Real Estate May 13, 2010 12:45 AM

What Projects Deserve Stimulus Funds?

What Projects Deserve Stimulus Funds?

At the end of March, Erie County's Legislature approved a program that allows private developers to compete for a pool of federal financing provided by selling Recovery Zone Facility Bonds (RZFB).

The City of Buffalo is receiving $7.2 Million in facility bonds while Erie County has an allocation of $17.1 million.

Recovery Zone Facility Bonds are a tool for encouraging private investment in economic development and job growth. RZFB are a new type of qualified private activity bonds. RZFB create the ability to use tax-exempt borrowing for a wide range of business development.

Representatives from Erie County and the City of Buffalo will be reviewing applications and selecting projects for funding.  To help ensure maximum economic benefit, there was a $3 million minimum funding request. 

The deadline to apply for the tax exempt financing was May 10.  According to Business First, eleven applicants are seeking a total of $113 million in funding for a range of new (and old) projects:

DSC_0580.JPG• Seneca Exchange/Larkin Partners are seeking $12.4 million for a pair of renovation projects at 701 Seneca St. and 635 Seneca St. (right) -- two new, mixed-use potential anchors for the Larkin area being championed by developer Howard Zemsky.

• Galvstar LLC has filed an application seeking $18.8 million for its plans to convert a former American Axle plant into a galvanized steel operation.

• Riverwright LLC is hoping for an $8 million allocation for its proposed ethanol plant in Buffalo.

• Developer Sam Savarino filed an application, seeking $4.5 million for his restoration and renovation of a historic warehouse at 500 Seneca Street into a mixed-use project. The property is also in the middle of the Larkin area footprint.

• Iskalo Development is seeking $4.6 million to aid with the renovation of the former Kane-Doyle Jeep dealership property on Delaware Avenue in Kenmore.

• Multisorb Technologies filed an application seeking $20 million for renovations and expansion of its plants in Cheektowaga and West Seneca.

• Developer Gerry Buchheit, through his Queen City Landing LLC company, is seeking $24.2 million for his plans to renovate the vacant, former Freezer Queen warehouse and manufacturing plant on Fuhrmann Boulevard into a mixed-use project anchored by upscale condominiums.

204Franklin.jpg• Mark Croce, under the guise of his Baha Beach Club corporate entity, filed an application for $6 million to convert the former Curtiss Building on Franklin Street into a 56-room boutique hotel (rendering right).

• 107 Delaware Holdings LLC is seeking $8 million for its efforts to restore the mothballed Statler Towers into a mixed-use development, anchored by a 235-room hotel.

• Retractable Syringe LLC is seeking $6.5 million to create a start-up medical incubator at a location to be determined later.

Projects will be evaluated based on their return on investment to the community, financial capability and ability to close the Recovery Zone bond by December 31, 2010.  Decisions are expected next month.

A few of these projects were previously unknown.  Mixed-use redevelopment of 701 and 635 Seneca Street would continue work in The Hydraulics neighborhood in a big way.  The mammoth Seneca Industrial Center at 701 Seneca and four-story building at 635 Seneca are adjacent to tje highly-successful Larkin at Exchange building.

Galvstar is a Canadian firm that wants to open a galvanized steel operation in a portion of the former American Axle facility on East Delevan Avenue.  The firm would create 50 jobs that would pay an average of $68,000 a year.

500SenecaOne.jpgSavarino is seeking assistance for a mixed-use redevelopment of a former factory at 500 Seneca Street (rendering right).  Mark Croce is seeking additional funding to rehab the historic Curtiss Building at 204 Franklin Street downtown.

Interestingly, 107 Delaware Holdings LLC is seeking $8 million for restoration of the Statler building.  The development group is believed to be the partnership headed by William Koessler, the high bidder at the Statler auction that failed to complete the purchase.

Personally, I favor projects that create jobs like Galvstar or Retractable Syringes' start-up medical incubator, or the synergy that could be added to the Larkin District's by the three projects proposed along Seneca Street.
 

View image

Comments

Leave a comment

JS> " Personally, I favor projects that create jobs like Galvstar..."

