for a season and then it pays rent, just like the other tenants have.

replied to al labruna
Score: 1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Not to be a pain in the butt, but I doubt the Lake Effect Diner was once a dining car. Most diners were manufactured expressly for the purpose, and only somewhat resembled passenger railway equipment.

Just looking at it, the LED seems way too wide to be a repurposed passenger coach. Perhaps it is, but it seems pretty unlikely. Id further would doubt its a old dining car, since those were heavier (read valuable) and much less common compared to run of the mill railway coaches.

Score: 1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

You're right al labruna, it was a poor choice of phrase. LED is a prefabricated 1952 Mountain View Diner reclaimed from Pennsylvania and lovingly restored by the Curtin family.

replied to al labruna
Score: 1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Here is what I like and what the ilk of Rudmore at the Buffalo Niagara Chamber of Commerce will not do....

the concept is to examine the economy of Buffalo and Western New York, figure out what sectors of the economy are not represented or are under-represented, then promote development which will satisfy that need locally rather than export our wealth outside our area.

I have been saying this for a long time and its nice to see there are loyal and patriotic citizens in the business community who want to steward such businesses.

UB, Buffalo State, Canisius, Niagara U, NFTA, etc...every institution and business has a civic responsibilities to seed businesses, to use their purchasing department to buy locally and support local businesses, to use their supply chain management to attract businesses here, to use their role in infrastructure to promote development, etc.

There is a bigger message here...unfortunately like Muriel Howard and Rudmore and others are incompetent ostriches...is this a bigger picture change...are the leaders of our community coming out behind their desks?

Score: -1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

there is no "rudmore," johnq, but there is an andrew rudnick.

and will you please get over your muriel howard obsession? she has been gone for over a year and buff state has a new president now.

replied to JohnQBuffalo
Score: 2 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Has the project in Freezer Queen building been totally scrapped?

As a boater in the NFTA harbor there some quicker to go food would be nice add. Dug's has to go food but for some reason you can't call in an order to pick up?

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I feel that this is the stepping stone that Buffalo has been waiting for. The production side of this seems to be the main staple, not the restraunts. Also since it would mostly be a center for production it would be make a great asset to the other markets in the city because it would allow more people to create the products needed to sell there to draw people.

Which would get more people to the city.

Which would bring more business.

Which would create more opportunities for new companies.

Which would bring more jobs.

It will take a few years to get going, but once it does? It will be amazing.

Score: -1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I applaud Tucker and his visions. Unfortunately, Buffalo's population would never support a project of this magnitude. It's great in theory but utilizing "local" farmers and suppliers for parishable products means that "local" population would have to support it. With a population of around 300K, and surrounding populations of just over 1M, we are simply too small. I cannot see this as a tourist attraction. Parishable foods are not high on the "souvenior" market and unless a particular item is demographically produced and not available anywhere else, I highly doubt we could count on the tourist trade for viable commerce. Canned tomatoes are canned tomatoes. I'm certainly not taking up prime realestate in my suitcase to house them just because they are from Buffalo. I am sure the "big guys", like Whole Foods have looked at Buffalo for future expansion. Our city right now is simply too small for a major expansion of the Organic market. At my local market, Wegmans, they have not increased their organic department, at least in size, for many years now. Though I tend to cook myself organically, there are not a lot of options in our "trendy" restaurants that cater to the organic enthusiast. If the project is scaled down to fit our demographics, then maybe Tucker's vision or a slight variation of it could work. But then what do you do with the rest of the building? Housing? It would be great to have affordable housing on the waterfront. Most of the waterfront housing is simply too expensive for first-time buyers. Maybe have condos or lofts that are available to only first-time buyers (not sure of the discrimination of other viable buyers), but they do have complexs that require one to be 55 or over, so... I certainly would not qualify for such development, but I would love to see this site utilized for something other than warehousing.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Seems you might be unaware that central and down state have both sent out feelers on a government and private level looking for 'local' foods. Yes fresh, but also frozen and otherwise preserved for schools and universities, hospitals and hotels. Entire counties in our state have required public institutions to purchase a certain percentage of local foods to support the economy, and in some cases these institutions are struggling to meet that level due to a lack of product, particularly in the cold season. Similar purchasing requirements have made their way into the policies of individual institutions, as well. There is an unmet need for local foods in this state, and there's no reason why we can't capitalize on our prime soil, micro-climates and rich agricultural heritage to be the provider of said items, but we desperately need PROCESSING.

Wow, great story. I hope he can cut through the bureaucratic nonsense and make it happen... it's a really good idea.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

It is such an honor to have the chance to join the discussion of this great blog site, but I can certainly appreciate the value of the contents provided by Curtin, this must be a efficient stuff to reach a diverse group of consumers and business networks through an innovative medium.
evansville indiana homes for sale

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Leave a comment