City August 11, 2010 12:00 AM

Obstructionist Victory 35+ Years Ago - See the Results!

Obstructionist Victory 35+ Years Ago - See the Results!
Article submitted by Preservation Buffalo Niagara: Historical Presentation Wednesday Night...

Buffalo's first Historic District was established in 1974 as a result of citizen-obstructionists (aka preservationists) successful efforts to prevent the demolition of 3 grand mansions to make way for a non-descript office building. Another victory was the "save" of the Wilcox Mansion, spared from demolition in the 1960s, which will be the starting point of a one-day event co-sponsored by Preservation Buffalo Niagara and the Theodore Roosevelt Inaugural Site.

On August 21, at your leisure on a self-guided tour, you can visit the interiors and grounds of 11 gloriously designed private homes built to last for centuries and now protected for the future.

100 years ago Buffalo was the 8th largest city in the US and one of the busiest ports and industrial centers in the world, with more millionaires per capita than any other American City. This concentration of wealth is evident today in the design and decoration of the fabulous mansions along Delaware Avenue, Buffalo's grandest street, and in the surrounding neighborhood.

"These mansions exemplify the luxurious lifestyles of Buffalo's most affluent citizens and remain the equal of any such homes anywhere in the country," according to Architectural Historian Martin Wachadlo.

Reed-House.jpg

This is a rare opportunity to take a look inside 6 of the magnificent mansions in the most prestigious blocks of the Avenue, and 5 impressive private homes on adjacent Oakland Place, a one block long street running directly behind the largest mansions.

Among those open will be the Williams-Butler Mansion (designed in 1896 by McKim, Mead & White, then the nation's most prestigious architectural firm); the Knox mansion of 1916, a grand home that was occupied by the Knox Family until the 1970s (designed by C.P.H. Gilbert, who also designed mansions for the Woolworths, cousins of the Knoxes); and the Goodyear mansion (designed in 1901 by Green & Wicks, Buffalo's most prestigious firm), that once hosted the King and Queen of Belgium.

Bonus Tonight - Pre-tour lecture for those with discounted early-bird tickets! (available at the door). Wednesday August 11 at 7:00 pm at the Theodore Roosevelt Inaugural Site, 641 Delaware Avenue, Martin Wachadlo will give an in-depth presentation on the architecture, the families, and their business connections in the prosperous city during the first half of the 20th century.

Tour Information: August 21, 10:00 am to 3:00 pm
Early-bird tickets $25 each (members' price of $20)
Day of Tour: $30
Tickets available at the TR Site or Preservation Buffalo Niagara, or by calling 852-3300
Online purchases at www.BuffaloTours.org

Photos:

Delaware Avenue: Knox Mansion, Music Room
 
Oakland Place: Reed House, Reception Room

View image

Comments

Leave a comment

This should be a required field trip for every student in the Buffalo Schools. It's just sad that so many people live their entire lives here without knowing the history that surrounds them. If more people were aware of the greatness in this city's past, they'd be more optimistic about the possibilities for its future.

I can /almost/ forgive people from out of town who say they drove past Buffalo, but didn't bother to stop because they thought there was nothing to see. But it's inexcuseable for people to live here and not realize that the city has more to offer than snow and football.

Score: 7 ( 7 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I also always though it would be a good lesson on American History to try and learn through the local lens. You get to talk about assassinations, inaugurations, industrial growth, world wars, art, architecture, civil rights, the ideals of democracy and how they influenced American city \ architectural designs.

I think the lesson about the American Political system would be much more memorable if it happened walking through City Hall and the common council chambers. As well as lessons on political corruption... ;)

I could not egree with you more about all schools (public, private, parochial and charter) going on field trips to understand Buffalo History.

But I also see the value not just in preservation but in reconstruction. There are some buildings that gave us a real sense of place. We have lost shelton square. Without Erie Savings Bank Shelton Square will never come back but we do have the potential in the future to restore the sense of place around Lafayette Square and McKinley Circle.

On a side note...The Roosevelt/McKinley Museum should consider championing an expansion plan for museums devoted to Cleveland, Fillmore and McKinley. Many have suggested Presidential Libraries for each at the Richardson.

Don't forget about Fillmore! As far as I know, we are still the only city in the country to put TWO of our boys in the oval office. (Bush Jr & Bush Sr are technically from different states).

McKinley has a museum in Ohio, Roosevelt has a Birthplace Historic Site in NYC (plus the inaugural site at the Wilcox Mansion)... but neither Cleveland nor Fillmore have much more than random plaques in various places.

There is a small contingent pushing for a Grover Cleveland library, which I think would be an excellent candidate for tying in Fillmore, McKinley and Roosevelt. What a swath of history could be covered by those four men! (and maybe even leave me an empty corner in case I ever decide to run, lol)

I had thought that CanalSide would be a good place for it, but like the idea of using the Richardson Buildings even better!

replied to JohnQBuffalo
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Exactly! We need to use our real assets as leverage to expand.

Using the Teddy Roosevelt Inaugural Site to create other museums and/or libraries for other presidents should be a common sense mission.

Yet it seems status quo for Buffalonians, Buffalo leadership and Buffalo Institutions to be isolated, myopic and unable to see a bigger picture beyond their own immediate and narrow focus of responsibilities.

Presidential museums/libraries for McKinley, Cleveland and Fillmore would only complement and secure the future viability of the Teddy Roosevelt Inaugural Site. Such a trio or quartet could see a sharing of tickets/promotions, a coordination of events, a share expansion/procurement of historical exhibits, etc. Its in their own interest.

The Richardson...is just one example of a building of the period which could be used as a foundation.

Deaner

Quick point - Roosevelt also has national park units @ home on Long Island, Mt. Rushmore, and his ranch in the Dakotas.

Of course there is a huge diffeerence between obstructing the demolishion of a historic building as opposed to obstructing construction on a surface parking lot such as the Webster Block.

Score: -1 ( 7 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Sally, I'm disappointed in you. For someone who is so facts-oriented, I'm surprised that you would choose to sensationalize something so completely false. There isn't a single person out there who is directly trying to block any development on the Webster lot. People are upset about the entire process that has gone on between ECHDC, the City, HSBC, Bass Pro, etc...

replied to Sally
Score: 4 ( 8 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Agreed, it is a crime to this city to live here and never know its greatness whether it be former, present or future.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Awwww, people don't like the "process". Because the "process" they prefer has been kicking ass so far - we'll all be dead before their vision comes true, but hey, that's the price to pay for progress!

JFC.

35 years from now we'll still be whining about the Peace Bridge rebuild and Canal Side will probably still be a mess.

Score: 0 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

our presidential history is great stuff and i'm all for capitalizing on it. don't get me wrong, but what do folks expect to have in this wondrous presidential library?

cleveland's and fillmore's papers have long been dispersed among multiple institutions who aren't about to surrender them just because a new 501c3 hangs out a shingle as a presidential library. you can probably get cleveland & fillmore books from amazon but that won't provide a particularly unique or compelling destination.

has anyone contacted these owners to find out how much traffic presidential papers actually attract in a given year? probably not much. most people google what they need to know about a particular president.

even if it is as high as 10 people per business day at an admission rate of $10 each, that isn't enough revenue to cover the utilities, much less sustain a professionally staffed research and exhibit facility.

well, i guess you could always print out some presidential pictures and autographs from the internet and hang them up.

Score: 2 ( 2 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Too bad the anarchists can't get organized! Buffalo's Polonia District maybe?

/too soon?

replied to grad94
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Leave a comment

Buffalo Rising Poll