Agree. All of these projects appear to have merit but I think the A.A. site venture has the most upside as far as job creation and economic development.

Retractable Syringe LLC? Wasn't that the name of one of those fictitious companies in the movie Boiler Room?

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I'd put my money into the Statler. It's a huge project in a very visible location.
It's going to need financial support if anything is going to happen there.

The longer it is abandoned, the more expensive it will be to ultimately renovate.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Agreed. But, couldn't there be a combo: Statler AND an incubator? So, we are preserving an important building AND creating a reuse/developing economic opportunity. Given the costs to reno the Statler, there needs to be some long-term view on putting growth businesses which would ultimately justify the short term expenditure.

replied to hamp
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

The stimulus funds are a pie and will be split several ways. I appreciate the gravity of the conspicuous Statler problem and have no problem having some of the pie directed towards putting it back in operation. However, a primary purpose of the funds is to create economic development. All these projects will create temporary construction jobs but I prefer to support the Galvstar project and any other project that creates permanent jobs. Some of the rehabilitation projects will be chosen too and I believe the Statler should be one of them provided the 107 Group's plan is credible. I'm cautious about the Statler because so many of the recent proposals haven't amounted to anything other than wasting valuable rehabilitation time and effort.

replied to Travelrrr
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

what is 107 Group's plan? So, they basically walked away from the original deal because of a lack of funds/subsidies from the city? That really is too bad--and exacerbated the situation of the building. Agreed on the need for real economic, as opposed to property, development.

replied to jstraubinger
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I am in agreement with the above sentiment that the funds should go to the projects that will create that create long term employement opportunities. Construction jobs are great but once the building is done, more work needs to be found. At face value, Galvastar appears to have the most employment bang for the buck. Residential development is great but it can be done once demand is created by an influx of workers created by employment opportunities.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Buffalo Central Terminal - 495 Paderewski Drive, 14212, for the High Speed Rail Project.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Does the winner actually get money or a right to borrow it? What are the repayment terms?

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

There is no sole winner. There will be several winners. My preference for winning is job creation projects first and then building rehabilitation projects. The winners get funds for their projects from the sale of the bonds.

replied to Carl R
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

So the project getting the award has to pay back the Bond/Note. They just get a lower interest rate because the lender/bond buyer does not have to pay taxes on their interest payments. My guess is that by the time they get done paying all the lawyers and bank fees, the lower interest is not going to be such a good deal. Bet it works out well for the banks and the lawyers.

replied to jstraubinger
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Business First's parent company, Bizjournals, offers a complete explanation of these bonds at this link:

http://www.bizjournals.com/triad/stories/2010/01/25/story4.html

replied to Carl R
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Thank you. This is very helpful.

replied to jstraubinger
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Well, if you can get past the idea of 'stimulus funding' from the Federal Government (eg: from all citizens or now all 'borrowed funds')then I agree - this should be used for projects that create long-term employment opportunities like the Galvastar project. Riveright ethanol project should be dead in the water as ethanol is a lost cause and an ecological disaster. And always there is the question if some private projects should be subsidized by taxpayers while others sink. Tough choices...

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

i'm glad someone said what i was thinking about riverwright. quite apart from the environmental hazards, you cross a moral line when you start feeding food to cars instead of people.

replied to WarrenG
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

If this money must be spent, then of the 11 who applied only 4 sound at all likely to result in real long term jobs that wouldn't otherwise be here: Galvastar at American Axle (asking for $18M), Multisorb expansion ($20M), Retractable Syringe ($6M), and Riverwright ($8M).

The other 7 sound like they'd involve shifting around hotel jobs, office space, and residential.

Galvastar and Multisorb easily sound like the best two that should be seriously considered. There’s too many doubts about Riverwright's viability.

Galvastar could get the $7.2M for the city plus some of the $17.1M for the county, and the rest of the county’s allocation could go to Multisorb. If Retractable Syringe is proposing a very good plan and if it wouldn't be redundant to other incubators here, then maybe they could get a small share. Those should be the 3 finalists.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Leave a comment

Buffalo Rising Poll